Ergonomy optimization

News and Views » News Features | Olympics

2010 Heart Attack disrupts Vancouver on day two of Winter Olympics

Carlito Pablo

Protesters in black march in front of an Anti-Poverty Committee banner on Hastings Street.

By Carlito Pablo,
Stephen Hui

A Province newspaper box was used to shatter a window at the Bay.

For almost two spirited hours today (February 13) under a grey morning sky, there was little doubt about who owned the downtown streets of Vancouver.

“Our streets!”, “Our streets!”, “Our streets!” anti-Olympic protesters defiantly chanted as they stepped off the sidewalk off Thornton Park at about 9:05 a.m. and occupied the northbound lane of Main Street, starting what turned out to be close to a full-blown riot.

Their ground zero: the intersection of Denman and Georgia streets where they hoped to block traffic going in and out of the Lions Gate Bridge, an artery leading to the skier paradise of Whistler.

It’s day two of the 2010 Olympic Games, an event that for years has stirred conflicting passions among many Vancouverites.

About 500 mostly black-clad and masked demonstrators showed up at the park for the event billed as "2010 Heart Attack". By the time they hit the streets, they were pumped up by what a leader promised on the bullhorn as “fuck day full of action”.

It didn’t take long before the action started, and right before the eyes of bicycle-riding police in yellow jackets.

At the intersection of Main and Wilson Streets, plastic road markers closing off the viaducts were toppled. At East Georgia Street, the first news box–Metro’s–came crashing down. This wasn’t the last of the several news and post office boxes to be trashed. Several moments ahead, a Georgia Straight box came down at the corner of Pender and Hamilton Streets.

This wasn’t the traditional placard-carrying protest that many are familiar with. It wasn’t a peaceful and pretty event.

As organizers have long advertised, it was one where a diversity of tactics were to be employed. 

“This is what democracy looks like!” protesters shouted as a hint of marijuana smoke wafted into the morning air.

A van bearing the sign of a government ambulance supervisor rode ahead of the march until it reached the corner of Hastings Street.

A brief moment of tension ensued as the crowd surged near the front of the Vancouver Police Department station. Would they spray anything at the cop shop? Nothing like that happened and after a few seconds they retreated toward Hastings Street.

Moving westward along Hastings Street and occupying all lanes, the demonstrators unfurled a huge black banner with deep red letters proclaiming the participation of the Anti-Poverty Committee, a group that is known for unconventional ways of political expression.

As they made it past Carrall Street, about three bike-riding cops quickly surrounded an unoccupied police patrol car parked on the northern side of Hastings, fearing perhaps it would be targeted.

The protesters turned left on Cambie Street, and a couple grabbed two grey garbage boxes and spilled their contents onto the pavement.

The crowd turned right on Pender Street and more news boxes came down. They manoeuvred left on Richards Street, putting them just two blocks off West Georgia Street.

By 9:50 a.m., they were on West Georgia Street, and immediately one could sense that things are about to go up several notches in intensity. Police had their hands full redirecting traffic, and cars bearing the marks of Olympic organizer Vanoc were told to quickly get out of the scene.

The Bay store, with all of its Olympic paraphernalia, was hit. Windows were either spray-painted or smashed.

There was the constant sound of metal grating against cement, as news boxes were dragged onto the pavement.

At 10:05 a.m., as the demonstrators approached Burrard Street, the first antiriot police were seen. Before reaching Thurlow Street, squads of antiriot police began boxing in the marchers.

Here the first scuffle occurred as a couple of youthful demonstrators attempted to stop the antiriot police from shadowing the march. A man was pinned to a wall, and a police officer said: “You’re disturbing the entire city.”

It was clear at this time, around 10:10 a.m., that the police would make their move. Crowds following the marchers were told the stay back, but such orders weren’t followed.

At the wide intersection of West Georgia and Cardero Streets, just before Denman Street, a wall of police and cop cars came. The “2010 Heart Attack” wasn’t going to move any further.

By this time, the ranks of the demonstrators had thinned to about 200 or 300. They looked like they were outnumbered by the antiriot police.

