Jean Chrétien's recovery and the future of Stephen Harper and Michael Ignatieff

Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff hopes that former prime minister Jean Chétien's political charm will help boost his appeal with the Canadian electorate.

Georges Alexandar

After former prime minister Jean Chrétien survived brain surgery this weekend, the current prime minister, Stephen Harper, issued a statement wishing him well.

"Mr. Chrétien, I am sure, will emerge as he always has from every challenge, by winning," Harper said.

I'm sure that Harper had the former prime minister's best interest at heart. But Harper is also smart enough to know that if Chrétien's health takes a turn for the worse and he dies, it could trigger a wave of nostalgia.

And that could conceivably return the federal Liberals to power.

A recent Ekos poll by showed that the Conservatives have fallen below 30 percent for the first time since 2006. Harper's crew came in at just 29.7 percent support.

The Liberals under Michael Ignatieff rose to 28.5 percent, creating a neck-and-neck race.

In a commentary on his site, Ekos head Frank Graves attributed the Conservative drop to the "highly questionable decision to announce the end of the one-in-five long form census".

"Call it the revenge of the propeller heads, but the swift reaction of the educated class suggests they see bigger stakes than simply the 2B Census," Graves wrote. "This may be the latest expression of a real culture conflict over the role of knowledge and expertise in society."

Here in B.C., Harper hasn't won much support from educated voters with his ostrich-like approach to climate change and his government's legal fight against Vancouver's supervised-injection site.

Harper's spin doctors appear to have taken note of Graves's concerns.

This weekend, the federal government Web site's lead story on the home page highlights new spending on science and technology.

The headline reads: "Government of Canada Bolsters Canada's Knowledge Economy".

The announcement came from science minister Gary Goodyear, who initially refused to tell the Globe and Mail last year if he believes in the theory of evolution.

Later, he reversed himself, though his original quote was: “I’m not going to answer that question. I am a Christian, and I don’t think anybody asking a question about my religion is appropriate.”

In addition to keeping an eye on the science file, Harper might also want to say a prayer for Chrétien's health.

When former Liberal prime minister Pierre Trudeau died on September 28, 2000, the Liberal party benefited from an incredible public outpouring of grief.

Chrétien, a wily political operator, called a snap election less than a month after Trudeau's passing. And on November 27, 2000, the Liberals won their third consecutive majority government.

While Chrétien might not match Trudeau's stature, there are still many voters who recall how well the economy performed during the Chrétien years.

Ignatieff is already trying to exploit this in his public appearances. This message would resonate to an even greater degree if the country were to be grieving the unexpected loss of the former Liberal prime minister.

If Chrétien keeps "winning" on the health front, as Harper so cleverly put it, the Conservatives probably have a better chance of winning the next election.

Follow Charlie Smith on Twitter at twitter.com/csmithstraight.

Comments

Maps Onburt
Really classy article... opining on what the Tories would do if Cretien died. Have you no morals? I'm a blue conservative but your comments about Cretien dying really make me angry.
 
GGower
I highly doubt there would be any real wave of nostalgia in the unfortunate event of a death. Mr Chretian is not Mr Trudeau, and the liberals have had only one poll showing close to a tie in a long time. They are a long ways away from public choice number one. Also, no one except the Ottawa press cares a fig about the census form. We real people do not care at all about that form, unless we are forced to fill it out, as I was. Anyway, no one I know is even noticing Ottawa or the carry on this summer.
 
albertaclipper
That's just plain sick on the part of the Liberals. They're hoping Chretien dies so that they can get back into power.
 
Margaret

Watch how this writer has slipped in "Ignatieff is trying to exploit this" in a really scummy article speculating about Chretien's death, to link Ignatieff with the speculation, instead of the writer.

Charlie Smith - mediocre scumbag writer.
 
reid
One of the most stupid articles I have read in a long time.Canadians deciding not to vote conservative because they scrapped part of the census form?You need to turn off Star Trek and climb out of your mom's basement for once.No one in Canada is talking about this except the print media.no wonder Harper won't talk to you guys anymore.Crisis after crisis about nothing.And for Chretien,yea,thanks for downloading everything onto the provinces in order to balance the federal books.Newsflash you clown,WE the taxpayers still keep paying,whether they take it directly or burden the provinces.What a joke.
 
Elaine Murray
Just how low could this columnist go? This is the most disgraceful thing that I ever read. Please don't be giving the liberals any ideas. Jean Chrétien is not everyone's cup of tea, but no one, especially our PM on the right side, would wish ill upon him.
 
