Commentary | HST

Rick Jeffery: HST will help coastal forest industry in B.C.

Rick Jeffery.

By Rick Jeffery

It’s a shame that voters are more upset about the way the HST was announced than about the tax itself. Unfortunately, the benefits the harmonized sales tax will bring to the province are being lost in rhetoric as the grassroots revolt led by ex-premier Bill Vander Zalm continues to gain steam. With Vander Zalm’s tarnished history in this province, one has to wonder about his true motivation and agenda.

But for the forest industry, which is still struggling through the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression and at the same time being significantly impacted by a high Canadian dollar, the HST is a lifeline.

Since the economic crisis in 2008, on the coast there has been a 40 percent employment loss in forestry and manufacturing. Manufacturing is less than half the size it was a decade ago on the coast. Some economists predict the Canadian dollar will trade as high as US$1.20 causing even more hardship to wood products manufacturers and exporters. Each one-cent movement of the Canadian dollar means a loss in revenue of $90 million for the B.C. forest sector.

We’re in survival mode and are bracing ourselves. Ninety percent of forest products are sold in U.S. dollars. The fast pace in which the Canadian dollar has gained strength presents a serious challenge to the coastal industry, especially in the markets for our high-value products, which are disproportionately impacted by the rising dollar.

Views on the HST

Jock Finlayson: Why the HST is smart tax policy for B.C.

John Winter: HST is key to a strong economy in B.C.

Chris Delaney: Finance Minister Colin Hansen’s magical HST land doesn’t exist

Bill Vander Zalm: Fight against HST is chance to take back democracy in B.C.

As the Conference Board of Canada recently reported, Canadian businesses have no option but to boost productivity through investment in equipment and machinery in response to the rising Canadian dollar. This is where the HST comes into play.

The coastal forest industry views the HST through a competitive lens. With the introduction of the HST, B.C.’s resource and manufacturing sectors are expected to benefit significantly, the forest sector alone paying $140 million less in investment-killing taxes. In addition, the removal of the PST makes the playing field more level with competitors around the world not subject to this taxation.

The HST is like a shot in the arm for our forest companies at a time when we are fighting for market share in competitive markets like Japan and China. When fully phased-in, it will result in B.C.’s taxes on business investment being lower. This means coastal communities will be an attractive place for investment, which in turn creates long-term, stable, and well-paying jobs.

And while many negative things are being said about the HST, evidence in jurisdictions around the world that have switched to consumption taxes shows overall prices paid by consumers have gone down over time. This is because savings companies realize down through the supply chain when equipment and supplies are purchased are passed on to consumers in the end. But most importantly, evidence in other countries and provinces with similar tax structures shows that the HST leads to higher levels of investment, higher wages, and a higher standard of living.

Looking forward, the coastal forest industry isn’t expected to begin recovery until next year, so we are definitely not out of the woods yet. Voters are outraged and we understand that. But the HST is critical for the future of our industry. We need it to help us restore jobs and get people back to work in our province.

Rick Jeffery is the president and CEO of the Coast Forest Products Association.

Comments

Hub
Without putting the HST, the Provincial Legislature could have reformed the PST to work like GST: what you collect is deducted by what you pay.

Problem solved.

HST is an unfair sales tax because it is not harmonized across the country, and it remove the autonomy in taxation that the Province had with the PST, where they exempted a certain category of product in order to stimulate consumers.
 
tim
you know would help better instead, if you stopped gordon campbell from allowing the tripling of raw log exports. we'd keep the jobs at home and have a thriving forestry industry.
 
RodSmelser
Ahhh Rick, ... I think you may have come a wee bit too late for the party.
Rod Smelser
 
cherylb
Hey Rick! You are full of crap! That's all I got to say about this!
 
Bruce McAra
Yes the HST is superior to the PST in almost every way. Lower the rate to 10% and there might be enough support to keep it.
 
