News and Views » News Features

Granville Street’s new beat

The Yale Hotel’s Waide Luciak (left, with marketing manager Stella Panagiotidis and son Joe Luciak) has adapted well to the changing face of Granville Street.

Long considered a seedy strip, Granville Street is gentrifying, and its new condos could transform Vancouver's entertainment scene

By Charlie Smith,

Waide Luciak has seen Granville Street go through plenty of ups and downs over the past quarter-century. When he bought the historic Yale Hotel shortly after Expo 86, it was on one of Vancouver’s seediest strips. This was before luxury condos were constructed across Yaletown, before the creation of the city’s entertainment district, even before Hong Kong–based billionaire Li Ka-shing built his first shiny high-rise on the north shore of False Creek.

In those days, the 900-to-1300-block stretch of Granville Street was Vancouver’s version of the downtrodden Parisian neighbourhood of Pigalle. Most noteworthy for its street kids, prostitution, porn shops, and occasional biker hangout, it was then known as Downtown South.

In an interview with the Georgia Straight inside the Yale’s blues bar, Luciak recalls doing a brisk business in the first five years of owning the hotel, before things started to wane. “We noticed that over the years, the business really became a little bit slower and slower,” he says.

Meanwhile, down the street, the Commodore Ballroom ran into severe financial trouble in the early 1990s, eventually forcing out its popular owner, Drew Burns. It was a far cry from the Granville Street of today, which is home to trendy restaurants, funky retailers, crowded nightclubs, and a growing number of street festivals.

Last month, Vancouver city council approved the Telus Garden mixed-used development, which will include a 45-storey residential tower in the block bounded by Seymour, West Georgia, Richards, and Robson streets. This will add more people to the neighbourhood. At the southern end of the strip, next door to the Yale, Rize Alliance is building a 187-unit, 23-storey tower. Across the street and behind the Best Western Hotel, Cressey Development is proceeding with a 193-unit, 32-storey development called Maddox.

That’s just the beginning. The city also plans to remove the “Granville loops”—two on-ramps connecting Pacific Street to the bridge—which will free up land for a new streetscape and new high-rises. That’s in addition to the Mark, Onni Group’s 47-storey residential tower being built behind the Yale on Seymour Street.

“Great public streets need population supports—they need anchors on either side, to move people back and forth,” the city’s director of planning, Brent Toderian, tells the Straight over the phone. “There is a lot of learning over generations in North America on how to make a great street like Granville work. Telus [Garden] and the Granville loops are an important part of that.”

All this follows a $20.8-million facelift to Granville Street completed just before the 2010 Games. This resulted in wider and fancier sidewalks, new lighting, and a rejigging of the block north of Smithe Street to create a public plaza.

“The Olympics, of course, transformed the perception of Granville Street and its role within the downtown,” Toderian points out. “It became more than ever the living room of the downtown. So we want to do everything we can to enhance that with additional population in the area.”

The executive director of the Downtown Vancouver Business Improvement Association, Charles Gauthier, tells the Straight by phone that buskers on the street, including rapper Marc Stokes, have injected an urban flavour. He adds that the VIVA Vancouver program, which transformed part of the road space into a pedestrian zone this summer, also lured more people to the area. “We get a lot of inquiries from people who want to do festivals and events on Granville Street,” Gauthier says.

He sees potential for conflict in the future between new residents and what he calls the "night-life economy." However, Gauthier adds that the clubs at the southern end of the strip where much of the development will occur, such as Ginger 62 and the Morrissey, have a different energy than those north of Nelson Street.

Meanwhile, Vancouver retail consultant Phil Boname says Granville Street was held back for many years because city planners decided to create a pedestrian mall and transit corridor without vehicular traffic, which was modelled on a similar experiment in Minneapolis. “We have found in many of our studies that converting a downtown street into a transit corridor does not necessarily work for the advantage of commercial interests,” he says by phone, quickly adding that this approach also doesn’t create a “social success”.

In 1997, Boname wrote a report for the City of Vancouver recommending several changes to breathe new economic life into Granville Street. He says he’s pleased to see more mixed-use development, but regrets that the city didn’t embark on a design competition to create a “glamorous” gateway at the bridge head into downtown. At the same time, he believes that the Canada Line, which was completed in 2009, will lure more major retailers to the strip.

“The corner of Robson and Granville will become increasingly powerful,” the consultant says. Then he tosses in a prediction that the Sears store will vacate this location within five years because its sales-per-square-foot ratio isn’t high enough to justify remaining in such a prime spot.

Sherman Scott, associate vice president of retail with Colliers International in Vancouver, tells the Straight by phone that lease rates are increasing along Granville Street. But they're still significantly lower than along Robson Street, where some are paying $200 per square foot.

"The highest deals I've seen on Granville Street are around $60 a square foot," Scott says. In an aside, he notes that he has never in his life seen so many vacancies on Robson Street.

Comments

Matthew Yeoman
I just hope that all these condo owners realize what they're buying and don't try to change Granville. If one busker has to move or leave, after all the work that's been put in to keep them around, the loss of this streets character will have begun.
 
