Commentary | Olympics

Isaac Oommen: Why Vancouver will welcome the Olympics with a massive protest

A poster for the 2010 Welcoming Committee's Take Back Our City festival and march.

Stephen Hui

By Isaac Oommen

On Friday (February 12) at 3 p.m., thousands of people from Vancouver and around the world will arrive at the downtown art gallery for a massive festival that will march to the opening ceremony of the 2010 Winter Olympics. Although the city, Olympic organizers, and security officials will brand them as protesters or demonstrators, they will be there to celebrate their right to be active participants, not just of their respective cities and neighbourhoods but of the world.

The convergence welcoming the Olympic torch in this way is made up of a number of groups that stand for everything from free-speech rights to the abolition of racist immigration policies. One thing in which they are all unified is their basic human rights, including the rights of expression and assembly.

Views on the Olympics

Derrick O'Keefe: 1980 Summer Olympics boycott echoes today

Peter Hamilton: Don't celebrate Olympics by donating goats for gold medals

Brad Cran: Why I have declined to participate in the Olympic Celebrations

David Suzuki: Going for the Olympic green medal

Cathy Wilander and Eric Doherty: Scrub the greenwash off the Freeway Olympics

Arthur Manuel: Vancouver Olympics can’t hide Canada’s dismal record on indigenous peoples

Martha J. Lewis: Impact of Olympics on Vancouver tenants less than feared

Marc Lee: First the Olympic party, next the hangover in B.C.

Deborah Folka: Who knew women couldn't ski jump in the Winter Olympics?

Chris Shaw: Why resist the 2010 Winter Olympics in Vancouver?

Am Johal: The 2010 Olympics have been an attack on civil society in Vancouver

Virginia Greene: 2010 Olympics will be biggest advertisement ever for B.C.

For years, the Olympics have branded those that have resisted this $6-billion showdown as being “anti-Olympics”. Very rarely do we hear about everything that the Olympics stand against. From a historical opposition to women’s rights in sport to today’s Orwellian surveillance state, the Olympics move in and oppose everything that we as responsible people of the world are trying to achieve.

At the end of the day, the Olympic industry—via the International Olympic Committee, Vanoc, and the plethora of alphabet agencies with which it partners—wishes to turn the people of this city, as well as every city left devastated in its wake, into mere hosts to drain dry, all under the guise of sport and nationalism.

Criticize the Olympics, and you will get from Vanoc the glib “Why do you hate amateur sports?” No one in this convergence hates sports. Most of us play a wide variety of sports, but do not mercilessly monetize it. Most of us cheer our local and international teams with all our lungs and souls.

What the people that will be converging stand against is not sports or even the Olympics as an idea, but the way in which the IOC and Vanoc have gone about their business, both historically and in Vancouver. The IOC has drained the municipal, provincial, and national treasury of money that should rightfully go to schools, libraries, hospitals, and a range of other more vital programs. All the while, Vanoc-endorsed politicians trumpeted lies that the residents of this town and province would not end up paying much for the Games. The result of this spectacle, we were told, will be the long-term benefit of investment in the city, since no one but the IOC will actually reap the money from ticket sales and corporate sponsorship.

It’s not just the matter of what Vanoc does but also the cloak-and-dagger way it goes about doing it. The Vancouver 2010 Integrated Security Unit has visited the residences, workplaces, families, and neighbours of dissenters in a blatant show of intimidation. Vanoc’s city-official friends enacted laws that tried to impinge dissent of any sort, whether it be signs in private homes decrying the Games or placards voicing protest against the IOC’s tactics.

The protest on February 12 will include people from all over Canada and the world that came to this city because they believe in democracy. What Vanoc and the IOC are perpetrating is the very definition of what Mussolini called fascism or corporatism—the merger of state and corporate power. It is the IOC that is anti-democratic. Everyone that stands against the Olympics is saying that they are a political participant and not a serf, and that they will not allow basic democratic rights to be destroyed so that the IOC can profit.

The Olympics may be here, but the people of this city are too and they will make their voices heard. They will also loudly tell other people of the world and Olympic host cities that we can together stop this behemoth from destroying entire cities under the obfuscation of “bringing the world together for sport”.

Isaac Oommen wrote this commentary on behalf of the 2010 Welcoming Committee, which is organizing the Take Back Our City festival and march on Friday (February 12).

Comments

paridigm shift
HEY protestors...something to think about ....I guess it's time to live in the NOW instead of constantly being chained by our negative thoughts about the future and our remorse for the past .

