Authentic Italian pizza, just like in old Napoli

There’s no denying Italians love their Neapolitan pizza. Just how important is the dish to those who call the Boot home? So crucial that the country is considering pushing for official UNESCO protection of the classic pie on the United Nations body’s “intangible cultural heritage” list.

Nicli Antica Pizzeria

62 East Cordova Street
604-669-6985
Open from 11:30 a.m. to midnight daily.
› Details

If you’ve never had the pleasure of travelling to Napoli to sample the real thing, you’re in luck. Gastown’s recently opened Nicli Antica Pizzeria serves up pizza so authentic you’ll swear you’re sitting in a bustling piazza and not in a stylish little restaurant with an exposed brick wall and stainless-steel accents on East Cordova Street.

Several factors combine to make Nicli’s pizza genuine and genuinely fine. Owner Bill McCaig (whose Italian grandfather’s last name was Nicli) sticks to the KISS credo: keep it simple, stupid. And to judge by what I tried on a recent visit, in the hands of Nicli’s team, simplicity is sublime.

You won’t find options like pineapple or barbecued chicken as toppings, and there are certainly no goo-stuffed crusts or canned black olives here. (Seriously, whoever uses those terrible, bland Cheerio-shaped things should be sworn at by Gordon Ramsay.) Instead, Nicli offers straightforward combinations on a total of 10 one-size-only pies. Uncomplicated and unpretentious, the flavours sing for themselves.

McCaig uses only the best ingredients: Italian “00” Caputo flour (for which cheaper, all-purpose stuff is no substitute); whole San Marzano tomatoes; velvety, barrel-aged 12-year-old Reggio Emilia San Giacomo balsamic vinegar; estate-grown, cold-pressed, extra-virgin Coratina olive oil; and so on. And finally, he cooks the pizzas as they were meant to be cooked: for about 90 seconds in a low-domed, wood-fired oven that reaches 900 ° Fahrenheit. The oven—a piece of art in its own right, encased in a tall, thick, white-tiled column underneath the white ceiling’s high arch—is an Acunto. Straight from Naples, it’s built by craftsmen using local clay, for the sole purpose of cooking pizza.

McCaig, who hails from St. Thomas, Ontario, and worked in his family’s waste-disposal company for a decade before going to the Cordon Bleu Ottawa Culinary Arts Institute, travelled to Naples to learn pizza-making from the pros. He’s so serious about providing the real deal that he’s hoping to get his pizza certified Specialití  Tradizionale Garantita, or “traditional specialty guaranteed”, this summer. The European Union label requires that a product meet certain standards (such as the use of the aforementioned prime ingredients) and be approved by a special committee.

The Prosciutto e Rucola ($19) is as pretty as it is savoury. Heaps of peppery arugula contrast nicely with the paper-thin meat’s saltiness. The portion of aromatic greens is so generous you’d be forgiven for thinking your waiter brought you a salad by mistake. The toppings appear bountiful across the board; one glance at the Margherita ($12) is met with big, bright basil leaves, not the shrivelled-up versions you might see at other Italian restaurants.

The big, juicy black olives on the Capricciosa ($20) are lusciously lemony and, together with the artichokes, mushrooms, basil, and prosciutto cotto, make for an indulgent dish.

The Misto Antipasti is a lovely start. At $15 for one person, the platter is easily enough to share, especially if you split, say, an Insalata Mista ($7) as well, with its whole head of roasted garlic. Served with mmm-inducing flatbread, which is topped with tiny, fresh thyme leaves, the antipasti include a plump, honeyed, preserved fig; simultaneously sweet and spicy orange and red peppers; oven-roasted tomatoes; Taleggio and Cappuccetto Rosso cheeses (the former is mellow and Brie-like, while the latter is stronger); lively green Castelvetrano olives marinated in a shallot-herb dressing; and mortadella, Bresaola (an air-dried, cured beef), and Genoa salami.

Nicli doesn’t take reservations, and by 6 o’clock on a recent Friday the place was packed. But it’s no hardship waiting for a table as you stand at the bar, cocktail in hand, checking out the pies going by (if not the diverse crowd: everyone from families with small kids to hipsters). Our date-night tab, including two glasses of wine each, came to about $100 before tax and tip. You won’t find a more bang-on take on pizza unless you go to Naples yourself.

Comments (16) Add New Comment
Ken Lawson
I love pizza!
5
6
Rating: -1
Hmmm...
Mellow and brie like? What?

Oh wait... you've probably only tried Canadian brie...
4
7
Rating: -3
R2
Nobody and I mean nobody beats Me n Eds in Burnaby!
They've taken Italian to a higher level and I know cause I'm a pizza freak.
8
11
Rating: -3
NDDP
I ate here 3 times last week. So simple yet so delicious. No complaints here whatsoever. This place is great as are the pizzas and the service.
7
8
Rating: -1
Norman
$100 before tip and taxes for a pizza joint? Hmmmm.
5
8
Rating: -3
Ghost town
Yikes! $100 for pizza night?
I guess this is what those cranky DTES activists meant by "gentrification"
6
7
Rating: -1
chien chaud
Seriously? $100 for pizza, some wine (4 glasses tis true) - what is this world coming to?
5
5
Rating: 0
S.R. Warren
I had lunch here last week with 2 pizza lovers from NYC and they were blissed out. This
pizza is unlike any we had ever had in North America. No wonder there are lines
to get in here. I couldn't finish all of my fab 4-cheese pizza, so I took it home. It was
yummy 2 days later. Simple, stylish decor-- this place is a true winner.
6
10
Rating: -4
JayJ
I just checked the website. Menu looks reasonably priced. Perhaps the wine list is short on weekday wines.
4
6
Rating: -2
Napule
This 'expert' critic has clearly never been to Naples...the pizza is alright compared to north American crap, but nothing about nicli reminds me of naples...give your head a shake
5
8
Rating: -3
Peter F
I like how a waste mangement worker, goes to cooking school and all of a sudden is going to show the world how to make Pizza. Earn your stripes first. Just because you have family money and can afford pr and a building does not make your restaurant the cats ass.
5
7
Rating: -2
jus
last sentence is utter stupidity
7
9
Rating: -2
Bruno15
Don't forget to mention the $300 deductible to get you car repaired after the inevitable break by the drug addicts after the change in your ashtray. Columbia and Cordova, are you kidding me?
7
6
Rating: +1
Charlie Smith
Thanks for the comment, Jus. It has been adjusted as a result of your input.

Charlie Smith
5
12
Rating: -7
Pat Crowe
I don't know about that Charlie Smith guy.
6
4
Rating: +2
Cici
My order came with the prosciutto plastic/wax still on my pizza apparently for that price they include everything. Other than that it was good.
7
9
Rating: -2
Add new comment
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.