News and Views » Straight Talk

Vancouver MPs voice opposition to Marc Emery's extradition

By Stephen Thomson,

Two Vancouver MPs are decrying a decision to support the extradition of marijuana activist Marc Emery to the United States.

In 2005, Emery was arrested as part of a joint Canada-U.S. law enforcement effort on charges that relate to an alleged online marijuana seed-selling business based in Vancouver.

Emery had been out on bail for the past six months from the North Fraser Pretrial Centre. With the period of his release set to expire, Emery surrendered himself to authorities this morning (May 10) at the Vancouver courts to await a decision on extradition.

Emery’s wife, Jodie, told the Straight earlier today that she had learned federal justice minister Robert Nicholson approved an extradition order.

The decision has now come under fire from NDP MP Libby Davies and Liberal MP Ujjal Dosanjh. Both MPs tabled a 12,000-signature petition earlier this year in the House of Commons that opposed Marc Emery’s extradition.

“It’s about Canadian sovereignty,” Davies, the MP for Vancouver East, told the Straight. “Why would we cart off a Canadian to serve time in America for something he wouldn’t have been charged with in Canada? Now what we’re left with is trying to press that he at least be allowed to serve his time in Canada.”

Dosanjh, the MP for Vancouver South, told the Straight that Emery faces a “disproportionate sentence that he wouldn’t have received in Canada”.

“I believe in that case we as a country should ensure that he’s at least able to serve his sentence in a Canadian prison,” Dosanjh said. “He’s not a dangerous offender.”

The federal department of justice could not be reached for comment.

Comments

ant jacques uk
i think its disgusting the usa can get away with extraditing people for acts commited in canada which are legal there. what the hell is going on in this world? FREE MARC EMERY NOW!!!
 
Jill Clarksen
A sad day for Canada. I am not a proud Canadian today...shame on you.
 
Bob Watson
Dosanjh is a turncoat NDP-Liberal. He will say anything to get votes. Even from DOPERS.
I hope Emery rots in jail.
 
Joshua
An American who wonders why Obama is even allowing this to happen. I guess he has his own agenda and it is not as liberal as the democrats and stoners of this country thought he was when he lied on the campaign trail. I hope Canada will fight this! Good luck Marc.
Former stoner who's govt wont let him smoke because I have a CDL license for my Job.
 
woolybuggerca
i absolutely agree with "Davies" comment. I really think all Canadians have to start politically being active again. not only where status quot apply but in every topic that is important to you! in this case it is absolutely a Canadian citizens freedom of liberty at risk,not a guy who actively promotes marijuana.when we agree to political actions like this,take a long look and see how the loss of this "sovereignty"could effect potentially every citizen at one point or another in the future (homeland security n all).we are a country after all i think we can deal with our own problems,personally i don't much care what big brother wants.let their own populous deal with theirs.our country is great by its diversity not it's conformity.
 
Danny Moe
THIS IS BULLSHIT! why should a Canadian be extradited to the U.S.A.? He paid taxes to the Canadian government for his business and if the Canadian government is willing to take those tax dollars they should also be willing to support a Canadian entrepreneur. He has never been to the US and should not be subject to their tyrannical laws. If we extradite Marc Emery I would like to see the US send over Smith and Wesson for selling handguns on the internet, it's illegal here so why not prosecute? Because it would be ridiculous, and everyone knows it, the Canadian government has to stop being a US yes man and grow a backbone. SUPPORT YOUR CITIZENS!!! VOTE DANNY MOE FOR CANADIAN PRIME MINISTER NEXT ELECTION AND BULLSHIT LIKE THIS WILL NEVER HAPPEN AGAIN. Fight the good fight Mr. Emery real Canadians support you, redneck wannabe hillbilly Canadians that dont can FUCK THEMSELVES
 
Stephan
"The federal department of justice could not be reached for comment."

Cowards.
 
Nite Owl
Does this mean that we're going to start extraditing Americans for their part in getting illegal guns into Canada? Does Harper have the guts to go against his masters? Do you think the Americans would let us or would they just laugh in our face?
 
J
I agree with Danny, It is absolutely ridiculous that our government would even considering sending Marc to a US prison for selling something he PAID INCOME TAX on to the CANADIAN GOVERNMENT. Once again it proves that the governments of this world are nothing more than organized crime.
 
Nina Menard
This is all about being politically active and making your vote count...In Guelph Ontario, we have had a medical cannabis club raided and shut down, this due, in part to the ambivalent and outmoded laws surrounding the usage and distribution of this herb....protests and rally's to follow....Marc Emery is a marijuana activist, not a dangerous criminal....after all, the governments have made gambling and alcohol legal, as well as lethal prescriptions ....this is out in the open, unlike some corruption and cover-ups within our own government....
 
