Open letter to the Baby Boomers from Generation Y

    1 of 1 2 of 1

      Dear Baby Boomers:

      We need to talk. We were surfing around online yesterday for a couple hours—just like any other day, really—when we stumbled upon an article on Wikipedia that we think gets to the heart of your recently revealed spiraling debt problem. Turns out, you suffer from oniomania—the compulsive desire to spend. Unfortunately, it looks like it’s a progressive condition, and likely to get worse. You need to get help before it’s too late, either for you or for us.

      You might not be inclined to believe us, so let’s review what got us to this point. For the last 20 years, while we’ve been struggling to finish school, start our careers or keep our jobs, you’ve been maxing out your credit cards, buying new Chevy Tahoes and Canyoneros, taking on super-mortgages, investing in hedge funds and high-yield Chinese ETFs, burning every ounce of fossil fuel you can get your hands on, and just basically consuming the hell out of everything.

      That all came crashing to a halt in 2008. You lost a bunch of money. We would have too, if only we’d had any savings. You seemed pretty shaken up by the experience. It seemed to give you a glimpse of your own financial mortality. You said, “Never again! We’ve learned our lesson. No more exotic credit default swaps for us. We promise we’ll start saving more prudently, and start spending less. We’re going stop living only for today, and start planning for tomorrow.”

      We were pretty caught up in our own problems at the time—you may remember that our shifts were cut in half at Starbucks right around then—but even so, we noticed, and we thought to ourselves, “Better late than never!” We allowed ourselves to hope that you had really changed, even as we worried that we’d have to wait longer to get the jobs that are supposed to open up once you retire.

      But now, we see that it was just words. Many of you started borrowing even more heavily after 2008! Seriously, how on Earth do you expect to pay all that off after you retire? You know you can’t fund a second mortgage, let alone the first one, without any income, right? (And no, we don’t want to buy the house after you retire so you can downsize. It’s too big, it’s too far from downtown, and you know we don’t own a car. We’d never get approved for the mortgage anyways. Thanks for asking, though.)

      You’ve meant so much to us, provided us with such important guidance in our formative years. You’re our parents, our teachers, our political leaders. In a few cases, you’ve even our grandparents. You inspired and encouraged us to follow our dreams, which come to think of it probably helps to explain why we still don’t have a full-time job yet. So much of what we are we owe to you, and we don’t just mean that figuratively. (Thanks again for the help with university tuition!) You’re family and we’ll always love you.

      All of that makes this letter just that much harder to write, but we need to be honest with you: you’re lovely one-on-one or in small groups, but as a generation you’ve become positively sociopathic. You’re incapable of thinking about anyone else. It’s actually worse than that, as you don’t even seem to realize the implications of your actions for yourselves over the long run. You’re the Bernie Madoff Generation, and the last 20 years have been one big Ponzi scheme.

      We’ve been watching you party since we were born, but it’s only now, just as we’ve arrived, gotten our coats off and placed our first order at the bar, that we learn that you’re planning on asking us to settle up the bill while you head on over to the retirement after-party. No matter how hard we work—and let’s be honest, we’re never going to work all that hard—we’re not going to be able to support you in retirement at the same time we try to raise our own families.

      (Speaking of which, yes, we haven’t quite settled down yet, and no, we haven’t found the right person yet. Just give us some time, all right? We don’t want to rush into something before we’re ready, like you did with… Oh, sorry. Forget we brought that up, okay?)

      To make matters worse, we’ve picked up some of the same habits that have gotten you into such trouble. If you think about it, you shouldn’t be so surprised. You were there when we got our first credit cards; heck, you drove us to the bank. (Of course, that was back in the days when you couldn’t order a credit card and become insolvent without getting out of bed. Thanks again, Internet.) It was your idea for us to get a line of credit to help out during university. You even co-signed it! (Incidentally, we promise we’ll start paying it off soon, once things settle down at work.)

      But we still want to help. To show how serious we are, we’ve jotted down a couple of ideas that we think could really help you turn things around, to refocus on the most important things in life.

