Snow could serve its subject better

Comments

Starring Sobaz Benjamin and Kalista Zackhariyas. In English and Tamil with English subtitles. Rated PG.

There is every reason to feel for the predicament of Snow’s Sri Lankan protagonist, whose whole family perished in the 2004 tsunami. And there is no cause to doubt the motivation of writer-director Rohan Fernando, who previously made an NFB documentary (Blood and Water) about losing his own family members in the same massive disaster.

Unfortunately, the movie is a mess, with bad acting, weak dialogue, and arbitrary plotting persistently undermining whatever emotional content is on offer. The good stuff comes from lovely Kalista Zackhariyas, well cast as Parvati, the young village woman who suddenly finds herself in Canada, living with remarkably insensitive relatives in faraway Halifax. She has the presence and physical grace to hold the screen while not much happens—and that happens a lot. Obviously working on a very small budget, Fernando is overly dependent on nightmarish flashbacks to illustrate Parvati’s anguish. As appropriate as an ocean of evil may be to this particular story, water is the single most overused element of movie symbolism; here it washes over a lack of anything insightful the characters might have to say to each other, or us. The people playing our doleful protagonist’s new family and friends (several are related to the director) mumble and throw away their lines, which are frequently buried in the sound mix anyway.

Furthermore, the decision to restrict lenswork (except for a few pretty sequences) to tight, shaky-cam close-ups, often on the back of Parvati’s head, actually takes us away from her sense of displacement, especially when compared with, say, long shots that could have shown her dwarfed by “exotic” Nova Scotia. Instead, Halifax looks like nowhere in particular, and the people we meet—alarmingly prone to early death from drugs, suicide, and accident—seem arbitrarily assembled. Falling snow may represent both oppression and rebirth to our troubled protagonist but, sadly, it remains just so many soap flakes to the viewer.


Watch the trailer for Snow.

Comments (2) Add New Comment
Rohan Fernando (writer/director of Snow)
As this reviewer says, this film was made on a shoestring budget. We had to use non-actors (except Kalista) because there is not enough work for professional Sri Lankan actors in this country. It deals with topics of immigration and displacement about a community that rarely (if ever) gets a voice in commercial theatres. Perhaps this reviewer doesn't agree with the approach the film takes to tell this story but his profound arrogance on how it should be told baffles me. This is a film about empathy. If the reviewer has no patience for a film that doesn't provide pat answers but tries to create a space for empathy and individual reflection, or for small independent Canadian films trying to survive against all odds in a market that is dominated by American mega budget films with clever dialogue and predictable plotting, please don't let that stop you from going out and seeing this film and deciding for yourself. I have faith that your own empathy and understanding will leave you with more than just soapy snowflakes.
2
3
Rating: -1
Kalista Zackhariyas (Lead Actress of Snow)
While I appreciate and am extremely grateful for your performance review, I agree with Rohan that if you have the ability to see past the budget and choices made as a result of that budget, you will see that this film speaks to the most beautiful, caring parts within each of us. I am incredibly proud to have been a part of this film and will always feel gratitude to the Director, Rohan Fernando.

I thank him for his courage for going up against the mega million Hollywood films. I thank him for creating an honest film and staying true to his vision (this is such a rarity considering many directors are willing to butcher a story for funding). Lastly, I thank him for giving a South Asian artist like my self a space in the highly competitive film industry. His achievement of having a Canadian, low budget film screened along side multi million dollar films in theatres across Canada is commendable and what he has managed to accomplish with a micro budget is truly inspiring.

I encourage every viewer be his/her own judge! Thank you for creating this space to respond.
2
0
Rating: +2
Add new comment
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.