News and Views » Straight Talk

TransLink to blame for increased transit violence, Bus Riders Union says

Qasim Baig, Mohammad Shujaath Ali, and Beth Grayer (left to right) hold a press conference to condemn recent violence on transit.

Matthew Burrows
By Matthew Burrows,

A Bus Riders Union organizer has blamed the TransLink board’s lack of accountability and closed-door meetings for increased violence in Metro Vancouver’s transit system.

“I think it is a concern that bus riders do not have a means of controlling their own transit system,” Beth Grayer, who’s been a BRU organizer since 2001, told the Georgia Straight at a press conference today (August 6). “We don’t have a say any more. There is no venue for bus riders who are either victims of violence or afraid of violence to go to their TransLink board and demand some accountability. So I do think that what we are seeing is that, if violence is increasing, the TransLink board and lack of accountability is to blame.”

Today, at the Masjid ul-Haqq Mosque in Vancouver’s Kensington-Cedar Cottage neighbourhood, Grayer sat alongside Imam Mohammad Shujaath Ali and fellow BRU member Qasim Baig.

Baig, 59, told reporters he was riding the #25 bus on Kingsway on July 29 when he was attacked by a white man who repeatedly shouted “bin Laden” before punching him in the head. The bus driver immediately stopped the bus and called police. The perpetrator had fled by the time officers arrived.

Ali offered Baig his support and denounced the attacks on behalf of the B.C. Muslim Association.

“Canada is an open society, where all law-abiding citizens and residents are free to follow their religion and the culture of their choice,” Ali said. “Islam is a very understanding religion. It is the religion of tolerance, respect, and freedom of choice. The B.C. Muslim Association encourages all members of Canadian society to stand up against any kind of injustice and prejudice done to anyone, irrespective of their gender, race, colour or religious affiliation.”

Grayer, who used transit to get the press conference, said a breakdown in communication means that TransLink is not hearing about racial slurs and attacks on transit in a timely manner. This is party because TransLink board meetings are now closed to the public, she said.

“Right now, TransLink has a private board, which does not allow for public input,” Grayer said. “And we would like to see that change with a transit board that’s accountable to bus riders.”

Until January 2008, TransLink board meetings were open to the public. However, following a TransLink Governance Review initiated in 2006 by former B.C. transportation minister Kevin Falcon, new board chair Dale Parker ruled they would happen behind closed doors from that point on.

At UBC Robson Square on June 27, 2007, then-TransLink chair and Richmond mayor Malcolm Brodie took the board into a closed session after a protest by the BRU over a planned fare increase disrupted a meeting.

“TransLink doesn’t like to hear what it is doing wrong,” Grayer told the Straight at that time. “What we’ve seen in the last eight years is that TransLink is shifting their priorities toward raising fares, public-private partnerships—which are privatizing the public transit system—and basically profit-making and development, rather than the needs of bus riders.”

Grayer noted that TransLink is now claiming to be in a funding crisis and could cut bus service by 40 percent.

“What is the impact of those cuts going to be on bus riders like myself, and bus riders like Qasim who rely on the bus to get to our faith communities and to get to work?” she said. “It’s going to increase the lack of safety that’s for sure.”

In response to the BRU’s call for a “community consultation” following the attack, TransLink spokesperson Ken Hardie told the Straight by phone that the transit authority is open to the idea.

“That is something we would look at if the community, in this case the Muslim community, felt the issue needed to be dealt with,” Hardie said today. “But the call would have to come from the community itself, not from the BRU. Remember, when the BRU plans a press conference, these guys don’t invite TransLink.”

Hardie added that public delegations can address the TransLink board of directors for one hour prior to each meeting.

Comments

What a joke
This incident is the fault of one bigoted jerk, no one else. How on Earth can TRANSLINK be responsible for the actions of an individual rider??

It's slightly appalling that the BRU would use something like this to promote their agenda of restructuring Translink. I'm not saying that Translink doesn't need some changes, but suggesting that there is anything less than 100% responsibility by the person who committed this crime is just a distraction from the real root of the problem. To try and draw a phony logical connection between the attack and Translink's growth strategy is transparently self-serving and disingenuous.
 
Transit rider
Dear what a joke,
Translink has set aside 17 million dollar budget for security and what do we see happening?
Increased violent and sexual attacks on riders, while the transit police armed with tasers busy issuing ticket of $179 to bus riders, where are they when this attacks take place?
Its pretty clear to me that the priority is not the safety of the rides, but the safety of the profits.
 
Kid Rock
My mother took transit when she was working split shifts as a waitress. After years of enduring creeps and perverts on transit, she managed to scrape up enough money to buy a car and stopped taking transit. Even today, mentioning transit makes her cringe. She won’t go near a bus. Likely, many on transit would stop taking transit if they could.