Katie Speed
Bob Watson, you are an ignorant fool.
Your money is being wasted to send him to the US. HE COMMITED THE CRIME IN CANADA, NOT THE US therefore he should stay in Canada. Also, EVERY POLITICAL CANDIDATE SAYS WHAT PEOPLE WANT TO HEAR TO GET ELECTED, quit thinking this is still a democracy, the conservatives have ruined our country.


Danny, I agree STRONGLY with the Smith and Weston remark.
Even my mother, who does not agree with Marc Emery thinks he should at least stay in Canada.
 
Dr VonBrain
Everyone....remember at election time. Let's make a few conservative MPs jobless.
 
Rickshaw
DRUGS ARE DRUGS
Take a stroll down hastings,90%of them started with pot,
young men & woman ,children selling their body's,
their are people that can try it and walk away when ever they want,and then their are people who cant.
if i had to choose i would have to vote no in the hopes of saving one of those lost souls.
 
COME ON
LETS PUT IT ON THE TABLE AND SAY WHAT NEEDS TO BE SAID.
First of all Mark clearly you've been smoking way to much,to think you sold seeds to the U S A (whom fights the war on drugs ) you did it by mail (a crime in itself ) and then you put your name on it,clearly you are in need of a goverment paid vacation.
as for canada allowing the U S A to arrest Mr Emery you all need to wake up we are the 51st state,you might not like it but thats a fact Canada would be Nothing with out the U S A.
YOU SAY WE HAVE A ARMY...............BAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA nothing like bringing a knife to a gun fight.
America ownes 30% of Canada they could shut us down anytime they want.
here's a idea how about they say no more imports from Canada? or were not gonna back you when Russia come's calling,if you think for one moment that the U S A doe'nt have a homeland security office here your out of your fricken mind.
you all need to put the weed away and wake up to the real world?
 
Statement in Canada
Making a statement in Canada and challenging authority is one thing. He was showing how silly our pot laws are. Selling to the big market in the US is not making a statement, it is making money. They are a different country, the US govt. is @na| about pot, and we have extradition agreements with them. It sucks, but he should have to stuck to making statements in Canada. Nobody in the US has heard of him (except for the war on drugs types).

It should be legal anyway.
- take away the easy money for gangs. They use pot money for guns and hard drugs.
- tax it an sell it in Government Liquor and Pot stores
- legalization will keep young people away from criminals. (When was the last time you saw a bootlegger for moonshine?)
- let me grow it in my backyard garden next to my vegetables
 
rangskye
oh please, those people on the street that are into hard drugs started on cannabis under cannabis prohibition. you dont buy pot next to your whiskey.
40 odd percent of people will try pot, now, the way they have it illegal, people are getting it on the street right next to the hardest of drugs. what do you expect?
cannabis is less dangerous than alcohol and tobacco yet we stick it with the hard illegals and then this shows how silly it is. potentially a fifty year sentence for something that in canada would give you 2 months. thats why this is unfair. he was not a heroin dealer or addict. he tried to help heroin addicts. you will always have the drug war problems if you want to keep hinting at higher penalties for pot. 40 percent of the populace!! i wonder if it were legal would more smoke it. if they wanted to, then that should be what the government says is ok. the government stuffed it up with help from people like you..gateway...yes! because it is unregulated.
 
Pinky
While the pot thing is there and debatable, the really disturbing thing about this is our gov't allowed another country to imprison one of our citizens while he did not break any (enforced) laws here or on their soil. I'm curious if this is a precedent.

Someone above asked if we can jail American gun suppliers here, and that's an excellent question.Tit for tat - you take one of ours, we'll take one of yours.
 
chris from BBY
while I don't find Marc to be a great spokesperson for legalizing marijuana (always reminds me of Jim Breuer in Half Baked..imdb.com it), I really oppose him being extradited. Total BS that our government is bowing down to the puppet master.

shame on Canada.....FREE MARC!


---------------
" American ownes 30% of Canada " ????

where the heck do you get this fact? are you that HIGH?? we sell them power, water, and oil. If Canada really woke up, we'd shut THEM down. As well, the US is so in-debt to China, that our other plan should be for everyone in Richmond to call home and have their relatives collect on their promissary notes.
 
pot smoker
Be strong Marc, you have more support than you know. Lets let the politicians know at election time. Time for the pot smokers to be heard!!!

Come home soon, we support you.

@#$% Ottawa
 
Your Mom and Dad
Either force an election or go to jail, be banned from public service, toss out your white shirts and continue to live this way forever.
 
Glen MacPherson
Every now and then a government takes an action that angers and motivates people who might otherwise just go about their lives and try to ignore what is happening around them. This is one of those times. Starting today I promise to work tirelessly to rid our great country of the sickening stench of American style puritanism. Harper and Company can genuflect to the USA all they want, but this is our country. DEA go home, and Yankee go home.
 
Conkey
Charges against Mr. Emery were only possible because CBSA and other Canadian authorities allow US police to work illegally in Canada. There are currently numerous US police agencies working in Canada. Many of these people carry guns contrary to Canadian law and carry police investigations reporting only to the US.
 
glen p robbins
blogged about this on another stream. The U.S. House of Representatives has been in contact with ROBBINS SCE Research (1998) this last 2 weeks -- including a poll where we 'lobbied' President Obama for the extradition (about 3-4 months ago).