Arrests quickly followed. A woman dressed entirely in black was grabbed and quickly surrounded by a squad of bicycle-riding police, who dragged her to a patrol wagon. Legal observers followed on the sidewalk, asking her for her name. She responded with a name that sounded something like “Dana Reily”.

Another man was held by both arms by two cops, and wasalso thrown into the wagon. A legal observer told the Straight at the scene that there may have been four or five people nabbed by police. But even arrests didn’t break the demonstrators' defiance. They kept banging the inside walls of the wagon until the vehicle took off.

At 10:35 a.m., the corner of West Georgia and Cardero Streets were occupied by rows of police officers. The streets belonged no more to the young men and women of 2010 Heart Attack.

Post a Comment

Comments

Mark Stevens
Rating: Loading...
This is what democracy DOESN'T look like. This is what fascist brown shirts look like. These losers should stay home.
 
Graham Williams
Rating: Loading...
Can we avoid using the racially loaded term "paddy wagon" please?

Irish Canadians everywhere are fine with the use of that term, just not when it's used to house cowards that wear masks while pretending vandalism is civil disobedience. "Hooligan wagon" or "Vehicle for transporting those with nothing better to do than engage in mischief" would be more appropriate in this case.
 
Dhorea
Rating: Loading...
what a bunch of thugs ! I am ashamed to be an activists if this is what the NOW generation thinks is PEACEFUL PROTEST
You are all a bunch of IDIOTS YOU are worse than any government when this type of behaviour is encouraged and thought to be useful in any way.
SHAME ON YOU
and you wont show your FACE ! GUTLESS to top it off GUT-LESS
do you HEAR ME ??????
Hiding like a Terrorist makes you ONE ~ take off your masked & act like HUMAN BEINGS not TERRORISTS! what is the matter with you? do you really think this will help at all? NO all you do is turn people away, the people you need to be with you
IDIOTS
GO HOME AND THINK ABOUT WHAT YOU HAVE DONE
 
Kennedy
Rating: Loading...
Jerks like this ruin it for people with valid arguments to be aired with non-violent civil disobedience.
 
Guardian article (printed)
Rating: Loading...
No matter the situation, there’s always someone intent on spoiling other people’s fun. Such is the case with Vancouver’s Olympic Games, where a cadre of loudmouth, red-in-the-face activists and hyperbolic critics have unleashed opinion pieces that blame the Games for the closure of local schools and stoke fears of an impending police state. What nonsense. While playing host to the Olympics may have its shortcomings, the massive, Games-led public investment in Vancouver’s infrastructure and arts will benefit residents of this city and province long after the Olympics have closed up shop.”

— The Guardian
 
Charlie Smith
Rating: Loading...
Graham Williams,
Our senior editor, Martin Dunphy, did not edit this article. He often talks in the office about how the term "paddy wagon" should not be used. I have replaced the term with "patrol wagon" in response to your comment. I didn't call it the "hooligan wagon", but you're free to offer that point of view. And we'll run comments by those who disagree with you.
Charlie Smith
 
Barb R
Rating: Loading...
Morons.
 
Kw
Rating: Loading...
please do not allow these freaks and balaclaved children to be spokespersons for free speech and legal protest in B.C. They stand for nothing of substance but an avenue to bring out their own aggression and show their sense of entitlement.
These are nothing but spoilt, children and if they don't look out it won't be the police they should be afraid of but the population of British Columbia.
If they are looking for a war they may just find one ....... just in an most unexpected spot.
 
Enough!
Rating: Loading...
This radical bulls**t has to stop! You are not helping any cause and you are hurting a lot more! You masked cowards are barely worth the air you breath!
 
Black Block go home
Rating: Loading...
As someone who protested at Saturday's anti-Olympics rally, these clowns doing the work of police agent provocateurs don't represent me.
 
dumbledore
Rating: Loading...
What a bunch of creeps. Do they realize how many tax dollars they wasted today?
 
Lisa Henderson
Rating: Loading...
Actually, fascism would be the police violently cracking down on any anti-Olympic talk or action for the past 6 or so years. Open your eyes, that's why they've spent more than $1 billion dollars on security alone, because the protests are for legitimate reasons. Sweeping the DTES of its homeless to make way for the games? That's a riot that I want to join.
 
