Stephen Harper's saving grace: Canada, China, trade, and human rights

"None who have always been free can understand the terrible fascinating power of the hope of freedom to those who are not free"

—Pearl S. Buck

During Prime Minister Stephen Harper's four-day trip to China last week he was hit with a non-stop barrage of sanctimonious scolding and chiding about how he has unwisely undermined Canada's relationship with China during his four years in power.

These public attacks came not just from the Chinese leadership and state-run media, but from the opposition parties back here in Canada as well, particularly the Liberals.

Now there's not much I respect about Stephen Harper, but his stand on China has been one issue where I believe he really deserves some genuine praise. While the rest of the western world has stumbled over itself to suck up to the People's Republic for trade and business purposes, Canada has retained a certain sense of dignity. Harper's refusal to kiss China's ass—when just about every other world leader has been doing nothing but—deserves some real respect in my books.

On just about every other issue, whether it be his shameful disregard for the environment or his abandonment of Canadian citizen Omar Khadr to torture and illegal imprisonment in America's Guantanamo Bay gulag, Harper has consistently shown himself to be one hell of a lousy prime minister. But not in this case.

The fact of the matter is when it comes to putting human rights above trade in this country's relations with China, Harper has truly taken an admirable stand these past few years: standing up to China, openly criticizing their horrendous human rights record, speaking up for the oppressed Tibetans. These are all worthy stands that every Canadian should be proud of.

Regardless of what some Canadians seem to believe, the sole purpose of a foreign policy is not simply to generate more trade.

Many of the same people who are outraged and disgusted by Harper's lack of concern about the treatment of Omar Khadr (as I myself have been) seem to have little or no concern themselves when it comes to the thousands of political prisoners wasting away in Chinese "re-education" camps. Or the many tortured and/or condemned to death for simply opposing the regime. Or the vast numbers of religiously oppressed. Or the prisoners used as unwilling organ donors. Sadly, none of these people seem to matter all that much to many Canadians.

Sure, lots of people in China are getting rich these days, but wealth creation doesn't legitimize horrendous human rights abuses. And millions of people in China are still living under constant oppression, particularly the Tibetans and the Turkic-speaking Uygers of Xinjiang province in the country's far west.

During the 10 months I spent in China earlier this decade I made a lot of good friends and I heard many horrific and heartbreaking tales of injustice and abuse, particularly from Tibetan and Uyger friends, but also from many Han Chinese as well.

But you don't need to have personally visited China to know about the Chinese government's human rights record. It's all very well documented.

Ignoble Ignatieff

The most ridiculous thing this past week has been watching Liberal leader Michael Ignatieff lecturing Harper for not showing China enough respect over the past few years. Isn't Ignatieff the same guy who supported the Iraq War because Iraq was a brutal dictatorship?

When it comes to hypocritical hysterics, it doesn't get much worse than this.

You get the feeling that Ignatieff and all these other business-before-all-else yahoos would be totally excited about close relations with North Korea and Burma too if they could only see a buck or two to be made there.

It would seem that to these people human rights are fine and all, but making some good dough is where it's really at.

Deafening Silence

Harper's insistence on speaking up on this issue has been especially noticeable—and heartening—due to the deafening silence from most other nations in recent years. It seems everyone is so consumed with trade and business opportunities that China's dismal human rights record has become almost irrelevant.

America, of course, is the most pathetically hypocritical of all when it comes to this whole issue, what with their constant condemnation and nearly 50-year embargo on Cuba and simultaneous newfound love of Communist China, as if it were some sort of bastion of civilized democracy and human rights, rather than the brutal dictatorship that it is.

Core Canadian Convictions

So, let me say it once again, no matter how much you may despise someone's politics or policies, it's only fair to applaud when they, no matter how infrequently, take the right path. And, like with George W. Bush's dramatic increase in foreign aid to Africa, largely to help fight HIV/AIDS, Harper deserves genuine praise for his non-ass kissing stance when it comes to China.

I mean, what do we believe in here in Canada anyway? Are we a nation that worships the almighty buck—or, in this case, the almighty yuan—or do we actually have some core Canadian values? We've already sold our souls, sold out our environment, and traded away our country's reputation to Alberta's oil sands in the name of "increased wealth and job creation above all else". Do we really want to trade in our belief in human rights as well?

I'm with Harper on this one. Both morally and ethically, the ass-kissers and soul sellers are on their own.

Mike Cowie is a freelance writer who writes about politics, music, film, travel, and much more. You can read more of Mike’s views on his Web site.

