News and Views » Commentary

Joanne Chang: Consider helping a turkey instead of eating one this Thanksgiving

Joanne Chang thinks people should consider breaking with Thanksgiving tradition by keeping turkeys off their plates.

By Joanne Chang

When most people hear the word turkey, they think of a roast on the table at Thanksgiving—the piece of flesh whose entire purpose is to satisfy our need to follow a tradition. It’s something that everyone must have at Thanksgiving, no questions asked.

I like asking questions. My favourite question to ask around Thanksgiving time is: Have you ever met a turkey? The answer to this question usually varies from “Oh, I’ve met lots of turkeys. My brother-in-law is one!” to “I heard they drown when they look up in the rain.” The responses do not surprise me, since most people who eat turkey do not have the opportunity or an interest in meeting the incredibly cuddly and affectionate creature in its living state. You must think I’m out of my mind to even suggest that an ugly bird can be cuddly and affectionate. But turkeys, like dogs, are truly affectionate by nature.

See also

Roger Clarke: Where's the lack of beef, Greenest City Action Team?

Leanne McConnachie: Backyard chickens won't answer demand for humanely produced food

Becci Gindin-Clarke: The cruel truth about organic and free-range meat and dairy products

Dave Steele: Meat just doesn't cut it in today's environment

Becci Gindin-Clarke: Foie gras is a cruel dish better left unserved

I was introduced to my first turkey when I spent a month volunteering at Farm Sanctuary in California. When the 70-pound tom named Wylie waddled up to me, I shuddered at his repulsive-looking face and took a step back. Wylie was bred for meat, which means his chest will grow rapidly and continuously until his legs cannot hold him anymore or until his heart gives out. Genetic manipulation is done in all farms, whether they are industrial, organic, or local.

At the sanctuary, Wylie was kept on a restrictive diet and had to be separated from the females. Because they are bred for maximum breast meat, today’s male turkeys would crush a female turkey if they tried to mate naturally. At turkey farms, the only way to make new turkeys is through artificial insemination. Yes, it is true. There are farm workers whose job is exclusively devoted to “milking” male turkeys for their semen and those whose job is devoted entirely to “breaking” female turkeys. How’s that for a Thanksgiving tradition?

As Wylie waddled up to me, a sanctuary staff member said to me, “Go ahead, he just wants a belly rub.” I was taken aback, but soon learned that turkeys are a lot like puppies. Wylie the turkey and many of the other turkeys at the sanctuary spend a lot of their days following volunteers around begging for kisses, hugs, cuddles, and scratches. I’ve spent many afternoons with a turkey preening on my lap while I scratched under her wings. The poor sweet creatures are so trusting despite the chronic pain they suffer from mutilations at the hands of humans.

Most of the turkeys I met were mutilated before their rescue; their beaks and toes were all cut off. Turkeys become frustrated and aggressive when overcrowded on meat farms. Instead of giving them more space, the turkey industry decided that it was better to cut off the birds’ toes and beaks so that they do not kill each other when they fight. Yes, this is also true. There’s someone at a turkey hatchery whose entire job is devoted to cutting off the toes and beaks of newborn turkey poults.

Wylie and most of the rescued turkeys eventually die prematurely due to collapsed organs and broken legs as their genetically manipulated bodies continue to grow out of control. The natural lifespan of a turkey is 10 years. But a turkey raised for food is killed at three to four months of age.

Every Thanksgiving, I think back to my time at the sanctuary and fondly remember the sweet gentle birds who knew nothing about hate and vengeance. They were mutilated mutants who lived in constant pain, but they were thankful to the humans who cared for them and enjoyed the short and peaceful life they had at the sanctuary. Perhaps they knew that despite all their suffering, they were luckier than the 20.4 million of their cousins in Canada who live in a constant state of violence and do not get to live beyond four months of age.

This Thanksgiving, please consider visiting a turkey at a local sanctuary instead of eating one. On the Web site of the Rest.Q Animal Sanctuary on Mayne Island, you can find out how you can sponsor a local rescued turkey.

Joanne Chang is a director of Liberation B.C., a Vancouver-based animal-rights organization.

Comments

Ginger
This is a wonderful story! Cuddle a turkey today!
 
Becci
I have also met turkeys--at both Farm Sanctuary and Rest-Q-- and I was absolutely amazed by how sweet and loving most of them were. The cows, pigs, and chickens were great, but the turkeys were by FAR the friendliest and most curious animals at both sanctuaries, something that really surprised me!
 
Eyes Open
That is so disturbing!! I am not sure what I thought went on in turkey farms but I have a whole new picture now. I hope that a lot of people read and share this article so that hopefully more will celebrate with out turkey in the future so that this suffering does not continue!
 
Christa
There is no better mark of a good human being than one who can extend compassion to all living beings.
 
Heather Leughmyer
Turkeys are beautiful and loving and should not be dinner! This year adopt a turkey instead of eating one! www.adoptaturkey.org
 
Paul Kevin Koehler
It's good to know that Joanne has given thanksgiving turkeys a voice with this informative article.
 
Lore
Thanks for the great post Joanne.

