Becci Gindin-Clarke: Foie gras is a cruel dish better left unserved

By Becci Gindin-Clarke

To some, foie gras represents the ultimate in luxury food. In reality, it is one of the most extreme forms of cruelty still permitted today, and yet it appears on the menus of many of Vancouver’s finest restaurants.

Foie gras is the liver of ducks who have been force-fed with a mechanical pump almost to the point of death. The purpose of this process is to swell the liver up to 10 times its normal size, so that it becomes fatty and extremely rich.

Canadian foie gras comes from Quebec, where 500,000 ducks are killed annually for foie gras. The majority comes from three producers, each of which slaughters in excess of 2,000 ducks each week. In these factory farms, ducks are raised in large, enclosed sheds. Some farms have small, crowded pens in which a few ducks are kept; others restrain each duck in an individual cage.

Two to three times each day, a farm worker goes down the line, grabs each bird, and forces a metal pipe down his throat. A machine pumps a corn-meal mixture directly into the duck’s stomach in only a few seconds. Each duck is force-fed up to one-third of his body weight in food each day. After two weeks, they are slaughtered.

The process of force-feeding enlarges the liver so dramatically that other organs are pushed to the side, making breathing difficult. The ducks must struggle to stand and can barely walk; they have been observed attempting to push themselves forward with their wings when their legs can no longer support their swollen bodies. During the force-feeding process, bills are cracked, tongues are torn, and necks are punctured by the metal feeding tubes.

The Global Action Network’s undercover investigations at Quebec’s foie gras farms have shown ducks vomiting bright-red, bloodstained food from their damaged throats. Necropsied foie gras birds frequently reveal signs of trauma—scarring, lacerations, and bacterial and fungal infections. Not surprisingly, the B.C. SPCA opposes foie gras, describing force-feeding as an “intrusive, stressful and painful experience”.

Why would anybody defend this wholly unnecessary “delicacy”?

Sixteen countries have outlawed the practice of force-feeding. Israel, once the world’s fourth-largest producer, banned it in 2005 because of animal welfare concerns. California has passed a law that will ban the production and sale of foie gras by 2012.

Chicago passed a nearly unanimous ban on the sale of foie gras which was repealed two years later through some sneaky political maneuvering. How would such a ban fare in Vancouver? Are our politicians willing to take a stand and stick to it like California, or would they wimp out like Chicago? The NPA-heavy council voted to ban rodeos in Vancouver. Is the current Vision Vancouver-led council going to be more or less progressive on animal welfare issues?

At Liberation B.C., we are hopeful that positive change will come about in Vancouver under Mayor Gregor Robertson’s leadership. We have been engaging the public and collecting petition signatures in favour of a ban on the sale of foie gras, and the support we’ve received has been overwhelming.

Becci Gindin-Clarke is a director of Liberation B.C.

Comments

ggaetz
Well-written and well-thought-out. A very nice article about this troubling and sad dish. Thanks for posting it!
 
ducksrock
Foie gras is so cruel I can't believe we still allow this to be sold in our country! I don't see why Gregor Robertson's council would not ban this ridiculous product. Who would want to defend torturing ducks with metal pipes?
 
foodl
Thank you for a liberating article. The animals deserve better and people need to make more humane choices !
 
Angelcake
Excellent article, we need more reality of animal cruelty like this one. Maybe people that read this article who thought ignorance was bliss will think next time and open their eyes to the cruelty. One of the biggest things we can do for going 'green' is to stop this horror!
 
alisonc
Good article. Thank you for bringing awareness of this cruelty to those who still aren't aware. I hope to see Vancouver following in the footsteps of these other places that have banned this barbaric and unnecessary product.
 
gwen
Very well written and informative article.Now,after reading this,how could anyone decide it is ok to eat this cruel and inhumane 'delicasy'? If the term "you are what you eat" is true,then the people who choose to injest foie gras are pro-violence people who choose their body as a burial ground for these poor,suffering birds.
 
Miranda Nelson
"Israel, once the world’s fourth-largest producer, banned it in 2005 because of animal welfare concerns."

I'm glad to see Israel is adopting such a progressive policy towards animal-rights concerns. I'm sure the 1000+ Palestinians that have been killed in the last month by Israeli forces will be very glad that no one in the area is eating duck liver.
 
wookie
interesting read. had no idea. thanks.
 
Amanda Daniell
It is amazing to me that our Vancouver chef's have the incredible lack of compassion to use anything they consider a delicacy. Where is their sense of morals, ethics or even humanity?
 
ambrosem
Thanks for raising awareness on this issue.

