Kelowna mayor Walter Gray receives a blast from pro-choice movement over "Right to Life Week"

Comments

The Abortion Rights Coalition of Canada has joined with Kelowna activists and others from across Canada to object to the City of Kelowna's "Protect Human Life Week".

ARCC's executive director, Joyce Arthur, has claimed in a statement that this proclamation must be rescinded "because it strongly implies that Kelowna does not respect women's legal and constitutional rights".

Numerous people have signed the following letter, which has been sent to Mayor Walter Gray.

Dear Mayor Walter Gray,

The signatories to this letter object to the proclamation you issued on July 3 declaring September 23-30, 2012 as “Protect Human Life Week.” This proclamation, issued at the request of the Kelowna Right to Life Society, is highly inappropriate and should be rescinded immediately.

When the city states: “It is the intention of this proclamation to promote respect and protection to all human life, especially the infirm, the aged, the handicapped, and the unborn,” it is an implicit endorsement of the Kelowna Right to Life Society’s opposition to safe and legal abortion for women. A quick perusal of the Society’s website makes clear that it is a radical political and religious group primarily concerned with opposing and re-criminalizing abortion, not with protecting the infirm, aged, handicapped, or even babies. A majority of Canadians support legal abortion, and our Supreme Court has struck down the previous abortion law as contravening women’s constitutional rights. Therefore, no municipality should make a public statement supporting an organization that is intent on reversing women’s guaranteed rights to “life, liberty, and security of person” under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Since the City of Kelowna has no legal jurisdiction to change federal or provincial laws on abortion (or anything else), it has no valid reason to issue the proclamation.

“Protect Human Life Week” is deeply offensive and upsetting to many people in Kelowna and across Canada, particularly women who have had or who are considering an abortion. It is wrong for the city to make proclamations that disregard women’s rights and make women feel disrespected and intimidated.

Although the city has issued this same proclamation in years past, it was never appropriate to do so because of its disregard for and opposition to established human rights under the law, and because it leads the city to improperly intrude into matters of federal or provincial law. Just as the “PRO-LIFE” flag will not be flown, all public support for “Protect Human Life Week” must now be withdrawn. We call upon you to rescind immediately the proclamation of “Protect Human Life Week” and to refrain from issuing it in future years.

Sincerely,

Signatories:

Joyce Arthur, Executive Director, Abortion Rights Coalition of Canada

Board of Directors, Abortion Rights Coalition of Canada

Dianne Varga, writer and activist, Kelowna

Kristin Staley, Summerland

Anne-Marie Brun, Kelowna

Jennifer Pickering, Kelowna

Susan Davenport, Kelowna

Kelly Megyesi, Vernon

Dr. Jennifer Gustar, Associate Professor, UBC, Okanagan Campus, Kelowna

Susan E. Morrison, Kelowna and District Pro-choice Action Society, Kelowna

Lören Price, Centre for Inquiry, Okanagan

Zena Ryder, Centre for Inquiry, Okanagan

Penney Kome, author, award-winning journalist, and Editor of StraightGoods.com

Dr. Ellen Wiebe, Clinical Professor, Reproductive Health, UBC; Medical Director at Willow Women’s Clinic, Vancouver

Jane Cawthorne, author, playwright, blogger, Calgary

Dr. Colleen MacQuarrie, Associate Professor, Graduate Faculty, Psychology Department, University of Prince Edward Island

Dr. M.K. Bryson, Director, Institute for Gender, Race, Sexuality and Social Justice (GRSJ); Professor, Department of Language and Literacy Education (LLED), UBC

Michael Payton, Executive Director, Centre for Free Inquiry, Toronto

Marilyn Roycroft, Acting Executive Director, Legal Education and Action Fund (LEAF), Toronto

Laura Track, Legal Director, West Coast Legal Education and Action Fund (LEAF), Vancouver

Dr. A. Brenda Anderson, Assistant Professor, Women's and Gender Studies, Religious Studies, Luther College, University of Regina

Dr. Darlene Juschka, Coordinator and Associate Professor, Women's and Gender Studies, Religious Studies, University of Regina

Jennifer J. Breakspear, Executive Director, Options for Sexual Health, Vancouver

Anne Rochon Ford, Executive Director, Canadian Women's Health Network

Ian Bushfield, Executive Director, BC Humanist Association

Board of Directors, BC Humanist Association

Vancouver Women’s Health Collective, Vancouver

Radical Handmaids, Ottawa

Comments (10) Add New Comment
Ron S.
We have to rid our governments of these right wing idiots and relegate them to the caves and rocks they crawl out from under. It's sad in this day and age that religion is allow to creep back into government.
2
2
Rating: 0
R U Kiddingme
@Ron S

I dunno, I would almost rather that wingnuts 'out' themselves to help the voters make an informed choice.

Just for argument's sake, uf Walter Grey wants to proclaim "I Support Reversing Your Constitutional Rights Day", "Al Qaida Is Awesome Day," or "The Beatles Are Nothing Compared to Chad Kroeger Day," thus resulting in bewildered, irritated opposition from the sanity-based community, what's the problem? Isn't it all healthy debate?
1
3
Rating: -2
Ted Gerk
Aww...so the pro-choicers don't like the proclamation? Tough. Ellen Wiebe is a career abortionist, so I guess she sort of has an interest in seeing it continue. And as for the rest, it is certainly their right to protest the decision, even though the idea that there is a constitutional right to abortion is just not true. The Supreme Court of Canada is on record supporting abortion restrictions in Canada.
3
3
Rating: 0
Julia R.
Hmm, the only other countries that don't have any abortion law are China and North Korea, and I think we can agree that they aren't giving positive examples of protecting human right?
I have to say, I don't like the fact that I'm missing a heck of a lot of my generation. Lots of friends and tax payers, and baby women who have rights too were dismissed before they could move locations from inside to outside their mama...
2
2
Rating: 0
Mike S.
We can't be legislating the indentured servitude of women in our society.

That's what banning or severely restricting abortion amounts to. The state forcing a woman what to do with her body.

A simple point overlooked, and a precedent that must not be set. Maybe one day when a fetus can be removed from the uterus without any sort of invasive procedure laws, pertaining to such things *might* make sense. That day isn't even on the horizon.
0
1
Rating: -1
carmel350
umm, the unborn baby is a unique human being, it's not the woman's body. Yes the child is in her body and I often wonder how pro-choicers don't understand how that child got into their bodies in the first place.
2
1
Rating: +1
JoelPenner
Rape notwithstanding, why is having a child considered "indentured servitude" when it was the man and woman's choice to engage in an activity which resulted in new life?

For all other circumstances, free spaying and neutering needs to be offered for humans. We do it to animals, why not humans?
1
1
Rating: 0
Thomas H. Sallaway
Political leaders should stop thinking they know what is right for everybody....they do not even if their religion demands it of them. Woman have the right to choose without interference from individuals who feel they represent a greater calling.
1
2
Rating: -1
KayleeS
These prolifers don't give a flying crap with this child comes along, Why can't
they abolish child poverty? Their moral responsibility is over after 9 months
then where are they?
1
2
Rating: -1
Gary Martin
Putting all religions aside, HUMAN life begins at conception. How can anyone not see that fact. How can it be something other than human, with his or her own identity and soul.
1
2
Rating: -1
Add new comment
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.