Just watch what your fellow persons do -when you become concious and head off on your own direction and not associate with a collective repressed identity.... Your decisive strength scares them and they will do what they can to keep you where you are... because your part of their lazy identity and you affirm their lack of goals. Only follow your conciousness not the collective . Hey protesters....Try and think of nothing for 30 seconds and observe how many of your thoughts rooted in the past and future ...and they are all mostly negative and constraining... live in the NOW and nothing is overwhelming. After all, the present moment is really the only thing that exists in whiich change can be made . So walk in a different direction and watch yourself think for today instead of protesting along with the repressed collective thought of others . Try it and your life will change
 
ger
Just a question. What do you hope to accomplish?
 
reality101
paridigm shift, I take it you don't care about your rights and freedoms? Don't tell others how to live their life
 
freedom advocate
To those of you who are crying bloody murder about your rights and freedoms being taken away for the Olympics:

If you were half as worldly and compassionate as you claim to be, you'd know that human rights are being abused on a massive scale in many, many countries around the world to an extent that is so far beyond what you're seeing now that the comparison is not even valid. Spend more time advocating on behalf of those people, rather than wasting your breath on this tempest in a teapot.
 
uhhhhhh1
"Just a question. What do you hope to accomplish?"

Maybe use the Olympics as a platform to show the public how our money is being thrown away by this government?
 
pwlg
As the commons continue to be occupied by a militarized zone, corporate branding and colonizing people's minds through corporate media, it is imperative that there be examples of critical thinking, moral reasoning and intellectual ability willing to be seen and heard. If not, we live perilously close to becoming a totalitarian society.

Neil Postman wrote in the forward to his book "Amusing Ourselves to Death" (comparing George Orwell's 1984 and Aldous Huxley's Brave New World) the following:

"in Huxley's vision, no Big Brother is required to deprive people of their autonomy, maturity and history. As he saw it, people will come to love their oppression, to adore the technologies that undo their capacities to think."

Postman's goes on by quoting Huxley in his sequel, Brave New World Revisted, "the civil libertarians and rationalists who are ever on the alert to oppose tyranny "failed to take into account man's almost infinite appetite for distractions".

"In Brave New World, they (people) are controlled by inflicting pleasure."

So, I take my hat off to those who are willing to be seen and heard and counted. Many of the residents of BC have followed the series of injustices, deceits and outright lies perpetrated against our society by those in positions of trust and its time to bear witness.

What do they hope to accomplish? Well let Leonard Cohen answer that,

"There is a crack, a crack, in everything...that's how the light gets in."
 
mew seng
Yay--Brad! I did not vote for the Olympics to come to Vancouver--I find that it is outrageous for this "Police State" to appear everywhere--one cannot park along Granville--bridges closing--now we should buy a candle and light it along the way of the "torch" along East Mall...? I will not be here/there--missed the plane to get out of town like my friends did--oh well-guess i can hide in my apartment. I do appreciate the excitement and all the "free venues", but to bar regular people who are from this city to certain public spaces and highways is outrageous!
 
zoolander
I agree with paridigm shift ... weird but it makes sense...
 
lazzzzyyyy
All the gimme gimme gimme people with no jobs who suck of the taxpayers titty will be out in force I'm sure.
 
Angie Roussin
How can you not support the people who are fighting for your freedom? It's like saying you're upset that black people, women and gay's now have rights? (The problem seems to be that people don't understand just how serious this political situation is).

There is no one they are fighting against, it is everyone they are fighting for. It's sad how easy it is to divide people when there are passions involved but I think you will find that we are all on the same side.

The only ones who are going to benefit should something go wrong, are the government officials looking to remove all rights. As a designer, I really love being able to express myself freely in this world and am grateful to the ones who have fought for that right. Thank you peace keepers! And good luck to all the athletes! I'm proud of you all.
 
fan22
^^^ "Police State"^^

I love how this term keeps getting thrown around. Maybe some of us would be better served if there were an actual 'Police State' in effect here during the games. Forget that, for ever.

I would love to hear..oh just wait if it were a police state, you wouldn't be complaining as your insignificant voice would silenced.

How is not parking along Granville, going to truly effect anyone?

Again..this has been 8 years in the making. Use your head, plan ahead.

How are 'regular people'; being barred from anything?

"Public Spaces?" I am pretty sure there are a lot of events that are held every year that require tickets, etc to get in. Are those events infringing on your rights?

Do you complain when the Sun Run closes roads? Do you complain that you have to pay to enter said race?

