News and Views » Straight Talk

Black Press-owned Web site upsets Grand Chief David Harper with racist ad

Grand Chief David Harper (right), seen with Northlands Dene Elder Pierre Denechezhe, has asked for a police investigation into a racist ad that appeared on a buy-and-sell site in Winnipeg.

By Charlie Smith,

A Manitoba First Nation is asking that police  examine an ad placed  on a Web site owned by Black Press, which is a huge Victoria-based publishing company.

Manitoba Keewatinowi Okimakanak Grand Chief David Harper said in a news release that he wants the incident  investigated as a "hate crime".

The site, UsedWinnipeg.com, featured the headline: "Free: Native Extraction Site" above a photo of three aboriginal youths. The text suggested that they are pests that can be netted and relocated to their natural habitat.

The ad stated that the service is free unless tranquilizers are needed to complete the task, in which case the fee is $9.95 for a six-pack of beer.

In the news release, Harper declared "the ad should have never made it to the website in the first place, the people who own and operate Used Winnipeg.com must be held accountable and guarantee better screening processes are in place so something like this won’t happen again".  

The young people in the ad are award-winning filmmakers from Washington state. According to the MKO, they have  shown the effect that  oil companies are having on their land.

“The Aboriginal youth in the photo have been unnecessarily victimized and we will not tolerate it," Harper said in the news release.  "This is a reality that we see far too often as First Nation People.”

The ad is no longer on the site. Video of Harper's comments can be seen here on the Winnipeg Free Press site.

Today, the Globe and Mail reported that Black Press is interested in buying Canwest's Canadian newspaper empire. Black Press owns community papers across B.C. and in parts of Washington state, as well as daily papers in Ohio, Hawaii, and Alberta.

This isn't the first time Black Press has been caught up in a controversy involving aboriginal people.

In 1998,  company owner David Black  prohibited his papers from publishing editorials in favour of the Nisga'a treaty, which was the first modern treaty in B.C. history.

Black also ordered his editors to publish eight  columns opposing the treaty, which were all written by Mel Smith.

Smith, a former assistant deputy attorney general, was  perhaps B.C.'s  most outspoken critic of the Nisga'a treaty at the time.

In January 1999, the  NDP government filed a complaint to the B.C. Press Council against Black Press, arguing that its policy breached its duty to act in the public interest and violated the council's constitution.

Black Press defended its action by stating that editors who disagreed with the policy were free to write their opinions about the Nisga'a treaty  on the letters page and that the policy had no effect on news coverage.

The council, which is a self-regulating industry body,  dismissed the NDP government's complaint, concluding that the David Black papers "did in fact carry a diversity of opinion on the Nisga'a Treaty, including those of Premier Glen Clark, Liberal Leader Gordon Campbell, Reform Party President Bill Vander Zalm as well as those of ordinary British Columbians".

Follow Charlie Smith on Twitter at twitter.com/csmithstraight.

Comments

John JJ.
Black papers "did in fact carry a diversity of opinion on the Nisga'a Treaty".... So why did you begin with trying to state otherwise, and what does this have to so with the story of a racist in Winnipeg?
 
Big Bill
A self-regulating industry body, such as the Chinese dairy industry or the hilarious B.C. Press Council, never finds anything wrong with a member's conduct. A "self-regulating industry body" expressly exists to avoid regulation where it is obviously needed. It wouldn't exist otherwise. Its members are always exhaustively whitewashed (investigated) but no evidence can ever be found of any wrongdoing, move along, nothing to see here. To put any weight to their findings is at best playschool level naive but more likely willfully ignorant to the point of dishonesty.
 
RodSmelser
The press council ruling that David Black was in the clear on his editorial policy basically said that the freedom of the press belongs to the man who owns one. Some things never change, I guess.


Perhaps people would like to remember that David Black and his wife tried to get agricultural tax rates for their mansion on acreage in Victoria's Uplands, an old CPR subdivision with homes and streets similar to Vancouver's Shaughnessy, but even pricier in that it contains some waterfront sites next to the Royal Victoria Yacht Club. Their argument was that they had sold about $3,000 in flowers to a nursery business.


The municipality of Oak Bay turned them down, saying there are no agricultural zones in their district
.
Rod Smelser
 
Salty One
David Black can't know about every ad that runs in every Black Press publication, either in print or online, so I don't think he should be held responsible. I think Black Press's used.com operates like Craigslist where people place their own ads. Nevertheless, someone has to be held responsible, and that someone is the new media moderator who is supposed to monitor these things but didn't.
 
Disgusted
How about Grand Chief David Harper showing some outrage where it belongs......against the group of young people in boats in Manitoba, who, while laughing and joking, threw ropes around the antlers of a moose trying to swim across a lake, and drowning it, all the while, laughing. They did manage to drown the moose. Chief David Harper defended this group of ignorants by saying they were getting food for their families. Now THAT is an outrage. And aboriginals wonder why they get a bad reputation. Come on Harper, teach your young people what you preach, a so-called respect for nature and love of Mother Earth.
 
GHoST
repley to "disgusted" thats the way we live here for hundreds of years, the earth provides for us, we respect the animals, we wear theyre fur for warmth, not like the whites for fashion, we eat their meat nothing goes wasted. i see white guys cutting the head off a moose n leaving the meat. race is nothing were all human yet we continue to divide eachother.if race is an issue, i want everyone to go home (france/german/british/iran/chinese/etc etc etc etc) we were the exiles, paddling to north america, now you come and take everything, judging everyone, and bringing your currupted laws. open your eyes and realize, we are all human!
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.