The baffling fight by ordinary Americans to defeat healthcare reform

"The best test of a civilised society is the way in which it treats its most vulnerable and weakest members."

—Mahatma Gandhi

That the majority of the rich and powerful in America, particularly those on the right, are vehemently opposed to universal healthcare and instead support the present free-market private insurance system is hardly surprising. Clearly they have nothing to fear, as it's highly unlikely that they will ever find themselves without coverage and they're certainly never going to be choosing between treatment and bankruptcy.

This stance—though truly despicable, completely devoid of compassion, and totally self-absorbed—isn't really all that difficult to understand. It's simply the latest manifestation of that age-old philosophy: "Hey, I'm alright. Screw everyone else!"

What IS extremely hard to figure out, however, is the mindset of all these regular, ordinary working class and middle-class, right-wing nutjobs who have been showing up all summer long at these town hall meetings chanting:

"Socialism! Communism! Stalinism!"

Not to mention: "Obama is Hitler!"

And: "Better dead than North Korean or Canadian!"

I mean, seriously, what's up with these people anyway? Don't they understand just how much they potentially have to lose? They may be feeling quite secure about their insurance coverage today, but that could so very easily change tomorrow.

Craving Some Karma

When you see these people on the news do you ever find yourself—as I so often do—hoping that they'll one day wind up extremely ill and in need of treatment, only to discover that their beloved for-profit, free-market insurance company has denied them coverage, forcing them into bankruptcy and leaving them completely destitute?

Now that may sound mean-spirited, but someone has to say it.

Because it's simply infuriating to see how they so scornfully dismiss and deride the genuine efforts of all those who have been working so hard to ensure that everyone in America has adequate healthcare.

And what of all these right-wing, anti-healthcare-reform senators and members of Congress? Wouldn't it be especially great if they were someday denied coverage right when they most needed it?

But of course that will never happen.

However, it most definitely could happen to any one of these rage-filled, right-wing, regular (that is, neither rich nor powerful) Americans, any one of whom could at any time find themselves sick, with their insurance company denying them coverage.

Seriously, wouldn't it just be so karmically perfect if, after battling so incredibly hard to defeat the implementation of a universal healthcare system, they found themselves unemployed, unwell, and uninsured?

Now, obviously I don't really want that to happen to anyone, but it is something that's hard not to think about when you see these people so passionately arguing against something that is—regardless of what they may have heard to the contrary on FOX News—for the long-term good of not just the nearly 50 million presently uninsured, but the whole country, including—at least potentially—themselves and their kids and grandkids.

A Communist Scheme?

You can argue that Obama's present plan is seriously flawed and that what the country really needs is a single-payer system—and I'd be the first to agree. But what these people are arguing against is not the specifics of this particular plan; they're arguing against the very idea of having any sort of government-run plan to begin with.

What they seem to be oblivious to is the fact that America already has a universal, socialized, government-run, single-payer healthcare system—at least for everyone over 65. It's called Medicare. And I certainly haven't heard many of these right-wing town hall shouters, yellers, and screamers calling Medicare a Communist scheme.

Besides, as it's been pointed out by many others before, universal medical coverage is no more Communist than government-run, tax-funded schools, libraries, and fire departments—and the police, Coast Guard, and search and rescue for that matter.

But of course this isn't a reasonable, logic-based debate, is it? No, this is a war against "a Stalinist takeover of America".

Irrational, Confused, and Nonsensical

This opposition to universal healthcare by ordinary Americans is almost as sensible as, say, Jews campaigning for the Nazis, African Americans donating money to the KKK, Cambodians clamoring for the return of Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge, or Americans electing Dick Cheney as president.

Or perhaps a more apt analogy is with the thousands of women in Mali protesting in recent weeks against a new law guaranteeing them equality in marriage. "We don't need equality", they shout, "it's just a Western plot to destroy Islam".

Give me your stupid, your ignorant, your muddled masses

Which brings me to my main point: Why do so many ordinary Americans consistently vote for and support politicians and policies that are so unambiguously opposed to their own interests?

