Eva Manly: Why is Jim Manly sailing to challenge the Gaza blockade?

Comments

By Eva Manly

Where did the journey begin that led to my husband, former NDP MP Jim Manly, accepting the invitation to be the Canadian on board the Estelle, the Freedom Flotilla boat sailing for Gaza to break the blockade?

Our decision was a joint one, a result of 53 years of working together as a team and supporting each other in both individual and joint pursuits. When Jim and I first met, I was attracted to his sense of humour, his ability to think “outside the box”, and the fact he did not fit my stereotype of clergy! After all these years, we still make each other laugh and are still able to surprise each other.

Another thing drew me to Jim: he has the courage to follow his convictions and the guts to act on them—even when these actions are unpopular. He is also one of the least confrontational people I know.

Over the years, Jim and I have worked together on many justice and human-rights issues. We are grateful to the Haisla people of Kitamaat, with whom we spent the first four years of our married life and whose friendships and influence we continue to cherish, for opening our eyes to the issues facing First Nations people and other indigenous peoples. This led indirectly to our involvement with many other human-rights struggles: those of the Mexican American farm workers, the refugees from the coup in Chile, the people of Nicaragua and El Salvador, the Maya of Guatemala, and refugees from Colombia and Nigeria among other places. It also led to our involvement in church sanctuary for refugees, refugee sponsorship, and accompaniment of people facing death threats. Through all this we avoided the issue of Palestine/Israel, accepting the line that “it is too complex”, too divisive, and likely to alienate friends.

So, people ask, when and how did that change? Well, our knowledge of the issue grew gradually till we were finally impelled to action when we read Drinking the Sea at Gaza by Amira Haas, the Israeli journalist who lived in Gaza and reported for the Israeli newspaper Ha’aretz. We heard Jeff Halper, founder of the Israeli Committee Against House Demolitions, and for the first time we began to understand the true nature of the “Separation Wall”, known among Palestinians as the “Annexation Wall”. We learned all we could on the issue (much of it written by Jewish Israelis) and became active locally in helping form Mid-Islanders for Justice and Peace in the Middle East, a group that includes several members of the Jewish community, and more recently in the United Network for a Just Peace in Palestine and Israel. We participated in a Pilgrimage of Solidarity, visiting some of the growing number of both Israelis and Palestinians who work together for a just and peaceful future for all. They inspire us to work with them.

In all the years I have known Jim, he has avoided the limelight (strange for someone who went into politics). It was only his strong sense of the importance of engaging with this issue that led him to agree to put his name forward. He is on the Estelle to bring attention to the suffering of the Palestinians of Gaza.

He is there out of a commitment to human rights and social justice. He is there in the hope that his action will bring awareness to his fellow Canadians about what is being done to the Palestinians in the name of Israeli security.

He is there in the hope that his actions may bring Canadian members of Parliament from all parties, but especially the NDP, the “party of conscience”, and particularly the younger generation of NDP MPs who were elected with the hope for change, to break the walls of silence and speak out.

Jim is on board the Estelle, and if there was room for another Canadian I would be there with him. There is no other place I would rather be now. May he come home safe.

Eva Manly of Nanaimo is married to retired NDP MP and United Church minister Jim Manly, who is sailing to challenge the Gaza blockade. For updates, see the Gaza’s Ark website.

Comments (23) Add New Comment
DavidJH
Follow Jim and the others onboard Estelle here: http://shiptogaza.se/en/
and the Gaza Ark campaign here GazaArk.org
1
1
Rating: 0
Melissa Fuller
Best wishes, regards, and hope to Jim and the Estelle. I am filled with admiration for those who have the strength of conviction to take this hard road in support of the people of Gaza.

Regards,

Melissa Fuller
Yahk, BC
1
1
Rating: 0
iSheep
Good on you! Shine some sunlight there.
1
1
Rating: 0
Free Gaza
End the apartheid!! Palestine forever!! Peace and unity all over
0
0
Rating: 0
Hamid
Instead of looking for cheep PR, they should so something meaningfull and go to Syria.........
1
0
Rating: +1
George Muenz
Nonsense, this is all about bashing Israel and has nothing to do with aid. More supplies go through from Israel every day than what was on the Estelle. If the Manlys were truly about helping people in distress, they would not have to go far. Syria is murdering its own people by the thousands. Why does Jim not go there? No Jews involved.
3
1
Rating: +2
anonymouse1962
Maybe you could set sail to Syria next and free people who are really being terrorized on a daily basis :-) Or why not have a fly-in to Pakistan or Saudi Arabia? The women NEED you to free them from Islamic apartheid. Or how about flying into North Korea? Their people are really starving and not overweight like the people of Gaza?

Not an option? Why not? Too dangerous to challenge the governments of countries that are not democracies? Governments that you would actually fear?
0
1
Rating: -1
Martin Dunphy
Attn: JC

Please limit your comments to one.
Thank you.
1
1
Rating: 0
RK
I'd have a lot more sympathy for those attempting to help the Palestinians, which I would normally consider a just cause, if they weren't focused on running a blockade into Gaza. The people of Gaza elected a Hamas government. Hamas is a terrorist group that is devoted to the destruction of Israel. I therefore have to think that the people of Gaza support the destruction of Israel. Those engaged in running the blockade, including Jim Manly, simply come across as naïve Westerners being used by a terrorist group.

