The $10-billion question: why isn't the F-35 scandal on the front page of "important" newspapers?
There are several disturbing issues raised by the auditor general's recent report on fighter jets.
They relate not only to the financial and political links to the scandal, but also to the way this issue has been treated by national newspaper chains.
Consider the magnitude of this story: Department of National Defence staff told a $10-billion fib to the Canadian public about the cost of buying and operating 65 F-35 planes over 20 years.
The $10-billion figure is equivalent to the annual revenue of B.C.'s largest company, Telus Corporation.
Today, Auditor General Michael Ferguson told the public-accounts committee that members of the Conservative cabinet knew that the planes would cost $25 billion—and not the $15 billion claimed by bureaucrats.
During the 2011 election campaign, Prime Minister Stephen Harper repeatedly claimed that the F-35 program would cost $16 billion. He has refused to answer opposition questions about when he learned that the real cost was billions of dollars higher than that.
So where did the Globe and Mail place the fighter-jet scandal in its B.C. edition yesterday? It was buried on page A4 with the relatively positive headline: "Feds scramble to save face over fighter jets".
Today, Canada's self-described "national newspaper" ran another inside story in the B.C. edition. Neither today's nor yesterday's Globe carried a single editorial or column on its opinion page regarding what Liberal Leader Bob Rae has characterized as "the worst example of economic incompetence and fiscal dishonesty that this country has seen in a generation".
Canada's national newspaper, indeed.
Meanwhile, Postmedia's Vancouver Sun put the auditor general's report on air safety on the front page yesterday. There was a hardhitting article and column on the fighter jets—buried on B3.
In a curious coincidence, the Globe and Mail and the Vancouver Sun endorsed Stephen Harper and the Conservatives in pre-election editorials last year.
"Those who disdain the Harper approach should consider his overall record, which is good," the Globe intoned less than a year ago. "The Prime Minister and the Conservative Party have demonstrated principled judgment on the economic file."
Meanwhile, the media outlet that is giving this story the greatest play, CBC, just had its budget cut by more than $100 million.
That's not the only troubling aspect of this story. Harper's chief of staff, Nigel Wright, is on leave as a managing director of Onex Corp., which is one of Canada's most powerful corporate conglomerates.
Onex Corp., which is headed by businessman Gerry Schwartz, owns Hawker Beechcraft Inc. It's a partner of Lockheed Martin, which is selling the F-35 fighter jets to the Canadian government.
Wright was a director of Hawker Beechcraft. According to a obsequious profile last year in the Walrus, he was a key Onex key executive dealing with the airplane industry.
“He’s in a completely untenable position,” Winnipeg NDP MP Pat Martin was quoted as saying in the article. “[It’s] a... profound conflict of interest on so many levels that in order to live up to any ethical standards, he would have to recuse himself from three-quarters of cabinet meetings. He would be out in the hallway more often than he would be in the cabinet room... [He] cannot even order a pizza for the prime minister without being conflicted.”
The Walrus then declared that Martin's comment was "nonsense" because an "ethical wall" was created to keep Wright's dealings, as the prime minister's chief of staff, separate from Onex. He pledged not participate in any discussions regarding the aerospace industry.
"A complex mechanism has been constructed to prevent information about these files from crossing his desk. And for the duration of his tenure in the PMO, his public equity holdings, including 93,957 shares in Onex and 44,024 shares of its Cineplex Galaxy Income Fund—worth roughly $3.5 million—have been placed in a blind trust," the Walrus added.
Schwartz's executives also have a connection to NDP Leader Thomas Mulcair, who hasn't raised the Onex connection to Harper's chief of staff.
As Vancouver antiwar activist Derrick O'Keefe has pointed out, Schwartz and several of his company's most senior managers were donors to Mulcair's recent campaign to become NDP leader.
The son of Toronto mining tycoon Peter Munk, Anthony Munk, was among them. Anthony is an Onex managing director.
In another coincidence, father Peter was quoted in the Walrus article, dishing out lavish praise for Wright.
In the past, Schwartz has also been a big financial supporter of the federal Liberals. It's a small world in Canadian federal politics.
So here's the story you're not reading in the national media:
• Corporations want to suck $25 billion from Canadian taxpayers over 20 years to buy some killing machines.
• One corporation's former director is chief of staff to the prime minister.
• One of the corporations financed the campaign of the leader of the Opposition.