This illogical support of politicians and leaders who oppose just about everything that's actually in one's own best self interest is not unique to America of course, but it's certainly nowhere near as prevalent in any other Western democracy.

Selflessness is great and all if you're working to help the homeless or orphans or anyone else in need. However, supporting Republicans who launch pointless wars that your kids will have to fight and die in, who lower taxes for the rich meaning your taxes will stay higher and your government services will remain underfunded, who fight against universal healthcare putting you at future risk of being uninsured, who... well, I think you get the point. It's just plain crazy.

Bangin' "Family Values"

One explanation is that these right-wing Republicans give lip service to the radical fundamentalist Christianity that so many of these "regular folks" follow (and which really explains where their minds are at in all of this).

But you'd think that after the umpteenth "Family Values" Republican of the religious right was caught banging his mistress down in Argentina or Alabama or some such place (or, say, caught hitting on adolescent Congressional pages, or caught in another financial scandal, or...) that it'd become pretty obvious that these people's real priorities have nothing to do with Christianity or "family values" and a lot more to do with power, wealth, and, well, banging their mistresses.

The Good Ol' Days

The fact is if you try to imagine a country that doesn't provide education and police, firefighting, postal, or search and rescue services to all of its citizens then you're either imagining a Third World country or you're thinking back to the "good ol' days" of the 18th or 19th centuries.

And that's exactly how the rest of the modern, industrialized world views America, a country with unlimited wealth and resources when it comes to launching wars in any given corner of the globe, yet somehow unable to provide the most basic of government services—healthcare—to its own people, leaving nearly 50 million citizens with absolutely no medical coverage whatsoever.

What If...?

Imagine what it would be like if, like the current healthcare-insurance industry, some of the following government-run vital services also operated on a purely for-profit basis:

"Nope, sorry, we can't educate your kid, he seems a little slow. It'd cost us extra resources. However, you can always watch educational shows like Sesame Street at home."

"No can do, we're not going to deliver mail to the countryside anymore. The profit ratio is simply too low. You could always move to the city."

"No, no, no! How many times do I have to tell you, we're not going to police your neighborhood. Too much crime there. You could always buy yourself a gun."

"Look, I understand that you want your son back, but both Search and Rescue and the Coast Guard are businesses and therefore you can't really expect us to attempt a rescue until the whole operation has been paid for up-front and, hey, let's be frank, it's pretty obvious that you can't afford it. Of course you could always go look yourself—just don't get lost."

"Sorry, sir, we'd like to come put out the fire and save your home, but to save money we've decided to only fight fires in wealthy neighborhoods where the pay is much better. You could always use your garden hose. Good luck!"

Death Panels

And one last thing: Yeah, death panels most certainly do exist. They're called for-profit insurance companies and they deny treatment and/or coverage to millions of Americans every year, many of whom—you guessed it—end up dead.

But, alas, those who need to hear this message aren't really listening to logic or reason now are they? They're simply screaming "Communism!" and, most bizarrely, "Fascism!" as they attempt to stop America from joining the modern world.

Mike Cowie is a freelance writer who writes about politics, music, film, travel, and much more. You can read more of Mike’s views on his Web site.

Comments

Canadians Vote Against Their Interests Too
This article is so true. And let's not just point the finger of incredulity only at our American friends. Many Canadians of lower socio-economic status routinely vote for and are adamant supporters of right wing political parties, even though, if they would just take the time to think things through, they would perhaps realize that they would benefit far more from government funded social programs and progressive income tax systems put forward by the left.
 
Smartiepants
The whole debate in the US is only about whether or not the government can tell you what to do. Simple as that. Under the US Constitution no government is allowed to tell you what to do since it violates the basic rights and freedoms (unalienable rights) meaning you have a right not to be bothered by the government on any topic. The system today is only the result of the merger between corporations and the government. America has no free market the way Adam Smith described it in his books. (most consider him the founder of capitalism) (neither does any other country)
Universal health care is nothing but a disguise for more government intrusion into people's lives. It has nothing to do with government caring about people. In the olden days doctors would help people when they needed it regardless of whether they could afford it or not. The whole problem is the money obsession of everyone. People outside the US just don't want to hear it because they have no freedoms at all left. Their governments control their lives 100% from birth to death. At least Americans still have some freedoms left and are willing to fight for it.
 