After reading how this product is produced I wonder if anyone could still eat it?

I know I couldn't.
 
MrMann
Miranda, do you mean that as long as a country kills people, they should have all the right to torture animals too? In that case, we should legalize dog fighting and get the restaurants to start serving live monkey brains. I mean, as long as Canada is involved in wars and killing people, we might as well torture the heck out of every animal we can!
 
Lish
It is long overdue for the Straight to have an article with the facts about foie gras production. To many times I have had to read local chefs gushing about this grotesque item. Foie gras has no place in a civil society. I for one will support any attempt to ban foie grasd in Vancouver.
 
Miranda Nelson
@MrMann: I'm really disappointed that you missed my actual point, which is that maybe a country that's so progressive on protecting its animals should have that sort of dedication to human rights as well. It doesn't seem hypocritical to you that Israel thinks it's unacceptable to torture animals but has no problems taking human life?

I'm not advocating animal torture—quite the opposite, in fact. Animals should be treated with kindness and humanity. I just think humans should, too.
 
carolgigliotti
Excellent article. I want to commend the Straight for printing this article and offer my support in printing more articles about the plight of animals. Long overdue! Thanks!

 
west coaster
Sadly, most people who eat torture don't want to think about it. Otherwise, how could they continue to eat animals, period? Do the majority bother to pay any attention to where their food comes from, who killed it, or how? No, obviously not.
Establisments that want to defend foie gross as a delicacy need to be shamed out of their trade in cruelty, but the consumers who claim ignorance are just as much to blame. Supply and demand, folks. There will always be people who have no idea what it means to excercise mercy, but I applaud Liberation BC and the Strait for exposing the truth in such an accessible, tangible way to the general public. It's up to everyone not to turn a blind eye to the most obvious perversions out there, and foie gros is absolutely one of them.

 
nofishfarms
I am hoping that people realize we need to ban this cruelty in Vancouver, in British Columbia, and in Canada as they have done elsewhere. Why people would choose to eat the "diseased" livers of birds I'll never know.
 
Annie
I believe Vancouver stands on the brink of becoming a cruelty-free zone, where things of this sort will not be allowed, where no cruelly-derived product can be bought or sold, where animal laboratories will be converted to true 'Centres of Excellence' rather than torture chambers, and both humans and animals will be treated with respect. The reason I believe this will come about? People like Becci Gindin-Clarke and those who listen to her message: there is a great reservoir of kindness here, and making people aware of issues such as foie gras is all that is lacking for us to tap into it.
 
alissraye
Great article, Becci! Yes, Vancouver should ban foie gras.. and continue to question all sorts of ways that we abuse and exploit animals for nothing more than our own mindless tastes and fancies. We need to become more conscious of where ALL of our food comes from.

I hope to read more from you regarding all sorts of animal exploitation issues. This kind of voice is way overdue in The Straight.
Kudos!
 
lady_familiar
Really a great article that lays it all out there. Hopefully BC is paying attention and does something to stop this.
 
Layla
Foie gras most definitely should be banned... in Vancouver and everywhere. I, for one, will not frequent any establishment that sells this barbaric product.

Laura K
Vancouver
 
Whitedeer
Excellent Article! Thank you so much for enlightening me to the horrors of foie gras, I can honestly say that I am shocked to learn that this type of farming even exists in Canada (or anywhere else for that matter). I do not know how people can eat something like this knowing how it is produced; and the moral standing of the chefs who cook it should be called into question as well. Thank you so much for this article!! Please keep us posted. I will tell all of my friends! Go for a ban Vancouver!!
 
Philippa1986
Philippa Holland
I am so pleased that someone has once again brought this to the attention of the public. Anyone with any sort of feeling or moral will understand that this is wrong. Foie Gras... don't we have enough food on the menus already? Do we need to torture more and more animals innocent creatures to feed our appetites? Can you not se the madness in that. Please, next time make a different choice on the menu. Don't keep giving them a reason to continue the toture, they have just as much right to be here as me and you. Please eat with a conscience.
 
retrobabe225
Disgusting dish and those who consume it knowing the background to how these livers are 'farmed' are just as disgusting. But that's the problem - not enough people do know. Ban it all
 
Paula Young
Oh my goodness! What terrible torture for the ducks! I can't even imagine the greed of the people who thought up this idea in the first place! There must be a better way to make a living...

I sure hope that those in a position to do so will ban this practice and the food itself. : (

Thank you so much for your efforts to educate the public and the politicians.
 