      First, we would like you to try yoga. We think that it’ll really help you clear up your chakras, which are probably pretty clogged up from all the debt-related stress you must be feeling. (Actually, we thought it was spelled “shackra”, but luckily we got Gen X to proofread this and they caught the error. They’re such good proofers! Must come from all those years working as copy editors, waiting for you to retire.)

      We also think you might have a better perspective if you spent a year volunteering in Africa. It’ll really help put things in perspective, to appreciate all that we have in our world, and really inspire you to make it a better place. Maybe in Bali? Bali’s in Africa, right? Anyways, we’ve heard it’s amazing.

      Initially, we asked Gen X if they wanted to help write this letter. They’re still pretty bitter about that whole “grey ceiling” thing though, so we decided to just do it ourselves. However, they did suggest that you might want to think about therapy. Gen X swears by it, saying that it has really help them come to terms with themselves and their place in the world. Within another few sessions, 20 or 30 at the most, they’re sure they’ll be ready to get on with their lives. They believe it could do good things for you too.

      We spoke to the Millennials about contributing as well, but they didn’t want to be seen making positive suggestions about how to change the world. Apparently, it would ruin their Occupy street cred. They did send some advice for you by text, though. We’ve copied it out here verbatim: “Dunno lol… mb they shd gt 1 more job? jk lol” They went on to add, “Hay aks them if we cn have teh car 2nite. Dnt 4gt k? Ok g2g l8r lol.”

      We also asked Greatest Generation for their thoughts. They send their love, but they’re really worried about you too. Not sure how useful their suggestions will be, but we promised we’d pass them along so here they are. First, they thought that you should start investing in something called a “government savings bond”. We didn’t really know what they were talking about, but they said you’d know what it was. They also suggested liberating Europe as a way to build character and stimulate the economy, and asked when everyone was coming to visit.

      As good as all of these ideas are, we know the problem isn’t going to get solved all at once. Because of this, we want this to be an ongoing conversation, and not just a one-off. It’s really important that we keep the lines of communication open. So, we started up a Facebook page where we can continue to exchange ideas. We’re talking about these issues on Twitter as well (#debt, #BabyBust, #GenXgetoveritalready), and we’re setting up a channel on YouTube to upload vlogs about it. We’ll also forward you a link to an online petition, asking the prime minister to fix the economy. Please sign!

      Love,
      Geny

      P.S.: Could we borrow $100? We dropped our iPhone the other day and need to get a replacement, but we only have a couple hundred left on our line of credit. We promise we’ll pay you back this time, as soon as things settle down at work and we start getting more shifts.

      Stewart Prest is a PhD candidate in political science at the University of British Columbia. His views and sense of humour are both his own.

      Comments

      36 Comments

      generation none

      Feb 2, 2012 at 2:21pm

      Stewart, don't be putting on the blame on ALL the baby boomers. How about looking at the marketing of mega corporations for the past 100 years or so? Gov't waste & corporate corruption resulting in the widened gap between rich and poor. Middle class no more.

      I see you have are a PhD candidate. Congratulations, your Boomer parents must be proud. I wonder if they had to re-mortgage the house to help you pay for your very exclusive north american education.

      Trying being the "inbetween" generation. Not a boomer with a high paying, union job, and not an X with the shredded leftovers.

      Great documentary about how the credit card companies are creating a NEW generation of overspenders. It is called Maxed Out.

      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hb1MGccPtUs

      canadianveggie

      Feb 2, 2012 at 3:59pm

      Awesome!

      Kelly Copeland

      Feb 2, 2012 at 4:12pm

      Stewart, I think maybe you have ivory tower sydrome. I am at the tail end of the boomer generation and I don't know anyone like the people you are talking about. I know there are folks who are likely exactly as you describe but I wonder if you know that you are speaking to a very specific group, who could not reasonably take credit for the state of our world at present. I do think that your letter is clever and sometimes very funny, but also cynical and bitter. Try to imagine a world of folks who are suffering at the greedy hands of a few - a very few, and see how you can apply your exceptional mind to helping that situation. Take care.

