Asbestos rules ignored in many B.C. home demolitions, contractor claims

    1 of 1 2 of 1

      Home-demolition contractor Jerome Klett is blowing the whistle on what he claims are rampant illegal practices in the industry.

      The owner of Vancouver-based 4W's Demo Ltd. told the Georgia Straight that unsafe operations place not only workers but residents at risk of deadly asbestos exposure.

      “There’s a lot of procedures involved with asbestos removal, and a lot of the companies that are doing it right now are cheating brutally,” Klett said in a phone interview.

      A fine and strong mineral fibre, asbestos has been used for heat and noise insulation, for fire protection, and in cement and plaster. It has been found to be a health hazard. Asbestos was used in house construction until the late 1980s.

      According to Klett, around 2,000 to 3,000 old homes containing asbestos materials are being demolished every year in the Lower Mainland.

      Klett said that such shenanigans as deliberately failing to put in place measures to control the spread of asbestos aren’t limited to firms that actually do demolitions. He claimed that some companies conducting environmental assessments of homes are also involved in questionable practices.

      “They will literally lie and falsify the documentation so the client will have less cost. But when they do that, they do that for a cost, of course,” Klett said. “To get an environmental report done, it costs around $500. But these guys, what they’ll do is, they’ll come in and say, ”˜Oh, I did a report. You’ve got all this bad stuff in your house. I’ll write a report for you for $1,500 saying you have no bad stuff in your house.’”

      Before old homes are either knocked down or renovated, contractors like Klett first have to remove all asbestos-containing materials. But before they can do that, they have to submit a "notice of project for asbestos" to WorkSafeBC at least 24 hours before the work begins.

      This NOPA provides details of the work involved and measures being taken to minimize the risk of asbestos exposure.

      “There are now companies in the industry that don’t bother with NOPAs,” Klett said. “They dump the stuff illegally.”

      WorkSafeBC is a provincial Crown corporation whose mandate includes the administration of an employer-paid insurance system that compensates workers for job-related injuries and diseases.

      Al Johnson, who is WorkSafeBC’s regional director responsible for construction, acknowledged that there is a lot of activity in the demolition industry.

      “I think in the City of Vancouver alone, there’s three or four houses demolished every given day,” Johnson told the Straight in a phone interview. “And a lot of those houses contain hazardous materials.”

      He noted that some contractors don’t observe regular procedures like filing NOPAs. “That’s not always followed, so really it’s a bit of detective work to find out where these places are and then inspecting them,” Johnson said. “We also work with the municipalities so that when they issue a demolition permit, they’ll also let us know where these permits are issued for.”

      According to WorkSafeBC, over 20 percent of all fatality claims it accepted between 1994 and 2003 resulted from asbestos exposure. These deaths were attributed to asbestosis, mesothelioma, and lung cancer.

      A WorkSafeBC enforcement report dated March 3 provides several examples of how regulations are not being followed.

      In one case, Nystar Developments Corporation was fined $2,500 last year while operating in Vancouver. It was established that 10 of the company’s workers were removing asbestos-containing materials from a demolition site “without following the proper procedures and without using appropriate personal protective equipment”.

      The firm also failed to ensure that the asbestos materials identified in the work site’s hazardous materials survey were safely contained, WorkSafeBC’s report notes.

      According to Johnson, the effects of asbestos exposure have a long latency period. “Deaths from asbestos diseases continue to grow in this province,” he said. “You’re exposed today, and the disease develops 20, 30, 40 years from now.”

      Comments

      7 Comments

      James Clarke

      Aug 14, 2011 at 12:20pm

      Can a building with Asbestos be moved?

      Gary Sugrim

      Apr 10, 2012 at 10:19pm

      I have been exposed to asbestos for one week. I need some advise on how to file a claim or report what happen. It was caused by neglgence and disregard on behalf of my employer. He needs to be stopped.

      Al

      Dec 13, 2012 at 11:08am

      They can be moved out on a flat bed truck but it isn't always practical. A move candidate is generally a single storey home probably not much more than 1000 ft2, and desireable for a use in a new location. If the building is too tall, it won't fit under utility lines, traffic lights, bridges, etc. Some of these obstacles can be overcome - lifting lines is possible, but may break the bank. Asbestos is not a concern if left undisturbed. Moving a home to a new site means someone else will inevitably have to deal with asbestos abatement in the future whether during a renovation or demolition at end of life.

      Derrick Fernie

      Mar 20, 2013 at 5:27am

      our Governments have been covering this up since 1925 instead of no pun intended coming clean.Watch a video called Fatal Deception it says it all.The law is there to stop these people, the criminal Code of Canada 217 ,217.1 ,
      219 220 they all apply but try to get the Attorney general to charge that's another matter.

      Derrick Fernie

      May 26, 2013 at 2:52pm

      This company is to be commended for speaking up! These owners that do this! need to be charged under the criminal code which carry's up to a ten year sentence.We have perfectly good prison's and very experienced prison guards going to waste in this country.We need to utilize these services and put these people where they belong.

      Gary Sugrim

      Nov 19, 2013 at 4:34am

      a very close friend of mine in the dry wall/renovation industry recently died of mesothelioma lately. He suffered with the disease for a long time.
      Asbestos is deadly! If you are a smoker, diagnosed with the disease, quit smoking immediately it helps.

      Shrink Wrapper

      Dec 6, 2013 at 3:39am

      Call in an expert like enviro-vac. They will do the job right, the first time, every time.