BC Liberals are Liars
Its embarassing that the BC Liberals assume everyone in BC is too stupid to realize this tax is simply shifting all of BC's corporate tax onto ordinary British Columbians.
 
adibese
Yes Rick, we know mining and forestry will make more money with the HST. Problem is, 78 percent of business in BC is service orientated. Problem two is we highly doubt a resource industry such as yours will hire more people than there are that ar elost from the service industry.

And I completely disagree that a federal tax is better than a provincial tax. Personally, I don't want to give my money to a spend happy federal government with no accountability to people in provinces and to a province that's a competitor.
 
Lorenzo
Sorry Rick your arguement doesnt work. You are saving money at the expense of the people of BC. Every penny you save the people of BC will be stuck paying. The majority of the products that will save money on HST will not even be bought by BCers and there is no proof that they will be cheaper to us. Create new jobs sure but how many jobs are going to be lost because of the HST. Taking money from BCers gives us less disposible income there we will be sending less on retail. The retail companys will be losing alot of jobs probaly alot more than the HST will create. HST will create a black market alot of legit companies will have a hard time surviving, saving 12% by paying cash is a huge incentive compared to the old tax. Now that we dont have to pay taxes in Washington anymore. Did you know the same 55 inch Samsung 3D TV at the same BEST BUY in Washington state will save us $900 even after duty and gas. I dont mind waiting in line for 2 hours to save $900 and I am sure many Canadians wont either. Let find out what the saving will be on LUMBER it may be worth a person while to buy it in Washington State. Good luck but dont get too excited the HST is here right now but it will never last.
 
AC
I feel sorry for a lot of BC businesses, but the fact is that you have been slavishly supporting a government that has grown as incompetent and arrogant as the BC NDP. The root of this all is the cribbed-together revenue projections the BC Liberal government foisted on everyone in the spring of 2009 in their pre-election budget. Of course, in their quest for re-election they introduced what was, for lack of a better word, a fudge-it budget, and they, like the NDP, are now reaping their rewards.

The HST is a good idea, but sometimes good ideas mean nothing when they're introduced by a government that has some debased itself that it literally can be seen in the voter's eyes as doing no right. There's little sense that the business community, particularly those portions of it which have so tightly aligned themselves with the BC Liberals, got the message that the HST was a powderkeg, and thus didn't defend it right from the beginning.
 
ds
Sorry Rick, but they should have upgraded their plants when times were good instead of waiting until the horse is out of the barn. Greed will do it to you every time. Wake up and smell the flowers or coffee.
 
BULLSH!T
I wonder how much it hurts the Sheriff of Nottingham's face to fake a smile like that?
 
NDB
"It’s a shame that voters are more upset about the way the HST was announced than about the tax itself. "

WRONG.

Its sort of a shame that you have resorted to miss quoting, or miss interpreting the publics feelings for your own person agenda. Yes people didn't like being lied too, but the reality is the over taxed people of BC dont want to pay more taxes to help big business. IF the tax refund for business is so important then the government should learn to streamline and cut in order to fund it for big business.

Anyway...like I told the other small minority of blog writers with share the same opinion of you. Thanks for your thoughts, and you dont have to sign the petition. Meanwhile step aside and let the majority decide whats best for the majority.

 
EX LIBERAL
Its funny you have 4 people giving negative votes to the anti HST supporters.
I have a questions about the HST. Gordon Campbell and the Liberals (which I supported) stated that without the HST they would 700 million less to give to essestials and important services. The 1 Billion + dollars from the federal govt would have to be returned.
Campbell stated that he never considered the HST until after the election. Yet during the election didnt he promise to have balanced books and no extra taxes. If that was the case they should not be short any money.
So it appears to me that the Liberals always considered the money from the HST before the election or else they would have have been able to balance the books. So in other words he lied and this is prove.....

Big business shouldnt get comfortable with the HST because they is a great possible that many other members of the liberals will either bold or vote against it to save their career. Or else recall.
Thanks GORDO for killing the Liberals you dont seen to care about the newer MLA that will replaced with recall.
 