Rob
Oh yes the blessings of the Canadian system. I can be homeless and get no help. I can starve on the streets and people will call me a bumb or loser. I can be suffering without shelter and food. But I have free healthcare. Yippie!!!!. I get fixed up and tossed right back out onto the streets. You gotta love Canada for their beautiful humane health care system. Wow. Yes Americans should really adopt the same system.
Nonsense.
 
greggron
Why is so hard for the loony left to understand that many people can take care of themselves and their families without government interference - including health care. The worst day in the USA is better then the best day in Canada. No American desires to move to Canada. Half the Canadian population dreams of becoming America..all except the loony left.
 
Markymark
The US State of Massachusetts has mandatory healthcare.
Since its introduction health care costs have soared by 40% in the State.
People without health insurance get fined over $1,000 for the year 2009. (it's cheaper to pay the fine then to pay for insurance)
If you don't pay the State can garnish your wages
If you can't afford to pay you have to apply with the State government for a statement that you are too poor to pay. But of course there is an application fee for that. Of course Americans don't want it.
Yes the blessings of universal healthcare.
Look at another country such as the Netherlands where mandatory healthcare is a total disaster. Some people pay over 20% of their income on premiums alone (100 euro's per month for basic insurance). If you don't pay you are fined 130% of the premiums up to 5 years. And how do they catch people? By comparing the mandatory insurance files with the mandatory civil registration files to see who's missing. Then we haven't even coverd "own risk" and additional things one has to pay for that are not covered by health insurance. On top of the mandatory liability insurance in the country, high taxes, expensive utillity bills etc. you get the picture. Lots of hidden poverty in this socialist country.
 
Tinkywinky
It was Albert Einstein who said "you can judge a society by the way it treats its animals". Ghandi copied that and changed it. Not very original
 
seth
Where are these right wing wacko's coming from anyway?

Is Russ Limbaugh being rebroadcast in town?

Does this same bunch make up the Straight's global warming denier contingent?

Hmm
seth
 
Bob Lee
Let me start off by saying that I'm American, although during the "W" years did I often claimed to be Canadian. 20 million Americans have the above mentioned mindset. Out of 300 million, not so many. These are people that don't like those of color, don't believe evolution is a fact, believe that the earth is a few 1000 years old, etc. They are very conservative, and like sheep, are easily stirred up by their shepherds. They're frightened that their way of life is waning. And fortunately, they're correct.
And for the record, I wouldn't mind being a Canadian one bit. I've visited Canada 4 times, so far, and love the people and country.

Bob
 
randomjames
"The worst day in the USA is better then the best day in Canada. No American desires to move to Canada. Half the Canadian population dreams of becoming America..all except the loony left."

w.t.f. Glenn Beck, is that you?
 
Sue
Right, left, republican, democrat, liberal...blah, blah, blah. They are all crooks stuffing their pockets at the middle class taxpayer's expense. If I don't want insurance that is my choice. I don't need government fining me because I choose to pay my "regular" medical expenses. Why can't we just pay for our primary care out of our pockets and carry catastrophic insurance to cover costs if and when we need it. One reason is all of the hypachrondiacs out there who go to the doctor everytime they pass gas. Another is frivolous law suits. Another is covering illegal immigrants for FREE. The main problem is corporate health care profits. Health care should not be a for profit enterprise. Period.
 
KH
This bull crap about everyone else in the world "dreaming" about being American? Come on now... I lived there for 5 years and I can tell you... the only thing I have is NIGHTMARES about the violence, greed, classism, ignorance, radical right, NRA and the "American Dream" which is a dream ONLY for the military, corporations and religious right of America.

Narrow minded fear mongering is the majority rule in the US. Words like "Freedom" and "Rights" are tossed around like dollar bills at a strip club by another me-me-me NFL football star. If the Bush era did anything it was expose the willful destruction of the educational system to breed lemmings to follow "the American way" and "their leader" unquestioningly at all costs. And what did that get them?