If there is ever going to be any realistic chance for peace in the Mideast, Hamas and its supporters need to engage in some realpolitik and recognize Israel and negotiate in good faith. Their current approach is just plain stupid.
0
1
Rating: -1
Diss appointed
I am ashamed a man who should follow the Bible chose to follow his lost heart instead. One tiny strip of land populated by Gods Chosen people, the Jews, and the whole world is against them. Not me, I stand with them and their right to protect themselves and I am not alone.
1
1
Rating: 0
John Gilberts
GIven that the leader of the Official NDP Opposition , Thomas Mulcair, is on record as 'an ardent supporter of Israel in all situations and circumstances', he may be closer to the position of Bibi Netanyahu than ex NDP MP Jim Manly. Surely Mulcair must speak out now else we will know that George Galloway was right when he said that Canada had become 'little more than an embassy for Benjamin Netanyahu'. It is a sad state of affairs when an opposition leader no less than a government is tied to a foreign power with such an obvious umbilical cord of piano wire, that he won't even speak out for one of the ndp's own. And if not than NDP = No Difference Party.
1
1
Rating: 0
Dr. Jacques Abourbih
Dear Eva and Jim

I was hoping you would take up the cause of Jews evicted from Arab and Muslim countries as passionately as you have taken up the cause of a terrorist organization as Hamas. We are over 1 million Jews who suffered humiliation, despoiling, hatred, rape, slaughter, decapitations at the hands of Muslims and Arabs. Yet the world has ignored our plight to recognize this unspoken injustice. Than you for considering the plight of my family.
1
1
Rating: 0
Lyn Adamson
Thank you Jim Manly for having the courage to follow your convictions and speak truth to power. It may take a lot more speaking truth to power before the oppression ends, but end it must. Thanks Eva for sharing the story of how you both came to be involved in this work. For those who say: should go to Syria: there are many areas of the world that need attention and change. Israel-Palestine is a root conflict that, unresolved, feeds extremism. I have been in the West Bank and know that there are so many people committed to change through nonviolence and collaborating to build a better future, Palestinians, Israels, and internationals. It's a very exciting movement to be part of.
1
1
Rating: 0
K. Pulfer
I am utterly a appalled that a minister of God, who obviously doesn't have all the facts, would choose to go against Israel, who are God's people, and have suffered greatly. Now, even though they must feed and support the Palestinians daily, they are ridiculed by the world and condemned because they must defend themselves against a terrorist regime. I think this man should stick to religion, and leave the politics alone. It is because of the interference of the west that the middle east is in such termoil. We need to mind our own business and let them handle it themselves! I will bless them that bless thee and curse them that curse thee, remember your bible JIM!!
1
1
Rating: 0
James Peter Abagay
Why is Jim not on a ship to Latakia to let the world know what is going on in Syria? Does the United Church of Canada not care about the thousands of Sunni Syrians who are being murdered by the Alawites Shi'ites? Gaza is paradise compared to Alleppo.
1
1
Rating: 0
Moebius Stripper
With her husband currently in custody in Israel, I'm sure Eva Manley has more important things to do than address the many commenters wondering why Jim isn't instead sailing to Syria. When Jim is safely back home, hopefully we'll hear from her, as I think it's fair to wonder why of all instances and suffering and injustice in the Middle East and elsewhere, it's the Israel-Gaza military blockade (legal under the 2011 United Nations Palmer Report), that has driven this white, western minister with no ties to the land to action.

And I have another question for her (which I've asked in comments the last time a flotilla made the Straight; no answer at the time): why are none of these activists attempting to bring goods to Gaza via the border it shares with Egypt?
1
1
Rating: 0
Jessie1
I would caution anyone to be very careful with any comments they make that could be interpreted as being critical of israel. Regardless of any actions taken by the state of israel, there is no tolerance in the media for any criticism. The comments on this story are a clear indication of that. The CBC will not even allow comments on their story covering this issue. If you express an opinion not deemed the correct one, you will be labelled a racist and an anti-semite.
1
1
Rating: 0
Martin Dunphy
Jessie 1:

How can you say the comments here are "a clear indication" that the media allows no criticism of Israel?
Both sides are well represented, although there appears to be a organized campaign to push one particular talking point.
1
0
Rating: +1
anonymouse1962
Don't think so Jessie1. The fact that papers have no trouble printing anti-Israel stories on a regular basis, like the Georgia Straight does, and that the media on TV have also pushed this story without balance disproves your point.

The media doesn't seem to mind presenting anti-Israel/pro-Arab stories without regard to any balance. So, the fact that you can't pile on with the anti-Israel comments doesn't really matter. Your view of things is already being presented.
1
1
Rating: 0
Miguel1
Arabs in Israel have equal voting rights; in fact, it is one of the few places in the Middle East where Arab women may vote. Arabs currently hold 8 seats in the 120-seat Knesset. Israeli Arabs have also held various government posts, including one who served as Israel's ambassador to Finland and the current deputy mayor of Tel Aviv. Oscar Abu Razaq was appointed Director General of the Ministry of Interior, the first Arab citizen to become chief executive of a key government ministry. Ariel Sharon's original cabinet included the first Arab minister, Salah Tarif, a Druze who served as a minister without portfolio. An Arab is also a Supreme Court justice.

Arabic, like Hebrew, is an official language in Israel. More than 300,000 Arab children attend Israeli schools. At the time of Israel's founding, there was one Arab high school in the country. Today, there are hundreds of Arab schools.2
1
1
Rating: 0

Pages

Add new comment
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.