David Suzuki: Citizen scientists can help monarch butterflies

    1 of 1 2 of 1

      From the age of five, Fred Urquhart was fascinated by monarch butterflies in his Toronto neighbourhood. Born in 1911, he spent hours watching the orange and black insects flutter about, wondering: Where did they go in winter? At school, he read voraciously about nature, especially monarchs and other insects.

      He eventually became a zoology professor and married Norah Patterson, who shared his love of butterflies, as did their son, Doug. To answer the question that had nagged Fred since childhood, in 1940 they found a way to attach tiny labels to individual butterflies that read, “Send to Zoology University of Toronto Canada.” They started the Insect Migration Association, now known as Monarch Watch, enlisting “citizen scientists” to tag butterflies.

      They finally solved the mystery in 1975with the help of two citizen scientists in Mexico. Ken Brugger and Catalina Aguado had come across millions of butterflies in the mountains west of Mexico City. The couple took the Urquharts there in 1976 and, miraculously, Fred found one of his tagged insects within hours. Their fascinating story is told in the documentary film Flight of the Butterflies and in an episode of CBC’s The Nature of Things, “The Great Butterfly Hunt”.

      Now, monarchs are in trouble, their numbers drastically reduced from the days when the Urquharts pursued their passion. And once again, experts and others are calling on citizen scientists—and politician—to help.

      Monarch populations in Mexico plummeted to a record low of about 33.5 million this year from an annual average over the past 15 years of about 350 million and highs of more than one billion. Causes include illegal logging in Mexico, herbicide use on genetically modified crops in the U.S. and climate change.

      In February, in response to a letter by Mexican poet Homero Aridjis, signed by more than 100 scientists, writers and environmentalists—including Canadians Margaret Atwood, Michael Ondaatje and John Ralston Saul—U.S. President Barack Obama, Mexican President Enrique Peña Nieto and Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper agreed to “establish a working group to ensure the conservation of the monarch butterfly, a species that symbolizes our association.”

      The letter to leaders said, “As Mexico is addressing the logging issues, so now must the United States and Canada address the effects of our current agricultural policies.” Those problematic practices are mainly associated with large-scale planting of corn and soy genetically modified to resist the herbicide Roundup, or glyphosate. It doesn’t kill crops—just pretty much everything else, including the milkweed monarchs need to lay their eggs and that is their caterpillars’ main food.

      We can only hope our leaders live up to their commitment, and we can speak up to hold them to it. But we can also become citizen scientists to help researchers better understand the butterfly’s breeding, migrating and overwintering cycles and help monarchs survive. Monarch Watch (monarchwatch.org) offers classroom resources, student-scientist research projects and information about building monarch way stations, raising your own monarchs and planting milkweed and butterfly gardens. The U.S. Monarch Joint Venture website (monarchjointventure.org/) offers resources for citizens to track migration, count butterflies and monitor larval populations and disease for monarchs—as well as other butterflies

      The David Suzuki Foundation website also offers a range of resources and activities to help protect these pollinating insects. And, as part of its Homegrown National Park Project, the foundation is launching a Toronto-based campaign in April to crowd-source a milkweed corridor through the city.

      Helping monarch and other butterflies and insects is a fun way to get kids interested in nature’s wonders. Planting milkweed and nectar-producing native flowers on balconies and in gardens, parks and green spaces will beautify the area around your home and bring bees and butterflies to the neighbourhood.

      Scientists still don’t know everything about monarchs and their migration, but we know they play an important role in ecosystems. And we know everything in nature is interconnected. When something that travels such long distances through a range of habitats is removed, it can have cascading effects on those environments.

      The world wouldn’t know where North American monarchs travel if it weren’t for the Urquharts and the continent-wide battalion of citizen scientists they inspired. We can all help ensure monarch butterflies continue this wonderful journey every year.

      Comments

      7 Comments

      Kiskatinawkid

      Mar 25, 2014 at 6:44pm

      With the three amigos jumping onboard, the Monarchs are truly screwed! We'll be lucky if 35 survive.

      Barometer

      Mar 25, 2014 at 6:50pm

      The Monarchs are a barometer on the way humans treat the environment. The way to save the monarchs is for North America to retreat from hyper-industrialization and over-population (of humans, especially in the US and Mexico - over-population that is).

      But then again, species extinction is a natural event as evidenced by 4 billion years of earth's history. Why should our epoch be any different?

      Physics Police

      Mar 26, 2014 at 1:42pm

      Save the milkweed, save the monarch butterflies. I believe this.

      But I don't believe this:

      "Those problematic practices are mainly associated with large-scale planting of corn and soy genetically modified to resist the herbicide Roundup, or glyphosate. It doesn’t kill crops—just pretty much everything else, including the milkweed..."

      Milkweed has the word "weed" in it for a reason. The problem isn't Roundup herbicide in particular, it's all herbicides in general. We don't need to stop using glyphosate in order to conserve a milkweed corridor. We just need environmental policy that recognizes and protects that milkweed corridor.

      Talking about GMO confuses the issue which *harms* the environmental effort.

      melanie

      Mar 26, 2014 at 8:13pm

      GMOs are part of the larger issue. Not confusing it, how short sighted are you?

      Paul Cherubini

      Mar 27, 2014 at 7:50pm

      The Monarchs are not in any trouble. Natural factors caused the population to dip in 2012 & 2013 and natural factors will cause the population to rebound in 2014 and 2015. I will be shooting and posting YouTube videos of SWARMS of monarchs in the upper Midwest -right next to the GMO crops -just 5 months from now. I invite any interested individuals or reporters who want to see these swarm videos to contact me at monarch@saber.net around August 30.

      Myron

      Mar 31, 2014 at 8:20am

      I want to start by saying that my sister has a butterfly garden and I am planning one as well. But there are several comments I would like to make.
      What were Monarch population numbers in 1910, 1940, 1970, during the peaks of past cooling and warming cycles? Does Monarch numbers increase and decrease during these cycles?
      What were Monarch population numbers 200 years ago before man was clearing land to grow crops? Could man clearing land made it easier for milkweed to grow compared to having to compete with other plants on uncleared land? Did this artificially raise the Monarch population?
      Weeds still grow at the edge of crop fields so agricultural use of herbicides do not appear to affect plants beyond treated crop fields.
      The construction of roads, buildings, homes, etc and man's desire for carefully manicured green lawns likely has had as big an affect on milkweed as herbicide use on crops.
      Blaming GMO's and agricultural herbicide use while ignoring our own lawns, the golf course we play on, the sidewalks and bike paths we use is taking the chicken way out. I doubt any of us will write a comment on how we want the food we eat to be scarcer and more expensive.

      S|tephen

      Apr 1, 2014 at 2:43am

      I've been to the Sierra Madres to see the wintering HIBERNATING monarchs. The Mexican govt.certainly has NOT resolved the problems at their end. The fir forest once covering a vast area has been clear cut right up to the smaller park's boundary. The monarchs cling to the branches of these trees for the duration of the winter occasionally fluttering from one tree to another. Braches can become so heavy they've snapped under the weight of millions of these amazing insects. What previously acted as a forest temperature moderating buffer zone has all become pastureland and the remaining fir trees on top of these mtns are exposed to much colder winter temperatures than bfr. Add global warming and temp. extremes and we are witnessing another species extinction. No butterfly garden will rectify this problem. All 3 amigo's can share the blame.