Did my questions provoke Gordon Campbell's promise to small business?

    1 of 1 2 of 1

      I think it's  fair to say that Premier Gordon Campbell's government has not treated the Georgia Straight with the utmost respect over the years.

      A few years ago, the government sent auditors into our family-owned company offices and tried to impose provincial-sales taxes on our newsprint purchases. This fee was not  levied  on big out-of-province publishers, like Canwest Global Communications Corp. The government tried to justify it by claiming that the Georgia Straight is not a newspaper, and newspapers are exempt from paying this tax.

      The Georgia Straight spent more than $80,000 on legal bills to convince the government that it is indeed a newspaper. One of the province's best-known lawyers contacted the government, which did nothing. Only after we held a news conference did the Campbell government back down. The publisher never received an apology.

      The premier's office also declined several  interview requests from the Georgia Straight, a family-owned business, after he was elected in 2001. But the premier regularly visited big corporate media outlets, which usually treated him with kid gloves.

      So we were denied access as well. He didn't have a one-on-one conversation with a Georgia Straight journalist during his entire eight years in office. I guess that's because it's not a newspaper.

      In addition, the Campbell government has had an impact on the company's revenues. The B.C. Liberal government frequently bypassed the Georgia Straight with its advertising buys.

      Big campaigns like the "Best Place on Earth", the "Conversation on Health", and a recent two-page ad campaign highlighting the government's climate-change policies were placed in newspapers owned by Canwest, a  corporation with a head office in Winnipeg,  and other big media.

      But they weren't placed in the Georgia Straight, which is a locally owned family business.

      Two local magazines recently ceased publishing in Vancouver. I wonder if they were bypassed by the Campbell government as well,  and if this contributed to their demise.

      Today, you'll see a full-page, taxpayer-financed  ad on page A5 of the Vancouver Sun, which is owned by a big out-of-province  business. It's celebrating the opening of the Vancouver Convention and Exhibition Centre. You won't see that ad in the Georgia Straight.

      I don't want to belabour this point and  I'm not writing these words to curry sympathy. It's just the reality of operating a family-owned business in Vancouver. I'm using our company as a microcosm to demonstrate  the bigger picture: the  Campbell government  has a record of favouring big businesses  over smaller businesses, and some of these big businesses happen  to be large campaign contributors.

      We've managed quite well despite all this because we have an outstanding staff who create a product that the public wants to read. I'm not crying the blues.

      By now, you might be wondering how all of this connects to the headline: "Did my questions provoke Gordon Campbell's promise to small business?"

      This week, much to my surprise, the premier actually paid a visit to our office for the first time since he was elected. We had to clear the topics in advance with his press secretary, Bridgitte Anderson.

      I guessed that the premier wouldn't consent to an interview if we were to ask about Patrick Kinsella, child poverty, or the lack of women with real power in his cabinet. So we offered up these two topics: transportation and small business. We were  told we would get  a half hour.

      I spent the weekend thinking about how to best use that very, very, very rare opportunity to ask the premier some questions. Much to my chagrin, I was told upon his arrival that we would only get 20 minutes because the premier was running behind schedule.

      I wondered at the time if this is what he told the Canwest editors when he showed up for editorial board meetings in its offices.

      Despite this, we soldiered on. Reporter Matthew Burrows asked some excellent questions about the Gateway program. On Thursday (April 9), you can read the premier's responses in the printed edition of the Georgia Straight, which will be distributed across Metro Vancouver, or watch a video of the interview at Straight.com.

      I  demanded answers from the premier on his treatment of small businesses. I asked about the Georgia Straight. I  inquired why ads were placed in Canwest papers but not in this locally owned family business.

      I asked about his four  meetings with Dennis Skulsky, the CEO of Canwest MediaWorks, in his office during his first term, and pointed out that the premier has also met privately with Skulsky's boss, Leonard Asper. I asked what the premier discussed with Skulsky in his office.

      At one point, I raised the fact that Canwest contributed $50,000 to the B.C. Liberals in 2005--at which point the press secretary interrupted and claimed I was sandbagging the premier.

      To the premier's credit, he patiently answered all of my questions. We'll bring you that later in the campaign.

      I also asked him why his government never compensated merchants on Cambie Street. I sought answers about what types of businesses will have to pay a new  convention-centre tax, which his government approved in 2004.

      My last question in this segment concerned why the premier won't level the playing field for small business by imposing limits on campaign contributions by big unions and big business. When the story appears, we'll post the video on our site.

      And I also asked why he hasn't made B.C. a leader in the taxation of small businesses.

