Roger Waters delivers a prog-rock spectacle for the ages

Comments

At Rogers Arena on Friday, December 10

At one point during Roger Waters’s spectacular sold-out show at Rogers Arena he pulled off what he called “an experiment in time travel”, playing in unison with a 1980 video of himself performing the ballad “Mother”. In actual fact, the entire concert was a journey back in time, to the days when his old band, Pink Floyd, would pull out all the stops and spare no expense to give its fans the type of massive rock spectacle they’d rave about for years to come.

Waters put on a riveting, state-of-the-art show three years ago when he played here on his Dark Side of the Moon tour, performing that cosmic 1973 Floyd opus in its entirety. And on his current tour, where he’s performing all of Floyd’s 1979 concept album, The Wall, he hasn’t cut back one bit on the staging and visuals. If anything, he’s ramped them up even more.

That became clear from the first song, “In the Flesh”, when huge fountains of shooting sparks cascaded around the stage and a plane came flying down on a cable from the far end of the arena to “explode” into flames at stage right. That really got your attention.

The centrepiece of the show was the wall of white bricks that was methodically built up while Waters and his crack band churned out The Wall’s tales of isolation and oppression. A major theme of the two-hour-plus presentation—which included a 25-minute break—was the futility and madness of war. Particularly heart-rending was the video footage shown during “Bring the Boys Back Home” of cheerful elementary-school kids breaking down when they catch sight of their returning soldier dads stepping into the classroom.

Waters’s own father was killed in the Second World War, and the fallout from that type of loss is just one of the issues plaguing Pink, the Waters-based protagonist of The Wall. He’s also burdened with an overprotective mother and abusive schoolteachers, the latter leading to a group of kid singers being brought on stage to proclaim “We don’t need no education!” and rail against a giant puppet teacher in “Another Brick in the Wall Part 2”.

It wasn’t just Waters’s personal demons that were targeted, though. Corporate greed and human-rights abuses also took a pounding, as on “Goodbye Blue Sky”, when animated warplanes unloaded blood-red Shell Oil emblems instead of bombs.

An hour after the show started the wall was complete, standing about 40 feet high and stretching the entire length of the stage, so that the band was completely hidden—and only Waters could be seen peeking through where one brick was missing, singing the languid “Goodbye Cruel World”. During the intermission the wall became a memorial for the casualties of human conflict, displaying pictures of scores of dead civilians, soldiers, and activists to a solemn soundtrack.

After the break Rogers wandered out by himself in front of the newly constructed barricade while his unseen band played along from the other side. One of the show’s most dazzling moments—and there were tons—came during “Hey You”, when he slammed his fists against the front of the wall and it exploded in a rainbow of light, bricks flying everywhere. It was only a trick of animation, though; the wall still held firm, and soon after the band appeared in front of it, carrying on with a set that included the atmospheric showstopper “Comfortably Numb”.

Apart from the stunning visuals, the sound quality of the show was unsurpassed—except maybe by Waters himself the last time he was here. How he manages to make a hockey rink come off like an acoustically designed concert hall is beyond me. I was still wondering how he did it after the wall had tumbled into ruin and a small army of workmen were folding down its cardboard-box bricks, stacking them aside for transport to the next unforgettable gig.

You can follow Steve Newton on Twitter at twitter.com/earofnewt.

Comments (20) Add New Comment
grinchbc
It wasn't 3 hours, not even close... started at 8:15 ended at 10:35 ... with the 25min break that only makes 2hrs.

