Sarah Cox: On Enbridge pipeline, Natural Resources Minister Joe Oliver is the true radical
I’ve been called some interesting things since I started working for Sierra Club B.C. five years ago. An eco-fascist, for starters. That unfortunate barb was from B.C. Liberal MLA Bill Bennett, who said that we were “eco-facists” (his spelling) who wanted to paint the province our favourite colour—green.
This week, an astounding diatribe from Natural Resources Minister Joe Oliver tarred and feathered me and everyone else associated with Sierra Club B.C. as “radical environmentalists”. According to Oliver, we have a “radical ideological agenda” that rejects the benefits of civilization, even hydroelectricity. I guess I’ll have to unplug the computer I’m supposedly using to hoodwink innocent British Columbians into signing up for the Enbridge pipeline hearings, and to cajole misguided citizens into emailing those dastardly form letters to the Canadian government. (Oops, I mean the Harper government.)
And then there’s the secretly-backed Ethical Oil group, which calls me a “puppet” of “foreign special interest groups” and “radical foreign saboteurs”. Those foreigners are doing such a good job with theatrical illusions that I wasn’t even aware that someone was pulling my strings. Ethical Oil spokesperson Kathryn Marshall says “foreign billionaires” are also meddling in Canada’s affairs, but she can’t name any of them. Maybe it’s not surprising that Marshall doesn’t know who is masterminding this alleged foreign billionaire “hijacking” of Canadian democracy, because Ethical Oil also can’t seem to remember who is designing and paying for its pricey attack ads on environmental groups who oppose the China-backed Enbridge pipeline.
Our radical environmentalist agenda? A drumroll please. Are you ready to be seriously shocked? Okay, here goes. Sierra Club B.C. receives funding from U.S. philanthropic foundations. There, that old cat is finally out of the pipe. It’s been on our website and in our annual reports for decades and suddenly it’s headline news across the country. I can see the next media cycle now, and this story is only getting bigger. “Sierra Club B.C. funded by individual donors, corporations, local businesses, and governments: Telus included.”
Telus, now that is really a radical operation. Haven’t you seen the Telus ad with the singing hippopotamus?
And governments? Hold on a sec. These same environmental groups that are saying no to what Oliver calls “the biggest industrial project on the planet” are backed by governments? Yup, Sierra Club B.C.’s award-winning environmental education program has been supported by the Canadian federal government—the Harper government, the one Oliver works for—along with that hotbed of radicalism that opposes all new and existing hydroelectricity projects, the B.C. government.
Oliver calls the people who run these foreign foundations “socialist billionaires”, and says they’re meddling in Canadian affairs. And these people are supposedly hiding out in the U.S. of A. I hope someone told Rick Perry.
Let’s turn to the so-called radical agenda of one of Sierra Club B.C.’s “foreign funders”, the Wilburforce Foundation in Seattle, which has been singled out by Ethical Oil. Wilburforce, by the way, is named after the lovable pig in Charlotte’s Web whose life is saved by a barn spider. Wilburforce’s mission is to “protect wildlife habitat in Western North America by actively supporting organizations and leaders advancing conservation solutions.” These people are truly terrifying!
Oliver advocates cutting short the democratic pipeline hearing process, ignoring the strong wishes of B.C.’s First Nations and the Union of B.C. Municipalities, jeopardizing 50,000 coastal jobs with a potential oil spill, risking our famous wild salmon streams and white spirit bears, lifting a 30-year ban on oil tanker traffic on B.C.’s treacherous mid-coast, and steaming full speed along a carbon-intensive energy path that scientists like NASA’s James Hansen warn will have catastrophic consequences for global warming.
Now that’s what I’d call radical.
Sarah Cox is the communications director for Sierra Club B.C.





By his methods, Sloppy Joe Oliver brings to mind another Joe: Tail Gunner Joe McCarthy.
The truly radical agenda we're presenting is to share this planet equtably with our children and their children while making space for all of the other creatures we share this beautiful province with.
Here's greenie superstar George Monbiot giving the WWF a well deserved boot.
"..This year, the environmental movement to which I belong has done more harm to the planet's living systems than climate change deniers have ever achieved. .."
Google "guardian sellafield monbiot"
In this case though - the northern pipeline - more by chance they've got it right.
seth
China's militarization reminds me that militaries need oil in order to operate. It is widely acknowledged that 25% of the oil the US consumes is for military purposes. Will Canada aid China's increasing militarization by selling oil to them? Who's next, Syria? Iran?
them all in hell? Do you want oil spills along the Coast? Do you want a major oil spill along the Coast? Then don't put in pipelines.
and the subsidies that Canadians pay want me to say turn on the light and quit giving these big polluters all the tax breaks.
While people's slice of the pie has been given another slice as Canadians are cut down to size and our beautiful coast has been given a death sentence.
If there is so much concern regarding "foreign" groups interferring in Canadian matters then when can we expect Harper & his Harperits to remove all foreign ownership of Canadian natural resources? I didn't hear anything from Harper & Cook when Christie Clarke picked up almost a Billion $$s from a Chinese mining consortium to "look" at mining in B.C.
There is also the small matter of Canada giving money to groups in other parts of the world. Wouldn't that be considered "foreign interferance". Now it maybe money for women and children in Iraq, Afganistan, etc. but hey to some Taliban guy, we are interferring in their country.
I suspect all this "foreign" money and how it is viewed depends upon whose ox is being gored.
I can only conclude Harper & Cook are on the talk circuit, saying the same things to try and get their point of view across. Just reminds me of the Goebels method of propaganda, tell a big enough lie, often enough, people will start to believe it. Of course that was before we had the internet and independant news reporting and columnists such as yourself.
Good column, I really enjoyed it.
I am not against pulling oil out of the ground and finding ways to use tar sands. What those who want to do it as fast as possible don't understand is that carrying on at that unsustainable greed-induced pace will drive our grandkids and their grandkids into the dark ages.
We had this guy all wrong... he supports communism over regimes that protect freedom of speech!
BTW, does one have to have greasy dyed dreadlocks and a piercing of some sort to be an "environmentalist"? Certainly seems like it.
The Enbridge pipeline and resultant oil-tanker traffic (to which I presume you are referring) would involve ship movement on B.C.'s mid-coast area (not out of Vancouver's harbour), where there is currently a moratorium for such activity.
Actually, I believe there are currently well over seventy oil tanker trips a year that carry oil from the Kinder Morgan plant and others in Burnaby through the Burrard Inlet right by Vancouver. There are efforts afoot to increase that to well over 300 tankers a year. Scary prospect, if even one ship has an accident. Can you imagine the impact to Vancouver, N.Vancouver, Burnaby, etc...with an oil spill of any significance?
By the way, Kinder Morgan was fined $150000 in 2007 for an oil spill from a ruptured pipeline in Burnaby.
Thank you for that information. It is certainly factual, and we have published articles on that very topic.
I was attempting to shift another poster's focus back to the particular situation under discussion--Enbridge and coastal tanker traffic--both in the article and in the comment thread.
Again, thanks.