News and Views » News Features

Vancouver woman links eviction to being transsexual

By Charlie Smith,

Pamela Burge has filed a complaint with the B.C. Human Rights Tribunal after she was ordered out of the social-housing unit where she lived for 13 years.

A Vancouver transsexual has filed a human-rights complaint, alleging discrimination on the basis of sex, age, and disability after she was evicted from a downtown social-housing complex. In an interview with the Georgia Straight, Pamela Burge said she was thrown out of the Wellspring, which is at 415 Nelson Street, at the end of June. This came after the society that manages the complex claimed that she owed $1,355 in outstanding rent.

Burge, once a well-known broadcasting executive who went by the name of Tim Burge, has alleged that the real reason she was evicted was that the building administrator, Joanne Graham, did not like her because she is transsexual. Burge, 65, claimed that she did not owe any back rent, and that the society refused to acknowledge receiving her documentation of her income from social assistance and the Canada Pension Plan.

“I could never imagine this happening to me as a middle-class man or even as a regular woman,” she said.

Burge has named Graham, the 127 Society for Housing, and the Diocese of New Westminster as respondents in her complaint to the B.C. Human Rights Tribunal. The Anglican church has supported the society and its name is on a plaque outside the front door of the building, but Burge said that it has absolved itself of any responsibility for her eviction.

Graham sent an e-mail to the Straight saying she reports to the directors of the society, and that she wanted to receive questions in writing. She was told about the nature of Burge’s complaint, and did not call back by deadline.

Burge said that she lived in the building for 13 years and was so distraught by the eviction that she checked into St. Paul’s Hospital. She added that she is living in temporary accommodation in the Downtown Eastside. She listed her disabilities as fibromyalgia, posttraumatic stress disorder, and bouts of depression.

“What rights do you have—never mind if you’re a tranny—if you go to a building managed by a nonprofit?” she asked. “B.C. Housing won’t help you.”

The NDP MLA for Vancouver–Mount Pleasant, Jenny Kwan, wrote a letter to Housing and Social Development Minister Rich Coleman on September 1 asking him to ensure that B.C. Housing gives “urgent consideration” to Burge’s application for new housing.

“Ms. Burge is in a tenuous situation, is housed only temporarily and is in imminent danger of being homeless,” Kwan wrote. “Ms. Burge is also a senior citizen, and a person with a disability.”

Burge said that her human-rights complaint covers actions that occurred in 2009 and 2010. She claimed that the society told her that she must clean her deck, which was outside the building and resembled a balcony, three times a year by hand. One of her advocates, transsexual activist Stephanie Castle, told the Straight in an interview that the society’s demand for her to clean the concrete slabs constituted harassment.

“They expected her, with her disabilities, to get down on her bended knees to scrub them by hand when they have a pressure cleaner in the building, which they used for other services,” Castle said.

Burge appealed the eviction to the Residential Tenancy Branch, which administers the Residential Tenancy Act. She said that the arbitrator repeatedly referred to her as “Mr. Burge” in a telephone hearing, which offended her. Another of Burge’s supporters, mental-health advocate Maryann Boyle, told the Straight by phone that she heard the arbitrator make these remarks.

Boyle added that the arbitrator, who upheld the eviction, called her “Mr. Burge” even after he was corrected. Boyle also claimed that his temper was “getting out of hand”.

“Pam never got a chance to really put her point across,” Boyle said.

Comments

Dana S.
How can Vancouverites claim that this city is liberal when shit like this happens?
 
CatherineCC
It is disgusting that the employees of the Residential Tenancy Branch are homophobic and transphobic. I wish I could see this as an isolated incident, but it is not. It is well known that if you're a trans tenant, they will work against your interests and likely belittle and insult you as they do it.
 
Blue Jay
Get all the facts first before making judgements in the heat of the moment.
 
Teresa
I've been following stories of trans discrimination for some time (I'm trans myself) and this sounds like something from another country. I am very surprised this kind of discrimination is still allowed to go on in Canada.
 
mad
she lived like a pig and the 127 society has lots of gay tenants and they have no problems i live in one of there building and i have never seen one bit of discrimination against anyone. Pam is just an angry person who didn't want to follow a few simple rules that all tenants have to comply with .her complaint is a bunch of showboating in my eyes do not believe this till you know both sides of the story
 
Sandra S
Sounds like she didn't have enough money.
 