The music was great, that's why I went. The visuals outdated
1
1
Rating: 0
kevin gladok
Dear me , As the recession hits the rich rockstars burn money live , No wonder there are riots
1
1
Rating: 0
Hugh
You got it right Steve. I was there last night and thanks for the review. It was one of the best concerts I've ever seen and I've seen a few. I'm still basking in the glow. Saw Pink Floyd at BC Place in 1994. Some similarites but I think Roger Waters really owns it does'nt he?
1
1
Rating: 0
Pat Cro
Here is my review.
Holy fuckin, fuck....FUCK!
1
1
Rating: 0
Steve Newton
you're right, grinchbc, I was wrong about the length of the show. If only it HAD been three hours! (I've made the correction to the review)
1
1
Rating: 0
cobra kai
my mind is still melted. un fuckin believable, worth every bloody cent. i just hope the guy we seen getting rolled out of the can, made out okay. he did not look good.
1
1
Rating: 0
Trevor
Ive never seen a Floyd concert let alone Roger Waters, and now after seeing the Wall Live, Im speechless god bless you Waters
1
1
Rating: 0
cobra kai
un fucking believable. worth every penny of the 104 bucks i spent. Poor cynical kevin gladlok. he sounds pretty bitter, betcha he would have been a pretty awestruck happy boy, if he bothered to attend. I f anyone knows how the dude made out near section 308. I witnessed him being carted out in a wheelchair looking in pretty rough shape, let us know.
1
1
Rating: 0
Lawrence Musser
Thanks very much for a review that was written from a point of view of appreciation for one of the truly genius musician/writer/performer/sound designers of this or any other time since I have been around (a few years now) and I have been attending musical events going back to Buddy Rich,the Beach Boys and Paul Revere & the raiders thru Cream,Hendrix,Led Zep ,the Who,,Frank Zappa then on to U2 , the Police and many form that era. I have always gone to concerts large and small, new and old from pop to jazz and everything in between and believe me when I say NOTHING matches what I witnessed at Rogers Arena last night.
It's unfortunate that some reviewers (perhaps one from another rag in the Vancouver area who appears to have a chip on his shoulder about some camping trip 30 years ago) would chose to find something to criticize rather than just absorb the brilliance because the likes of this show will not be seen again and maybe when they produce something equivalent to "The Wall" their criticism might actually be worth taking into account. Larry Musser
0
1
Rating: -1
kitts
I find it odd when millionaires charge a fortune for their tickets but feel the need to sing about corporate greed.
1
1
Rating: 0
bsm
I had the worst seat in section 325 row 14 which means no video. But, It did not make any difference to me because his music has sent me to a different world since 1979. I lived in Iran back then.
1
1
Rating: 0
Martin
I came from Germany 3 time to see 4 US shows (Chicago, Washington, Uniondale and Atlanta) and I can say that it was worth every penny of the money I spent, even if Roger gonna come next year to Europe (and then I will attend another 11 concerts). :-) 'The Wall' is the best show ever produced! The first time I saw it in Dortmund/Germany back in 1981 and I've sworn to myself that I will see this incredible show again if I ever get the chance to do it.
1
0
Rating: +1
evpollen
Great review, Steve. I always look for your work in the Straight. Good ear.
1
1
Rating: 0
Pat Cro
WE ARE SPARTACUS!
Spine chilling. Mind numbing.
Now I have seen it all!
Thank You, MR. PINK!
1
1
Rating: 0
Chantelle Walker
It was amazing, and made me feel ashamed to be a part of a society that has all the answers, and still causes so much harm.
1
2
Rating: -1
Terry
Great review Steve. My seat was row 30, seat 29. Center floor. There was the middle aisle behind me and then the mixing desk! I tip my hat to the crew that did sound & lights! ROCK-ON!

I'm picky when it comes to sound but heard nothing to criticize. I was very impressed with it! There's one thing I need to say about the song "another brick in the wall part 2" and noticed it during the 2007 tour Roger did here also. The opening bass note "drop G" is quit full & open on the Vinyl record but I've yet to hear it like that live. I just think it's funny the mixer hasn't nailed that. It's just a comment, I really enjoyed this show. It was fantastic! everything & more than I expected. The band was rock-on! The only thing I wanted to buy was the 30x24 poster that's part of the tour merchandise on Rogers site but they weren't selling them there! Why? Oh well, I'll see if I can order one on-line.

Thanks for a great show Roger!

1
1
Rating: 0
Thomas Hunt
Great visuals. The original 1980 show was more intimate and moving. Waters was clearly lip-synching to the vocals on MANY occasions.
1
1
Rating: 0
Westerly
Seen Pink Floyd twice and Roger Waters twice. Friday nights show was by far the best. Couldn't sleep for 2-3 hours after I got home as my mind was so over stimulated by the visuals and sound. Hope he returns.
1
0
Rating: +1
jewels9
seems ironic they'd charge so much for a concert against corporate greed, true. but how much do you think that show cost just to produce, let alone transport from city to city? none of the band members made any money off of the original tour back in the early 80's because of operational costs. i wonder if Waters and his band earned any money off of this tour at all. they probably barely brake even just with ticket sales. amazing show and worth every penny!! i hope they come back just like they have in other cities. i hope to be as young as Roger when i'm his age.
0
1
Rating: -1
Jed
If The vancouver show didnt entertain you or you like you feel you need to criticize it! Then you have issues! THE SHOW was amazing! Had a chance to see pink floyd in 1994 in edmonton but sold out to quick, I'm still in awe of this concert, The sound, the effects, just all around amazing show.
1
0
Rating: +1
Add new comment
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.