• Two of the country's biggest newspapers don't want to give this story on play on the front page or in their editorials.
• The magnitude of the lie to Canadian taxpayers is the equivalent to the annual revenue of B.C.'s largest company.
Scandals involving a pittance of this, such as Defence Minister Peter MacKay's $1,452 hotel room, are treated with practically the same level of seriousness as a $10-billion whopper by the Conservative government.
Is it any wonder some of us think Canada is going down the tubes right before our eyes?
Follow Charlie Smith on Twitter at twitter.com/csmithstraight.




- The F35 was the top story on the G&M web edition this morning, and remains the lead story in the Politics section.
- The story is the second lead on the National Post web edition today.
Trust me, I am no friend of the corporate media that we're stuck with these days, but I think it's important to get the facts right so that criticism is clearly justified (as it usually is).
Does story placement in print editions really matter these days? Don't think so.
Since then Harpers Conservatives have gone onto prorouge Parliament twice, been ruled by House of Commons Speaker as in contempt pf Parliament (2011), and engaged in a nation-wide voter suppression scheme --all historic "firsts" for a sitting Canadian government.
Maybe if the Auditor General had the legal ability to criminally charge those responsible this would be given the diligence it deserves. But it's taken a decade long effort from big oil to put Harper in place and hell hath no fury like the nefarious oil industry!
That said, I realize that electronic and print media are distinct. It can be argued though that more individuals read electronic versions of newspaper rather than the actual newspapers.
I'm not surprised that Thomas Mulcair accepted donations from corporate executives. His behavior indicates that he wants to replace the Liberals as the party representing the center, or more vaguely but politically popular, 'the middle class.'
The next step is more important though. Anybody curious how the deficit for 2011-2012 is $25 billion dollars? It's up to the New Democrats to demonstrate that the Conservative government's spending priorities are not in the best interest of this country, from either short-term or long-term perspective.
This notwithstanding the fact that F-35s are maladapted and wholly inadequate for the purposes of "defending" our country. I mean how would we scramble an F-35 from Bagotville to defend our sovereignty over Hans Island? In addition to the fact that we would never be able to defend it in the first place against more formidable neighbours...wink wink nudge nudge.
May we all live in peace
Ghenghis and Don
Yeah, I believe that.
Miguel
By Soyoung Kim and Andrea Shalal-Esa
NEW YORK/WASHINGTON | Wed Mar 28, 2012 7:56pm EDT
(Reuters) - Hawker Beechcraft Inc, the aircraft manufacturer owned by Goldman Sachs Group Inc's (GS.N) private equity arm and Onex Corp (OCX.TO), is preparing to file for bankruptcy protection in the next several weeks, according to several people familiar with the matter."
L. Clemens
The extra $10B isn't going to come out of their pockets, they have all sorts of tax breaks. It comes out of the average taxpayer's pockets & who cares about them.
With the extra $10B they could have solved a lot of housing problems on reserves & provided clean water for a lot of communities in Canada. But hey MacKay won't be able to have any fun with that. He likes all the toys for boys.
The F-?/ are a waste of tax payer's money. It is a given Canada may require new jets but I am sure there were less expensive ones to be had. Didn't anybody think of sending out tenders so companies could bid. I mean it is what smart businesses do. Oh, right the neo cons aren't all that bright.
The F-??? is just another example of the neo con & harperits going off the rails. Harper is off selling Canadian resources to foreign companies while Canada continues to deal with all sorts of social problems.
It is always so interesting when these "fiscal responsible" parties shovel money out like sand onto an ice road. However, people got what they voted for. They gave harper his majority or let him steal it.
People seem to have forgotten Mulroney & his years in office. Ran up some of the biggest deficiets in history. Then we have the federal Liberals where the deficiet was going down & now a Conservative government again & money is just going out the door to their friends like there was no tomorrow. Unfortunately we have 4 more yrs of tomorrows & I can only shutter to think of how much money they will shovel out to their "friends" & how much of Canada they will sell to foreign companies.
I read this news site and some others. The newspapers you mention are nothing to me.
Miguel
Your word is everything and when you don't keep it you can't be trusted and blaming it on someone else isn't going to cut the prime minister any slack with the people of this country if I trust my instincts. Because one thing for certain I can't trust anything the prime minister has to say. There is no accountability robo calls and all and all the fall guys will not stop the fall, humpty dumpty.