John McLachlan: What I really think of the B.C. Spirit Festival idea

Somebody has to say it.

The arts community has been stuck with the most idiotic and stupid arts-grant program I’ve seen in the close to 30 years I’ve been involved in the arts in British Columbia.

Very few are speaking about it because they fear they will lose out on potential grant money.

Here’s what’s happening right now: arts groups around the province are scrambling to jump through new hoops and twist and bend themselves to come up with ideas to create events in February that will supposedly, as Minister Kevin Krueger puts it, “celebrate and renew the pride and excitement British Columbians experienced during the 2010 Olympic and Paralympic Winter Games”¦”

FOR GOD’S SAKE. This is the most ridiculous thing I’ve heard.

It’s creating artificial excitement that is completely inauthentic. (The excitement during the Olympics in Vancouver was authentic, but that’s because the Olympics were actually happening then).

We have arts organizations with slashed funding and many collapsing but we will have “festivals” in February. Woo hoo.

People and organizations working in the arts often get accused by the general public and many politicians for not being “businesslike” in how they operate. In fact, many people in the current B.C. Liberal government probably really believe this.

Yet, they foist an incredibly stupid model onto a sector that knows better than almost any other how to run on a shoestring, effectively.

Instead of the millions of dollars that will be spent on Spirit Festivals, they could have given the money to arts groups for operating which would have then spent the money in very prudent and fiscally responsible ways.

Now, we have millions being wasted on what will most likely be harebrained funding proposals that do little to help anyone.

It makes me sick.

John McLachlan is a former chair of the Alliance for Arts and Culture and a former executive director of the B.C. Touring Council. This commentary first appeared on his blog.

Comments

Tom Durrie
Bravo! You've said what surely everyone is thinking.
 
Clair
Hear hear!
 
Vanessa LeBourdais
Thanks for speaking up. I agree with you completely.

Vanessa LeBourdais, Executive Producer, DreamRider Theatre http://www.dreamridertheatre.com
 
Lorraine K
This is similar to the Federal Gov't's 'Culture Days' thing that is supposed to happen in September. How many people know about it? We are all supposed to come up with some arts event (no funding) open to the public. Free, volunteer, we supply everything etc. Supposedly this will allow us to 'market' ourselves. We couldn't declare April 'Arts Month' because the Feds were making their own declaration in September. So they get some kind of 'points' because the are 'supporting the arts'. Right.
 
Jay Hirabayashi
Thank God the world is ending in 2012. At least we will all go together when we go. Starting a festival just to access a grant is the same as buying a rope to hang yourself with.
 
Terry Hunter
Another brilliant, articulate and bang on assessment from John McLachlan.
 
Maria Insell
Brilliant & great incite from the voice of experience. Thank You John.
 
Kevin Dale McKeown
Thank you John. You said it.
 
Don Robinson
let's just say that the current arts community and even a whole lot of charities from which this govt has stolen monies could have subsisted very well for many years on the 30M they miraculously "uncovered" for this fiasco

Few festivals thrive in February (other than maybe the Push Festival -- which is brilliant) -- but BC spirit festivals?? Thye're kidding, right? They aren't? Oh my freaking god.

Kreuger has not clue one what he is doing, supposed to do or even what he could do ... a more useless politician there is not and a more misinformed clueless individual in this province there is not.

This government is a complete joke -- sadly they are stealing money reserved for charities and the arts and directly affecting my livelihood.
 
Tara Cheyenne Friedenberg
Thanks you John! we don't need spirit festivals, or retractable roofs or whatever. Its just a little too 'art for the state' flavoured for this jew.....
 
David Diamond
Thanks, John. Too bad we can't draft you onto the BC Arts Council. The gagged silence from those who are supposed to be the custodians of culture in BC is deafening.
 
Lidsville
Amen, John. This is without doubt the worst example of incompetent mismanagement of the cultural sector in Canadian history. The BC Arts Council does need to take a very strong public stand now, but the real villains are Minister Krueger and Premier Campbell whose unprecedented political interference in the cultural life of this province makes us the laughingstock of the whole country. The only artistic production in this province that needs its funding cut is Liberals du Soleil.
 
elaine-c@mdi.ca
Well said and thank you, John McLauchlan. These Spirit of BC festivals grants for artistic propaganda promoting the BC so-called So-Cred-Liberal government on the backs of struggling arts organizations sound suspiciously like Leni Riefenstahl's work for Hitler's Germany. Let's remember that artists like Kurt Weill, Bertolt Brecht, George Grosz, Kurt Schwitters, Otto Dix and others left Nazi Germany. Can BC afford this kind of exodus because it's already begun - Crystal Pite, Kika Thorne, Cheyanne Turions and others. Elaine Carol, Artistic Director, MISCELLANEOUS Productions (comment page is not cooperating)

 
Art Buzz
This has Campbell written all over it. He's just looking for another expensive party for his rich friends and a chance to wave his fucking red mitts in the air. There's sea of drunks on Granville street already and it's free! Give the money BACK to the real arts.
 
Kristi
Agreed!
 