Comments

carpediem
another piece of olds that shows the narrow Eurocentric and sinophobic perspective. Your ignorant complacency shows that you know nothing about the real reason behind China's rise and where the world is headed for. America rised because their innovation and liberty. China is rising because of their discipline and comradeship. The left and right might be opposite to each other, but human beings need both for progress to be sustainable. Notice that when you discuss China's human rights you clings to the cold cases and refuse to compare them with problem in your own country's present and history?
 
mikey
" During Prime Minister Stephen Harper's four-day trip to China last week he was hit with a non-stop barrage of sanctimonious scolding"

"sanctimonious scolding"? Give me a break, lol. I'm sure Harper is secure enough to take jibes as good as he gives when he lectures China on just about everything?
 
asgoda
Food on the table is one of the basic human rights. Narrow minded author suggested no need to visit China personally, but why not get out there experience the culture first hand.
 
MikeCowie
asgoda says: "Narrow minded author suggested no need to visit China personally, but why not get out there experience the culture first hand."

If you actually read the piece you'll see that I did in fact spend 10 months in China earlier this decade.

And I agree, food on the table is indeed a basic human right, but what on earth does that have to do with authoritarian dictatorship? The cutthroat capitalism that exists in China today certainly doesn't need a Communist dictatorship to flourish.

The Chinese Communist Party is simply interested in retaining its position of power. It stands for self-preservation and little, if anything, else these days.
 
Wang
UN Food and Agriculture Organisation(FAO) announced that in China 58 million more people no longer hungry but India add 30 million more people to the ranks of hungry. (chinese government did a good job compare to democratic India)

Food in the belly, lets talk.
No food, lets work.

China will work first and talk later.

MikeCowie and Mr Harper just don't know the feeling, talk and debate with empty stomach.

http://www.mg.co.za/article/2009-11-12-food-summit-dilutes-hunger-and-ai...
 
lydia
How do you know China doesn't need Communist dictatorship to flourish???
Do you know the reasons behind China's prosperity?
How much knowlege do you have about China's history, society, and cosmology?
How do you know all those "heartbreaking oppressions" are all real and not tales?
Don't Canada and US have some "heartbreaking oppressions" out there? Be honest. Peace-keeping armys? or "ignorant" Aboriginals?
Have you ever tested your IQ?
If you know nothing for sure, shut up.
 
lydia
the author only sees negative things about Chinese Party. 10months spending in China is nothing, not to mention where you stayed,and what kind of people you stayed with. You cannot possibly understand China's culture and society in merely 10 months.
When there comes to the disasters, Chinese Communist army is the most efficient to save people's life. The Party's leaders are the most caring responsible leaders in the world.
Even you say these are all for a show, has any US and Canada leader played that well?
Capediem says: "China is rising because of their discipline and comradeship". True true true.
China is a unique country. They have unique history and culture foundation.
the Society has different structure. and there is nothing wrong to be different from US or Canada. Chinese are not Canadian!!
Wake up.
 
He
I just curious, how Stephen Harper make this visit real? China didn't invite him at first place, he sent 6 or 7 ministers during last few months? I'm really curious what deal they made before he got invitation???
 
Stryder
I can't imagine Harper lecturing anyone on just about any issue seriously, without sounding and looking like an absolute hypocrite.
 
DM
Obviously, the progress since the Cultural Revolution (which was a disaster for China) has been remarkable. However, freedoms and rights cannot be traded off. People should eat AND have freedom of speech and freedom of religion without heavy state persecution and detentions.
 
crade
Whether we like their policies or not, walking up and punching the Chinese government in the face isn't going to help bring about change, it will just make them hate us.

He isn't refusing to kiss China's ass, he is just refusing to ever *not* kiss the U.S.'s ass.
 
Dave from toronto.
Very unfortuneately, This just again shows how narrow view and blindly self-rightous that many canadians are, just like the picture that CBC picked to show Canadians Shanghai's "shocking" (that's the reporter said) skyline, which might look same as Toronto downtown if you see it from the lake, but, that's a very a narrow view, cause if the reporter is willing to show a 360 degree picture at same spot, you might be really shocked the that skyline is in every direction endlessly, and also thanks to Canadian medias and writers like Mike Cowie, Canadians won't know actually the same skyline can be seen in many many second line cities, like Wuhan, Nanjing and. Because of the Canadian medias' 'hard' working, Canadians are very welly kept in a honey pot thinking they are the best without knowing what really is happening outside world. And thinking they can somehow charm the China or Bully China.
Wake up, like Prof. Jiang said, "China is too old to be charmed, and too big to be bullied." The reality is the CCP do have dominate support from Chinese themself, so why should we bothering trying so hard to teach them what they should do? Stop your day-dreaming, we need to take our own business, need better job and give our children better live.
 