Graham Williams
Rating: Loading...
Cheers Charlie. It was meant mostly in jest, but as an Irish Canadian I appreciate you making the change.
 
Does it matter?
Rating: Loading...
Where is David Eby and Pivot? Where are the "Legal Observers"? What about my rights to not be intimidated, to be able to walk down this public street wearing what-ever clothes I decide to wear without being harrassed by these protesters? What about the rights of property owners not to have their property destroyed by vandals? I would like to hear his comments on this wrong behaviour. But of course it is easier to only defend the rights of those you choose to. And to stay silent when you are wrong. Cowards. Why don't you put on a mask like the other criminals running around that you "defend". I have rights too.

 
Eric Vancouverite
Rating: Loading...
The right to speak freely is not the right to be heard.

Formulate a cogent argument, present it in a compelling way that the majority decide accords with their beliefs, and win: Democracy.

I suspect most of the public is not compelled by today's actions, but what do I know...

(a DTE-born-and-bred guy that really thinks Vancouver is headed towards serious conflict...)
 
GC
Rating: Loading...
The Georgia Straight comment boards have been invaded by paid people who are certainly not readers of the newspaper, how sad.

Part of VANOC million dollar promotion propaganda action.
 
Nadina Barrie
Rating: Loading...
It's a shame that both sides of the fight seem to harbour so much anger--clearly displayed in the words and actions of many.
Pretty shocking for Vancouver, considering I haven't personally heard a VIOLENT anti-2010 statement--simply that folks don't agree with HOW this whole pissing contest is being run (and let's face it--we're glorifying our city to the world: It's a great big weiner-measuring affair). However, I have heard pro-2010 folks express angry and/or violent sentiments regarding those who oppose the Olympics. Everyone's a little guilty--of feeling powerless and expressing that ineffectively. These are not easy times. The Games will always pose a challenge to the host.
 
Eric Vancouverite
Rating: Loading...
@Lisa: Have you lived in the DTES? Are you sure you know their plight? How many of the local residents have you spoken to recently?

Olympics aside...

It would have been much cheaper to just plow through the protesters than to train and employ all these yellow jacketed piggies. It would have been much cheaper to stop subsidizing post-secondary seats filled with weak people being taught by washouts that can barely finish their own PhD. We'd then have funds left to help the poor.

This is where our money is being wasted. Go flip some burgers, translate for tourists, and bus a table... this is all Vancouver people have proven to be (that and hole-drilling speculators, gamblers, pornographers, web2.0-SEO-make-money-quick-wannabies, etc). Quit trying to act smart. There's probably a reason why the world thinks we're retarded... Yes, nice mountains, big trees, nice ocean... Stupid locals that make crap wages washing bedsheets at hotels (although hookers make more I suppose). Trust me, this is what this city is good for... lashing out and wishing we were better is just a waste of energy and time. Becoming better is an internal journey, one of strong will and determination. Not a quick scream for others to change.

Everywhere I've travelled to lecture, people comment on how beautiful Vancouver is... nobody comments on how influential, capable, or intelligent the people are. I wonder why...

Regarding fascism: We voted for the current government, who's laws the police are trying (with abuses, yes... but don't start on the two-wrongs fallacy again) to uphold. I do not recall a black-hooded-chicken$hit as an option on past ballots. Reveal your face, explain your platform in dumb enough words that maybe I might understand, and hey... win a democratic platform. Otherwise your free speech is likely to merely generate low-level heat.
 
guardian response
Rating: Loading...
In the past six months provincial funding to the arts has been drastically cut, with plans to reduce a number of corner stone arts organizations down to 2% of their 2008 funding.
At the same time billions of dollars are being spent to throw a nationalist sports party that serves elite athletes and affluent sports enthusiasts.
There will be an Olympic legacy in British Columbia - the arts community that has given Vancouver a large part of it's global identity will have either gone underground or returned to Europe. Leaving Vancouver with bleached one dimensional arts organizations whose sole function is to entertain tourists.
 
