Matt Toner: B.C. Liberals’ indifference to film industry will prove hard sell come election time

Comments

By Matt Toner

If—unlike thousands of people across our province—you don’t work in the film, television, or video-game industries, you might have missed the gathering storm that broke over the weekend. But it’s worth your attention, because it speaks volumes as to exactly how our province has been governed since 2009.

At issue is an Arts and Culture Branch report that fed into the creation of the B.C. Jobs Plan: it’s thanks to sleuthing by the NDP’s Spencer Chandra Herbert that this document was dragged into the light.

There’s lots to be read there, but for my money (and yours), the killer quote is:

Government has taken a close look at the screen-based entertainment industry as a possible focus for the Jobs Plan, and has not found a compelling case for any additional emphasis on this sector.

That is to say, we’re not going to even try to create any new jobs in this industry. Which is staggering when you consider the undisputed positive impact of this sector, the active engagement of governments in Ontario and Quebec, and the mounting flood of creative talent heading away from Vancouver to all points of the compass.

With this issue, however, there is the extra layer of Orwellian tactics that have been ladled over the mix.

Upon hearing about the recommendations of the Arts and Culture Branch, many people took to Facebook to voice their concerns. But over the weekend, hundreds and hundreds of these critical comments were apparently purged from Christy Clark’s official page, voices of dissent silenced with the click of the mouse.

Or were they?

Well, no, because you really can’t pull that crap in this day and age. The lost comments were captured and posted (and reposted) throughout the weekend. And that’s when people started to get angry and that’s when the Save B.C. Film movement was born.

Save B.C. Film only started a few days ago, but it’s growing fast: since Saturday, its Facebook page has registered more than 3,200 “likes”. Or check out the @savebcfilm Twitter feed, which had hundreds of followers within 24 hours. And if you agree with what they’re saying, sign the online petition, which had 13,000 signatures in two days.

The government’s response? So far, barely a yawn.

Thankfully, it’s an election year and the B.C. Liberals are going to find that ongoing indifference is going to be a tough policy to sell to an angered industry. They’ve squandered our trust and I can’t imagine them making the effort to rebuild it.

Adrian Dix, on the other hand, clearly understands the importance of creativity and innovation as a path to our province’s future. And the way we get there is by taking a series of measured steps that engage the industry and the people working in it.

The NDP is ready to make a change, not only to save jobs in the creative sector, but to also create an atmosphere that fosters growth. If they weren’t, I wouldn’t be running on their ticket.

Comments (28) Add New Comment
average joe
FYI some people who want to work in the industry do so as an unpaid Intern, for months at a time, PA's take the work at the agreed rate because they want more,its a foot in the door. If they choose it as a career that is there decision. The job they agreed on with the long hours are not a surprise. get your head out of your ...
5
6
Rating: -1
Save Vancouver
@temaster - any industry could make the same argument that you do, that their workers return taxes to the economy. So do we give tax breaks to everyone and go broke so some studio heads in LA can take home fat paycheques?
10
3
Rating: +7
ant-HST
@averagejoe: So what you're saying is, that it's okay to pay these people less than minimum wage, make them work 15 hour shifts, without a proper break for lunch, and make them pay union dues because - "they've agreed to it and it's a foot in the door?"

Sounds like they don't have much of a choice. That sounds like dangling a person's dreams in front of their eyes so that you can exploit and discard them to me.

So, averagejoe: This is your argument as to why the people of BC should be giving you tax breaks?

I guess it's a good argument. Hang on a sec, there's a bunch of people here who need help getting their heads pulled out of their ***es.
9
2
Rating: +7
Lewis
Hmm, what a dilema , A mutibillion dollar industry in our Province, or NOT in our Province, do you need a calculator? What is any percent of Zero! I keep hearing the word "subsidy", are they talking about the money they blew on promoting BC as a great film location, when anyone concerned already knows this. The BC government keeps trying to make it sound like they are paying productions to come here, there NOT! It's a TAX CREDIT!
6
3
Rating: +3
provincial tax credits are "refundable", i.e. subsidies
From Investopedia: Definition of 'Refundable Credit'
A tax credit that is not limited by the amount of an individual's tax liability. Typically a tax credit only reduces an individual's tax liability to zero. Refundable credits go beyond this and so really can be considered the same as a payment.
5
0
Rating: +5
Sam
Once again the BCNDP jumps on the bandwagon in an attempt to make their selves look good (spin), but I find it a contradiction when Matt says, “The (BC)NDP is ready to make a change, not only to save jobs in the creative sector, but to also create an atmosphere that fosters growth”. I say this because, in 2011 the film industry lobbied to keep the HST which they said, “would help to level the playing field in Canada's nationwide motion picture industry”. While at the same time, the BCNDP supported the fight against HST and joined in with the emotional arguments given by Bill Vander Zalm and Bill Tieleman. If BCNDP truly supported the film industry and business in general, then they would have not made the HST political issue or spread misconceptions about the tax. I believe they did wrong by the film industry, businesses and the people of BC. Matt might want to stop running.
6
2
Rating: +4
Ray I
You know what else may have been hard to sell in the next election? Borrowing millions of dollars (or taking it from health and education) to prop up an industry that demands taxpayers subsidize their highly profitable industry or they will go somewhere else. Giving in will just lead to more and more industries seeing that taxpayer money can be theirs just as long as they whine about leaving the Province.
5
0
Rating: +5
Heather
People may ask why should we still subsidize the film industry in BC, well all the jobs it creates and all the spin off jobs, added revenue, hollywood stars in town to spend money at restaurants, staying in swank hotels, going on mini holidays on days off(I saw Matt Damon and his family in Gibsons a couple of years ago!).... It also lets people work in the film industry which they may have dreamed of, but could not feasibly go to LA. Ditto for actors and actresses who didn't think they could make it in Hollywood, but perfectly happy to have minor roles in film and tv. Battlestar Galactica hired several canadians for major roles which was great and provided them with more work later on.
Saskatchewan had film tax breaks, there was a small but busy film industry and provided work for many many people with the same economic benefits mentioned above. The Sask Party got in power and scrapped it. Everything shut down overnight, the sound stage that had been specially built is now empty.
Think of all the people in film programs studying production, costume, make up, set design, film crew, cinematography, direction, acting, writing...because they know BC has had an active film industry for years, nobody expected that would change. The Liberal Government trying to 'focus' on the arts and education, but sacrifice the one area where creative people and artists can get viable work is ridiculous!
Countless industries are heavily subsidized that do not have nearly the benefits of the film industry. So I hope it can be saved, I still have film fantasies myself to fulfill..
3
0
Rating: +3

Pages

Add new comment
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.