Harry98
I would like to see a few more polls other than Ekos. Frank Graves is a Lib supporter and I think his polls are skewed big time. I don't believe anything this guy says.
 
Steven Trinh
How the hell is this thing the top story on NNW??? What garbage!!! Since when do we muse about the benefit of dying politicians in Canada??? Shame on you.
 
William Ajax Ont
The entire context of this article is MORBID...
The writer has no scruples, Liberals really ARE desperate.!
 
tony durke
Good article. It's nice to see the Sun actually taking the piss out of the conservatives. And I am not offended by the Chretien dying talk because, after all, death is part of life. And in the shrewd world of politics, death is used as a game piece. Like everything else.
 
Observant
If Chretien should suddenly take a turn for the worse and depart, that would help close the Liberal book on Sponsorship. Liberals would be trumpeting that ADSCAM died with Chretien ... regardless of the fact that the old Liberal MPs from Quebec still reek of corruption and criminality.

Nothing can rescue Ignatieff from political oblivion unless Donolo can create an election campaign based on voting for the local party candidate and ignoring the fact that Iggy would be PM by default.

Conservative election strategists would not let that happen .. and will decapitate the Liberal leader from his Liberal body politic.
 
opining on what the Tories would do if Cretien died
Steven Harper has absolutely no shame. The speculation is valid and likely.
 
Macky Avelli
Let's see if I've got this straight:

There are still "many voters who recall how well the economy performed during the Chrétien years.". So when he dies, Ignatieff, who wasn't around in those glory days, is going to channel Chretien via a ouija board, to get instructions on how to run the country ?

 
bugzy
He Harry!!! Graves has been under contract for the past 5 years doing polls for the Reform slease balls. Get your facts right before you spew your venom like the snake you really are.
 
Michael K.
"Really classy article... opining on what the Tories would do if Cretien died. Have you no morals? I'm a blue conservative but your comments about Cretien dying really make me angry."

Seriously? Do you honestly that the strategist Harper is NOT considering the effect his death would have? This is Politics 101, understand what your enemy is doing, understand how it affects you, counter it.

Don't shoot the messenger.
 
Jim Pook
Of course the pressure on his brain goes a long way in explaining why he supports Iggy for PM.
 
Dee Sturber
That operation is just routine. My friend had the exact same one about a month ago. Operated on Friday, home Monday. What I'd like to see is the haircut they gave Chretien, but we wont see that. The press, as always is making a mountain out of a molehill.
 
Michael Harkov
Stay classy, MSM.
 
Arnold Murphy
Whatever happened to go tell it on the mountain? Did I hear a cock crow three times?
 
seth
Posting this article on a Sunday sure brings out the Conbot's doesn't it.

Sunday morning down at Stevey "Brimstone" Hapro's CRAP (Con/Reform/ALLIANCE (church?)) HQ in Boulder CO, the word goes out to all the parishes in Canada, telling the preacher men to get up on those hind legs and exhort the sheep to smit the those Liberals - agents of the Lucifer all.
Cut and paste scripts are posted on the CRAP website.

And here they all are.

seth
 
TJ
the census is a pain to fill out but without it, the government has no way to determine how to allocate funds in the budget...this would make it very convenient for the current government to distribute funding with impunity to who ever they want...are you people so very blind and stupid as not to realize how this works? Of course any educated person is going to be concerned; of course all the 'sheep' are going to accept all they are handed!
 
Evil Eye
Charlie, I see that you raised the ire of many Liberals with your speculations. But of course your speculation on Canadian politics if Jean Chrétien dies is valid as political parties plan for this all the time. I'm sure the NDP have a plan if Campbell dies and visa versa for the Liberals if James meets her maker.

What I see is a massive amount of political immaturity and naiveté by political commentator wannabes.

http://civicscene.ca/an-absolutely-classless-piece-of-journalism-by-char...

May I say to them; "grow up because you will never be a good commenter if you can't see 3 minutes into the future."

So here it is in plain fact: people die, politicians die, and the world goes on and it is absolutely no use whatsoever if we pretend a politicians death doesn't alter political strategy!

Grow up people!
 
glen p robbins
Harper's numbers are not down because of the Long form Census debate--in my opinion - this is contrived. However - Harper's actions over the Long Form Census debate--reinforce criticisms of Harper as a unilateralist--his numbers were heading downward anyhow.

The Opposition - would like the Census issue to be presented as the one that got Harper -- but it isn't -- it is additional evidence - not the core of the reason (for dwindling support).
 
Ontario1
Hey seth - Removeth thy head from betwixt thy cheeks. Not all Right-wingers are Bible thumpers / Satanists like you seem to think, just as not all Left-wingers are Crazy paranoid conspiracy theorists. (Wink, wink).
 
