Journalist Laura Robinson sues John Furlong

Comments7

Freelance writer Laura Robinson has filed a defamation suit against former Vanoc CEO John Furlong, alleging that he libelled her in six public statements.

Central to her claim is that Furlong wasn’t truthful when he repeatedly alleged she had filed a complaint with the RCMP that he had sexually assaulted a former student—a claim that Robinson has adamantly denied.

In a 25-page notice of civil claim filed in B.C. Supreme Court on January 27, Robinson also named TwentyTen Group Strategic Marketing Communications Inc. and TwentyTen Group Holdings Inc. as defendants. Robinson alleged that these firms, doing business as the TwentyTen Group, have been “the exclusive media communications representative for Furlong”.

Robinson alleged that Furlong’s public response to an article she wrote about him in the Georgia Straight in September 2012 has “caused and continues to cause injury, loss and damage to the plaintiff, and was deliberately calculated by the defendants to expose the plaintiff to contempt, ridicule and hatred, and to cause other persons to shun or avoid the plaintiff, and to lower the plaintiff’s reputation in the eyes of right-thinking members of the community, all of which has in fact occurred”.

She is seeking an interim and permanent injunction to stop the defendants from continuing to libel her, as well as general damages, special damages, aggravated damages, punitive damages, and special costs.

None of Robinson’s allegations have been proven in court.

In November 2012, Furlong sued Robinson, the Georgia Straight, publisher and editor Dan McLeod, and editor Charlie Smith, alleging that Robinson’s article, “John Furlong biography omits secret past in Burns Lake”, defamed him.

The story cited affidavits sworn by eight former students who alleged that they had either witnessed or experienced physical abuse or racial taunting by Furlong when he taught physical education at Immaculata elementary school in Burns Lake in 1969 and 1970.

Robinson’s story in the Georgia Straight did not include any allegations of a sexual nature.

Three adults claiming to be former students of Furlong have filed lawsuits against him alleging sexual abuse, which Furlong has vehemently denied.

Last December, RCMP corporal Quinton Mackie wrote to Furlong’s lawyer, Marvin Storrow, declaring that one plaintiff’s claims “are not supported” and that there were no reasonable and probable grounds for recommending charges against Furlong in that case.

Last October, Furlong filed a notice of discontinuance against the Straight and its employees but vowed in media interviews to “escalate” his action against Robinson. Two of those interviews are cited in Robinson’s lawsuit.

In an October 28, 2013, chat with Global TV’s Chris Gailus, Furlong described Robinson as an “activist” and alleged that she had filed a complaint against him with the RCMP.

Furlong made similar comments in a Maclean’s magazine article on October 29.

According to Robinson’s notice of civil claim, these words meant either that Robinson had filed “a complaint with the RCMP alleging that the defendant Furlong sexually assaulted one of his former students” or that Robinson had filed “a false police report concerning the defendant Furlong”.

“Each of the above meanings is false, malicious and defamatory of and concerning the plaintiff,” Robinson’s notice of civil claim declared.

Furlong also issued a lengthy statement on his website on October 29 alleging, among other things, that Robinson’s “unproven written and verbal allegations” in her statement of defence exposed him and his family “to continuing humiliation, ridicule, and destroyed our privacy”.

Robinson’s notice of civil claim alleged that Furlong’s comments in his October 29 statement “meant and were understood to mean” that Robinson is a “liar”, “heartless”, and “cruel and spiteful”, and “continually fabricates stories in her professional occupation as journalist”.

Robinson, who has an honorary doctorate of laws from York University, maintained that each of these meanings is “false, malicious and defamatory”.

On November 13, Robinson’s lawyer, Bryan Baynham, demanded that Furlong retract his comments, remove defamatory statements from his website, and issue an apology.

“Through public statements to the media the defendant Furlong has indicated he will not retract or apologize for the allegations set out above, despite actual knowledge that the plaintiff did not initiate a complaint with the RCMP as alleged,” Robinson’s notice of civil claim stated.

Ironically, Baynham acted for two of the defendants in the most famous libel lawsuit ever filed by a B.C. journalist.

Former Vancouver Sun business reporter David Baines and Southam Inc. sued stock tout George Chelekis, Market News Publishing Inc., Robert Shore, and others.

This came after Chelekis had attacked Baines in several newsletter articles, a news release, and a public statement at a seminar.

In a 1998 ruling, B.C. Supreme Court judge J.F. Rowan awarded Baines $875,000, including $200,000 in aggravated and punitive damages against Chelekis.

Comments (7) Add New Comment
Laura Robinson
Thank you to the Georgia Straight for their continued support of freedom of expression, and investigative journalism in Canada. Please note the fund-raiser, "Speaking Freedom: Canadian Writers Read in Support of the Robinson Defense Fund" will occur on the evening of May 1 at St. James Hall in Kits. Great show, food, drink and silent auction. See you there! To read the Notice of Claim, please go to: www.laurarobinsondefensefund.org

32
20
Rating: +12
cuz
How funny! Laura Robinson says John Furlong's comments "caused and continue to cause injury, loss, and damage to the plaintiff, and was deliberately calculated by the defendants to expose the plaintiff to contempt, ridicule and hatred, and to cause other persons to shun or avoid the plaintiff, and to lower the plaintiff's reputation in the eyes of the right-thinking members of the community, all of which has in fact occurred". That's exactly the damage her not-yet-proven comments have caused to John Furlong's reputation. It's obvious the straight went out of their way to separate themselves from Laura in Mr. Furlong's lawsuit because the straight isn't so sure Laura really can prove anything she has charged. Especially since the claims have been lying around a couple of years now, but no charges have actually been filed against Mr. Furlong by the authorities. I don't blame the straight from wanting to get far away from this "journalist".
17
41
Rating: -24
Charlie Smith
Dear cuz,

I don't know what you're basing your comment on. We never went out of our way to separate ourselves from Laura Robinson. John Furlong chose to file a notice of discontinuance against us, which came as a complete surprise.

We first learned of this while watching his televised interview with Chris Gailus.

He chose not to file a notice of discontinuance against Laura Robinson.

Charlie Smith
30
8
Rating: +22
Alan Layton
I was going to make a negative comment about Laura Robinson, but she scares me.
15
28
Rating: -13
RUK
@cuz

I'm not a huge fan of the muckracking expose style of writing, but in this case it is pretty difficult to accuse Robinson of "deliberately exposing" Furlong to ridicule.

Exposure? This man wrote an autobiography. He didn't call it a novel. Seems to me that having your autobiography fact-checked by a journalist is pretty standard stuff. If the journalist learns that Furlong omitted some key passages of his life from his autobiography, that's his lookout. It ain't her job to suppress contrary evidence.
37
8
Rating: +29
Laura Robinson
To Cuz:

You have stated "the claims have been lying around for a couple of years now but no charges against Mr. Furlong have been filed against the authorities" as your rationale for believing the allegations made by First Nations people in the Sept. 26, 2012 story http://www.straight.com/news/john-furlong-biography-omits-secret-past-bu... are not valid. Please read the story again. There are no allegations whatsoever of sexual abuse. These allegations were made by other media--not the Straight and not me. Interestingly, none of them were sued.
14
8
Rating: +6
Bob
Laura will go to hell for this.
7
16
Rating: -9
Add new comment
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.