God forbid we have world class events here. Remember the Indy? Good thing we got rid of that event. Its not like it brought in any money into the local economy.

There are so many mis-truths being put out there it is getting more than annoying.
 
rob
The ISU is visiting homes and engaging in intimidation campaigns? good they re ;learning from the same anti Olympic activists who harassed Olympic organizers and politicians and vandalized their homes and offices a few years ago.

I'm not very confident in the RCMP's ability to control these morons all they seem to do is be able to kill confused tourists and harmless drunks. But I think were about to see that a lot of vancouverites and maybe a few tourists are fed up with dealing with protesters spoiling everything about the Olympics and will take matters into their own hands
 
Von stall (EUR)
I am facinated with paridigm shifts comments... such a insightful perspective that we can all follow
 
GC
Issac thank you for restoring my faith in journalism again temporarily.

What the Olympics will really show is how so many silver-spoon whites have lost their souls in search of consumerism and partying while the world continues to march downwards.

Vancouver has a chance to show the world we are not about Coca-Cola and McDonalds or even beer-swilling braindead hockey fans.

People who live here can still think for themselves and it is inspiring to see your article!
 
cassandra d
sounds like a psychoanalyst trying to make group dynamic opinions. hmmmm
 
Deb papish
As an Inuit I believe the Inukshuk as an olympic symbol is a complete joke considering the slap in the face the Labrador Inuu residential school survivors received instead of the benefits received by other aboriginal people.Imagine Father Canada saluting the inukshuk while wearing his inuit mukluks(moccasins).Have you ever witnessed such hypocrisy?
 
dan
Can we all go to mcdonalds for a coke after the protest? Or maybe that minus 5 ice lounge at monk mcqueens... I mean how long is the protest supposed to be anyways?
 
anonymist
I wish I was smart enough to understand that poster in the window. Why are the mascots that everybody mocks suddenly cool? Just about as confusing as the argument in the commentary, but better executed.
 
distraction
Forget the IOC, forget the cameras and billions hijacked. There's a war, a real shooting war going on. For the last 8 years we have been killing people (and denying their human rights) in a country which resisted the Soviet Army for a decade and which is now blackmailing us using weapons we gave them. Want to make your righteous voice heard? Stop the war. Everything else is a sideshow.
 
attend
I agree with living in the now. I also think this parallel celebration should be held. It shows presence. If you look at any group that holds any amount of control, you will see they have presence. We are all to busy watching TV and putting people on pedestals for being good at games. I think it is happening NOW. It's really should be a celebration of the fact that we don't get shot in the street like dogs in this country. The paradigm shift will happen when people stop existing indoors, watching small shifts happen in the background of news reports about mostly sad events; It's this that keeps people in a state of deprivation of triumph and happiness until the magical day comes to watch others do what we do not.
 
Laugh Riot
Best of luck with your loser rally!
 
a human
.help save a life stop execution of iranian youth call 1.613 2354726
 
Dann
So after the protest want to go to some of the cool olympic bars! I hope this protest does not take too long.
 
FUGC
Ugh, GC do you honestly think you're an original? Just because your flock faces a different direction, you still flock together. You're a sheeple of a different breed, that's all.
Leave it to a bunch of misinformed, pretentious carbuncles to turn the Olympics into an excuse for rich white people (let's face it, if you live in Van you're richer than most people in the world) to paternalize the issues of the poor and different ethnic groups.
 
Guardian article (UK)
“No matter the situation, there’s always someone intent on spoiling other people’s fun. Such is the case with Vancouver’s Olympic Games, where a cadre of loudmouth, red-in-the-face activists and hyperbolic critics have unleashed opinion pieces that blame the Games for the closure of local schools and stoke fears of an impending police state. What nonsense. While playing host to the Olympics may have its shortcomings, the massive, Games-led public investment in Vancouver’s infrastructure and arts will benefit residents of this city and province long after the Olympics have closed up shop.”

— The Guardian
 
Kris2
I still don't understand these protesters. If the Olympics din not come to Vancouver it's not like school closures would not happen, the homeless would all get a place to live, poverty eliminated, taxes cut, and every little girl gets her own pony. I bet these charities get more money from the Olympic sponsers and local businesses/tourists from the money brought into the economy then they would have if the Olympics weren't here. This is also about the atheletes, I hate that people keep trying to turn this into their own personal soap box.

Also I like how the protesters are against the Olympics, but I bet you they won't even dare protest at Paralympic games which are also a part of the same deal. All our local atheletes earned this chance to show us what they're made of. Stop ruining this for them and their supporters.
 