Happy Tofurky everyone!
 
alissa
Great article, Joanne! Thank you for doing your part to enlighten people to the realities of turkey life. It's so sad that people only know this animal posthumously. After bonding with a turkey, seeing the carcass disgusts me just as much as imagining a beloved dog or cat skinned and beheaded on a platter.
 
flower
Thanks Joanne. This is a painful topic but we can do so much! Thanksgiving is about appreciation, not entitlement to cause suffering. Why not enjoy a nice plant-based meal in appreciation of our power to change the world to a better place?
 
Alison C.
Wonderful article. I hope it will educate some people about how amazing and beautiful these creatures truly are, and that they deserve to live and not die for a stupid holiday tradition. Eat Tofurky instead!
 
rclarke
Glad to see this article. Let's give the turkeys something to be thankful for this year!
 
Glenn
Turkeys truly are wonderful animals. I've always been amazed by how social and friendly they are. They'll just come right up to you. It's actually one of the reasons why turkeys became so popular - it was so easy to shoot them because they were so friendly. Ben Franklin saw them as a symbol of brotherhood. To him they were more than just an "ugly bird" - they represented much of what he thought was good in the world. That's how I like to think of turkeys as well.
 
Mmmmmm turkey
Many friendly and cuddly animals are also killed for food. Don't like it, don't eat them. But don't tell others what not to do.
 
Linda Elsay
I've raised free range turkeys for years. Some are pets, some are food. I can appreciate Joana's view but please dont force your views on me. If i choose to eat a turkey with my family thats my business - NOT YOURS!
 
Michael Snyder
The problem with animal rights extremist groups like Liberation BC is the fact that they do not draw a distinction between humans and animals. Animals are not humans and do not have the same rights as humans. Killing animals for food is not a going to be good for the animal, we all know this and don't really need Joanne Chang to tell us what to eat.
 
Lora
Great posting, Joanne,

Which is it Linda... do you appreciate her view or do you consider she is "forcing" her views on you? You can't have it both ways.

This is simply an article about what turkeys are actually like when they are alive, with the hope it will convince some people to reconsider their desire to eat them. I don't see anyone forcing anything onto anyone. Newspapers and magazines are full of articles pushing meat and dairy products into our faces. Why so much offense over one small blog posting putting forward a compassionate alternative? Does free speech only apply to people who are OK with animal abuse and exploitation?
 
JM
Great article. I had no idea that turkeys were such wonderful creatures. I will only be eating a tofurkey feast this Thanksgiving!
 
Michael snyder
Lora does not seem to understand the difference between expressing an opinion and telling others to do as you do. This is generally the case with animal rights people.
 
Humans ARE Animals
I hate how people say that humans are not animals...we are. We have the ability to cage and harm those who can not build weapons and fight back. Somehow we want to pat ourselves on the back and say how wonderful we are that we can eat/maime/kill/abuse/destroy all we want and you better love it!!
Humans love to seperate themselves from the natural world and yet want to call this factory farmed meat natural. There is nothing natural about the way humans "grow" meat for consumpton.
All this article does is give a glimpse into a turkey's life and you have a choice to turn a blind eye to the suffering or make a positive change and choose not to include yourself in the pain and suffering of another animal.
Call veg*ns all the names you want but at least they aren't god aweful meat eaters.
 
Sally
Why is it that, whenever an animal rights person speaks up about an issue, everyone else thinks the information is being shoved down their throats? Joanne wrote an informative piece about how turkeys are bred and raised, and merely suggested you try to skip turkey this year. Egads! Honey, can you even imagine not having turkey on the table this Thanksgiving? What a riot! What a crazy animal rights extremist, telling me how turkeys end up on my plate! The NERVE!

Grow up. Learn something. No one is shoving the information down your throat.

Way to go, Joanne. I, for one, will skip turkey this year and for many years to come.
 
Michael Snyder
It is amazing to me that people in this thread pretend to not understand the difference between understanding the difference between humans and NON-HUMAN animals. Of course Humans are Animals. But Humans and NON-HUMAN animals are very different. Do you not understand this? Do you actually believe that a human being and a turkey deserve the exact same rights? If you wish to live your life with these beliefs, no one is stopping you. Why must you insist that everyone else believe the same as you? Sally is clearly unable to comprehend the concept that others know very well that animals must be killed so we can eat them. We are happy to do it. You can sit in your corner and eat your tofu, no one is telling you to stop. Why tell us to stop eating our turkey. Understand the difference, Sally?
 
Marielle
This is a great article Joanne, I'm glad that people are being exposed to the truth about factory farmed turkeys, although it's almost shocking that they didn't already know about the horror that goes on.
I however was unaware that these birds were so loving. Makes me want to go hug a turkey right now!

What have turkeys got to be thankful for?
I am thankful for the compassionate, good people in the world. Vegetarian or not, you can still show compassion for living things.
 
KeithM
WOW.. I just finished having my first ever Tofurkey Feast! I can't believe I never tried it earlier!
If it hadn't been for your informative article Ms. Chang, I would never have given tofurky a chance. I am glad I did. I feel better about myself, and I also can sleep well tonight knowing that at least one turkey has been spared the torture that you have mentioned.
I look forward to any future articles from you and your organization!
 