      Yawn

      Feb 2, 2012 at 4:14pm

      I'm "GenY" and even I find this just the same old boring social-comentary we've been hearing for years.

      It's not any generations fault. As a political Science PhD student I would have hoped you would know that. It's corporate greed, morphed into nameless public greed through the stock market(s) and the need to always keep stock values high no matter the cost (in wages and job cuts) to working people. By investing in companies whose only concern is the bottom line and keeping their stock value high it regular, everyday people who are part of the problem without even realizing it.

      Of course the other way to look at this letter is that it is making fun of "GenY"'s constant need to blame other people for their perceived issues. Which is how I choose to read it.

      To GenX

      Feb 2, 2012 at 4:39pm

      I will use My money to pay for My retirement. Including paying for the care-facility you will eventually place me in as you wait for me to die. Just remember, to settle up with your bill.

      GOT

      Feb 2, 2012 at 5:01pm

      Gen Y...are you the guys bumping into me when you're stumbling down a sidewalk with your earplugs in and texting someone, completely unaware of anything around you, including the cement mixer you just stepped in front of? The operative phrase there is 'completely unaware of anything'...even this article's 'humour' is derivative. Holden Caulfield with a lobotomy. A botched one that left him with only two thoughts: "I want everything right now, and I want it for free.." and "Why can't I have everything right now, for free?" Back and forth, back and forth...lol!
      Us boomers' grandparents fixed the world once, back in 1914-18, then our parents had to do it all over again in 1939-45. Time you lazy little fuckers stopped whining and picked up the slack, OK?

      Dr Octagon

      Feb 2, 2012 at 5:56pm

      @ Yawn
      I agree that blaming an entire generation of people for today's socioeconomic woes is shortsighted and a good example of lazy thinking. Corporate and private greed are the culprits, as you point out.

      You also state that "By investing in companies whose only concern is the bottom line and keeping their stock value high it regular, everyday people who are part of the problem without even realizing it."

      Well, there aren't many companies whose concerns go beyond their bottom line and keeping stock value high. That is a large part of the problem right there. We've built a society that is well on its way to becoming a corporatocracy - a society where greed has become a virtue and becoming rich is trumpeted as the only goal worth pursuing....a society in which the 1%, if you will, enrich themselves on the backs of the rest of us.

      @ Stewart Prest
      My father (Baby Boomer) is not responsible for the massive transfer of wealth from the public to a few private hands, nor is he responsible for cutting your shift at Starbucks and the litany of other things you blame his *entire* generation for.

      Reading your "analysis", complete with its broad generalizations, vapid buzzwords (Millenials etc.), lame attempts at humour and gratuitous navel gazing I was surprised - shocked even - to see that it was written by a PoliSci PhD candidate. All I can say is don't quit your day job, dude.

      Occupier

      Feb 2, 2012 at 7:33pm

      You should probably join an Occupy group and stop whining. We are actually building new institutions like farms, mutual aid groups and new financial institutions, and we're also lobbying Congress and writing pieces for outlets like the Financial Times.

      http://ftalphaville.ft.com/blog/2012/01/31/860721/guest-post-from-ows-to...

      http://occupythesec.nycga.net/

      http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2012/01/occupy-wall-street-submits-letter...

      Again, if you want to be part of the solution rather than a lazy whiner, get involved with your local Occupy group and get to work.

      monty/that'sme

      Feb 2, 2012 at 7:45pm

      Well done.
      Terrific sense of humour. As one who is not totally over-the-hill but sliding in that direction, the ALL ABOUT ME gneration has been the most amazing, self-centered, ill mannered group to come down the pike.

      And now with the Boomers yakking about seniors costing the medical system zillions of dollars, can euthanasia be next?

      out at night

      Feb 2, 2012 at 8:32pm

      You want a smug, entitled, spoiled shithead bent on destroying the world? Try scratching a boomer, and if turns out to be one of the good ones (still hippies, god bless 'em, after all these years), then try the boomer's kid. Bingo.

      Generation X