Conservatives should condemn Stephen Harper's gutter politics

This week, I stumbled across another piece of garbage  sent through  the mail  by a Conservative MP.

Download


Michael Ignatieff: Just visiting

This one featured a "pop quiz". It asked  how long Liberal Leader  Michael Ignatieff was  away from Canada.

On the flip side, it contained the Conservative slogan "Ignatieff: Just visiting".

There was not a word about public policies, plans, or issues--just a vicious personal attack on the Opposition leader.

I wonder what thoughtful conservatives think of these tactics, which are so typical of Prime Minister Stephen Harper.

Harper seems to think that if you treat the public like they're idiots, you have a better chance of getting reelected.

It's time for people like Senator Hugh Segal, former federal cabinet ministers John Crosbie and John Fraser, and former prime ministers Kim Campbell and Joe Clark to stand up and condemn this nonsense.

Harper is debasing our political culture. As we've seen in the United States, whenever this occurs, there's a corresponding decline in political literacy.

That's  likely followed by reckless policies that can bankrupt the nation and lead it into perpetual war.

It's time for conservatives to say enough is enough. The ends don't always justify the means.

Comments

Ruth Seeley
This is one of the most politically naive things I've ever seen. I notice you're suggesting that only those Conservatives who don't have to worry about being re-elected break ranks to condemn Harper. What on earth do you think they would have to gain by doing so publicly? Do you seriously think he'd be shamed into behaving better? The pressure on Harper needs to be exerted publicly by ALL the other political parties, and privately by Conservatives who disagree. While I would be happy personally to see the Conversative Party disappear completely, the Conservatives don't feel that way, and a public debate on this issue would have that effect. Perhaps that's the hidden subtext of your column though.
 
Charlie Smith
I have a hunch that Conservative MPs who are collecting salaries greater than $150K per year are not likely to speak out. That's why I mentioned those who aren't in Parliament. Harper won't be shamed into changing his behaviour, just as Gordon Campbell can't be shamed for his contributions to child poverty with draconian welfare policies directed at single mothers. However, Harper can be persuaded to change if he senses it's in his best interest not to debase our political culture. Will it happen? Probably not.
 
Margaret
I agree, 100%. It's not going to happen though. Gutter politics and lying have become a part of the fabric of the Conservative Party now.
Nobody can "shame" Harper. Harper has no idea how to behave. He needs Ignatieff around to tell him how to be Prime Minister, and how to behave properly. Summer vacation, Ignatieff's gone, and Harper shoots himself in the foot twice.
 
Karol
Keep it simple Charlie,
Ignatieff is just visiting Canada.
What is wrong with that message??
 
seth
Because it works.

It is a a well known fascist election tactic to keep as many voters at home as possible - they're all a buncha crooks tactic. The 'She's just not ready" series of commercials worked extremely well for Gordo's Neocons although Carole James' refusal to respond in kind made them more effective than any fascist could have dreamed.

By creating as much doubt as possible into Dear Michael's motives, competence, and history then amplifying it with your fascist evening news outlet at Canwest-Global (aka Fox News) the already disinterested voter sees no point and just stays home.

The old wisdom that "politicians are like diapers they need to be changed often and for the same reason" no longer applies when the media is almost one hundred percent owned by Neocons.
seth
 
delnab
It's time for conservatives to say enough is enough. The ends don't always justify the means.

Anything that keeps Liberals out of power is automatically worthwhile; so sorry you haven't figured that out yet.
 
Billy B
Get real man. I get mailouts from Liberal MPs all the time, personally attacking Harper

If you think this is one-sided, wake up. Its a common tactic used by all parties whereby MPs in safe seats send mail to ridings the party believes it can win next time around.

Save your outrage and do a little research before you spew typical, banal anti-Conservative garbage.
 
greggm
More snivelling liberal sour grapes. How is pointing out the truth that the Liberal leader left Canada over 30 years ago and returned only because he sniffed power considered gutter politics. I want a leader who devoted his life to this country...not an effette snob who's on thr record refeering to the USA as "his country" and the UK as "my adopted home".
 
Macky Avelli
Give it a rest. Negative ads are what they are. If done well, they work. If done badly, they backfire. They are the classic example of a "double-edged sword" in politics.

Let me use a football analogy ... The offense basically has two weapons--rushing (postivie ads) and passing (negative ads). A coach would be a total idiot to restrict his plays to one or the other. He understands that, when passing, there might be an interception. That is the other edge of the passing sword.

I suspect what is REALLY bugging the anti-Harper crowd is not the CONTENT of these ads, but that they are being run OUTSIDE the writ period. If so, admit it, and then have the debate revolve around that aspect.
 
Joe Hueglin
This is a new variation of misuse of M.P.'s mailing privileges.

Is it possible to have a copy e-mailed to me to circulate?