Dan Clay
BC Spirit festival? The spirit of fascism, is being celebrated, attempting to thwart the spirit of artistic creation? pulling funding from that which goes against their corporate business like ideological spirit..? thats what this is about. Cant wait for these pigs to wake up to a complete rejection by the citizens of BC.sooner than their 3 year nondate.
I can say I never once darkened the door of any BORELYMPIC festival during those horrible 2 weeks.
 
Kelly Gough
Well said. Haven't business types always assumed that the art community lacks acumen of any kind? Are they trickling some scraps our way to appease us? Please, we must not re-elect them.
 
Kuba Ohms
I loved your work with Mahavishnu Orchestra, John.... ;)
 
Bill Horne
This program is worse than those stupid Millenium grants. How many arts organizations and artists were looking for ways to celebrate the Millenium? The quintessential top-down policy.

In this case, how many arts organizations in the north want to hold festivals in February? Another fine business model from the supposedly fiscally-prudent govt.

I can't wait for winter with hordes of people driving to Wells from the Lower Mainland and Victoria in their all-season tires :-o

How about a Spirit of BC Rail Festival? We could set up model trains all over BC and then sell them to the highest bidder - after a few insider shenanigans!

Or a Spirit of PST Festival? Set up yard sales & kiosks and charge the good ol' pre-HST %.

No doubt there are many Spirits lurking in the wings that would make excellent themes. Otherwise, I hope every arts group boycotts this nonsense.
www.claireart.ca
 
John McLachlan
Given the amazing response to this, I wonder if any of the powers-that-be are listening?
 
Ursa Minor
These 'Spirit Festival' organizers should have taken a look at Calgary's desperate attempts to keep their 'Olympic Spirt' on life support after the 1988 Games. There's a reason why you've never heard of the Calgary Winter Festival.

It's like the people who won't take their Xmas decorations down until well into February - give it up and move on already.
 
Marc L'Esperance
Well said, John. Thanks for the straight talk.

We need the BC government to restore arms-length funding of culture and art, and stop bleeding real artists and cultural organizations dry!

Diverting funds from real art to a blatant propaganda event is reprehensible behavior and indicates no respect or understanding of what art or culture is. Real art and culture creates a real legacy.
 
Ken Pickering
John, In complete agreement with your thoughts on this issue. It's really disheartening to see the BCAC on life support and the adverse affect the radical funding cuts are having on the provincial arts sector. Spirit Festival concept is complete rubbish designed to buy votes in non urban communities and simultaneously to tell the "real cultural workers" in the community exactly what they (Liberal gov't) think of them. The gov't just doesn't give a damn about culture and art. That much seems pretty clear.
 
Fiona Kendall
Totally agree. Everyone I talk to think that the idea of 'Spirit Festivals' is really tacky.

Is there any chance that the government will back down on this ill-conceived and incredibly gauche idea? Is this REALLY going to happen? Maybe it's a government conspiracy...they're hoping that all the arts orgs will be so upset that everyone will boycott, so they can shrug 'your loss' and put the money back in their pockets ?
 
D. Zaster
Given the unanimous opposition to the BC Spirit Festival expressed here, will artists take the next step and boycott it?

Artists and concerned citizens can complain all they want - but what does any of it mean if grant applications continue to be submitted?

If you hate what the government is doing to the arts - if you hate this festival in particular - you have to unite and, in solidarity, declare you will have nothing to do with it.

Boycott the BC Spirit Festival.
 
frances wasserlein
Thanks, John.

Consider this folks - the 'Spirit Festival' grant can only be applied for by Members of the Assembly of BC Arts Councils, or Aboriginal Friendship Centres, Band Councils or other Aboriginal cultural organizations.
 
Linda Crosfield
Too bad they didn't resurrect the BC Festival of the Arts. Every year a different city took it on, it supported all manner of art and artists, all at the same time. It was uplifting to be present at one whether or not you were a delegate.

And February? A bad storm and there go your participants.
 
Linda Rogers Victoria Poet Laureate
The pork in this barrel is full of worms.
 
Helen Clay
Absolutely agree. Thanks for saying it out loud.
 
Norman Armour
Well said John. Thank you!
 
KRickO
yes a veneer of Excitement has gotta be created for the benefit of der fuhrur Campbell , so he can show that bc is the best place on earth, under his rule
 
Stewart Champion
Well said, well written, and well aimed, John.

These 'festivals' are the inevitable result of what happens when the Philistines get to throw the first rock.

Campbell et cie were pleased to trot us out for the Olympics, throw us away immediately after, and now with this nonsense are trying to buy our silence. No one should come so cheap.

I strongly agree with the call to name this one -- over and over and over -- for the hoax that it is, to refuse to support it in ANY way, and to allow it to fall apart of its own absurdity. Kreuger may not have a clue, but some around him do, and will be horrified if we were truly united on this one.

We might refer to these as the BC Ghost Festivals. Such wraiths are completely without substance, and will disappear in a flash. NO ONE wants them.
 
Maureen Berger
Why assume that this idea is stupid? If you spend your money on a half-assed festival that no one cares about, then you are creating proof that spending should be cut. Obviously the arts are irrelevant and boring, and unworthy of benefiting from gambling (oops, I mean tax) revenues.
 