Hell... what did it get the world? Well... we're seeing it now.

Obama's only issue... that he's actually intelligent and compassionate enough to WANT a discussion, he has the audacity to hope for a civil debate. Seriously... maybe he didn't grow up American if he believes this is possible.

Not in America man... where a man convicted of slaughtering dogs can be hailed as a hero as long as "my" team wins. Where a pastor who rapes boys, cheats on his wife and embezzels millions can not only preach about "family values" on national TV, but also be seen as a leader.

The dream I have... is that Obama can help usher in an era where we see America grow up. This spoiled kid with access to the liquor cabinet full of bourbon, Dad's gun rack equipped FORD F-150, cash laced with cocaine and an ego matched in size only by the growing US debt and it's falling reputation around the world... I gotta tell you, I'm frickin' tired of having him as a neighbour.

Come on Obama... ignore the mouth breathers and their parent network, their religious mission and their Alaskan warrior woman. Push through Universal health care and take away the biggest tool of fear the GOP can play with. Think about it... if families in the US don't have to "pray" for a miracle to save their sick/dying relatives then why go to church? No church no radical religious pulpit and no pulpit equals no GOP.

That's what the real fight is about...
 
Clarence
KH, thank the damn lord that you left America. We don't want you here more than you could ever not want to be here.

Your a crazy left-wing libtard that is crying to his momma because people don't like "the intelligent, compassionate" Barry Obama. Barry is a crook and an idiot. If he is so intelligent, why does he keep f'ing everything up? Why can he not speak without a teleprompter? Why does he think the U.S. has 57 states?

What about Obama makes you think he is intelligent. He is America's first affirmative action president and has only made it to where he is because of his skin color and penchant for BS'ing.
 
KH
Clarence, so let me guess... you voted for the guy who couldn't speak WITHOUT a teleprompter because of his skin colour and because he always, only, truthfully spoke from the heart and loved America FOR America right?

Or should I say.... really far right?

Have fun watching your health care premiums shrink, your churches congregations start to dwindle and the fear that has gripped your nation subside as the Democrats ram Health Care reform through.

Granted, I bet your momma had to force you to eat your vegetables as well right? Tough to swallow things that are good for you isn't it?
 
adam b
this is just another installment of the so called 'culture wars'. it's time the smart community basically dropped a nuke on the dumb community and called it a day.

America's in decline and taking everyone with them precisely because of this kind of narrow minded ignorance. all those that claim America #1 truly living in the past. These days, Beijing, Moscow and Abu Dhabi are the new LA, New York and Washington.
 
Clarence
It's always easy to spot a clueless liberal (KH). You have no answer for the idiotic things that your messiah does, so you pull out the ever faithful "Bush was a bigger idiot, doyyyyyyy" card.

Why the hell are you even still complaining about U.S. politics if you don't even live here anymore?

By the way, the vegetable comment was just dumb, sorry.

Now go log in and out so you can "disagree" with my comment 16 times, it is what probably helps you through your day. You ugly hippie.
 
KH
In the movie "It's a Wonderful Life" Clarence, the angel that comes to save George Bailey, tells George that every time you hear a bell ring an angel gets its wings.

In this instance my bet is that whenever our thoughtful, even headed and intelligent fellow poster of the same name hears a bell ring it means any one of these things:

a) Have been challenged - must resort to name calling at all costs because THAT is the way adults make their point.

b) Another bundle of parietal lobe neurons die a quick and merciful death hoping, in that fleeting moment, that maybe in this last and only functional act of their dormant life that they're the connection that will finally turn off this bodies speech center.

c) Another American family, through no fault of their own, files for bankruptcy because a relative of theirs selfishly got sick.

d) Time to eat more twinkies.

e) Wipe drool from corner of mouth.

And Clarence... don't worry if your comprehension skills don't allow you to fully understand Obamas health care speech on Wednesday. Fox news will break it down in their easy to understand fear mongering way for you.

