Ergonomy optimization

Blogs » Blog - Movies

MTV's Jersey Shore is offensive to Italians

By Doug Sarti,

With all the hubbub over MTV’s new reality program, Jersey Shore, and its portrayal of Italian-Americans, I thought I’d better check it out and see for myself what all the fuss is about.

After all, as an Italian-American myself, I have a vested interest.

The show, which debuted earlier this month, chronicles the lives of eight summer housemates in the New Jersey resort community of Seaside Heights. Cameras follow the group from bars to hot tubs, as they stew in massive amounts of alcohol, aggression, and sexual tension.

The controversy, aside from the group’s grossly decadent lifestyle, lies in the portrayal, and propagation of, Italian-American stereotypes. With the group’s overwhelming Italian-ness always front and center, the heavy-handed stereotypes are hard to miss. Especially with the epithet guido (as well as the female version, guidette) tossed around liberally.

While guido may not have the same history and resonance as wop, guinea, or dago, it’s still an ethnic slur. And it’s staggering to think that MTV, in this day and age, would really think it’s okay to shill a show with “the hottest, tannest, craziest guidos" who "keep their hair high, their muscles juiced and their fists pumping all summer long!"

The problem, aside from an insult to viewers’ intellect, is that this sort of thing promotes a false impression to a mass audience. With the repetitious nature of network television, people become desensitized to the characterizations and begin to think this is what all Italians are like. We’re not, but as Joseph Goebbels said, “If you repeat a lie many times, people are bound to start believing it.”

It’s especially shocking since MTV touts itself as being hip, now, and in touch with the youth of this country. In reality, all they prove with this is that they’re old hat, out-of-touch, and lacking in any kind of sensitivity. I mean really, what’s next for MTV, a show done in blackface?

The good news is that it hasn’t gone unnoticed. Domino’s Pizza and American Family Insurance have already pulled their ads from the show. Italian-American advocacy groups have called for a boycott. And Linda Stasi, TV critic for the New York Post, wrote that Jersey Shore is “the most hateful, anti-Italian-American show ever allowed on legitimate TV”.

Granted, Hollywood’s never been kind to us Italians. For every Moonstruck, there are scores of gangster stories and other unflattering or patronizing characterizations.

I’ll even admit that I’m partial to some of the negative portrayals, such as the Corleone family from The Godfather series, The Sopranos, and pretty much any character in any Scorsese film. They’re rich and deeply layered characters. Although flawed, they come across as real and believable people.

The housemates depicted on Jersey Shore, however, have no redeeming qualities. Their actions and attitudes are offensive. Their behaviour displays all seven of the Deadly Sins, quite often simultaneously. Their lives, as portrayed on the show, are moronic, vapid, and pointless.

In short, Jersey Shore illustrates perfectly the banality of prejudice.

Post a Comment

Comments

MB
Rating: Loading...
it's a reality show. no one is telling them what to say or how to act, they are being themselves. How can you call that an illustration of prejudice? I don't see how it's any different from The Real World or other similar reality shows. Plus, these characters are not ashamed to call themselves guidos and guidettes, they are proud!
 
Bobby G
Rating: Loading...
Jager bomb, jager bomb, jager bomb, skank, skank, skank
 
RS
Rating: Loading...
The controversy over this show is ridiculous. This is reality tv - get over yourself people! MTV has the real world which portrays everyone on there as trash, they have a teen pregnancy show (only seen an ad for it) that portrays it's subjects as trash.... this is what MTV does, everyone knows it, but they can't stop watching these train wrecks. So just avoid MTV, there's a lot more important things to worry about than 'negative portrayals' of people on TV ... like maybe the impending doom of our planet if the human race doesn't get its act together.
 
Sean Serritella
Rating: Loading...
This show is the worst thing to ever be put on the air. I've been verbally abusing all the cast members on facebook and will continue to do so until the show is off the air.
 
MikeCulhane
Rating: Loading...
I think the point here is that these people DO exist. All MTV is doing is showcasing their idiocy. In the negative points of Hip Hop culture are focused on for entertainment.

You mention the popularity of hip Hop culture in your article, however did it ever dawn on you that this is the very same thing as Jersey Shore. Sure its a negative portrayal of a culture for ratings, but you cant in the same sentence condone one while having a problem with another.
 
Meghan
Rating: Loading...
Why isn't there a blog about Peak Season? I find that more offensive than Jersey Shore.
 
super offended Sandra
Rating: Loading...
I'm guessing there's no blog about Peak Season because it's a scripted show that is filmed in a reality-tv style, but is not actually reality tv. As an Italian, I'm sick of hearing about shows and movies that are based on stereotypes...Sopranos, Godfather, Jersey Shore, and Everybody Loves Raymond! All these shows are based on stereotypes and there aren't any mainstream shows or movies that accurately portray the general Italian population- be that from Italy, the US, Canada or where ever. Jersey Shore should be cancelled because of its offensive nature to Italians. If such an outcry would be expressed by other visible minorities, it would be the focus of every major news station, as it should be...and we deserve the same respect and attention. I've never felt so offended in my life!!
 
guidette
Rating: Loading...
I LOVE JERSEY SHOREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE .. they all have swag i'm italian and i thought the show was hilarious if anything the sopronos is more offencive to italians than the jersey shore is.
seriously
 
Nicky C, Brooklyn
Rating: Loading...
you're an idiot. none of the characters in the godfather or sopranos are real characters.

jersey shore cast are real people, and they celebrate italian culture like food and family without making italians look like murderous criminals.
 
[Comments Disclaimer]

Post a comment

· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.