Here are the real reasons why Gregor Robertson and Christy Clark won't march in the Pride parade

Comments

Vancouver mayor Gregor Robertson has decided to jet off to London on a "trade mission" in advance of the annual Vancouver Pride parade.

Poll

Should Mayor Gregor Robertson head a trade mission to London or march in the Pride parade?

Go to London 25%
137 votes
March in the parade 50%
272 votes
Neither 25%
139 votes

Special coverage

Premier Christy Clark, the MLA for Vancouver–Point Grey, won't walk in the parade for the second consecutive year, even though she was quite happy to make the time as a CKNW broadcaster.

When Toronto mayor Rob Ford takes a pass on the parade, he's regularly roasted by the media in his town.

But when B.C. political leaders do the same, they mostly get off scot-free.

According to a Statistics Canada report, B.C. had the third-highest rate of police-reported hate crimes in the country in 2010. The highest rate by a significant margin occurred in Ford's province of Ontario, followed by Manitoba and then B.C., at four crimes per 100,000 people.

Among Canadian cities, Vancouver was in the middle of the pack at nearly five crimes per 100,000 people.

Hate crimes are most commonly rooted in race and ethnicity, but those involving sexual orientation are the most violent.

"This trend was also seen in 2010, as almost two-thirds (65%) of hate crimes motivated by sexual orientation were violent," Statistics Canada reported. "In comparison, 34% of racially motivated hate crimes and 17% of religiously motivated hate crimes were violent."

In the face of this, why wouldn't the mayor of Vancouver show solidarity with those facing this issue by marching in the annual Pride parade?

I would suggest there are three explanations:

• Robertson wants to go to London to take in the Olympics and be photographed with Canadian athletes.

• He sees no need to attend the Pride parade because he's already locked up most of the LGBT vote, and the next election won't occur until 2014.

• The mayor is unfamiliar with research conducted by UBC Sauder School of Business professors John Reis and Keith Head, who demonstrated there's no evidence that high-profile trade trips led by politicians generate any financial returns.

Robertson's trip will cost taxpayers $100,000. A month ago, he was in Singapore at taxpayers' expense rather than hanging around town for Canada Day.

Someone should tell the mayor that he's not some big-city U.S. mayor with real authority.

Robertson has one vote on council in a country with a constitution that grants most powers to the provincial government, some powers to the federal government, and no powers to municipalities.

Canadian cities are mere creations of provincial legislation to deal with land use, parks, engineering, and fire services, as well as serving as funding sources for police boards that are mostly appointed by the province.

Why this mayor feels he should be heading trade missions all over the world eludes me. If he was paying more attention to his back yard, Vancouver-based businesses would be less vulnerable to being lured to Burnaby, Richmond, and Coquitlam by mayors who appear to be a lot more knowledgeable about the division of powers in this country than Vancouver's top elected official.

But enough of Robertson. At least he has attended the Pride parade every year he's been mayor (and he also attended the launch of Vancouver's Pride Week at city hall on July 30). The same can't be said of Clark, who has a responsibility to send a message to people across the province that she supports equal rights regardless of gender or sexual orientation.

I think I know why Clark won't walk in the parade. The official excuse will be some rubbish about her family. I suspect the reality is she doesn't want to get booed by some in the crowd.

If Clark had real guts as a political leader, she would march down Robson and Denman streets and Beach Avenue in the parade with her son Hamish to send a message to every redneck and homophobe in the province that she's on the right side of history. And she would amend the B.C. Human Rights Code to offer some protection for transgender people and order every school district in the province to create an antihomophobia policy.

But it won't happen. So instead, the hundreds of thousands who line the streets on Sunday (August 5) to show their support for the LGBT community will witness a large contingent from the B.C. NDP headed by their leader, Adrian Dix.

And after he wins the 2013 provincial election, LGBT kids will finally have a premier who's willing to show them at next year's Pride march what real political leadership looks like.


Follow Charlie Smith on Twitter at twitter.com/csmithstraight.

Comments (21) Add New Comment
BC
With Clark's recent revelation that she relies on the bible to help her in her most difficult times as Premier, I would think she will not be attending anything remotely condoning gays. Also, Spencer Chandra Herbert is our MLA in the west end, and I can tell you he is highly thought of. My husband and I met him while he was out talking to the public and I found it incredible the way people seemed to respond to him. Passerby's were yelling out to him saying hello, good job, etc all the while we were chatting. So, needless to say, I do not think this is Clark friendly territory. We don't want her anyway, she may just suddenly proclaim "In her heart she is a lesbian".

2
1
Rating: +1
akvavit
Who gives a shit whether Clark or Robertson 'marches' in this parade? It's their decision, there's no law saying they have to, and since when is being gay something to be inordinately proud of? Aren't we past all that? Maybe it's time for a 'straight pride parade'. Yeah, sounds ridiculous, doesn't it. Much like 'gay pride parade' does.
1
2
Rating: -1
cn
Did you just roast Robertson and then state that he has attended the event every year he has been mayor?

He was Vancouver's Olympic mayor, and 2 years later, he is attending the very next Olympics. Probably a VIP. Expect him to also be in Sochi.

I'd bet there is a large contingent of the LGBT community that misses Pride 25% of the time when other (or better) opportunities present themselves.

I have no interest in Vancouver's municipal politics (I haven't lived here long enough) and am a full believer of LGBT rights on ALL levels. I'm just commenting on the idiocy of the article, and a clear bias toward the NDP party (who I have voted for at all levels regularly). Lambasting him on an issue in which he has a great record - out of the US Republican Party playbook.