Proud Asian Canadian
I'm amazed by the nationalistic views of some posters here. It's frightful to imagine that they're remotely Canadians living among us here. Clearly their hearts are in that beloved foreign motherland and live on our Canadian charities here at home.
 
Bad Canada
Is more like it as human rights abuses are prominent on Canada's streets as Harper's government makes homelessness a household word across Canada while peace keeping Canadian soilders engage in torture.
Food and shelter a human right not in Canada as truck loads of questionable garbage is used to feed the poor as malnutrition and rickets are becoming only to common place amongst Canada's low income. As shelter becomes harder to obtain and many can not deal with the prospect and would sooner die in their sleep. Suicide will sky rocket this XMAS as peace and joy are not for the homeless and the low income but a rock and a hard place as police force non human residents to non existant shelters as Canada sets out to dehumanize, demoralize and finally deleagalize its low income.
 
Wang
Really, was the chinese human rights bother the author so much or something else?
Please, everyone read between the line or listen to the tone in the article.

Was Mike Cowie scared of anything? Was he jealous about anything?

Or just the author has been repeatedly tell himself " Not way in hell, those little chinese going to be better off than me financially in near future, they are not even ...." "I, Mike Coiwe going strike Chinese down with my blog and most importantly, I will stir up the hatred".

Chinese people have good memories about Norman Bethune, Pierre Trudeau, Jean Chretien.

To most of us, Stephen Harper, just a confused guy shouldn't be a leader.
 
Proud Asian Canadian
Majority of Canadians of Chinese origin irrespective of whether they are from the mainland or overseas, are pleased with Harper's recent visit to China. We celebrate the friendship between the 2 countries with a song written/composed by 2 prominent Vancouverites from the community.

http://www.gcpnews.com/articles/2009-12-09/C1063_46532.html

Let's not split hair to prop up your facebook idols. There's always the next election if your party can get your act together by then.
 
Iseeyu
Same person writing most comments . Person loyal Communist . Person belongs in China, Western ways piss person off. Freedom of expression enjoyed in Canada, not allowed in China. Funny how person enjoys freedom Canada brings but praises Communism . Internet access by all people will bring truth to all who seek it. China rising Militarily, economically .Oppressed population used to fuel progress. Chinese people have support from oppressed peoples, from all nations, we are the same. Let Freedom reign .
 
harry the tiger
yes, Mike Coiwe is trying to stir up the hatred towards chinese people and china, there are some very dirty part deep in his heart that he would not tell everyone else.
let us watch closely to his hehaviour.
 
MikeCowie
Well, "harry the tiger" and "Wang", the fact is this article is in no way "trying to stir up the hatred towards Chinese". This article is simply about the Chinese government.

The truth is I had the most amazing time in China and I thought the Chinese people were absolutely wonderful - very friendly and quite hospitable. I had so many great times with local people all over the country. In fact, I have quite a few Chinese friends, not only in China, but also in Hong Kong, Malaysia and right here in Canada.

Chinese people are great. The Chinese government is anything but.

It's that simple.

I'm not sure why you think criticizing a brutal regime like the one in China is akin to hating the people of that country. For instance, I think the regime in North Korea is horrible too, but that hardly means I hate Korean people. Don't care for the Burmese military junta, but I like all the Burmese people I've met. Didn't much care for Pol Pot's regime, but I like Cambodian people. Stalin's regime was brutal, but that doesn't mean I don't like Russians.

Come on, you've really got to stop equating the Communist Party with all Chinese people because it's simply nonsense.

As "Proud Asian Canadian" says above, it's amazing how much allegiance some Chinese Canadians still seem to have towards the Communist Party of China.

It's quite bizarre indeed.
 
Wang
Stephen Harper stoped commuication with China for FIVE long years!

Did Canadian economy benifit from it? NO.
Did it hurt Chinese government? No.

Stephen Harper will keep his job because he stroked canadian people's ego real good by giving them the impression he stood up to a evil mighty China. What he really did was refuse to help a country with 9% people are still starving.