A speedy recovery
For our former Prime Minister and a Liberal government in power as who is God backing in the next race as election brings the Conservatives to their knees prayers books and all as party is about to lose the race.
 
JC2436
The problem for the Liberals is: As bad as Harper has been as a leader for Canada, Ignatieff is viewed by many as someone who would have a problem ordering a hamburger at a drive-thru, let alone running a whole country.
 
Truth Party
The economy was good when Mr. Cretien was in power (and Mr. Clinton was in power) because the banks injected trillions into our western economies.

Now the banks are cutting off the currency and credit supply, and you have been saddled with the debt.

We will blame our current leaders for bad economies. We praise our past leaders for good economies. They were not in control then or now. The banks decide how our economies fare, not the politicians who serve them.

"We are completely dependant on the commercial banks. Someone has to borrow every dollar we have in circulation, cash or credit. If the banks create ample synthetic money we are prosperous; if not, we starve. We are absolutely without a permanent money system.... It is the most important subject intelligent persons can investigate and reflect upon. It is so important that our present civilization may collapse unless it becomes widely understood and the defects remedied very soon."
-- Robert H. Hamphill, Atlanta Federal Reserve Bank

"Once a nation parts with the control of its currency and credit,
it matters not who makes the nations laws. Usury, once in control,
will wreck any nation. Until the control of the issue of currency
and credit is restored to government and recognized as its most sacred
responsibility, all talk of the sovereignty of parliament and
of democracy is idle and futile."
-Prime Minister William Lyon MacKenzie King, 10th Prime Minister of Canada

This is a complex problem with a simple solution. It's time to elect leaders who tell the truth.

Nobody has told you about the banking. Try this tomorrow: Walk up to your bank teller and ask them how money is created. They will have no idea. They weren't taught. None of us were taught in school, because the teachers do not know, as they were never taught.

Henry Ford said, The people of the nation do not understand our monetary and fiscal policy, for if they did, we would have revolution before tomorrow morning.

This is a long journey.

But start here:
youtube.com/thetruthparty


We will form a new provincial government in 2013, and then spread our new model of economics and transparency worldwide.


Truth Party:
Blueprint for Free Humanity


Consider what the opponents of the Truth Party must represent.
 
DC in BC
Charlie Smith, interesting article and theme. And, let's be honest readers, today's politicians and their spin-meisters are quite savvy and will use anything in any way to help themselves or hinder their opponents.

Having said that, I vote center or center-left, but Michael Ignatieff leading the Liberals does nothing for me and until a younger, charismatic leader with vision comes along (Gerrard Kennedy, Justin Trudeau?) they won't be seeing my vote anytime soon. Oh, and I think the Cons are pretty useless as well.

 
n koks
Hope mr Chretien has good recuffery . Is a born leader !
 
Linda
Canada is a morass of, theft, corruption and greed. Politics, are no longer, what is good for the people, the provinces, nor the country. On TV, in the Federal House, I saw a motion pass to give, banks, big business, gas and oil companies, billions of tax payers dollars. They are also given, huge tax reductions, and, now they are squealing for the HST. Does Canada, have such a political party, or Leader, who is willing to put a stop to the corruption? Not on your nelly.
 
Chris Keam
We all think about what will happen after we die. That's why we write wills. That's why there are succession plans in case of untimely death in all gov'ts. It's pretty much the main topic of most religions. When Steve Jobs was ill a while back, business stories speculated on what would happen with Apple if he died. Any major media outlet keeps a file of ready-to-print obituaries on public figures. All examples similar to Mr. Smith's speculation in this article. A politician as shrewd as Mr Chretien would probably be disappointed if his party didn't use his death to further its fortunes.
 
Camero409
Harper is as diabolical a leader of a political party as I have ever seen. He will use every newsworthy headline he can. Hitler and Stalin would be proud! Building prisions for a low crime rate? What's he expecting to happen? Something is afoot.
 
Federal Liberals back in power
It dosen't matter if you have a minority or not as Harper does his own thing with Canada and Canadians are expected to get over that. Harper's day are numbered as the economy Harper takes credit for falls flat along with the BC provincial Liberals who are also about to take the big fall. As it as certain voters will be in harmony with that and it will take the party sometime to get over it along with the Conservatives who will be gone for at least a decade just imagine that.
 
N'est ce pas?
Disgusting. Came here via a link. This is why I don't read this horrible newspaper. SAVE A TREE (or 2, or 3) and abstain from reading this rag (rag is too nice a word probably).
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.