Gap_flash
I just don't understand how these people can do this for a living. I would choose being poor in a heartbeat if my only alternative were to make poor defenseless animals suffer this way on a daily basis. Seriously, not only should we ban foie gras, we must put those farmers behind bars!!!
 
dpwell
Thanks for writing this article. The production of FG is barbaric and a disgrace. I'd like to believe that most people who eat FG have no idea how it's produced, and would stop if they did. So articles like this are a great help to that end. Hopefully at least some people who read this will stop buying the stuff.
 
KKnowles
Hurrah Liberation BC and to everyone who works to spread awareness of the extreme cruelty associated with this 'delicacy'. It is simply unacceptable for civilized societies to allow such a cruel practice to be perpetrated on living, sentient beings. Please Gregor, do the right thing and let's make Vancouver an example for the rest of the country!
 
interactbiz
NRF

The Straight article makes no effort to be balanced and factual. For example, it claims that Chicago repealed its ban on fois gras "through some sneaky political maneuvering." Real sneaky: city council voted 37-6 to repeal the law after the Mayor said it was the "silliest ordinance" the city council ever passed and it made Chicago "the laughingstock of the nation."

The American Veterinary Medical Association examined the foie gras issue and concluded that potential risks to animals can be mitigated by effective management. They found that empirical research addressing health and welfare states of bird production is limited in both quantity and quality. Becci Gindin-Clarke seems unbothered by that information gap.

Will meatless warriors be satisfied if farmers stop forced feedings? Of course not. The goal is to turn us all into vegans, whether by persuasion or coercion.
 
Fujiappleman
Here are some things to add to the list of things that need to be banned in Vancouver: Chicken (non-organic), any conventional vegetables produced with harmful pesticides, and bottled water. Well that was just to name a few -- we should pretty much just close up the grocery stores and make people do it themselves. If you don't have the stomach to slaughter it, you shouldn't eat it.
Back to the original topic. I applaud people that become informed about issues and voice a logical, well formulated argument and I encourage such debate. However, I ask the question why Liberation BC slanders a number of fine establishments in the city that promote some of the most wholesome and balanced culinary programs in Vancouver, yet allow many other more influential establishments (aka supermarkets that shall remain nameless) carry on what they are doing and polluting a far greater portion of the population?
Priorty #1 in BC's culinary world is not a ban on foie gras. Although I sympathise with and understand the position against some foie gras production, Liberation BC wastes the public's time with these miniscule publicity stunts while choosing not to tackle the bigger, tougher issues that are confronting us today. More people in our generation will be harmed by obesity than foie gras production or consumption, therefore I would ask Lib BC to crawl back into their self-aggrandizing cave and emerge when they have a comprehensive, logical, and action-oriented program to liberate BC from the biggest evils that haunt our culinary world.
 
interactbiz
NRF
I spent a day on a small bird farm in the Perigord. The woman showed how they fed their geese and explained that the birds must be handled gently because, if they were not, the quality of production would suffer. This young family produced ducks and geese with respect, most birds wandered freely in an orchard pasture, not even bothered by young children and a dog playing nearby. Compare that to a battery chicken farm in the Fraser Valley with tens of thousand of chicken stuffed together. Or, the feedlots where steers and hogs stand in excrement, waiting for the abattoir. Come on vegans, choose your targets with sense.
 
ggaetz
I have seen countless videos of the current intensive farming operations - which is where all of Vancouver's foie gras comes from. That this intensive and destructive farming practice is allowed to continue is very disturbing.
 
WildTreeLeaf
Foie Gras is disgustingly suffering inflicted upon feeling beings and should be banned.
 
beccigc
The American Veterinary Medical Association examined the foie gras issue and concluded that potential risks to animals can be mitigated by effective management. They found that empirical research addressing health and welfare states of bird production is limited in both quantity and quality. Becci Gindin-Clarke seems unbothered by that information gap.

Hi, interactbiz. This is the author here.

Thank you for your comment. You'll be relieved to know that I did recognize this "information gap", and to figure out exactly what was going on, I did some research.

As a result, our website has a good deal of information on this very issue. You might be interested to know that the AVMA has also not come out against gestation crates for pigs or forced molting and battery cages for egg-laying chickens, which are both practices that individuals such as yourself recognize as morally indefensible. The AVMA has traditionally sided with the industry; their animal welfare committee has, on the other hand, recommended that the House of Delegates adopt the following position: "Resolved, that the AVMA opposes the practice of mechanical force feeding of ducks and geese to produce foie gras because of the adverse effects on the birds' health and welfare associated with this practice."