No body benifit from this 5 long years.
 
lydia
First, I am not a Canadian.
Second, to Proud Asian Canadian, and the author, "their hearts....live on our Canadian charities here at home" is nonsense.
It is funny you dare to say that.
how much money your government receive from those immigration?
are you familiar with the immigration process?
It is your gvnmt who announce they need labours and talented people from all over the world. and people with dreams believe it.
But what happened next?
talented people can never get a real job. and you guys blame people live on charities?

besides, it is just riduculous for you to decide what kind of governement is good and what is nonsense. You think you are God? You think you know "truth". What is freedom? it is a western social constructed term.

Every government has defects. and has advantages as well.

Hey, Chinses are not simply minded and people know what is good for them.
if they want to protest, THEY DO IT.
BUT it is NONE of your business to discuss.

Chinese society has thousand years of history. dynasty after dynasty, revolution after revolution.
People create, achieve, fight, live. and how they do it? what is their ideology?
You guys just know nothing about it.
you just stick on your ideology. and judgeing others.
stop humiliating yourself.
 
lydia
to MikeCowie,
I would say it is really bizarre for you to say you love Chinese peopel but only hate the government.
It is like telling a girl that you like her ass but hate her face.
also like you tell a kid that you think he is great, but you parent sucks.
but the truth is you know nothing about their family and their unspoken emotions.
whatever they do they say, they need each other, and they solve problem themselves. they are family. you are nowhere in between.
you are just a guest who stayed in their house for 10 months out of the five thousands years.
i suggest you enjoy the courteousnessn and mind your own business.
 
Proud Asian Canadian
You posts speak volume of where you're coming from. Sure twitch and bitch like a worm swirling in ashes. Western countries owe you a golden rice bowl because you chose to ditch you lowly origin to emigrate. There are no lack of success stories of immigrants who prospered in Vancouver because they work hard. Examples:

TNT Supermarkets - started by a mere housewife originally from Taiwan and recently sold to Loblaw for 70M or 100M.

Asenda pharmaceutical wholesaler - started by a Chinese immigrant and his Filipina wife. Bought over by the American.

Aero Systems - started by another Chinese immigrant who does not speak English. Bought by the French.

Now I'm not saying you are of that calibre and genre. There are other mid-size and family-run businesses that are doing extremely well.

wrt Mike Covie's article, I thoroughly enjoy reading it. I appreciate his articulate views and the nuances that differentiate the subtlety. Welcome to democracy. If you need to verbally or physically bash one for writing his blog, then you have come to the wrong place, A goulag may be what you are looking for.
 
Wang
Look at it, Now, how much 'ProudAsianCanadian' & 'Lydia' are hating each other! Job well done, Mike Cowie.

People are losing their focus, they fogort what got them into this hatred. The problem was this article was not well researched emotional piece. It lack of understanding of chinese and Canadian history and how international relationship should be dealt at current stage.

The article filled with emotional phrases everywhere, Ignatiff is hysterical, Haper kiss asses etc. Most of readers are influenced by Mike Cowie 'insightful opinons' or self-righteous rant. No matter freelance or not Mike Cowie should be responsilbe to the quality of his work.

Should we ask ourselves that did Stephen Harper's China policy (5yrs no show)helped Chinese people and Canadian people? Or was Jean Cheriten's way more active and constructive?

What Stephen Harper really did was bullied a group of poor countrymen in Asia and turn around tells maple leaf people he beat up a fire breath dragon.

Everyone is upset, but, please 'PAC' and 'Lydia' no physical bash needed here. Leave the physical out off this.
 
Proud Asian Canadian
Trade between China and Canada flourished in the last 5 years and continues to do so. Yet you and your lot are not satisfied. "Hate" is your tool to divide and conquer.; "Emotional" your strategy to achieve you political means.

Did Harper visit India, Slovakia, Check Republic or Poland in the last 6 years?! And why aren't Indo-Canadians and others making that a bitter issue to pursue political arguments.

Enough already. Show some respect for others, be they Mike Cowie or Harper.
 
mikey
It's kind of heroic to assume that we in Canada, a nation of what 50 million?, can dictate to China, a nation of over a billion, what it should or should not do. Harper's political grandstanding may work at home but it's just not practical.

It wasn't too long ago when we were admonished and told to clean up our plates and think about all the hungry people in China. How things have changed! I have no doubt the same can be said about other "rights".

You get further by engaging with other countries that have different political systems - isn't that what democracy is all about albeit practiced on a macro level? NDPs, conservatives, liberals, democrats, republicans, communists, socialists etc all living and interacting together.

China recently has had a tumultuous and violent history. During this time the west and Japan took advantage of this - the Opium War, the Japanese invasion, civil war. No wonder the leadership is paranoid about stability/harmony.