Pauline
Rick: Your opening statement is right on!

I have heard that this is the case regarding most, if not all, of FightHST's organizers & canvassers. Key organizers have been known to say that for them, the issue has never been about whether the HST is good or bad but how it was rolled out ....

IMO, it is almost criminal that some FightHST organizers have been permitted to canvass for signatures and even lecture to citizens on tax reform, when they do not fully understand it themselves. I think that it is scandalous that Elections BC has permitted this to take place.

I am also wondering why NDP operative, Bill Tieleman, hasn't had more of a "public" face on the FightHST team, since he is/has been, one of Mr. Vander Zalm's key strategists.
 
stanmortensen
Pauline - have you ever heard of the democratic process and the citizens rights to express themselves and to be heard clearly and loudly especially in opposition to a specific piece of legislation.
We, as citizens/voters elect people to office, they are not appointed by business interests. But then, I guess 75% opposition to HST (most polling numbers) or 2.25 million people are not worthy or must be just plain idiots in your august opinion.
Kindly spare me any of the Liberal talking points about mis-information. That would be the result of the governments' lack of ensuring the full information was out there in the first place which would not have changed the response. These folks promised opennes and transparency when they were elected in 01. Thus far they have failed on all accounts.
 
Mel
No matter how you dice this it is still passing 2billion dollars in tax revenue from Big business to the average taxpayer regardless of the so-called tax rebates which will cover only a small amount of all the increases that have been passed....ie...Hydro, Msp, Carbon tax and the list goes on......
 
glen p robbins
I have a very close friend in the tree growing business--who tells me the seedling business is behind 10 years already.

The forest industry in BC is one sixth of what it was.

Please put that crackpipe down ' o' meter 8.5/10 brown - nosin'
 
RodSmelser
Pauline Anonymous

am also wondering why NDP operative, Bill Tieleman, hasn't had more of a "public" face on the FightHST team, since he is/has been, one of Mr. Vander Zalm's key strategists.
===============================

Incredible.


An anonymous poster (PAB?) demands to know why someone else, Bill Tieleman, who's been publicly leading a lot of the opposition to the HST, isn't featured even more prominently. Since Bill Tieleman is not and has never been an employee of the NDP, how is he an NDP "operative"?

Rod Smelser
 
glen p robbins
Bill Tieleman's businesses have done quite well with New Democrats and associates of that party. He hasn't been a big endorser of Carole James -but for political purposes he is an NDPer who could be a candidate with a new third party-without apology or explanation required.

 
Disgruntled
HST for big business? what about HST for citizens! if the government charged HST for people then we would have more money to spend in order to boost the economy. Anything can be rationalized.
 
Lorenzo
I though I would post again. HST is really going to hurt alot of legit businesses. I recieved 3 quotes on gettng my roof done. Two of three companies will not charge HST if I pay cash, the third one from Home Depot has no choice they have to. So what do you think I am going to do? Pay an extra $1200 or just pay cash? I am not sure yet but these are some of the problems that will arrise with the HST.
Remember some say the HST is good for big business but at the end that make sense. When the govt take the taxes from the people and gives the saving to big business of course it good for there business. Where a large amount of people are giving money to anything business will always be better. But what happens when the people decide not to gvie there money anymore? Alot of business are going to be punished because of the HST and it wont be there fault but consumer will take it out on them. Alberta and Washington state will be smiling all the way to the bank
 
Kim
Coast Forest Products Association donated $61,700. to the BC Liberals between 2006- 2009. I wonder what they got in return?
 
cherylb
I would strongly suggest that you all read today's Nanaimo Daily News editorial to see the real arguments against Mr. Jeffries' assertions. And as for the mining industry needing the HST, haven't we just been reading for the past few days about them making record profits during the worst times of the recession? WTF? Why is it that every word that drops from the lips of these Libs is a lie?
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.