Agent Cooper
Calling Vancouver a police state is offensive. People have a right to security and this is not Belfast in the 90s or Tehran. Smarten up. You're minimizing the actual suffering of people elsewhere. It's disgusting.
 
Get a grip
"As the commons continue to be occupied by a militarized zone, corporate branding and colonizing people's minds through corporate media, it is imperative that there be examples of critical thinking, moral reasoning and intellectual ability willing to be seen and heard. If not, we live perilously close to becoming a totalitarian society."

Did you actually write this? Seriously, get a grip. Take a deep breath and stop reading Orwell novels. No one will deny this money could have been better spent (but would it have been?), it is a parade of sponsors and a drain on our local economy, but seriously you are far to melodramatic and the reason why "the common folk" dismiss protesters as crazy hippies with too much time on their hands. There's your crack...
 
BC-er
What's interesting about the pro-Olympic folk is the passivity. Just let it happen. that's why the pine forests collapsed, schools are closing, medical services are being cut to the elderly and disabled and let's not forget the HST snuck in after an election by a convicted Drunk Driver running a government under investigation by the RCMP.
Your method of lying on your back and making the best of it has really made this Province great, hasn't it?
Your children will look back with kindness, I'm sure.
 
jackson dt
Why does anyone have a problem with protesters exercising their right to free speech and freedom of assembly? Listen, government officials, corporate sponsors, businesses, and other interested parties are utilising the olympics as a platform and a venue to communicate their messages to domestic and foreign media, to consumers, to the public at large and to foreign dignitaries. So, why shouldn't the protesters utilize the same strategy? It is the smart thing for them to do.
You may disagree with their message, but one cannot disagree that this is prime opportunity for anyone with a message and the desire to communicate it. Corporation, politicians and protesters alike.
 
kreativekaur
Dear freedom advocate...

I agree with what you are saying.... BUT... Being a humanitarian (as an experienced NPO working around the globe, and local) I believe that we need to look at our backyard first, before trying to clean up someone else's alley. Democracy and freedom of speech are necessary, but I do not advocate violent means in order to practice these human rights. If we stop voicing ourselves in a democracy, we will lose everything, even the hope in our future. I certainly do not want my children to inherit that fate as we ourselves tether on a fine balance.

And for the protesters...
Be peaceful and respectful, that is the true Canadian way, so be the part :)

Just my 2 cents.

-
kreative kaur
- Imagination is more important than knowledge.
Knowledge is limited. Imagination encircles the world." - Einstein
 
lillian
The sad state of BC, is not the young athletes fault. They are here to do their best for their country's. It is the underhanded methods, Campbell uses, against the people of BC. He, has destroyed our province, so, he could play, the big fellow. I, am afraid Campbell, already has the title of, being the worst Premier, in the history, of Canada. That is what he will be remembered for. He will no doubt will, be remembered, for the Olympic debt.
 
BC Best Place On Earth
$6,000,000,000 isn't really all that much money when you consider what other monetary amounts have accumulated to. This *is* the Olympics after all. There is a call to showcase our face as a nation to the world, but I don't think it should be about who gets what monies, rather expressing our freedom of peaceful gathering and how we want to care for our world, and our country and it's respective provinces. We are so blessed to have this place where we can speak our minds about pollutions whereas unlike communist China their free speech is repressed. You may think that you are thinking *big* talking about this debt, and really you *need* to think bigger since there's much more going on than that, just sayin.'
 
ger
So dod the thousands of people sleep in?
 
Kw
you all have showed your true colours today.
You should be shamed. Shamed at the damage you and your ilk are doing on a global scale to human suffering. For what? So you and your anarchist club can march up a street and destroy buildings and businesses built by people. Who do you think pays to support your causes. Who do you think fundraises for those you talk about representing.....the people. You have spat in our face. ...shame.....
 
OB1Kanobee
So sad that protestors have purposfully turned violent today. Then they turn around and say that violence against property is not the same as violence against people so therefore it was the police who are responsible for instigating violence. My, my.. Once property damage starts to occur, the right to protest needs to be cancelled.

As far as the "right" to protest..... what about my right to go to an event of my choosing without dealing with these misguded individuals who have nothing better to do than make up false facts to put across an idea that I dont care about! Having a RIGHT does not mean it is absolute in itself. Having a right that infringes on anothers rights is not a real right at all.... and society must, as a whole determine on an individual case whether or not to accept that RIGHT This is called democracy.
 