If we truly want China to change for the better in terms of democracy and human rights then engage them, set a good example, help them. Criticism, name calling, giving them the cold shoulder ain't working.

Democracy and human rights are universal ideals that transcend politics and naions. Some countries have had civil wars to attain these ideals. Do we want a civil war in China among the Hans, Muslims, Tibetans, Manchus and 50 other odd ethnic groups each wanting a free state? If so, be prepared for thousand of boat refugees landing on the west coast and be prepared to give these same refugees their human rights.
 
mikey
Kudos to Harper - see below.

I guess if it took the Chinese-Canadians 80 years to get the vote/democracy in Canada (from 1867 confederation to 1947) then China should at least be democratic by 2029 ( from 1949 founding of PRC). Let's hope so!

Source of below from Wikipedia:

Canada was slow to lift the restrictions against the Chinese-Canadians and grant them full rights as Canadian citizens. Because Canada signed the United Nations' Charter of Human Rights at the conclusion of the Second World War, the Canadian government had to repeal the Chinese Exclusion Act, which contravened the UN Charter. The same year, 1947, Chinese-Canadians were finally granted the right to vote in federal elections. But it took another 20 years, until the points system was adopted for selecting immigrants, that the Chinese began to be admitted under the same criteria as any other applicants.

After many years of organized calls for an official Canadian government public apology and redress to the historic Head tax, the minority Conservative government of Stephen Harper announced as part of their pre-election campaign, an official apology. On June 22, 2006, Prime Minister Stephen Harper delivered a message of redress in the House of Commons, calling it a "grave injustice".

 
Wang
Good points from Mikey.

First quote from Mikey "If we truly want China to change for the better in terms of democracy and human rights then engage them, set a good example, help them. Criticism, name calling, giving them the cold shoulder ain't working."

Second quote from Mikey "Do we want a civil war in China among the Hans, Muslims, Tibetans, Manchus and 50 other odd ethnic groups each wanting a free state?

The Second quote from mikey may contradict with 'ProudAsianCaniadian's 'Dvide & Conquer' tactic. But, please believe or not, no one trying to achive any Political Means here. Just a fair view what really is going on about China and Canadian relationship. Is Mr. Harper capable for the job. What is going on in his mind.

We just cannot keep Mr Harper on any more. Even 'PAC' point out that Mr Harper didn't interact with quite number of other countries for 6yrs. What Mr Harper has been doing? He might be busy on 'Dvide & Conquer' tactic by meeting the famouse ex serf(slave) owner, the one and the only one meat eating Buddhist monk(Dalai Lama).
http://www.contactmusic.com/news.nsf/story/mccartneys-meat-row-with-dala...
http://www.shambhalasun.com/sunspace/?p=3404

Mr. Harper doesn't need know the histry of Tibet, all he need to konw is 'China's enemy is my friend' and 'Dvide & Conquer' tactic.

Reference from neutral point of view on Tibet history(not from China, not from Lama)
http://www.michaelparenti.org/Tibet.html
Follow the link, take look what is a responsible writing looks like with full reference & bibliography (Author has Ph.D from Yale University)

 
mikey
MikeCowie says : " As "Proud Asian Canadian" says above, it's amazing how much allegiance some Chinese Canadians still seem to have towards the Communist Party of China.
It's quite bizarre indeed."

Not so bizarre. Simply because it's the only party they have, good or bad.

Lets use a family as an analogy, with a very strict father, no mother (remember, it's a one party family). The family is very poor and hungry and the neighbors, close and afar, humiliates and takes advantage of the family. No one comes to help or provide for their basic human rights. Finally the strict father is able to feed and clothe the family but make the kids work their ass off and restricts their freedom to talk back. The kids love their father but resent him for what things he does or doesn't do. Then a stranger comes along and tells the kids that their father is the worst father ever. The kid agrees that their father is very strict and sometimes beats them. But they will also say how good a father he was. What's so bizzare about that?
 
mikey
Proud Asian Canadian says: " wrt Mike Covie's article, I thoroughly enjoy reading it. I appreciate his articulate views and the nuances that differentiate the subtlety. Welcome to democracy. If you need to verbally or physically bash one for writing his blog, then you have come to the wrong place, A goulag may be what you are looking for."

Gulag? Aren't you being a bit harsh?
He's just learning to use his right to free speech.
I think we should welcome his input, whether we like it or not. That's the only way to promote better understanding.

And I'd be a little patient with his english. Don't feel sorry for him because in a few years we'll be sorry we can't speak Chinese, lol.

 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.