Other side of life
Rating: Loading...
Well I wouldn't follow their example, personally, but I imagine they would claim that direct action is the only kind authority really fears. Peaceful protest is easily ignored. Physical disruption of the spectacle, less so.
In any case most disruption of regular life in Vancouver has come from the organizers, not protesters
 
zev tiefenbach
Rating: Loading...
i don't think that it's okay that coca-cola and rbc get to parade around the city advertising themselves as they effectively destroy many foundational aspects of a free and healthy society. these corporate goons do own the streets and are protected by gun-toting thugs. those corporate floats are what worry me and are undemocratic. these corporations and their henchman are the ones that are armed and do real damage and violence to us as society and to people abroad.

a bunch of black-blockers overturning newspaper boxes on our streets is a most miniscule expression of balance to counterattack the assault of corporatism that now pervades our public spaces.

by the way, i appreciated how well written this article was.

further thoughts: http://www.chroniclesofzev.com/2010/02/our-children-political-footballs-...
 
Lyle Wagner
Rating: Loading...
Nazi thugs.
 
Kw
Rating: Loading...
As@@#$%)!s .....they are......
Don't stand for anything concrete. Don't represent anything other than anarchy. Don't have anything positive to bring to the table ....arrest them all and parade they and their faces in front of the media so that we may all see who they are and shame them and their families (who should be ashamed) ..... until they learn how to protest in a constructive manner. if I were representing any of theses causes I would be very worried right now ...all of the work done to this point is being wiped out ....and on a global scale.
 
Charlie NoSong
Rating: Loading...
Hi Carlito, thanks for making accurate estimations of how many people were present in these groups of people. I've noticed many articles have been under-estimating the amount of protesters that were present which is kind of strange?

Here's a short video of protesters at Robson and Broughton:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/kharvey/4353835609/

 
East Van Mom
Rating: Loading...
I am embarrassed by these protesters! The Olympics are our chance to shine & show the world all that we are as British Columbians, Canadians....kind-hearted, peaceful & generous. I hope that SOME kind of media attention is give to the millions of us who disagree with these violent protesters! What cowards to hide behind their masks! They look more like terrorists than protesters.....are these people fallen youth? Angry young adults? Obviously angry at the world and seeking attention in the worst of ways....
 
huh
Rating: Loading...
They didnt do anything that bad. I mean they seem to be protesting stupidly, but what else you gonna do when your disenfranchised?
 
iang
Rating: Loading...
There is a big difference between these Black Bloc tactics and the peaceful tactics of Friday night - don't get them mixed just for the sake of making your point.
 
Linda
Rating: Loading...
As a visitor to the city, i gotta say this protest was a bit successful. There was a protest yesterday that was "peaceful". And i have no idea what was being protested because no one was listening to them. They were content to stand there with their picket signs and not force anyone to listen. And i didn't. But i did to this protest. And now i'm aware of a problem with poverty in Vancouver. It kinda works. Sorry.
 
Sheelagh
Rating: Loading...
If one bought the argument that there were a few police agent provocateurs then that makes the rest of the idiots following along nothing more than mindless sheep. That I would believe.

And it's amusing to think these thugs are trying to communicate anything to the public - or did they make their message clear before they chased everyone away with their violence and intimidation?
 
Tyler
Rating: Loading...
The VPD have shown incredible restraint. Certainly more than I would.
 
John Merzetti
Rating: Loading...
To East Van Mom:

You said, "The Olympics are our chance to shine & show the world all that we are as British Columbians, Canadians....kind-hearted, peaceful & generous." Apparently we are not all kind-hearted peaceful and generous; your Pollyanna outlook is a little inappropriate in this age of globalization and the unrest that has resulted from it. Where have you been these past couple of decades?.

I think the protestors were idiots to behave as they did; they have lost a lot of respect (assuming that they had any to begin with). It is truly unfortunate, but to try to gloss over things and pretend that we, as a people, are some sort of homogeneous species of automatons is no better than any efforts to hide the reality that is the DTES,
 
be effective
Rating: Loading...
Study Gandhi
 
rick
Rating: Loading...
You just knew this was going to happen to Vancouver. Bad mojo and technical glitches set the stage for a negative branding campaign by people who have promised to do this all along. From a global perspective, Vancouver can still look golden as it has managed to maintain the perception that reconciling with Aboriginal peoples is taken seriously here. If that breaks down, this will surly be a dismal Olympics. This is something that everyone who desires to showcase whats good about vancouver should keep in mind. It is after all a world stage.
 
