Ergonomy optimization

Search Vancouver Listings Find concerts, movies, restaurants, arts, & events

Blog - Politics

Taser death in Vancouver: authorities' arrogance led to man's unnecessary demise

There are several investigations underway into the death of Robert Dziekanski, the Polish man who was tasered last month by RCMP at Vancouver International Airport.

Don't expect any of these probes to touch on the real cause of this man's untimely demise: institutional arrogance, which starts in Premier Gordon Campbell's office and extends into the upper ranks of the RCMP and the coroner's office.

For years, human-rights lawyers such as Cameron Ward, have pointed out the obvious problem of having a former RCMP officer in charge of the coroner's office. Terry Smith, the former RCMP superintendent in Surrey, is only the latest example.

The premier didn't feel that Ward's concerns were worth addressing. The premier isn't big on the notion that justice must not only be done, it must also be seen to be done.

Smith's office reports to B.C.'s solicitor general, who was also a former RCMP officer during Campbell's first term. The current solicitor general, John Les, might as well be a former cop when you listen to him defend police.

The coroner's office has a statutory responsibility for investigating in-custody deaths.

As long as the provincial government keeps installing former RCMP officers as the chief coroner, police officers across the province know they have one of their own in a key oversight position.

Before Smith was chief coroner, the position was occupied by blowhard Senator Larry Campbell, who didn't feel that the disgusting treatment and death of Frank Paul was worthy of an inquest.

Other provinces appoint people with medical expertise to head the coroner's office. Not this premier and not this solicitor general.

The consequences extend beyond the investigation into in-custody deaths, which is conducted by the police, thanks again to Les and Campbell.

The chief coroner can also ensure that police-friendly lawyers are appointed as the coroner's counsel at coroner's inquests. This reduces the chance of uncomfortable questions being asked of police at inquests into in-custody deaths.

The provincial government won't pay legal aid to ensure that the families of victims are represented. Chalk up another one in favour of the cops.

Is it any wonder that police didn't show much restraint in using tasers against Dziekanski, even though there had already been more than a dozen other deaths following taser attacks in Canada?

Two days after the attack, former Vancouver police chief and former RCMP superintendent Jamie Graham was crowing on the radio about how useful tasers are.

The police at the airport planned to use tasers before they even reached the man and evaluated his condition, according to the tape released yesterday. The police used their tasers within 30 seconds, even though Dziekanski appeared to be surrendering.

But why should police show any restraint? They likely knew that there would be no consequences. There almost never are.

Vancouver's taser death is now being shown around the world. It has harmed our country's reputation, and it might even cause a few tourists to reconsider visiting Canada in the future. It has undoubtedly damaged relations with the Polish people.

It has brought shame upon our country.

It's outrageous that the head of the Vancouver International Airport Authority, Larry Berg, waited weeks before speaking publicly.

Long ago, the federal government turned the airport loose by creating an "authority", meaning there was no longer a minister responsible for its operations.

Why should Berg have stepped forward earlier? He's not really accountable to anyone except his board of directors. Campbell doesn't care that there is no real public oversight and accountability. Nor does Prime Minister Stephen Harper. They see our publicly owned airport as little more than a business.

Nothing is likely to change as a result of this taser death because our arrogant and grossly overpaid leaders think they know better than the rest of us.

They see nothing wrong with putting cops in charge of investigating cops. They see nothing wrong with eliminating any real public accountability around publicly owned facilities, such as the airport and the ferry terminal.

They should be ashamed of themselves for having such contempt for democracy, accountability, and for the common people. But there won't be any shame because it's not possible for the most arrogant among us to experience that feeling.

Post New Comment

Comments Disclaimer

How can Vancouver call itself a "world-class city," good enough to host the Winter Olympic Games, when a non-English-speaker like Robert Dziekanski is tasered and tackled by police simply because he can't make himself understood? What are we going to do when all those foreigners, some of whom will surely not speak much, if any, English, come to Vancouver in 2010? Sure, we're willing to shell out millions and millions of dollars on the Canada Line and other overpriced Olympic venues, but are we putting any money or even any consideration into ensuring professional translation and interpretation services will be available to assist people who come for the Olympics? Seeing as we haven't heard much, if anything, on this topic, the public should be worried. The only consollation? When a foreigner dies due to a misunderstanding during the 2010 Olympic Games in Vancouver, this time, THE WORLD WILL BE WATCHING.

It doesn't surprise me to hear that Jamie Graham is championing a randomly lethal weapon that has been, time after time, used without restraint. Graham's disdain for the concept of restraint was clearly shown when he left the bullet-riddled target sign on the city manager's desk.

I can not believe the RCMP's judgement in this particular death, unbelievable.

What caliber of policemen is Depo producing??

The video tape says it all, four police officiers with weapons versus an unarmed polish man with a language barrier.

If four men cannot submit one unarmed man, they should not be on the force.

Green, green, rookie mistakes.

My father and two uncles were RCMP officiers and I have two uncles who are city policeman, all agreed that these officiers are a laughing stock.

Of course the department covers there own. What a joke.

The police are only showing how afraid they are by using tasers all the time. To pretend you have control over a situation by tasering first and asking questions later just shows the fear of the police department. The police would have less fear if they were trained more in situations like this. Lots of people are trained heavily in dealing with far more out of control people then Dziekanski. Nurses do it every day, they don't pull out tasers. The police seem to show a complete lack of understanding of these situations, the taser has ended up with a false sense of security for the police, something they have been convinced is a good thing by the makers of tasers. The use of a Taser for them is a way of eliminating the situation they obviously have fear of and seem untrained to deal with. Many professionals have to go through years of training to deal with difficult situations like this. The police don't go through years many have very little in the way of people skills and are just handed a weapon that has very little testing done. it always seem the police just hide behind the "authority" ticket they are handed after a short amount of training compared to other professionals dealing with people every day. They are right and if you disagree you will be either tasered or charged with obstruction. Hardly helping people.

Hey B -

I see your point: that the police feel a false sense of security because of their weapons, a sense that robs them of their ability to de-escalate situations. I think that's true.

I think it's probably overly generalizing to say that if you disagree with the police you will either be tasered or charged with obstruction. I'm sure (or at least, I hope) there's a wider range than that, including them saying, "Okay, let's disagree - without bloodshed."

After all, the police are human. Underneath all that battle gear.

You might be interested in reading a nurse's take on Tasering.