Chris Vollan, Rize Alliance
Kudos to the Straight for recognizing the importance of the enormous changes now underway on Granville Street. Our construction crew is busy on The Rolston, (actually 187 homes) and 23 storeys of pretty cool architecture set for completion in Spring 2013. We are also on track to revitalize the landmark Yale Hotel as part of our overall commitment to Granville Street and Midtown. We defintiely see both of these, and the new residents who will live at the Rolston, as adding to the existing character of Granville Street.

 
Joe Klymkiw
Coming from out of town I only hear bad things about Granville st. That the city funnels people there by closing surrounding bars in East Van, Kits at 1am. At night is littered with drunken suburban kids who were responsible for the riots. You take one type of seedy for another.

The fact they close off the street just so drunken hooligans can walk the street with pizza I guess is a upgrade from hookers. But if you want that just go to Seymour.
 
corporations
speculators will drive up the rent so high nobody except 'global brands' will be able to open a business. with the influx of new yuppies to the area, they will start complaining to the city about noise.

vancouver 2030 will be nothing but condos as far as the eye can see and coffee shops run by starbucks, ordered to be closed at 9pm to satisfy old ladies in condo towers.

 
mm
Granville Street was way cooler in the 90's. Seedier, yes, but it had soul. Old architecture and all-indie businesses brought a more interesting and eclectic demographic... I miss The Royal, the old winos, the hookers and hustlers, the Hotel California with its giant mermaid mural and dirty rock'n'roll bar downstairs. Now all my friends and I avoid Granville like the plague. It's mostly clone clubs, clone chain stores, and clone people. After dark it seems to be run by, and for, 20something suburban pigs. That's why Granville is now called "The Asshole District".
 
ernie
Isnt the guy with the moustache one of the old guys from the muppet show?
 
greggron
Lamecouver
 
revitalize this
Granville Street looks like Robson Street now. When I walk down it, I get the sense that I'm supposed to feel 'chic', 'hip', and 'sophisticated'. What will happen when this urbane brand that the city has adopted grows tiresome and unprofitable?
 
Richard Jenkins
I grew up in the West End, hung out all up and down Granville and everywhere else Downtown. That street is yuppie shit right now, and the future for culture there is bleak. What kind of "life" are a bunch of yuppies and rich fucks gonna bring to Granville by buying a bunch of condos? What magnificent cultural exchange will occur when all those humourless materialistic try-hards get together in their freshly bought shoeboxes and compare products? Granville is as hip as Kitsilano. Commercial will be the next to fall.

Don't even act like it's not the truth. This city has been without a soul since some time in the early 2000's... and it's my home town. Makes me want to cry.
 
mm is right
"Twenty something suburban pigs" is right. Drunk assholes falling around trying to pick each other up while listening to top 40 pop.
 
Foxxe Wilder
Amen MM! The BIG difference between the poor that lived there and the drunken rich jerks that visit there at night are that the poor NEVER crap on their own doorstep. The rich drunks don't care at all.

Trendy shops are about as attractive as an overweight 80 year old in a bikini, and just as moral.

When I see the human garbage down there on "Fried-eh" nights I just want to retch. Vancouver is not a haven for publicly violent drunks. Let Toronto do that crap.
 
Is the sq. footage price an cultural index?
Maybe culture, character, charm, urbanity rise/fall inversely to the price of a square foot of property? The more expensive property gets, the blander culture and street life become. That would account for the sterility that has overcome so much of Downtown Vancouver, esp. Yale Town, Coal Harbour, Robson Street etc. Run down parts of town tend to have more interesting bars, bookstores, clubs etc. Bring in the big bucks and you get corporatism and its ceaseless search for the lowest common denominator (i.e. the appeal to as many as possible leads to the blandification of downtown). That also explains the horrid bars and weekend partiers on Granville downtown.
 
SunshineDay
I live close to Granville. I like being so close to the action, and for the most part, I can deal with extra weekend noise. I knew what I was signing up for in that respect. What I can't deal with, however, is the lack of respect that people seem to have for the surrounding streets of the neighbourhood. Walking around on a Saturday or Sunday morning is a sad experience. Pizza plates, fast food wrappers, and cigarette packages line the sidewalks. Come downtown, have fun, but show some respect for the people who live here.
 
bowser
Removing the loops that connect Granville to Pacific is stupid. Sure to cause more traffic problems but hey, gotta let the developers build every square inch.
 
Times square
This is what happened to Times Square in NYC. Speculation pushed up the rents, and Guiliani's council refused every new business permit except from the largest corporations.

Now all you see are big box chain stores and advertising. There is no longer soul there just cleanse, fold and manipulate the masses for profit. Sound familiar New and Improved Granville st?
 
RF
Yeah, sorry, but the Yale is doomed - unless of course it becomes a branded faux-gritty yuppie barn like a House of Blues. The new condo people - that is, those who will actually inhabit the buildings - won't be clamoring for some blues and R&B anytime soon. As others have pointed out, they'll be more interested in shopping at chain stores and staying home drafting up complaints about the noisy neighbourhood.

The real estate mafia who run this town won't be happy until we've all been replaced by beige pod people.
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.