2010 Olympic closing ceremony: Why wasn't there any aboriginal content?

Infusing Vancouver's Olympic closing ceremony with humour was a brilliant idea.

In more ways than could have been predicted, it was a fitting approach to cap off the intense emotional roller coaster, ranging from unexpected heartwrenching tragedies to overwhelming victories, that viewers have been riding for the last few weeks.

Whether or not it actually worked on a global level is another issue.

Using humour in an international context can be incredibly risky. What's funny in one part of the world may not necessarily translate well across cultures and languages.

Irony, sarcasm, and tongue-in-cheek humour are fairly sophisticated forms of humour that require a solid familiarity with the source material.

A presentation of stereotypes may not be understood as tongue-in-cheek by those whose only points of reference are, in fact, stereotypes.

A notable strength of the opening ceremony was its strong visual component, which made it easy for those with limited English comprehension to take in the images without detailed explanation.

However, the long Canadians Anonymous monologues in English in the closing ceremony, which relied heavily on in-jokes, may have been understood by North Americans while sailing over the heads of many international non-Anglophone viewers (and even some Anglophone populations).

Yet if the ceremony was about taking on stereotypes, it could have addressed some of the most internationally pervasive stereotypes of Native people that the opening ceremony may have actually contributed to.

Around the world, and even in Canada, people still have misconceptions about contemporary Native life based on images that continue to focus on Native characters in traditional or historical settings and lifestyles, such as in Hollywood films like Dances With Wolves or Pocahontas. What compounds the influential power of these images is the invisibility of significant modern or urban Native characters in mainstream media.

Strangely, while the opening ceremony included a considerable display of First Nations culture, there was a conspicuous absence of Native content in the closing ceremony. Although the event was attended by the four host First Nations leaders, they did not participate in any presentations or actual content during the broadcast, aside from being introduced and seated.

The “Aboriginal Participation” section of the official Olympic Web site states that on November 30, 2005, the Lil’wat, Musqueam, Squamish, and Tsleil-Waututh First Nations signed a protocol with the Organizing Committee that had several goals, including “Increase participation in medal ceremonies, Games Opening and Closing Ceremonies”.

It also states that Vanoc is “working closely with our partners, including the Four Host First Nations, to encourage Aboriginal people across Canada to participate in as many areas of the 2010 Winter Games as possible, be it as athletes, volunteers, employees, entrepreneurs, artists and performers, spectators or cultural ambassadors.”

Had there been an integrated commitment to including First Nations content, instead of segregating First Nations people into one segment in the opening ceremony and then forgetting about them after that, established aboriginal performers such as Buffy Sainte-Marie, Inuk singer Susan Aglukark, or Inuit throat singer Tanya Tagaq could have been chosen to participate. (After all, if the inukshuk was used for the Olympic logo, couldn't there have been northern aboriginal performers?)

Or why not have successful actors like Adam Beach (Flags of Our Fathers), Evan Adams (Smoke Signals), Tantoo Cardinal (Mothers&Daughters), or Graham Greene (Dances With Wolves) present a monologue, for example, poking fun at aboriginal stereotypes that continue to persist around the world?

When I interviewed Cree filmmaker Neil Diamond about his documentary Reel Injun, which examines the history of Native stereotypes in film, he told me that he took a jocular approach partly because Native humour is something that has been largely overlooked in mainstream representation even though it has been an integral part of many Native cultures. (He cited the example of the heyoka, or sacred clowns, who were like court jesters and taught people to do the opposite of the silly things they would do.)

He also said that he felt humour was an effective way to get his message across without making people feel defensive. Perhaps in the future, there will be some opportunities for other events to integrate Native humour in an effective way that will help to build bridges between different groups in Canada.

While there were clearly efforts made to achieve greater aboriginal participation in these Olympics, it’s important that other similar Canadian events can build upon and learn from both the strengths and weaknesses of this example.

On the one hand, the First Nations presentation in the opening ceremony did acknowledge Native cultures and people in a significant way and broadcast their presence to the rest of the world. On the other, it remained rather unbalanced in many ways that perhaps can be improved upon in future instances.