Fresno B
Rating: Loading...
Punching someone in the face is violence. Knocking over a newpaper box or breaking a window is not. Spending 7 billion for a bunch of sporting events while people starve in the streets is violence.
 
fan22
Rating: Loading...
THese people are nothing more than trash. Time to treat them like it. Make them disapear!
 
Suspicious in Vancouver
Rating: Loading...
'Black Block go home' wrote:

"As someone who protested at Saturday's anti-Olympics rally, these clowns doing the work of police agent provocateurs don't represent me."

How can you be sure that people acting like agent provocateurs are not in fact agent provocateurs? Is BC so different from Quebec? (You must remember Montebello and the SQ officer disguised as a black block member hitting a uniformed SQ officer with a rock in 2007.) For example see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agent_provocateur

 
@Fresno
Rating: Loading...
You're a fool. It's extremely violent to be throwing stuff through windows, potentially injuring people inside. On top of that, some of the protesting fools jumped someone on the street who disagreed with what they were saying.
 
fan22
Rating: Loading...
Fresno B - How anyone can defend what these retards are doing is beyond me.

Knocking over a newpaper box, breaking windows is a crime. How can someone not understand that. It is probably one of the simplest concepts out there.

Why didn't these protesters use this time to run a meal program on the DTES instead of causing damage to people's property?

These people are not helping anyone, let alone their cause..or causes..or non-cause whatever the case may be.


 
Jeff S
Rating: Loading...
Get out of our city. The police did a great job here, unfortunately these idiots won't end up where they belong, jail.

We live in one of the most accepting, multicultural and open societies on earth.
 
n/a
Rating: Loading...
shame on the protestors. There is no need to hurt people emotionally and physically just because you are against something or people. To the protestors, you have absolutely no empathy. What if you were in the place of those who were in support of the olympics and or vanoc's side, you wouldn't like to be hurted emotionally and or physically. and because as for the protestors i am ashamed to say that i am a vancouverite. The protestors have stooped beyond low. HEY protestors, you have absolutely no brains, you're all stupid people!!!!
 
Brad Smith
Rating: Loading...
These individuals are the first to cry foul if they think their rights have been violated, yet they have no hesitation in violating the rights of others. They did not "own" the streets at any time today. Nor should they think can hide behind their masks. By their own behaviour they have unmasked themselves for the louts they truly are. Congratulations to the police in handling them in such a professional way.
 
Jim
Rating: Loading...
Remember 48 hours ago when the Olympic Resistance Terrorist Network, despite being a self righteous facade of a movement, actually had some public support and credibility. Soon the police are going to have to protect they cowardly protesters from the general public. Amazing how quick the city is turning against the terrorists, I mean protesters.

Could Pivot Legal Society Olympic Legal Defense Team please hold a press conference on the rights of the general public in response to the increased terrorist presence around Vancouver.
 
Nicholas Headon
Rating: Loading...
If these societal leeches directed these energiess towards, say, actually getting a job, or at least something positive in their lives then they wouldn't be "disenfranchised" in the first place ..... but responsibilty is too much work, isn't it. It's just the "cult of victimization" taking over ... I'm poor because he's rich, blah blah blah. "Wasted tax dollars" ? What-a-joke: I bet that I (gladly) paid more in taxes lat year than the whole group of these clowns combined. And don't kid yourselves, those of you that praise them with faint condemnation are just part of the problem.
 
apeasant
Rating: Loading...
Oh enough already. There is no place for violence during the Olympics, unless you're sanctioned media who get close-up images of a dying luger's last moments for the game-obsessed masses.

