News and Views » Straight Talk

Bob Geldof prepares to file complaint against BBC over report on Ethiopian aid

By Charlie Smith,

The London-based  Independent newspaper has reported that Irish musician  Bob Geldof and several aid agencies are preparing a complaint to Ofcom, which regulates the British Broadcasting Corporation.

The complaint concerns a BBC World Service  documentary by Africa editor Martin Plaut. It  quotes  two former senior  rebels with the Tigrayan People's Liberation Front saying they diverted famine-relief funds to buy weapons in the mid 1980s.

The TPLF's leader, Meles Zenawi,  later became  Ethiopia's prime minister. According to the BBC, the two former rebels are on the outs with him. One was tossed out of the movement in 1985.

In 1984, Geldof, a former Georgia Straight music editor,  and Midge Ure founded Live Aid, which raised approximately US$280 million to address widespread starvation in Ethiopia.

Geldof told the Independent that the Internet has transmitted the BBC story around the world, creating a false impression. He also called the BBC report a "disgrace".

"At the time of Live Aid we had journalists crawling all over everything we did trying to find something wrong--and they couldn't," Geldof told the Independent. "And now, on the strength of one disgruntled soldier, the BBC has undermined the faith of ordinary people across the world in the effectiveness of giving to people in their hour of need."

(To listen to Geldof's rebuttal, go here.)

The BBC World Services editor of news and current affairs, Andrew Whitehead, posted a statement on the broadcaster's Web site  offering its side of the story, and  saying that  Geldof declined to be interviewed for the documentary.

Zenawi, Geldof, former British prime minister Tony Blair, and current British prime minister Gordon Brown were among the 17 members of the Commission for Africa.

In 2005, it  issued 90 recommendations in areas ranging from aid to debt relief to trade to alleviate human suffering across the continent.

Follow Charlie Smith on Twitter at twitter.com/csmithstraight.

Comments

Sami
The more I see Bob Gildof and other aid groups struggling to dismiss the report made by BBC reporter, the more I realize how Meles Zenawi fooled them smartly.

I strongly and wisely advise Bob and the aid organization to spend thier energy and time on following what the breliant BBC reporter has exposed.

PLEASE trust Ethiopians. We have been telling you that ZENAWI is the most dangerous man not only to Ethiopia, but (at this time) to the world as well.
 
Danie
Before you commenting make sure to spell some one's name correctly. Bob Geldof is a man who help your own people during the wrost time in your country. What he saying or witnessing is what happened during then. You can not tell or say Bob Geldof was fooled becuase you heard unproven new on BBC. Please don't rush for comment like your "breliant BBC reporter" Make sure to read story and history and do some research before writing.
 
Yilma
why? I think Sir Gildof made a very serious mistake, I think he lacks the knowledge of the Ethiopian despot, he should quitely sort out the facts instead of advocating the dictator, Meles is good wagging his tale when he see westerners who can give him dollars and pounds. so I don't surprised
 
Pat V
Yilma, I believe that you are mistaken to think Mr. Geldof had anything to do with the final disbursement of the funds that are alleged to have been diverted. Mr. Geldof was a fund raiser, period. While he may have had some input as to which aid organizations received the money he helped to raise, he is far removed from where those agencies spent those funds.

The BBC has made serious accusations about the diversion of funds, based in part on a CIA document written BEFORE the concerts were even held! Consider the source. ;-)
 
kikyu
Ethiopians are so funny, no shame at all. Just b/c Meles Kicked these soldiers out , they make up false stories. Last time, the old rebel member, Siye Abraha said his supporters are denied of food aid by the government!!! hahaha
 
tera
gildof if you just trust the people of ethiopia keep your promiss to run a proffetional investigation to find the truth b/c meles zenawi is not a kind of person that we trust, since he is a profetional lyer. so, please Gildof try to do your best we ethiopians are waiting for as we always do.
GOD BLESS ETHIOPIA
 
abiy chelkeba
why would u z BBC coment on isssue zat had the opportunity to reporet it
before 25 years?why would X fiters of the T.P.L.F soliders talk about it after 25 years?why z BBC made last three roports on ehiopia zat trys to damage its image?why z CIA was used as an evidence and strarting point where in the document zer is serious omissins?it is just motive.
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.