I suspect he will be sent back to Canada---
 
Koots Kid
Don't be too soon to right this off. There are still the Nelson charges in front of the courts.
 
Turned On and Tuned In
This is truly a sad day for the country. I'm so ashamed to have been born in this corrupt spineless part of the world where Justice is now OPENLY used to facilitate political objectives. If Marc had an above board business and was paying taxes, that by definition makes Revenue Canada guilty of complicity in this "crime". But you don't see anyone there being extradited now do you? 5 years of a man's life spent in a concrete cage with violent criminals for selling SEEDS !!! What do we have to look forward to next...witch hunts and book burnings? So much for an evolved society.
 
canadians=pot potatos
It is not true, that pot is not addicting.
Smoking a pot = not solving problems in Canada
Smoking a pot = running from the unconvenient
truth about Canada.
The truth about Canada:
Everything I have touched in Canada, doesn’t work:
Canadian car makers are the most ineffective in the world.
(That is the fact, GM admitted it)
Your public education system is a disaster,
Your waiting time in medical system is KILLING people (fact)
Your cell network is horrible, 10 years behind Europe
and one of most expensive in the world (fact)
Your phone companies always connect me to employees living in Asia, because it is difficult to fire canadians
Your people are uneducated.
You sell wood to Oregon (USA) and import tables form them,(facts)
because you are not able to make a table.
YOU DON’T KNOW ANYTHING TO DO.
YOU HAVE ALL MONEY FROM SELLING OIL, METALS, WOOD
 
nazi_hunter2012
to COME ON:

Go back to school and learn grammar.

Then learn critical thinking skills.

Then look at your post.

Then feel shame!!
 
widget
Let's not forget that Emery paid income tax to the feds all along, and made no bones about his method of work. So the Feds and the Canadian public are basically in a conflict since they too have profited and utilized revenues from his tiny seed biz.
At least this isn't some Asian country where he would be renditioned into years of torture in an undisclosed location. Humans sure do shitty things to each other in the name of rightiousness.

Previous "potato" poster is a complete and utter moron. Wonder what he's been smoking...tarballs and burnt fuses?
 
Slavery
I am very disappointed with democracy in Canada.
People who don’t have government jobs or connection on government-federal, provincial, municipal levels or connection to union or don’t have any grant for researches are SECOND-DEGREE CITIZENS.
Talented scientists work for $8 CAD/hour and untalented people with grants and connections earn 10 times more.
It is a slavery.
You smoke pot, because you are afraid of the truth.
 
Realist
It seems to me that Marc voluntarily entered a plea bargain and accepted 5 years in prison so that he wouldn't risk facing 20 years. So, if you accept that term, then it is inconsistent to try and get out of it after you signed up for it. I think if he was fighting 'the good fight', he would have gone for broke, and fought the charges entirely and perhaps would have won and received no time. But if you plea bargain, and accept time as a condition, then unfortunately, you have to do the time and it is ridiculous to argue that after the fact.
 
Igby Mac
And who claimed Harper, the Straussian theocrat, was not a stooge of the US structure?
 
REGULAR JOE
This is classic wedge politics from the Harper admin. Its a real shame when an honest tax paying citizen is forced into a situation like his. GET OUT AND VOTE!
 
Patriotic Canadian
I say, as we protest in every city to free Marc emery, we should also organize a political campaign and put HIS name on every ballet. imagine him winning while he is still in jail in the states, they would have to send him back to do his political stuff.

legalizing the tree of life would bring in a redundant amount of tax dollars, and the benefits to the industrial and agricultural industries would be enormous. Also, as many have said before, this would take pot production and distribution out of the hands of criminals and into the hands of licensed business owners.

if we put his name on the ballot and he wins, I think we could get him back
 
ben
@ Realist : He may have saved himself from a much longer sentence this way, but that doesnt mean WE cant get him out by consistently nagging the Canadian and American Governments to let him out, he is after all, a Canadian political activist with MILLIONS of supporters.

@ regular joe : Conservatives in power is definately a "worse case scenario" for Canadians. I think if more young people could vote nowadays we could see green and side parties getting a fair share of the power. These smaller political groups have "common good" much more ingrained into their hearts, but even if the liberals win, we are better off then we are now. I agree "GET OUT AND VOTE!!!!"

@Patriotic Canadian: Your idea of running Marc emery for politics while he is incarcerated is kind of funny, I`m not sure if it would work, but it would definitely be interesting to see happen, and if it does, he has my vote.
ring....ring....ring....president answers "hello" .... "mr.president, this is Canada, we would like our politician back please"


@everyone: no matter what, we can`t stop fighting to get our citizen back, to fight for his liberty is to fight for your own liberty. if there is to be a precedent here lets make it a good one.
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.