Number of homeless in Canada is "pretty fuzzy", expert says

A day before he began a weeklong hunger strike calling for a national social housing program, Michael Byers, a political-science professor at the University of British Columbia, sent an e-mail to his supporters.

"Fasting for an entire week is a very uncomfortable experience," Byers, a former federal NDP candidate in Vancouver Centre, wrote in his January 4 message. "But it is unconscionable that there are 100s of thousands of homeless people in this country today."

One reader who commented on a Straight story on the hunger strike took issue with Byers’s approximation of Canada’s homeless population.

"Really? Doesn’t that seem a little high? I haven’t seen any reliable stats on the homeless count, but would be interested to hear where he’s getting that," Brent Wittmeier wrote on January 7 in response to an article by reporter Matthew Burrows.

Byers’s fast will end on Monday (January 12). It’s part of a hunger-strike relay kicked off on December 29 by Vancouver housing activist Am Johal, who hopes the protest will continue until the Winter Olympic Games open in 2010. Sarah Evans, manager of HIV/AIDS and harm reduction programs at Vancouver Coastal Health, will take on the third leg of the relay.

Looking for answer to Wittmeier’s question, the Straight called the Wellesley Institute in Toronto and spoke to Michael Shapcott, a leading housing-policy expert who’s the organization’s director of community engagement.

According to Shapcott, Byers isn’t exaggerating the size of the problem. Advocates began saying there are 300,000 homeless people in Canada about 10 years ago. That figure was extrapolated from a study of homelessness in Toronto.

The actual number of homeless people in the country is unknown, and any estimates we do have just represent the “tip of the iceberg”, Shapcott said. Although it’s easy to count those in homeless shelters, it’s difficult to find out how many “rough sleepers” are living on the streets and “couch surfers” are staying temporarily with friends and family, he explained.

Another problem, Shapcott noted, is that Statistics Canada misses a large number of people when it conducts a census.

“If we don’t know the scale of the problem, we don’t know how big the solution needs to be,” he said.

Housing groups are asking Finance Minister Jim Flaherty to invest $2.5 billion of the January 27 federal budget in affordable housing. That cash could create between 30,000 and 50,000 new homes, according to Shapcott.

“Unfortunately, some politicians do use the fact that we’re pretty fuzzy about the specifics—because we simply don’t have the numbers—as an excuse not to do anything,” he said. “That’s got to stop.”

Shapcott said he supports the hunger-strike relay begun in Vancouver and plans to take on a leg of the protest.

“I haven’t formally committed to it, but I certainly will do it,” he said.

Comments

BajaWind
being unwanted is more painful than being hungry. M.T.
sounds like Michael is on a Homeless Holiday: http://hhinvite.blogspot.com/
 
Brent Wittmeier
Thanks for following up on my question.
I realize it's a really difficult logistical problem to count the homeless. And Shapcott's right, it's no excuse for inaction.
But there has to be a better way than extrapolating Toronto numbers!
 
BajaWind
there is already too much starving in BC. we need beds, storage, meals, rooms, clothes baths phones, computers, tools, jobs, places to do good...to be together supportig each other. not isolated in dingy rooms.
 
FoggyView
Homelessness is an age old situation. It can't be magicaly swept away. If we provide more services and housing, more homless people will come. Vancouver is attractive to the homeless because of it's moderate weather. Throw in free housing and what not, only makes Vancouver more attractive. The bulk of the homeless population would migrate to the lower mainland in time and create an even bigger problem. I compare it to traffic. If you build bigger rods, more lanes and wider highways to reduce congestion, you can provide better transportation routes to comuters but creat more traffic and polution. Offer free housing and such, at the tax payers expence, attract more homeless folk and a need for more housing and such at the expense of the tax payer. I don't know what the answer is, but maybe if we didn't import everything from China we would at least have jobs in manufacturing that would let people earn a living wage...which might keep them off the streets.
 
ALikelyStory
I have personally served many meals at different locations to the homeless in Vancouver. Judging from my own experience, there is no reason a homeless person has to go hungry. There are a lot of groups who pitch in. A real sacrifice for Mr. Byers and others would be to live on the street for a week. He'd truly be walking the walk then.
 
Mich Cat
Homeless youth is growing at an alarming rate. I hope that these
kids get any important help that they need. This is not something
that anyone wants to deal with in life. As a good community we
must take control of it before it controls us. Good luck to the youth
and their street dogs... Life can get better, if you make it happen!
 
someonelikeyou
I think it is just a sin that there are so many people homeless in Canada,some are turned down by the shelter homes and some just dont get a second chance from their family,about 4 years ago me and my husband found a little girl on the streets of new york and we took her in and just this year it was approved that she can legally be ours,since 4 years ago me and my husband has made our home a shelter home for homeless people, altogether now we have 6 elders,4 woman,and 8 men staying at our place,we have upgraded our house to 20 rooms and 5 bath rooms,we get money and clothes donated to us for the wonderful job that we are doing,and since we had this home open, 5 of our take ins have found their way back to their families and are now living a happy life.....think about it,what if you were homeless? what would you want someone to do for you?
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.