Michael Snyder
The only thing that is proven in these comments is the fact that vegetarians just don't get it. It's like trying to have a logical discussion with a christian.
 
AF
Another ineffectual animal rights article in the online version of the Georgia Straight, where no one cares what is written. File this one under, Who Gives a Sh*t? Your husband Glenn Gaetz and friends Roger Clarke and his wife Becci are, as usual, prasing your article. And there's Alison and the rest of them, but where's Canaduck? Really, Joanne, is this the best you can do to proselytize the rest of us? Give back Liberation BC to Fruno, cuz at least she can be half entertaining and has t*ts.
 
KeithM
I could tell from Mr Snyder's previous comments that he was very anti-animal rights, and in general, just plain dumb. But now he shows that he is even an Anti-Christian!
I quote from one of his previous comments: "others know very well that animals must be killed so we can eat them."
Guess what Mr Snyder... You are wrong.
You do not have to kill animals to eat. It has actually been proven that the majority of the time, vegans (people who don't eat any animal product) live healthier lives then most meat eaters. It also takes much less resources from our planet to feed vegans or vegetarians than it does to produce meat based diets, and the animal agriculture industry (according to a 2006 study by the United Nations) is actually the number 1 cause of global warming.
So please, quit pretending that you HAVE to eat meat, and start being honest. And just remember, you are what you eat!
 
Michael Snyder
KeithM embodies all that is ignorant in the animal rights movement. The sad thing is that he appears to be so very proud of his ignorance. Of course humans do not HAVE to eat animals. We CHOOSE to eat animals; and when we make that CHOICE, animals die in the process. Only ignorant animals rights extremists like yourself think that you are educating anyone in telling us that animals must be killed if you CHOOSE to eat them. People like Joanne, and KeithM, and Lora, need to get off your high horse and understand the concept of CHOICE. No one is denying you your right to choose, yet you wish to deny the rest of us that very right. How do you justify these ignorant beliefs?
 
Bhytf
The problem with animal rights groups like L***ration BC is that they anti-choice, all the while trying to disguise it as "education" and "outreach". Yes, I choose to kill and eat your animal pals, and nothing you do or say is going to change that. You can call it unethical, compassionless, etc, it doesn't bother us heartless meateaters.
 
jackj
I love turkey, I'll eat it on festive occassions like many others, but I still think that more money, time and campaigning is put to stopping the abuse of animals and of protecting animals' rights than that of homeless people, single mothers, low income seniors, making sure Canadians are educated and stay in school etc. Farm animals are bred for food. Many humans aren't raised as humanely as animals are and left to defend themselves. Especially in Vancouver. Cook a turkey, and invite a homeless person over to eat it with you.
 
Leesalee
Hey Joanne, Love your story!! It's moving and it touched my heart. I also see you get undeserved flack from people who can't get past the dead animal on their plates they're actually salivating over. Like how sick is that?! But you can bet there are a growing number of us who don't WANT to eat ANY meat - period. I had a fab tofurkey dinner this past Thanksgiving and it was my first time. I was so impressed!!! I haven't eaten meat since '89 and it's awesome to see so many vegetarian - better still vegan alternatives out there now. Thanks for sharing that!!! And btw, I think your org is doing an amazing job of spreading the word for a better world for ALL animals - keep it up!
 
Olivia
If each person who "loves" turkeys -- and eats them -- were put on an island ALONE with a single live turkey and told that if they harmed the turkey they would be shot dead, I think they'd end up letting the turkey befriend them. They'd have a friend for life! And they would NEVER (if they had any scruples) want to harm/kill/eat another turkey again, or any other animal, for that matter. :-) Thanks Joanne for sharing your turkey friends' generous spirit with us. I volunteered at Animal Acres one day and wish, in retrospect, I'd taken time to get to know the turkeys. (My job was to clean out the hen house.)

God bless all the turkeys, all of us, especially Michael S., who could use a a little love in his heart. (I'm not being facetious or unkind, only sincere: there is no way that someone who loves all beings unconditionally can desire to hurt, kill -- or pay to have killed -- and eat any being for any reason.)
 
Reg
Do your part and save a turkey! Eat an animal rights activist!
 
courtney
i do not understanmy domestic male turkey and female have had no troubles naturaly makeing babies and as on right now we have thre with a possibility of like 6 more. I read something about the male turkey crushing the female is she tried to reproduce naturally. We have not interfered at all with her and her nest and now there are babies should we take them away from the mother or leave them with her and the baby daddy?
 
Tyler99
Michael, what exactly is the difference between human and non-human animals? I suppose humans have children, nurse and protect them. Humans experience fear, pain, happiness. Humans have hearts, brains, nerve endings. Humans enjoy the company of others, play, fight, get jealous. But wait.....non-human animals do all of these as well. So what is the difference really. Oh yeah, they are a different species, that's it.
 
Sharon Creelman
Happy VEGAN Thanksgiving!
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.