Life is so much easier when someone else does the thinking isn't it?
 
puzzledislander
all differences aside,
why would anyone who thinks of Canada (or Holland for that matter) as being a socialist country bother to read (never mind commenting) a leftist, hippie paper like Straight ?
 
morphyous
Dear Clarence, perhaps you should remember 911, that's when the Canadians you hold with such contempt , reached out to our neighbors, the American people, and gave them shelter, food ,and hope. Our two Countries are linked, not only by Geography, but by common interests.We have free speech, don't you?.To engage in the type of language and hate speech, that you have, because someone dared voice an opinion that is different from yours ,is ridiculous. No wonder Nations cannot get along. I would hope your next comment is a rational reply, debate not hate. That is how civilized people talk..I understand you may not like some comments,but don't over react, the trick is to discuss your point of view , not scream it.
 
It is how Americans have been programmed
As war, and guns and poverty are more their heavy artineary, while peace loving Canadians were into helping neighboring countries out. No more as another 100 Canadians find there way to a cold slab in a part of the world where peace loving troups have no business being as Harper takes all that is truly Canadian and takes up arms against neigboring countries for no avail while families are torn apart from the lose of loved ones dying for not.
 
Bob Lee
Clarence the cross eyed Lion. 'Member that character? Surly, confused, bitter, lonely......, yes I'm talkin' 'bout conservatives. C, go have a beer with W, talk 'bout how he and you saved America from the libbys. And how bright you feel he is. He and Reagen cut form the same cloth. Greed and self rightousness.
 
Bob Lee
KH, I've got to stick up for the 280 million Yanks that aren't whom you posted about. That 30 million you did post about are loud and shout down the reasonable peeps at every chance given. Watch the pundits pitted against each other and the Conservys talk over the libbys every time. Marching orders and all that. No KH, all Americans aren't the same no more than all Canadians say, eh?
 
common tater
greggron wrote;
Why is so hard for the loony left to understand that many people can take care of themselves and their families without government interference - including health care. The worst day in the USA is better then the best day in Canada. No American desires to move to Canada. Half the Canadian population dreams of becoming America..all except the loony left.
Canada ranked 3rd in the World for Standard of Living. U.S. ranked 15th http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Development_Index .My worst nightmare would be to wake up and find I was an American just think what the rest of the world would think of me, oh right I'd be American So I wouldn't have a clue what the rest of the world thinks. I guess ignorance is Bliss unless your endeavoring to improve your Country.
Here is some medicine for ignorance;
The average life expectancy for Canadians was 80.34 years compared with 78.6 years for residents of the U.S.
Canada government-spending was $2,120 (in US dollars) per person on health care, while the United States government-spending $2,724.
In the World Health Organization's ratings of health care system performance among 191 member nations published in 2000, Canada ranked 30th and the U.S. 37th, while the overall health of Canadians was ranked 35th and Americans 72nd.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_Canadian_and_American_health_...
 
common tater
Tinkywinky said;
It was Albert Einstein who said "you can judge a society by the way it treats its animals". Ghandi copied that and changed it. Not very original
Yeah Tinkywinky; Ghandi was such a faker, eh, not very original of the mahatma, eh. Who did Ghandi think he was? Ghandi?
 
KH
Bob Lee... you're completely right. In my 5 years in the US I made some incredible friends, met some amazing people.... I even married one of them and our Daughter was born in the States.

Certainly I was not trying to use a broad brush at all... I think it's pretty obvious that my comments are directed squarely at that subset you mentioned. Here's hoping that the good of the many outweighs the furor of the few the loud and the ignorant.
 
Bob Lee
Puzzledislander, conservatives of the US variety are programmed to convert. If talking nice doesn't work, scare hell out of your audience. And/oryell louder then they do, take it to the enemy and your place in heaven is assured. That's the point of the 1st several posts. Old testament teaching and all that.
 
Money Makes Republicians Go Round
And that is it in a nut shell, big, big money keeps the Republician party in much needed cash as to ensure big, big business is taken care of. Is American Health Care Big Business? The Biggest. So thats it Republicians are looking after their best interest and that of Health Care Providers in America. Republicians will protect it even if it means the unecessary lives of fellow Americans.
Republicians put the scare into their followers with we are doomed as talks of Universal Health Care takes center stage.
 