In the end, whether or not the ceremonies helped to counter or reinforce stereotypes about Canadians and Native people is uncertain as there’s no way to accurately measure it.

Ultimately, it may all depend on who you talk to.

As a starting point to learn more about aboriginal stereotypes, the Canadian Media Awareness Network has a section devoted to depictions of aboriginal people in media.

Comments

Birdy
Cheer up!

There obviously should have been some marijuana content as well, if this was supposed to represent all the minority groups in Canada. But hey what can you do? I though it was awesome, had some good laughs.
 
Polyglot
Like many Canadians I am a "visible minority" ( How I hate that tag and also how I dislike being called an East Indian..I can deal with Indo-Canadian but please lets shelve this East Indian stuff..then again I could write a book on the cultural ignorance of my fellow Canadians. )
A good point made by Craig is that there was very no aboriginal content and hardly any diversity during the closing ceremony.
Once again the First Nations people were sold a bill of goods which was not delivered.
If a Martian was watching he/she would have come to the conclusion that Canada is a country mostly made up of Caucasians with a few folks of African background in Toronto and few First Nations people in the North.
I heard one TV commentator in a Latin country refer to the closing ceremony as a Great White Vegas.. and he wasn't too far from the mark.
Neil Young was definitely a good choice but was Leonard Cohen invited? He could have sung "First we take Manhattan then we take Berlin".
Okay , now Mr. Campbell please get back to work, and put that flag down...you looked like Fat Albert as the Indy 500.
The bills are going to come due very soon and there's no money in the kitty.

I would like to see Charlie write an op-ed on this Olympic affair.
 
PaNDA mONEIUM
They should have included Nestor Pistor!

They Said Prostest
We Said Party

And We WON!
 
Linda
The closing ceremonies were dreadful and embarrassing.

The poking-fun-at-ourselves approach only works if it's funny and it was not. There was some pity laughs but that's about it. Neil Young was great but he sang a song about a car. And Nickleback?! Really??

There was a joke last year that the ceremonies would be just Anne Murray onstage by herself sining "SnowbIrd". It wasn't that far off.

Left out? Lucky.
 
ayteeo
I found the closing ceremonies corny & crass, especially after the superb opening ceremonies. We need to get past the obsession with how others see us: in reality, many of the stereotypes only travel outside our borders because we market them. We're better than the ceremonies suggested, especially musically.
 
ursa minor
Polyglot - Leonard Cohen was invited to perfrom "Hallejulah" at the Opening Ceremonies. He deferred to K.D. Lang, as he believed his song would sound better with her performing it.
 
Chookwa
Derek Miller who played guitar and sang with the two girls at the beginning of the ceremony will be suprised to learn he is all of a sudden not First Nations from Six Nations in Ontario.
 
Craig Takeuchi
Thanks for pointing that out, Chookwa, and apologies to Derek Miller.
I guess though my main point is that what was visibily recognizeable in terms of First Nations content in comparing the opening to the closing ceremonies seemed very unbalanced.
While a friend said that he knew there was one Native person for sure among the hip-hop dancers at the end, for example, there wasn't any way a viewer would be aware of that.
 
Pedubs
They didn't have any aboriginal content in the closing ceremonies because the producer was afraid they would be late again
 
hadenough
The Natives got their representation by putting their simplistic art on the medals. Not sure why that was done, but so be it. Now people are complaining about not enough native culture in the closing party. Besides receiving about $5 Billion a year (for the past 20 years) of taxpayers money every year, the Native peoples are well looked after and represented in many provincial and federal programs. Where were the bag pipes? The Irish dancers? Hindu music? One could go on, and on. Let's face reality: the Native population has little to do the mainstream white society, it's their choice. Trying to promote an antiquated way of life is holding back an entire culture. Let's move forward people and embrace the future!
 
Great White North
I agree. Neither the opening or closing ceremony did our multi-cultural country justice. As someone watching it on television, it would be hard to notice individual performers of colour in the mass of dancers etc. But I certainly noticed a lack of Canadian celebrities of colour (with a few notable exceptions). It's not like we don't have any fampus non-white Canadians who could have carried the Olympic flag, or lit the cauldren, or delivered a better comedy bit than Katherine O'Hara. The inflatble mounties and cardboard hockey players were all white (and male, incidentally), so that even our cartoon representations of ourselves lacked diversity. Sad.
 