Terry
Sounds like "mad" has alterior motives. I've known Pam for many years and visited her many times at her home which was always clean and beautifully decorated.
Having been a tenant myself, demanding a disabled senior citizen to get down on their hands and knees to clean a HUGE concrete balcony is NOT just one of a few "simple rules."
By the way "mad", there's a difference between being gay and transgender. Need I say more?
 
Noel
I agree "mad" has alterior motives. Why won't he/she give their name?
I highly doubt a man of Mr. Smith's integrity, who is obviously trying to get "the other side of the story" would write this article without having done the necessary research.
 
patricia
I have known Pam for years and have been to her place and it was always neat and tidy,this harassment has been going on for years, this is just one incident of many she has been put through,it is about time that these low income housing were checked into as to how they treat their tennants
 
Roslyn Cassells
As low-income renters, we are all one step away from being homeless. Market housing slumlords, BC Housing, DERA, and other so-called housing outfits run their buildings like small fiefdoms...treating the tenants like so many bothersome children. It is time that this province creates a climate where decent, clean, affordable, safe housing is available to all. Good housing is the greatest predictor of overall health, which would explain why the DTES looks like a scene from Dantes Inferno. Hang in there Pam, if there is anything I can do please contact me at roslyncassells@yahoo.ca
 
Tami Starlight
Another example of separate and NOT equal.

I feel it is so unfortunate that trans Canadians are STILL SECOND CLASS CITIZENS! (I am being kind with my words)

Certainly the conclusion of this story had me VERY angry.
Where the arbitrator spoke in such blatant oppressive terms.

We all need to be held to account how we oppress others.
Classism/racism/gender-ism/homophobia/ablism/transphobia and so on......
Especially when we are public servants. Yet, not to let off those who are simply other Canadian citizens.

I strongly suggest throwing your support behind organizations, political types, and people who support FULL EQUALITY. Check out BIll Siksay's BIll C389: http://www.billsiksay.ca/default2.asp?active_page_id=1166

Also - help plan, attend and pass on info about the Vancouver Transgender Day of Remembrance. Nov. 20/2010 5:30pm Carnegie Center - march to SFU Harbour Center.
See:
Planning committee group
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Vantdor
Facebook group
http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=112582138799998
Main Transgender DOR website(international locations, names & media info)
http://www.transgenderdor.org/
 
Art Belew
I see no sign of discrimination in this case, at least as described in the article. Seems to be a case of a woman who could not live within the rules, got behind in her rent, and then yelled, "discrimination!"
 
glen p robbins
I'd need to see the written correspondence, however Ms. Burge says she owes no back rent, and if she does, she should all things considered be given an opportunity to redress that situation is she does owe money.

If the arbiter behaved the way it is alleged, than this is not right -

It sounds like a cause of action -- is valid.
 
cinni
Transsexuals are second class citizens(or worse)throughout the world, sad, but true. I live in the USA, where trans people are frequently treated this way by citizens, by the police, by employers, and the legal system, etc. The Trans population as a whole is comparatively so small, and so powerless, there just isn't much help or remedy when events like this occur. There are many gay and lesbian women in government, in popular entertainment, and in many positions of society where they can exert pressure for change and also be heard. The same can not be said for the tg population, and especially transsexuals. Champions of trans-justice are few and far in-between, and rarely are they given a platform or voice in the public or legal arena. For what it's worth, I am a transsexual, well traveled and informed, so I do know something about this topic. Also, though I believe my statement to be true, that transsexuals are second class citizens, I do not accept it to be right or fair, I fight discrimination as best I can, and I also hope for a day when it no longer exists.
 
Charlotte
To the skeptics I say try walking a mile in her shoes. For whatever reason society looks down on transsexuals and even many in the lesbian /gay community are not true allies. I am a late blooming transsexual senior and I never, ever expected I would spend my retirement years having to deal with this birth defect that can cause so much torment and anguish in a person's life. I also hope and pray for the day when society is enlightened enough to treat transgendered people the same as everyone else.
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.