      I relied on a recent report from the Canadian Federation of Independent Business, which I wrote about on this site a few days ago. It showed that B.C. was in the middle of the pack, and fared particularly poorly on sales and excise taxes.

      The premier acknowledged that he read my story, but he hadn't read the report.

      The next day, his government issued a short news release saying B.C.'s small-business tax will be the lowest in Canada by 2012.

      Vancouver Sun columnist Don Cayo wrote this morning that the announcement was not only "bereft of details", but "it seemed to catch the finance department flat-footed".

      In other words, it was a back-of-the-envelope announcement probably issued as a defence against a coming feature story in the Georgia Straight, which might expose how the premier actually favours big business over small business. It's typical of what we've come to expect from  our  one-man government.

      Small-business owners across the province are probably hoping that this latest  promise  on taxation--which was apparently done with no bureaucratic input--carries more weight than the premier's previous promise to create the most open and accountable government in Canada.

      I'm not even going to get into his promise not to sell B.C. Rail. Otherwise, this post will never end.

      Comments

      6 Comments

      Chrystal Ocean

      Apr 8, 2009 at 9:22am

      "My last question in this segment concerned why the premier won't level the playing field for small business by imposing limits on campaign contributions by big unions and big business. When the story appears, we'll post the video on our site."

      Am looking forward to reading Campbell's answers to your questions, particularly that last one!

      Travis Lupick

      Apr 8, 2009 at 10:17am

      Funny Campbell can only give the Straight 20 minutes in eight years but can find time to spend a full hour with Bill Good on CKNW this morning.

      MauriceCardinal

      Apr 8, 2009 at 11:29am

      It's a good thing you're not a newspaper Charlie, because what I've seen lately is that newspapers are all teetering on bankruptcy.

      It says a lot when a newspaper is scared to include a COMMENT section on their important articles.

      It's what happens when you think advertisers are your customers.

      Breaking news for The Sun - readers are your customers, not VANOC.

      The music industry made the same mistake.

      Canwest was just given another two week reprieve with the hope government will bail them out.

      Corruption runs rampant in this province.

      davemacdonald

      Apr 8, 2009 at 8:16pm

      I attended his speech on leadership at the new Convention Centre on Tuesday and it was a great speech. Unfortunately, knowing how to represent leadership and leading all British Columbians are two separate things.

      The fact he felt compelled to present this talk on leadership to the business community rather than regular citizens speaks volumes, I think.

      His best reference to small business innovating the province was Plutonic Power - an organization smack in the middle of the run of river power controversy. I think he gets the 'concept' of small business, but he doesn't understand that small business can also mean really-small businesses where livelihoods hang in the balance every day.

      He was also anxiously touting the "lowest taxes by 2012" line which was quite well received by the Vancouver Board of Trade, Chamber of Commerce and Business Council of BC - the kinds of not-so-really-small business that he gets.

      Looking forward to the upcoming piece and video!

      Charlie Smith

      Apr 8, 2009 at 11:05pm

      Premier Campbell's "lowest taxes by 2012" wasn't a coincidence. The government has three-year service plans, which are required under the law. Because smaller business is so low on the B.C. Liberal priority list, this issue wasn't dealt with in the budget. But when he was asked about it by me -- and he suddenly realized that his election campaign was a bit of a charade in that it was predicated on his concern for small business -- he had to fix this immediately.

      But because the budget planning was completed for a three-year cycle, he dreamed up the date 2012. That way, he's outside of the time horizon for the budget. And people like me can't say: "Jeez Mr. Premier, if you're so concerned about small business, why didn't you include this goal in your budget and show us how you were going to get there through the Ministry of Finance's three-year service plan?"

      Will the boys who speak to the B.C. Chamber of Commerce annual meetings (Vaughn Palmer and Keith Baldrey) report on this? I doubt it. I'm still waiting to find out how much, if anything, they're getting paid to speak to this group, which is headed by the front man for the premier's small-business endorser. (B.C. chamber president John Winter is spokesperson for jobsforbc.com, which was created to promote the B.C. Liberals by the Coalition of B.C. Businesses, a registered election advertising sponsor.).

      If Palmer and Baldrey decide to post something on this site telling us how much, if anything, they're getting paid by the B.C. Chamber of Commerce to speak at the next a.g.m. starting on May 21, perhaps they can also take the time to say how much, if anything, they were paid for speaking at the B.C. chamber's annual bunfest last year.

      Did John Winter's group give Palmer and Baldrey a raise in an election year? Just wondering.

      anna17

      Apr 9, 2009 at 1:15pm

      Good comment, Travis. I heard that pathetically sycophantic interview on my way to a dentist appointment.