PNE Forum bans electronic music concerts after noise complaints

Comments

For a long time, East Vancouver resident Barry Sharbo has been making a racket about noise from concerts at the PNE Forum, a public venue at Hastings Park.

In a small victory for Sharbo and other Hastings-Sunrise dwellers, the Pacific National Exhibition, the entity that manages the park on behalf of the City of Vancouver, will no longer allow “electronica” concerts at the Forum.

Kate Huffman, manager of community relations for the PNE, brought the news to the neighbourhood in a letter dated April 24.

“The PNE hired an acoustics consultant to perform noise tests in early March to further analyze sound propagation from the Forum during this type of concert,” Huffman wrote. “This comprehensive testing yielded results that led to the PNE’s decision to discontinue electronica concerts in the Forum.”

Wikipedia defines “electronica” as follows:

Electronica includes a wide range of contemporary electronic music designed for a wide range of uses, including foreground listening, some forms of dancing, and background music for other activities. Unlike electronic dance music, which is sub-genre in the category, all examples of electronica are not necessarily made for dancing. Genres such as techno, drum and bass, downtempo, and ambient are among those encompassed by the umbrella term, entering the American mainstream from “alternative” or “underground” venues during the late 1990s.

However, according to Huffman, there is one more “contracted” electronica concert, scheduled for August 11 at the Forum. That show is a stop on Kaskade’s Freaks of Nature Tour.

But Huffman also informed residents that “efforts are being made to relocate this show to the Pacific Coliseum, a venue that has increased sound insulation”.

The PNE representative added: “Following this, the PNE will no longer book any further electronica concerts into the Forum.”

Comments (51) Add New Comment
cranky mom
What I don't understand is you that these people made a choice to live near or close to the PNE. What do you expect? I lived by Trout Lake for years, and vowed never to live near a large park again. Lesson learned.
1
1
Rating: 0
jimbowarrior
the PNE will regret this in a couple years. No one else was using that dump
2
0
Rating: +2
R2
I say hire a few high school students and have them scoot around the 'Hastings Sunrise' hood prior to shows and hand out complimentary earplugs and 2 unlimited PNE passes for the fair for each resident....
If they don't like that then take away their privileges of selling parking spots during events.....Problem Solved!
I mean hell it's only a couple of hours of your life 7 or 8 times a year, live a little.
2
1
Rating: +1
Ian G62
they'll be banning bagpipes and drums from city streets next :-)
3
1
Rating: +2
Woot
Best news I've read all week! The forum is hands down the worst concert venue in Vancouver. Hopefully these shows move to a better location and become 19+.
1
2
Rating: -1
pissed off
Really? If you chose to live next to a concert venue, it's your own damn fault. Why do you think your house was so cheap? Get over yourself, or move somewhere else. This is the biggest BS I have read in a while.
1
1
Rating: 0
woohoo
Good it was terribad venue for edm shows anyways. Much prefer the commodore... no kids either!
1
2
Rating: -1
Bone
Well, part of me thinks that these folks chose to live where they live and this is part of the deal of living there.

But then I think, what would happen if the venue was in Point Grey or Shaughnessy? I'm guessing it would've been shut down after the first show.
1
1
Rating: 0
downfromthePNE
I find it amazing that these whiney little old farts who live around the area feel they have the "right" to sell parking spots, yet complain about what's happening at the PNE itself. Wow.

So rent your bed to the hookers, then complain when they scream too loud.....this is childish and embarassing.
2
0
Rating: +2
Norm
Nice that the PNE is so quick to act when they really don't need to--this is an area that has had concerts as far back as the 50's and rock shows at least since the 70's. It took us years to get the Croation Center to shut up--and they are in a true residential area.
1
2
Rating: -1
John232942983742934
I used to live near Westwood Racetrack and residents bitched for years about "those noisy cars." Now they bitch about the residents in Westwood Plateau and reminisce about the "cool racetrack that used to be here." These people should be ignored.
1
1
Rating: 0
Damdam
After giving this issue some thought I think it's best that this happened.

We need a better venue to host EDM shows in this city, perhaps we should have more shows in BC Place.
1
2
Rating: -1
Luke McKeehan
Dance music officially the "new" rock'n'roll when one genre gets singled-out like this.
3
2
Rating: +1
f
does this include the coliseum?
2
3
Rating: -1
André Pineault
I say we invite Pendulum to do a show then! They play with live instruments and sing, so this SHOULD be what the idiots along side Barry are looking for. Would they then decide to ban live music in the end? Seems like something they would do.
3
1
Rating: +2
Michael_K
Simple solution really: Tear down the PNE and build condos. Then there will be peace and quiet for all to see.
0
0
Rating: 0
Jordan Arsonist
Great. No fun city strikes again. Underground is better anyways...

But yes, bring pendulum. Muahahaha
1
1
Rating: 0
fuckayoua!
Wow that guy who banned thats a fuckin.tool and should burn in hell after sucking his own dick and balls!!!!
3
2
Rating: +1
RowdyTeenIntoElectro
every show that has been there so far has ended at eleven. last night justice finished at 10:45. these old farts need to invest in a good pair of ear plugs or just settle down. the pne is going to lose a staggering amount of money because of this. i only hope they aren't serious about this. oh yeah almost forgot: fuck you barry.
1
2
Rating: -1
bambobingo
this city is literally ruled by complainers. two thousand people could be having a great time dancing, and one couchbound curmudgeon with a phone can shut it all down. it's such bullshit. same thing all over the city. cant have a fire at the beach. cant walk around with a beer. cant play loud music in the park. have to wear a helmet. resident only parking. cant smoke in the park. no inner tubes at the beach, cant have a drink in a movie theater, no liquor on sunday...meanwhile, we all are forced to tolerate endless construction and development noise, trucks spewing diesel, volleyballers taking up half the beach, the folk fest, 100 person hindu barbecues, sun runs, dog shit parks, expo, the olympics, hockey riots and corporate parades of every manner...Our civic policies seem to reflect the demands of a heaving conglomerate of tiny special interest groups. they take up all the space. what about the majority, average person and their liberties? It's so fucking uptight here, and getting worse. we're just scared babies here. over in europe, they know how to party shamelessly, and have been doing it for thousands of years. vancouver is just a scared baby.
2
3
Rating: -1

Pages

Add new comment
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.