Chariot racing was the most important event at the Circus Maximus... an extremely dangerous sport, frequently resulting in spectacular crashes and the death of one or more of the contestants
 
insimplicity
Rating: Loading...
It is sad that a few items got smashed. It is expected for people to be emotional about this cause but not excusable. Imagine if the people who are exploiting the minimal damage caused by this protest with such distaste juxtaposition themselves and found themselves pushing for a greater cause than entertainment I am sure the damage done to the streets would be much worse. But whatever helps you sleep at night. It is not a good feeling to know deep down somewhere that many of your fellow citizens are hurting. And it is certainly not a good feeling to know this and to continue pushing for entertainment in the wake of it. This protest was not about party poopin but how much people value entertainment over human lives. I most definitely agree with the cause. I do not believe the method was carried out as well as it could have been but it is a small price to pay. Protests just can't always be perfect.
 
Rob
Rating: Loading...
My god the Canadian police forces are incompetent we've spent how much on security and these people still can't be controlled. They can kill confused tourists on camera but can they hospitalize a few dozen protesters as a message which most of the city would welcome ( don't deny it, your sick of this as I am) nothing, bah
 
pictues
Rating: Loading...
I AM NOT PAID BY VANOC however I do AGREE with the right to protest but what these people did is NOT protesting they are vandalizing peoples property and harassing people with olympic clothing on, which last time I checked vandalizing peoples property and Harassing someone is ILLEAGAL
 
Arby
Rating: Loading...
Anger. Normal people who encounter paid enforcers for the corporatocracy and find that suddenly 'public servant' actually means 'servant of power', will react with anger. Normal people who see mindless violence, especially when it's committed by others who champion (or pretend to champion) a cause those normal people believe in, will react with anger. And when you're angry, you can't think clearly.

Who benefits from that?

Diversity of tactics? How you go about doing things says something about you and your true goals. It matters. Let's leave the mindless violence for those in darkness, such as managers of our 'law and order' governments and their paid tools. (Remember the police who posed as protesters in the Jelly Bean Summit? See: http://bit.ly/bGLpUd )Let's stay civilized, at all times, including when protesting.

We are in a war, unfortunately. A class war. The majority is losing because it's essentially unarmed and civilized. That is the price of agreeing among ourselves, including some of us who are wolves in sheeps' clothing who will become our enemies, to follow rules that would, normally, conduce to a civilized society. If you agree to be civilized and play fairly, then the other players immediately get an advantage by breaking those rules - if you are not willing to.

What irks me is that we, the majority, are okay with that. Our elites regard the people as the enemy (except when some among them are trying to get elected in one of our regular election rituals and must talk nice to us). And they act accordingly. Our elites are not our brothers and sisters. But they are smart. Therefore, To have any chance of getting out from under the boot of the corporatocracy and it's fascist tools, we must be smart too, in all we do, including protesting.

We need to stay sharp, like the tip of the bayonet pointed at us.
 
Goldorak
Rating: Loading...
Oh and by the way who is behind this demonstration? Green Youth Climate Movement
http://itsgettinghotinhere.org/2010/02/09/feb-13th-call-out-for-solidari...

So the Straight obviously condones this garbage... little eco marxist/fascists...
 
Luna
Rating: Loading...
You can bet, if this same protest had taken place in the streets of Beijing during the 2008 games, a lot of the same people currently denouncing it would be calling it a justified response to the violence of the Chinese state.

That being said, it's premature to think we can have the last word on this protest with regards to the specific tactics used by a small number of the demonstrators, unless the use of agents provocateurs (ie cops dressed as protesters, instigating violence) can be ruled out.

http://www.straight.com/article-241166/isu-wont-rule-out-agents-provocat...

That being said, I personally don't feel that that it's a very effective tactic to smash windows and such, but that doesn't mean I want to denounce the people involved (unless they were in fact cops, then I will denounce them...)

I'd much rather talk about ways we can make the movement more effective, but it requires hard work - a long term commitment to organization and education of the working class...and this isn't the kind of glamorous stuff that will appear on the nightly news.

Forced relocations, closed schools, closed hospitals, environmental destruction, the militarization of urban streets, and unsustainable levels of public debt incurred so elites can feed at the trough while the rest of us pay - THIS IS VIOLENCE.
 
[Comments Disclaimer]

Post a comment

· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.