Joe.
Canadian Daily Digest - http://cdndailydigest.blogspot.com/
 
Durward
Perhaps you could get the Liberals to play politics of some kind, talk about a hidden agenda, theirs is buried so deep even they can't find it.
Nothing wrong with asking that question, many don't know and it is pertinent to the office of PM in my mind, I want a PM loyal to Canada not one dropping by for a golden pension promised him by the Lib insiders to get him to come up here because even he is better than the known losers that sit with him in Parliament on the opposition side.
 
Mark K
And I guess your article about Liberal 'Gutter Politics' concerning a certain series of attack ads that said Harper would put our troops in Iraq, destroy healthcare, outlaw abortion, increase gun violence (complete with a gun firing at the viewer's face!) got lost in the mail? Or maybe you just have selective memory.
 
CPG
Lets get real here...the Liberals have invented gutter politics...the "Radical Harper"..."the soldiers in the streets"...oh, and lets not forget...if you vote Conservative "They'll be in bed with the block"...or "or the Bush ads depicting Harper as Bush lite"....oh..oh..isn't it Ignatieff with all the Bush, US and Bloc connections...
Its time the MSM got over their anti Harper / Conservative agenda...forget the Liberal talking points...lets get real, forget the spin and look at the real facts....Things alwayslook a little different when the facts are looked at..
 
CPG
And on the other side of the Political, I receive mal in Halifax this week form Alan Tonks a liberal MP from away...sent at taxpayers expense...ridiculing the the Conservatives and EI...the same EI formula that the Liberals reformed and implemented with their former Liberal majority...what a Hypocrite...wasting taxpayer money with propaganda...and misleading them about EI...if it is such bad public policy...then I ask Alan Tonks to tell me why his Liberal Majority and his "Somber second thought" group of senators implemented this policy in the first place...
 
HLH
The following comments were made by others.
I felt that they accurately portray the state of the Liberal party in Canada.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

First the Liberals held a Seinfeld convention. Now with the demand for universal EI standard off the table the transformation is complete. The Liberals stand for nothing. They are Canada's Seinfeld Party
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Robert McNamara may have been a highly educated intellect, but his policies gave us the disaster that was the Vietnam War.
The lesson: Sometimes great intellectuals just don't make great leaders.

That's something Canadians might want to remember when judging the merits of a certain ex-Harvard professor now leading the federal Liberals.
 
steve b
This is what you call a "vicious personal attack on the Opposition leader" when the ad is merely stating a fact? A vicious personal attack on someone would be doing something like making fun of a persons religious beliefs. Kind of what the liberals did to Stockwell Day, you seem to have forgot that one eh?
 
Nastyboy
Stephen Harper has been subjected to the worse kind of smears immaginable and now that the shoe is on the other foot the left screams foul? Turn about is fair play and if the Libs don't like it then man-up, buy a cup and give as good as you get.
 
Oogy Boogy
"...vicious personal attack..."

Oh please. If politics is too tough for you, take up knitting.
 
Chipmunk L
Can't anyone remember the olden days, when politics wasn't so psychopathic and disgusting? It was civil, respectful and even humorous much of the time. Each character was responsible and accountable for their own behavior, the country was protected, policy tended to make things better for the public, and, propaganda and advertising was at a minimum..... God, having a long memory, and knowing that decency IS possible, makes all this crap so depressing.
 
terry
technically expecting one traitor to humanity to condemn another traitor to humanity is about as useful as that statement.
They are all fully aware concerning the medicinal (and every other) benifits of marijuahna yet they prefer to commit anti-GoD actions against the populous, for TEMPORARY material wealth.
Remove traitors from public office and public services. Vote, for anyone not Corporate Sponsored.
 
Lets Harpoon Harper!
Why not harp on Harper with a fall election. Now that is more like it just vote the guy right out of office along with the rest of Harper's Conservatives. It takes for ever to hold these guys accountable as we have Mulroney getting caught up in scandals from yesteryear that cost the public dearly along with his party.
Can Harper be trusted to do the right thing for Canada or the right thing for Harper? I do believe Harper views them differently.
 
DanO
Shame requires a conscience, and this is just another sick political tactic to add to his many lies about the Chuck Cadman bribe(s) & lies about audio tapes alteration. Like Rick Mercer said - why is he still adding more cabinet ministers at $75,000 per year plus limos - Harper does not care about Canadians, just perks & pensions for friends. Why is the $54 Billion EI fund out of reach of most Canadians who need it ? (see torontostar.com) Why were banks given $75 Billion (globalresearch.ca) when they own over $400 Billion ? Why are environment laws degraded for industrial pollution by redefining "tailing ponds", etcetera ? We need the legal power of petitions to enable recall of politicians, and to veto their large, blatantly bad decisions. We need e-voting and referendums on major issues.
 
Stryder
Conservatives wouldn't wipe their bottom without permission from Da Fuhrer, and if they dared defy him he would crucify them.
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.