Jack Ness
Protesters: In order to be taken seriously in an opposition to the spending of "public monies", perhaps some level of contribution to that amount would stand you all a better chance of being taken seriously. In the mean time I hope the cells are cold and uncomfortable while you await trial.
 
carl bailey
to fan 22, who wrote: "^^^ "Police State"^^

I love how this term keeps getting thrown around. Maybe some of us would be better served if there were an actual 'Police State' in effect here during the games. Forget that, for ever."


there is no requirement for police states to be brutally repressive in order to be police states. all that is required for a police state to exist is the legislated and court-approved 'legality' of suppression of rights, such as freedom of speech, freedom to gather in public places in order to voice disagreement, or the freedom to take a photograph on a public street, to name just a few of the rights that have been limited or outright banned in order to present this corporate circle-jerk, complete with performing animals, for the pleasure of those gordon campbell seeks to please (and, undoubtedly, be counted amongst the mighty of, someday).
if you feel that brutality is required, just recall the wonderful celebration of the canuck stanley cup efforts on robson street back in 1994. i was there. i saw no violence being perpetrated by anyone while i was there, and i left just mere moments before the police decided that the crowd's inability to shift quickly enough out of the way for the ambulance that had picked up the jackass who had tried to shinny across the transit cable justified their decision to attack from 4 sides. a tactic they were roundly criticised for by police forces who routinely deal with violent riots that are actually started before the police respond to them.
you might also want to contrast the swift use of rubber bullets and tear gas on a celebrating crowd with the "restraint" exercised against masked protesters smashing windows on saturday, and ask yourself why the contradictory tactical responses keep occurring.
there is a simple answer, and occam's razor is usually correct about simple answers.
 
nhcs
I think Paradigm Shift has got the winning plan. This is all a grand delusion, so why not dive in?
 
Strategis
These pithy and timeless statements by wise and eloquent souls, I feel, speak to the question of why to protest this Olympics. By protesting the Olympics, I don't mean protesting venerable traditions, fitness, amateur sports, friendly competition, excellence, travel, being a good host, international sharing, etc. I mean protesting against the deception, the broken promises, and in general the dishonest, immoral, and destructive side of the modern Olympic tradition.

About saying that the Olympics are a fait accomplit, so just suck it up and stop crying over spilt milk:

"To sin by silence when we should protest makes cowards out of men"
Ella Wheeler Wilcox

About buying into the bloated and absurd security measures that have been instituted for this Olympics, that we will be paying for over many years, in more ways than one:

"Collective fear stimulates herd instinct, and tends to produce ferocity toward those who are not regarded as members of the herd.”
Bertrand Russell

Regarding the demonisation of protestors, the poor, anarchists, the police, Muslims, Palestinians, the Taleban, criminals, etc. to justify actions and policies that directly contravene basic human rights and international laws:

"Racism [or any crude basis for negative prejudice] is man's gravest threat to man - the maximum of hatred for a minimum of reason.”
- Abraham J. Heschel

“Racism is not only limited to classification of human color but more found in the religion, nationality and rich community.” Martin Dulal

And to those who think that unless troops in Nazi uniforms are knocking on doors to haul people away to be cremated alive in concentration camps, that we live in a perfect democracy, and full compliance with and endorsement of all institutional mandates is justified:

"None are more hopelessly enslaved than those who falsely believe they are free."
Johann Wolfgang von Goethe - (1749-1832)

"A nation of well informed men who have been taught to know and prize the rights which God has given them cannot be enslaved. It is in the region of ignorance that tyranny begins." -- Benjamin Franklin - (1706-1790) US Founding Father
 
buzz
Wow, 1000 people - how "massive". Compare that with the 60,000 who came to the opening ceremony and the countless other thousands who came downtown just to be near the excitement. Time to quit giving the professional whiners all the publicity.
 
buzz
What's really funny, aside from the hypocritical clowns at ORN, is the fact that their "massive" protest consisted of about 1000 people. Luckily the police were there to help them make their way through the crowd of 100,000 or so who were downtown to support the Olympics. Just another example of why the Straght is a waste of paper.
 
The real purpose of the 2010 Olympics
The trappings of a state of siege trap us in a state of fear, ill-equipped to deal with the patriot games, the mind games, the war games of an unelected president and an undisclosed vice president."
US Presidential candidate Dennis Kucinich

 
where are the police
police state? i wish! you cant get a cop to respond to a real emergency these days in a timely fashion at all. . . guess they are all stuck downtown directing traffic wtf
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.