9 similarities between Stephen Harper and Vladimir Putin

    1 of 1 2 of 1

      Every once in a while, you'll hear Conservative Leader Stephen Harper compared to former U.S. president Richard Nixon.

      In 2013, Toronto Star columnist Tom Walkom likened the $90,172 payment to Sen. Mike Duffy to the grubby Watergate scandal that finished off Nixon's presidency.

      More recently, Globe and Mail columnist Jeffrey Simpson dragged up comparisons between Nixon and Harper after reading John Ibbitson's biography of the Canadian prime minister.

      Two B.C.-based MPs, New Democrat Nathan Cullen and Liberal Joyce Murray, have also invoked the Nixon analogy.

      But if you really want to get under Harper's skin, forget about Nixon. Compare him to Russian president Vladimir Putin.

      Earlier this year, Harper's spokesperson accused Tom Mulcair of "fear mongering" after the NDP leader accused Harper of pandering to Islamophobia in the same way that Putin panders to antigay Russians.

      Mulcair's comment was in connection with Harper's comment that the niqab "was rooted in an anti-woman culture".

      This led me to think about other similarities between Harper and Putin, who clearly loathe one another. Here's my list.

      1. Both leaders have chipped away at the democratic underpinnings of their country. Harper used the Fair Elections Act to prevent the chief electoral officer from encouraging people to vote and from investigating wrongdoing. Putin did an end run around his country's constitution by taking one term off as president to serve as prime minister, then returning to the top post for another eight years. Conservative operatives have been caught breaking the rules in each of the last four elections. Similarly, Putin has also been accused of electoral manipulation.

      2. Harper and Putin are pariahs in the international fight against climate change. Putin reportedly said in 2003 that global warming might mean that Russians don't need to spend as much money on fur coats. Twelve years later, Putin is seen in some quarters as a threat to the upcoming UN climate summit in Paris. So is Harper. And both Putin and Harper have rejected extending the Kyoto Protocol to curb greenhouse gas emissions, with Canada being the first signatory to withdraw from the international treaty.

      3. Harper and Putin both pander to religious leaders to maintain their lock on power. In Canada, it's often Christian evangelicals through tough-on-crime laws, including the criminalization of the sale of sex. In Russia, Putin assiduously courts the Russian Orthodox Church, most notably when his government prosecuted members of the punk band Pussy Riot for ridiculing the country's dominant religion. 

      4. Putin and Harper each demonstrate deep contempt for the media, though admittedly, being a reporter is a far more dangerous job in Russia. According to the Committee to Protect Journalists, 56 have been killed in that country since 1992. Harper hasn't killed any Canadian journalists, but he rarely answers their questions except during election campaigns.

      5. Harper and Putin both play to their political bases by making a big deal about their love of hockey. Harper wrote a book about the sport. Putin, in his early 60s, still dons hockey gear and gets on the ice.

      6. Harper and Putin both use their knowledge of history to political advantage. Harper has remade Canada's image from a peacekeeping nation into a country of warriors by constantly invoking past battles, such as Vimy Ridge. He's even reached as far back as the War of 1812 to reinforce his political messages. Putin likes comparing himself to Pyotr Stolypin, a former prime minister who was murdered in 1911. Stolypin was widely seen as a reasonable leader who helped rebuild the Russian state. Putin also likes coming to the rescue of Russians in high-profile situations, similar to the way some czars acted on occasion.

      7. Harper and Putin have each formed deep friendships with one national leader who's scorned in many parts of the world. Harper's bond is with Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu; Putin has formed a long-lasting attachment with former Italian prime minister Silvio Berlusconi.

      8. Harper and Putin are masters of controlling their own images. The Canadian prime minister has crafted his own taxpayer-funded videos, 24 Seven, showing his friendly side. Putin likes being photographed shirtless on a horse. There's a famous photo of Harper petting a panda to drive home a message that he's some sort of softie. Putin, on the other hand, has been seen petting a tiger to remind people of his macho side.

      9. Each of them has a potty mouth. The National Post recently reported that Harper sometimes swears like a longshoreman in private. Putin has also been known to use crude language, talking about taking Chechen terrorists to the outhouse and hanging former Georgian president Mikhail Saakashvili "by the balls".

      Comments

      21 Comments

      Not Much Difference

      Aug 16, 2015 at 11:12am

      Can just barely tell them apart as per their Politics & Policies.

      The right wing Alberta Tea Party Mail Room guy taking orders from Corporate HQ just does not have the balls that Putin does.

      Example.

      Putin would never sign away sovereignty over Russia's resources a la former Mail Room Clerk.

      In Canada or more to be precise our Canadian Guy signed the Communist China Free Trade Deal (FIPA) Treaty in Vladivostok Russia like a good Communist would do.

      It allows Communist China carte Blanche access to any Canadian resource like NAFTA (under which Canada is the most sued Country $5 Billion and counting in fines paid by all of us).

      No Canadian Court or Govt. can overrule or prevent this access without huge financial fines.

      Putin would never do that to his Dictatorship of Russia, thus Balls vs No Balls of the Albertan.

      The Albertan former Mail Room Clerk likes to ACT tough, Putin is actually a tough Dictator.

      In a contest of competent Dictators Putin wins vs the structural deficit former Mail Room Clerk.

      After all everyone knows Mail Room Clerks take orders from Corporate HQ.

      Whereas Dictators like Putin never take orders he actually gives (Genocidal) orders.

      Dear Leader

      Aug 16, 2015 at 11:26am

      There are also big differences between Harper and Putin too. For example Putin has been able to improve the overall standard of living for Russian people. Harper, who claims his economic policies are greatly improving the standard of living for Canadians have done just the opposite. Harper's policies have instead, drastically lowered the standard of living for many Canadians, particularly in the middle class.

      In Russia, Putin has a popularity rating that is close to 90% while Harper's unpopularity rating in Canada is close to that.

      traveler

      Aug 16, 2015 at 12:58pm

      What a load of BS on Putin, Charlie

      Bill dmith

      Aug 16, 2015 at 2:29pm

      Wonder if Putin has a boyfriend?

      Rod Croskery

      Aug 16, 2015 at 2:46pm

      There's one clear distinction between Harper and Putin: Harper won't murder to further his goals and Putin clearly will.

      When the Duffy imbroglio erupted I posted a blog entry in which I stated that the least desirable job in Ottawa for the next while will be that of Mike Duffy's food taster. To Harper's credit, Mr. Duffy remains snorting at the trough.

      So regardless of how we would like to tar Stephen Harper as a totalitarian despot, he hasn't had Duffy assassinated.

      Ed Bagley Jr.

      Aug 16, 2015 at 4:33pm

      The both wake up in the morning.

      Hmm

      Aug 16, 2015 at 6:56pm

      Can't vote for someone who says Khadar has more class than... the man murdered someone's father, husband, and finally someone's child - he murdered ..
      Enter the Liberals - can still remember the sponsorship scandal and the endless scandals which cost millions upon millions not 90k and what has really changed with these guys anyways.
      Finally it's Mulcair - wants to open constitutional crapola to cater to separatists, will build pipelines to satisfy his union buds, just don't see anything here for me.
      So who should anyone vote for ... is Harper really the worst choice - not sure about that at all.

      SaskEst

      Aug 16, 2015 at 8:53pm

      wow what a stretch to make these comparisons. I suppose you could compare him to Maggie Thatcher too but that would be too much work

      Jason Andres

      Aug 16, 2015 at 9:55pm

      The one major difference is Putins country men adore him, can't say the same for Harper.