True North
I have to agree with you, common tater - my worst fear WOULD be to wake up as an American !! I find it interesting that the worst comments made about Canadians are made by those who couldn't find Canada on a map?!!
As a Canadian, I don't have to worry about the CIA knocking on my door because I made a comment about the government.
As a Canadian, I can demand answers BEFORE I send my children off to be sacrificed to the god of war.
As a Canadian, I will neve know the agony of watching a loved one die because I cannot pay for their treatment (I wonder if greggron has ever had to pay for assistance from the police or fire department, they are, after all, state funded - why not make them for profit as well!).
Maybe Canada isn't such a bad place, after all ??
 
r blanc
I have met some of those who rabidly oppose the Obama healthcare reform, and they are neither rich nor powerful, but who I believe are scared by the prospect of the benefits they currently have getting reduced to accommodate government spending on more people. These are people on Medicare, Medicaid, plus those with health benefits for the military and their dependents who fear a reduction of the benefits they currently enjoy should something more universal gets adopted and the budget gets strained as a result. It is difficult to argue against the selfishness of their perspective; rather it is best to help inform them of the public good nature of health wherein your neighbor's health can be good for you as well -- and that's where all the isms come in, the charges of socialism, communism. Craving for some karma may be asking too much, so what about a bit of the Golden Rule maybe?
 
Reader via e-mail
As a member of a hospital geriatric emergency team, I’m on the front lines of a major health care issue that need immediate attention. The costs of keeping a person barely alive during their last few weeks of life easily run into the millions. The procedures undertaken at such times are painful and poorly thought out, and do not at all increase the quality of one’s life. The unfortunate senior who falls into the end-of-life emergency medical cycle can expect his or her final days to be miserable and lonely, with family relegated to the sidelines, while medical people rush around administering “care.” Such a person is robbed of dignity, and robbed of the right to die with loved ones nearby.

The reason why medical teams are pressured to perform endless procedures on our most ill seniors is because the legal and ethical issues at stake are in limbo. That’s because the questions raised are not just for individuals to answer, but for society as well. They are questions for a nation.

Our president injected himself into this conversation recently, by pointing out folly of the total hip replacement endured by his grandmother weeks before she died. His comment was pertinent, and any health care worker who was paying attention should have been pleased. We’ve all been there, poking and prodding someone who is well into their ninth decade of life, thinking to ourselves, “What do we think we’re doing?”

But rather than appreciating the chance to work out a helpful policy that would be good for everyone, the media pushes the Republican “death panel” distortions. All news organs mention Palin’s and Huckabee’s fabrications again and again, letting their lies go unchallenged, muddying the air with nonsense, as if the president and the Democrats honestly want to enter the business of cutting people’s lives short. That’s ridiculous and everyone knows it. So why does the Right Wing Scream Machine get a free media pass to spread their fabrications? Because Sarah Palin’s lies are flashy and dramatic, that’s why. Honestly, before someone is pulled into spreading that woman’s nonsense, they should take a walk around an Intensive Care Unit and see what’s at stake.

Molly Holmes
 
USA, USA, USA, USA...
These people, average Jane and Joe, are downtrodden, overworked, underpaid, and certainly ignorant people...it scares me...especially since they have so many guns...the most powerful nation in the world has the most ignorant population of all western liberal democracies...as Canadians we are not that far behind...stop watching all that crap on tv...talk to each other...eat together...TALK...ISSUES OF SUBSTANCE...we are so socialized into mass consuption and all the values that it is founded on...we forget how to communicate on anything of substance...for example, if sport fans spent as much time learning about their government and the policy debates...they could kick some serious political gluteus maximus...and at the same time impress some hottie who is worth impressing.
 
Stryder
That silent majority 2/3 of Americans you talk about had better get off their asses and start making some serious noise, turn the channel from Fox, stop buying from companys that support these subversives. You are that close to being a third world country if you don't get your house in order.
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.