Nathaniel
First Nation's aren't even a visible minority in Vancouver. If anything, Chinese and Southeast Asians should have been better represented. Check this chart: http://tinyurl.com/yhopda3

In my opinion they received too much attention already in the opening ceremonies. They barely exist on the map, and yet we ignore the Chinese (who suffered great injustice by Canadians but still built our railways).

I think it's pretty obvious First Nations were used as a prop for tourists anyway. Not something to be proud of or encourage.
 
Sammmmm
No First Nations culture, no Inuit, no Metis, no Acadian, no Quebecois, no Maritime, no prairie, no Hutterite, no Alberta oilpatch redneck, no second generation Asian Canadian, no Japanese-Canadians whose grandparents were interned during the Second World War, no Montreal Orthodox Jews, no second generation white people whose families have been living North of 60 for 50 years....

Craig, I don't think the closing ceremonies' intent was to display the rich diversity of Canadian culture - it was to mock the stereotypes of what Canadian is, just because they are so limiting. All of us know about Mounties and beavers, but very few of us are represented entirely by it.

And Nathaniel, aboriginal people are a visible minority pretty much anywhere they exist in this country. Just because you don't see them, doesn't mean they don't exist.
 
Bobby G
Spare me the "poor Chinese" nonsense. They were here for "gold" of Gold Mountain (their name for Canada) just as much as the Europeans. And the Chinese exploited the natives just as much as the Europeans did.
 
panic
Pedubs - the reason the First Nations cheifs were late at the opening ceremonies is because they were being detained at security... ahem
 
Yeahbut
Sammmm - It's true that it would have been impossible to showcase every single Canadian culture during the ceremony. But if you are going to sell yourself (as VANOC and the City of Vancouver did) as a multi-cultural ,Gateway to the Pacific, then you better make sure that there is at least some token Asian or South Asian presence in your event.
 
Transitrider
So Derek Miller doesn't count, nor does the reception given to the Chiefs of the Four Nations count...The Georgia Straight doesn't do it's research and is just looking for any scrap it can get to support it's anti-olympic bias.
 
patrick m
Why wasn't the men's hockey team at the closing ceremony ? I'm told they attended a private dinner party. First and foremost they are supposed to be members of the Canadian Olympic Team.
 
flameon
maybe a better question is why was there so much in the openning ceremony?
 
seef)
I agree they were an embarrassment - from the syrupy buble with his pantless mountiettes, to the table hockey, 2-man canoes, bad comedians (where's Ron James when you really need him?) and the talentless musicians, except NY, of course, it sucked. Someone should tell Neil there's no running in the winter olympics.
 
Nathaniel
@Sammmmm: I see them everyday in (North-)East Van. Just because I see them, concentrated in this area, doesn't change the fact they make up less than 3% the population of Vancouver. I meant "visible minority" in the technical political term sense.
 
anonymous
As someone directly involved with the Ceremonies, it was incredibly challenging getting the amount of people of aboriginal descent involved in the opening. The interest or commitment in participating was not there. So how do you deal with that? We had a group of amazing aboriginal drummers perform with scrap works during the finale Hip Hop Segment.
 
ljm
Seriously need to stop complaining about the amount of aboriginal representation in the Olympics...come on, the opening ceremony, the logo, the medals, the mascots...I'm pretty sure people get the jist that there is aboriginals in Canada. It's all over know so just remember it for what it was, and that was awesome.
 
lori
Complaining about the lack of diversity in the closing ceremoinies is ridiculous! unless you were on the floor in the crowd with all the people dancing how are you to pass judgement and say they were mostly caucasion? Why do people insist on bringing up the race in something as global and obviously un racial as the Olympics. Perhaps they all looked white because they were all dressed in Winter White. The ceremonies were a little corny but really great, and after that hockey game who cares that was enough of a closure!! Vancouver and Canada represented the people the culture and the country with great poise. I think they brought a sense of pride to the Nation that has always been there but hidden and quiet, these games allowed the ever "apologetic"Canadians to openly express there pride and patriotism. Be proud, Walk Tall and know that the world has taken notice of a great country, with great people!!
 