Stewart Champion
Perhaps even better:

BC GHOST FESTIVALS: no one wants them, and they disappear without a trace.
 
Melissa
Agreed completely. Having to contrive some ridiculous festival out of thin air for groups that are already struggling for core funding is insane. It's like offering a dying person money to throw a party, but taking the money out of the health care funding that's keeping them on life support.

Funding for the arts pays back to the community, the province, and the country ten-fold. Not only in terms of enriching people's lives, but in actual money in taxes, corporate investment, and real capital.
 
Cathy McCashin
Right on John. I was wondering when someone would speak the truth about this ridiculous idea. 30 million thrown away while bonafide groups, like mine, the Vancouver Philharmonic Orchestra, limp along after 100% cuts. It;s sheer insanity.These Liberals wouldn't know art from a f-art. These are scary times for democracy and the arts, two things that go hand in hand.
 
Lisa Desprez
Right on!!! Thanks for speaking up when so many of us feel we can't . Millions of dollars being sucked up by/for the Olympic Games...AGAIN, instead of being used for and by the community at large. It would be laughable if not so devastating.
 
Joan Blackman
BRAVO!
 
Renee Iaci
Well put, John. And yes, shameless hussy productions will boycott this BC Spirit Festival grant crap. Why not go out in flames?!
 
Bill Sample
Thank you John for saying what so many of us have been feeling....we need to be braver in the arts, but we're so damn poor all the time....
 
Robin Greenwood
Boycott the Spirit Fesival!
 
Graham Ord
Perhaps a full scale boycott of this "festival" would be in order
 
Isaac Bull
The "Spirit of B.C." related to Arts during the Olympics was promoted largly by "volunteer" performers (just going for the "exposure". Aritists are obviously not regarded as real professionals or capable business people as mentioned in previous comments, but just clowns serving the whim of our political masters to give them the glory for their own show. No thought to the fact that the truth is, dollar for dollar, the arts brings in heaps more to the economy than it takes from the mediocre and shrinking funding that governments provide. Great shame. Thanks for speaking up and ringing loud and true!!!!
 
Allison Haley
I applaud John McLachlan and Jane Danzo for standing up and telling everyone that what the Campbell Liberals are doing to the Arts in BC is unacceptable. They give us something to cheer for but unless we stand with them and form a united artistic protest we lack a strong enough voice. If we apply for these Spirit Grants and implement the government's vision of what artists should do, we sell out our own community and our own visions. Let's do what artists do best - show people what is and what is possible!
 
Lisa Yater
Everybody could apply for the 365 day long festival of arts organization's bills and programs...
 
moemol
This is bang on. The only art gallery in my northern B.C. town lost all it's funding from the province and is now fundraising locally in order to keep its doors open so that local artists have a place to show their work. It's sad times and a festival celebrating last year's news isn't new or innovative.
 
Lorna Brown
Dear Kevin,
It seems that your exposure to the arts in recent years has had an interesting outcome – now you want to make it yourself! You have awarded yourself funds, expropriated from actual artists, to give yourself a production budget. I notice that you plan to outsource your production back to those same artists as long as they promise to adhere to your vision. You have settled on your theme (celebration of the province) and your form (low budget spectacle) and are full of anticipation about how the public will respond to it (retroactive olympic pride). Having watched more than a few fledgling artists make similar kinds of mistakes early in their careers, I'll offer some advice.

It is simply not possible to control how the public will respond to your work, Kevin. While you may want more than anything for the public to remember the olympics fondly, and feel that flutter of pride in their hearts about their beloved homeland, they just might feel a bitter resentment and righteous anger about the fundamental dishonesty of your artistic process. They may refuse to feel what you want them to feel about the state of affairs in their province and decide to not go along with any forced-march celebrations. Your work might remind them more of Kim Jong-il than would be entirely comfortable for you. They may object to having their tax dollars used in such a cynical and coercive ploy. I know these are hard lessons, Kevin, but every artist must face them. While you may think that you have covered all your bases, your audience is very discerning and much more sophisticated than you think. This is what is meant by 'artistic risk': similar to political risk, but ultimately much more important in the long term.

Sincerely,
 
Maureen Berger
It occurs to me that some (who probably don't know me) may have missed the sardonic tone to my last post. Just to be clear, I was speaking of the malicious motives of our elected leaders, not denigrating any actual artistic endeavour or the arts in general.
 
Jonathan Hanley
The naive me thinks perhaps the Gov't really was impressed with all the BC and Canada pride, but the realist in me thinks the Gov't doesn't understand anything about Art beyond using it as a promotional tool.

It is times like this that we see the power of the Govt to do whatever they want, even if it damages the Province for many years to com. Unfortunately it seems that we had our say when the Campbell was reelected, so now it's all bets are off.

I did NOT vote for this. Stop killing the Arts.
 
unknown sample
If the arts community cannot sustain itself as opposed to perpetual reliance on the taxpayer for funding, then it has no reason to exist.

The sense of entitlement here disgusts me.

Get financially creative, creative types.
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.