If you are between 25 and 55, working and taking transit, I feel sorry for you. When you look at the inconvenience, hassles and bugs (colds, flu anyone?) associated with taking transit, transit is a miserable way to get around and we’d be better off if more people could stand on their own two feet to buy an car (electric/hybrid) or bicycle or lived close enough to amenities, work or school to just walk.
 
bus rider
I suspect that most violence caused by transit users are by those that do not pay the fare. Transit police are trying to discourage fare evaders from using transit by challenging them. Thus less violence. Virtually no security is going to stop random attacks on the thousands of buses in the system. This is a societal problem. No particular government or group is responsible, as much as the righteous would like to believe.
 
What a joke
The presence of security on that bus would not have made a lick of difference. The officer could only have reacted after the guy was attacked, and the outcome wouldn't have changed: bus stops, guy runs off. As far as perverts and molesters go, all they have to do is wait until you're off the bus, and then all the transit security in the world again makes no difference.

Where do people get off suggesting that Translink is somehow this big profit-hungry corporation anyways? Can you buy shares in Tranlslink and earn dividends? Of course not, it's a public service for crying out loud! You cry about wanting more security, better service, more infrastructure, and then call them greedy when they ask the taxpayers to pay for it.

Call it big, bureaucratic, and inefficient if you like, but suggesting that it is a bad thing for Translink to be turning a profit is like saying it's bad for the gov't not to run a deficit.
 
Gerry
You can't blame Translink!! This Bus Riders Union has no credibility!! There allot of angry people riding the bus, and walking around. The roads in vancouver are designed to make all traffic, including buses, move as slow as possible. The traffic never gets better, for decades now the congestion has been getting worse. No one addresses the problem, and people feel ignored and frustrated. Buses ride on roads.

Improve the GD roads!!!
 
capt. crunch
I used to take the bus and train to work for years. I was also sick every year many times with flu's, colds, pneumonia, all kinds of bad stuff. Having a chronic health condition, any of these could easily kill me. Since I've started driving again I've only had 1 bad head cold in 2.5 years. Besides not putting up with the inefficient service and the clowns riding the buses and trains, driving means life and death to me.
 
UUUUUU
TransDink hired way too many expensive cops with guns and not enough security guards - I have traveled the locomotive at night and never saw ONE guard of any sort on any station platform.... fire some cops and hired more guards!
 
AJB
Hey Kid Rock, who's fault is it that "creeps and perverts" take transit? The board, the driver, who is responsible? Do you want a transit cop on every bus that runs? Are you all nuts? Do you understand that this can only be dealt with after the fact. You can't stop a "creep or pervert" from some act He/She hasn't done yet.
As far as our muslim friend goes, I'm not surprised that citizens act out when we see the problems the world over caused by the radical element of that religion. It might upset him but isn't he just like a Saskatchewan fan at a Lions game. If he wants to wear his uniform he shouldn't be surprised if some small sector of society reacts negatively against it.
 
transit user
Nice try BRU, but this is a week attempt to get some media presence. Their real beef with the fact that Translink board meetings are no longer open is that they no longer have a stage for attention grabbing acts.

I'm a bus rider myself, but you clearly don't represent me, and while I respect the general idea of advocating on behalf of transit users, many who have few, if any, other transportation options, I object strenuously to your methods. This pathetic attempt to link an increase in crime to Translink actions seriously undermines any credibility the organization may have garnered thus far.

I do think that Translink needs to take the spate of recent violent acts on transit seriously and develop a pro-active response. The justice system needs to take a zero tolerance approach to these acts - they are completely unjustifiable, whatever the underlying cause of one's rage. There just isn't an excuse for this type of behaviour.
 
cgwyl
Placing the blame on TransLink is not the way to go here, who allowed them to have closed door meetings, who lets the criminally inclinded go with but a pat on the fanny? It's our beloved govorning body that is screwing us in the end... sorry, the rear end, and we keep taking it up the wazoo with a confused smiles on our collective faces.
 
cgwyl
PS: more cameras on the buses and TV / YouTube coverage of all haneous incidents should keep all but the real nut bars passive and from following people off of the buses.
 
agent X, insight
>>>AJB,
I suppose with that opinion, you believe if a person dresses to revealingly, they should expect to get raped for it right? So we should adhere to the masses?
 
aesop
BRU is not even a joke. They're pathetic in every way.
Last I read, they had 500 members, maybe it's 1,000 now, if you could even trust their figures. They should have 500,000 members, or at least 50,000.
Then they could join their mentors from the US and start Israel bashing.
What does that have to do with buses? Who cares.
If you're a leftist organization, that breeds members like Mabel 'Zionist' Elmore, any anti western / anti jewish agenda is up for grabs.
Three cheers to VanCity Credit Union for funding eloquent Elmore's 'Ride with Dignity' (Seriously!) to the tune of $10,000.
And three more to GS for airing this left wing wingeing.
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.