Emil
No First nations in closing ceremonies!!! Can you imagine the outburst if they had done a steretype of First nations. They would have had our white butts in court so fast (faster than a Weber slap shot) for prolonging the racial stereotype
 
pap
Vanoc talked about diversity but it was only lip service as was evidenced by the lack of diversity in the opening and closing games. Yes, there was First Nations, Anglo phone and Francophone cultures represented in opening ceremonies but what about the Asian, South Asian, Middle Eastern and other cultures that make up Metro Vancouver, BC and Canada. The ceremonies needed to show the outside world who we are as people that make up Canada. The past was represented but what about the present? John Furlong walks around getting pats on his back for a good job but I hesitate to congratulate him due Vanoc's lack of respect for the present society we live in. The outside world is probably more confused about Canada after the closing ceremonies. From viewing the comments here and on other sites the unity that John Furlong talks about is just wishful thinking. There is no unity and whatever unity there is will fade in the coming months.
 
Sylvia Harvey
The involvement of First Nations in the Olympic ceremonies, whether intentional or not, served to diffuse the influence of protestors who were trying to draw attention to the desperate situation of many First Nation people in the downtown Eastside.

To her credit, one of the Olypians got the message loud and clear. After "accidentally " ending up in the DTES, Bronze medalist Clara Hughes was so influneced by the suffering she saw there, that she is donating her medal bonus of $10,000. to "Take a Hike", a program that takes at-risk kids from Vancouver and exposes them to different experiences than poverty, drugs, and crime. She challenges us to join her.

Imagine harnassing the Olympic spirit in such a positive way, and actually being the kind of Canadians who change a city into the image our tourist brochures portray.
Has anyone considered turning the Olympic village into affordable housing units? Just a thought!
 
Your thinking it too
Has the author ever visited a "contemporary" first nations community? Maybe it would have been better to throw the Hollywood stereotype out the window and have them pull out a rusted mobile home onto the stage while a pregnant Pocahantas falls out of the door with 20 empty bottles of colt 45. Give me a break.
 
MK
After all the content involving aboriginals in the opening ceremonies did we need more in the closing ceremonies? Especially when there was almost no French-Canadian content in a supposedly bilingual nation? We basically treat natives like Americans treat black people, and I for one was embarrassed to see them trotted out as this symbol of Canada when in day-to-day life we let them anguish in poverty and completely ignore them. They're only part of our culture when the world is looking and we want to pretend we have culture.
 
OMG
Not enough aborginal stuff omg! There was far to much in the opening ceremonies and bot ceremonies were dreadful. Every Canadian would have been more than happy to have a replay of the Gold medal game for closing ceremonies. Who ever planned the opening and closing antics should be hung.
 
Camille
God I am so sick of the complaining. Everyone has a gripe, the French and the Aborginals, can we not all just be Canadians!!! Give it up already. There was a ton of aboriginal stuff in the opening ceremonies and a ton of French too, even though English is our first language and it was held in an english speaking province. All signage was written in French first and all announcements throughout both ceremonies were in French first, what is it that you people want? I was very impressed with the opening ceremonies acknowledging Atlantic Canada and the Scottish and English influence in our country. Not everything in the country has to do with the French and Aboriginals. My ancestors immigrated from Scotland to work in the BC mines and it is about time that my heritage in this country was recognized too.
 
Toronto Ron
This country was built by the British and the French, not the Indians
 
Thunder Bay
I was releved to see they did not put "natives on parade" as part of the closing ceremonies. There was a large contingent for the Opening and polite acknowledgement at the end. Imagine the uproar if blow-up Aboriginals had been juxtaposed to the blow-up Mounties. Best not to go there. It was all rather light hearted and kitchy in a fun way. I found myself laughing many times. I guess what they say is true...you can't please all the people all the time.
 
RodSmelser
PaNDA mONEIUM

They should have included Nestor Pistor!
=================================

I haven't heard of Nestor since the 1970s? Is he still doing shows?

Rod Smelser
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.