Gwynne Dyer: Capt. Amadou Sanogo creates chaos and division in Mali

Comments

Imagine that you are a junior officer in a West African army. You joined the army at 18, you worked hard, you managed to get sent to the United States four times for various training courses, but somehow the promotions never came.

You have just turned 40, and in 10 or 15 years you will have to retire on a captain’s pension. What to do?

That is Capt. Amadou Sanogo, and in March he finally figured out what to do. He launched a military coup and declared himself president of Mali. Nice work, if you can get it—but then the roof fell in on his empty head.

A military coup against an elected government rarely lasts long if the general population is willing to defend it: the soldiers can usually be driven from power by a general strike. However, Sanogo had some grievances to work with. Mali was extolled elsewhere as a beacon of democracy, but the government was actually both corrupt and incompetent.

The main thing you need for a junior officers’ coup is the support of the ordinary soldiers. There’s not really much in it for the men in the ranks, apart from the opportunity to loot: they’re never going to sit in the president’s chair, so they have to be deeply unhappy about the civilian government before they’ll back a coup. Happily for Capt. Sanogo, they were quite cross at President Amadou Touré.

Yet another revolt among the Tuareg ethnic group in Mali’s northern desert broke out last January, the fourth since 1960. President Touré’s government was not giving the army adequate weapons and supplies to deal with it (or at least that was the army’s excuse). The rebels had only seized a couple of small towns on the far-distant Algerian border, but Malian soldiers were feeling humiliated and neglected.

But while the soldiers were very angry at Touré’s government by this March, there was no need for a military coup to change it. National elections were already scheduled for April, and Touré, having completed two terms in office, could not run again. How can you justify using military force to remove a president who is leaving office next month anyway?

You can’t, but then nothing’s perfect. At least the ordinary soldiers at the base Capt. Sanogo commanded just outside the capital, Bamako, were ready to follow his lead.

So on March 22, he moved his troops into Bamako and declared that he was taking power because the elected government was not doing enough to halt the rebellion in the north.

President Touré went into hiding, and suddenly Capt. Sanogo was the most powerful man in Mali—but within a week two things went badly wrong for him.

Sanogo seems not to have realized that ECOWAS—the Economic Community of West African States—strongly disapproves of military coups in its members (since each member government fears such a fate itself). He was therefore surprised when ECOWAS banned all trade across landlocked Mali’s borders and froze Mali’s accounts at BCEAO, the central bank for all the West African countries that use the CFA franc.

He was even more surprised when the Tuareg rebels took advantage of the turmoil in Bamako to overrun the entire north of Mali, an area bigger than France, in only one week. There was little fighting: the Malian army units just fled, as did tens of thousands of black African refugees.

Pale-skinned Tuaregs living in the south also became targets for violence. Sanogo’s coup brought about exactly what it was meant to prevent.

These events, plus the growing shortage of fuel for transport and electricity (Mali imports all its oil), forced Sanogo to talk to ECOWAS. On April 12, after only three weeks in power, Sanogo agreed that the speaker of parliament, Dioncounda Traoré, would become the country’s interim leader until new elections could be held. Sanogo was paid off with a mansion and a pension suitable for “a former head of state".

Only a week later, however, Traoré was severely injured by a mob that invaded his residence while Sanogo’s troops stood by and did nothing. Sanogo is still running things from behind the scenes, while Traoré is now in France undergoing medical treatment. And last Saturday the two rival Tuareg rebel groups that now control the north managed to settle their differences and declared the independence of the Islamic Republic of Azawad.

For a man whose ambition outran his understanding, Sanogo has accomplished a lot. In just a month, he has ruined an imperfect but serviceable democracy and divided it into two hostile states: it will take years for Mali to recapture the north, if it ever can. And in “Azawad” the fighting will continue, because the black Africans living along the big bend of the Niger river in the south of that territory do not accept Tuareg rule.

Those who doubt the ability of mere individuals to change the course of history should contemplate Capt. Amadou Sanogo.

Comments (9) Add New Comment
Jayjordan
Clearly gwynne dyer is a complete idiot from these writings. Go to Mali, meet sanogo, spk to the people and see the country and I can guarantee you would write such a different article
0
1
Rating: -1
Taxpayers R Us
@Jay

I don't know if something went viral the past 5 years or if the extreme left abandoned all reason in favour of drugs, but Dyer has managed to build a following.

In a single glance, he is an expert on middle eastern affairs, languages, European debt, electric cars, Jews, Latin America, some guy from an Asian alley elected as community leader, prime mortgages, bin Laden, fair-trade soil, England, cats, and whatever else is in the news today.

Luckily, the people who read and follow this mouthpiece are about as completely delusional as the large one himself :)
1
1
Rating: 0
bruce knecht
Taxpayers R Us
Next time you have nothing to say, don't say it.
2
1
Rating: +1
petr aardvark
much better to get it from right wing talk radio.. Taxp. & Jay hey what happened to Glenn Beck? That other fat guy is going down too.
0
3
Rating: -3
cassius
I'm a longtime Dyer reader and haven't been diagnosed as delusional. Dyer is more often right than wrong. I may disagree with what he says, especially on Venezuela and Cuba, but he's got lots of facts to back up his opinions. His style is readable as well. But like @jay, I wonder how he can range far and wide from Mali to Venezuela to nuclear reactors and the environment.
1
1
Rating: 0
Jinx Removing
I think what you are missing is Mr. Dyers commentary does not come from his expertise in economics, African history, alternative energy, etc. He is a Military historian (who has served in 3 navies and is not hawkish) and his expertise is generally of war and military affairs, and how they affect world events. That perspective is what makes his insight valuable.
1
3
Rating: -2
Toddly
@Jinx: well said. We may not need to agree with Dyer on all points but certainly we can respect his bona fides and long-time experience as an analyst.
1
0
Rating: +1
Issac Chandler
>Sanogo sent to the United States four times for various training courses"

Maybe he went to the wrong school?
A US bill to abolish the School of the Americas was introduced in 2005 but failed by 6 votes.
Venezuela Argentina, Uruguay, Costa Rica, Bolivia have stopped sending soldiers to train at School of the Americas:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Hemisphere_Institute_for_Security_C...

The President of Ecuador , Rafael Correa said the other day 'The only country that can be sure never have a coup d'état is the USA because it does not have an American Embassy:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZvUwC5JTAJY&feature=player_detailpage#t=104s

>"A military coup against an elected government rarely lasts long"

The 2002 CIA usurpation of power in Venezuela lasted only 2 days but the 2009 Honduran coup d'état was much more successful:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roberto_Micheletti#Presidency_of_Honduras

Rafael Correa has closed the American military base and has tried to stop the Americans from funding Ecuadors police:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZvUwC5JTAJY&feature=player_detailpage#t=118s
http://assange.rt.com/correa-episode-six/
2
1
Rating: +1
Brent1023
Events over the last 8 months have shown Dyer to be correct in his diagnosis of Mali and his predictions for the future of the country have come to pass.

Dyer has written several other columns on Mali which can be found by a search on gwynne dyer mali. Worth reading if you are catching up on events there.

Contrary to the views of earlier writers, Dyer is almost certainly a valuable source for anything on which he writes. Do some additional reading, but he is a good start.

Thanks to the Straight for publishing him.
1
0
Rating: +1
Add new comment
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.