If you would like more information, you can check out the full research here: http://liberationbc.org/campaigns/foie_gras/fuel_facts

As for your second comment, in which you suggest we choose our targets more carefully, I would recommend you once again check our website. There you will see that Liberation BC's most major campaigns have been specifically against the factory farmed chicken and turkey you (very appropriately) malign.

Thank you again for your input.
 
AndyWang
Gosh, thanks for posting this article. It opened my eyes to cruel "cuisine". Foie gras is definitely one....I heard from somewhere that veal is also obtained by confining poor young calves in small cages so that they cannot move for the rest of their lives until they are killed. Is this true ? If so, it's so sad.
 
Chef Stefan
This is such a onesided and rediculous article. Any human being who is eating any kind of meat should be ashamed to even consider the legetimacy of these rantings. The same argument could be used for cattle farming, chicken farming etc. why not go further....farming of any kind, destroys large areas of land mass and forces relocation of many wild animals causing them stress............................lets get real about this we are human and we eat other animals.

culinarydesignsolutions.wordpress.com
 
SoberReasoning
ya, it's cruel but then again, all commercial meat production is cruel. Cruel or not, I like my foie grois once a year :)
 
Sable Marten
It is shameful that Robert Belcham and his gang of talentless goons continue to profit off of the torture, force feeding and murder of these innocentducks. Any chef or restaurant that has a hope of staying in business or creating any kind of positive reputation for themselves must learn actual culinary skills. Real food cannot come from tortured, factory farmed animals. Come on Belcham, drop foie gras and do what's right.
 
Halifax Guy
You are kidding right ? Do your research.....yes there are instances of what you speak of but it's not wide spread as you suggest......Everything we eat is "killed" in one sense or the other. Unless we all start eathing grass (also living).......we will always have these issues. Perhaps more people should become farmers and achieve this utopia they speak of.....otherwise.......if you settle for large producers or grocery stores........well.......
 
Foodie
I would write an article in SUPPORT of foie gras. As far as natural products go, this is far more natural than most of the commercial chicken, beef, and pork you will ever buy! Goose and duck meat are almost always free range and rarely locked in cages like commercial chickens are. The force feeding process itself is done by hand in a manner analogous to say a human sword-swallower or a party-goer bonging a bottle of beer - extending the neck back (as in looking up) straightens the esophagus and gives a direct line to the stomach, which allows sword-swallowers to pass the blade straight down, or allowing some grain to go down the neck of a goose. This is NOT torture!

I would much rather buy a small quantity of foie gras once or twice a year, than the vast amount of commercial, antibiotic-laden beef, chicken, and pork that are produced. These animals are the source of major environmental problems - from antibiotic-resistant bacteria, to greenhouse gas, and land-fill waste management!

I am saddened and disappointed by the amount of emotional rhetoric surrounding this "animal cruelty", when far crueler and devious practices are being performed by Big Business so that you can buy cheap meat at the grocery store. Use your brains, not your hearts, and set loftier priorities instead: boycott large commercial meat operations that clearly have a larger societal/environmental impact than the relatively unimportant foie gras issue...
 
Omegaboy
Well, I believe force feeding animals is cruel but I am wholly more concern with human atrocities such as killings of neighbors, brothers and sisters in Africa, in the Middle East and wherever it may occur. My wish is to have no killings of living things but that is not possible so I was wondering perhaps we could channel our voices and energies towards our repugnance of human suffering instead. Remember Rwanda? Where were our voices then? Silence is not always Golden. Foie Gras.....Rwanda.....seems trivial now doesn't it? Not to down play the sufferings of animals but rather to demonstrate the spectrum.
 
repentant
I'm sorry - it's delicious.
 
nofoiegras
Great article! I encourage anyone who has a problem with foie gras to stop going to restaurants where they serve it. Or if you do go, let them know that you disapprove! I think a ban is within reach, the sooner the better.
 
only thing is food
This is ridiculous. you guys r out of your mind. try to pretend you guys are all kindness? It's like those ladies see a deaf and keep saying owwwwwwwwww~ so saaaaaaaaaaaad~~he/she is a deaaaaaaaaaf. owwwwwwwww i always cry T.T
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.

Liberation B.C. is calling for the removal of foie gras from Vancouver restaurant menus.
Liberation B.C. is calling for the removal of foie gras from Vancouver restaurant menus.