Yes, you are only the Straight (horribly boring-saved by the concert litings, but you are still media, and the left must keep its integrity.
1
1
Rating: 0
Michele Baillie
I don't think Ms. Clark will march in the Pride parade either; I paid close attention to her back in the early years of Mr. Campbell's government when she was education minister.

She had a big opportunity then to set the tone about bullying and homophobic bullying when she could have ordered all BC's school districts to produce anti-bullying and anti-gay bullying policies in both of these areas and did not. The closest she will come to being against homophobia is "protecting the family" and leaving the gay community with hints about support from her or her Government.

She is not going to support the gay community in any way for fear of alienating her primary voter base.
2
2
Rating: 0
Ronald
All good points about Robertson's trade missions, but I think there's another reason he & Clark don't get roasted for not attending: They don't behave as bullies nor louts: the exact type one might expect to go bash teh gays.

Rob Ford? He needs to show his acceptance because he seems more a gay basher than a live & let live kinda guy.
2
2
Rating: 0
Jill Jacobson
Would the LGBT community (or any other) really want Crusty Cluck anywhere near them? Just when we thought public approval ratings couldn't get any lower than Gordo's, who fell below George Bush's ratings, Crusty steps up and takes it to a new low. She would be bad news at any event one was trying to promote or enjoy.
1
1
Rating: 0
roopert
I could personally care less whether or not mayors take place in Pride Parades, or any other parades for that matter. They show up, great! They got other stuff to do, great! When did this all become part of mayor's job description? Let them do whatever they want in their free time.

As for the premier?! Who gives a crap? It's the Vancouver Pride Parade, not the BC Pride Parade. The Straight should take it's Vancouver-is-the-only-place-in-BC-that-matters glasses off occasionally.
1
1
Rating: 0
Vantage
Robertson was proud to wave the flag in last year's parade. Why read so much into it?

Evidence here: http://vanvantage.com/celebrating-diversity-in-vancouver-pride-week-2012/
2
0
Rating: +2
Gerry T NcGuire
What strikes me more than anything about the comments is an endemic self-satisfied cynicism.I might add that Vancouver is more autonomous than most municipalities because it is unique in BC in having it's own charter.The province is loathe to meddle lest it alienate provincial votes,so Vancouver does operate like a city-state,the regional growth strategy notwithstanding. Addressing the cynics, an ancient philosopher (Plato)? said "The penalty for not participating in politics is that you will be ruled by those stupider than you".
1
1
Rating: 0
Arthur Vandelay
Christy isn’t going as she's afraid to get boo'd? Really? She's never step out in public then. Bit of a superficial analysis, wouldn’t you say Charlie?

Maybe more likely is that she is worried about giving more ammo to church-lady Cummins with which he can bash her over the head in Bible country (everywhere outside of the GVRD where they apparently just don't get the homosexual thing) which she desperately needs to win?
0
1
Rating: -1
Jiff
Why is there always at least one dim-bulb thinking they're making any kind of point by blathering, "How about a straight pride parade?" Hyuk, hyuk.
1
1
Rating: 0
cathy
Hey Christy has to rest up after her lunch in Delta Friday-no media allowed.
It's a so called town hall for women-but not women in the media. ha ha.

http://www.southdeltaleader.com/news/164527196.html
2
1
Rating: +1
Bruno Madsen
Learn to read, Jiffy Boy... the last thing I want is a 'straight pride parade'.
1
1
Rating: 0
politics101
While Christy won't be marching in this year's Pride Parade, the BC Liberals will have a number of MLA's including Children and Families Minister Mary McNeil proudly marching under the Pride banner and will also have a booth at Sunset Beach manned by members of the Party. Cheers!
1
1
Rating: 0
Diotoma
Re: Plato

You may wish to take a closer look at The Republic.

Scary stuff.

The playbook for every oligarchy for the last 2,000 years, at least.

Nothing ever changes.

Sigh.
1
0
Rating: +1
election
the Christy party is too right-wing and doesn't support the gay community
2
1
Rating: +1
Bellwork55
The point here I picked up on was:

At least he has attended the Pride parade every year he's been mayor - meaning Gregor Robertson. COMMENDABLE, at least!

- Not sure if any of you remember, but Gordon Campbell never attended any Gay Pride Parade in the time he was premier; but also if you remember, he was very popular with the business community mainly boys club mostly, the Fraser Institute guys -- doesn't that tell you a little something? Ms. Clark is continuing in the same way. This maybe something you would like to think about.
1
1
Rating: 0
CR
Every year it's the same story about which public figures are marching in the Pride Parade and who's not and what that might mean. Quit with the petty little attendance-taking already. It's the Pride Parade, not the Let's See Who's on our Side Parade.
1
1
Rating: 0
T. Setala
It's sad that gay or trans people feel they warrant special laws above and beyond what other people have to protect them. As my husband and I agreed the other night, if some people are more worthy of protection than others, then we should, as wealthy people, be able to get stronger sentences against people who rob our house. Obviously they robbed us because we're wealthy and therefore, using the same logic, we're picked on for who we are. And if you want stats showing the hate leveled at those of us with significant means, simply look at the property crimes numbers. They make your hate crimes numbers invisible by comparison. If there's one way of showing how much the poor hate the hard working, successful people of this province, it's in the property crime numbers. And this in spite of my husband using his customers donations to the Food Bank as a sign of his community spirit! Some people are so ungrateful.
1
1
Rating: 0
Martin Dunphy
T. Setala:

For a moment there, I thought your post was satirical. Then the small blood clot in my brain broke free.
Perhaps if your husband used his own contributions to the food bank as "a sign of his community spirit" instead of other people's, you would be less picked upon by criminals.
And gay and trans people don't want "special laws"; they just want equal treatment.
Happy Pride!
1
1
Rating: 0

Pages

Add new comment
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.