SlutWalk Vancouver challenges blame placed on sexual assault victims

Comments

On January 24, a piece of advice that a Toronto police officer gave at a safety seminar for York University students triggered a worldwide reaction.

“Women should avoid dressing like sluts in order not to be victimized,” said Const. Michael Sanguinetti.

That was the last straw for many Toronto citizens. On April 3, more than 3,000 people—dressed in such provocative attire as raincoats, track pants, and sneakers—took a stand against victim-blaming and participated in what organizers billed as SlutWalk Toronto.

Toronto’s SlutWalk participants, who marched from Queen’s Park to police headquarters, were not only responding to Sanguinetti’s comment. They wanted to inspire a shift in the way mainstream culture blames victims of sexual assault rather than targets the perpetrators of the crimes.

SlutWalk Toronto has already inspired cities around the world, from Canada and the U.S. to New Zealand, to launch their own SlutWalks. In Vancouver, student activists have used social media to mobilize thousands of people in a short amount of time to bring about SlutWalk Vancouver. It will take place on May 15 along Granville Street downtown.

On March 31, SFU student Josh Tabish emailed fellow communications student Katie Raso a link to a newspaper article in which a Saanich police officer was quoted as saying that victims of sexual assault are “people who have placed themselves in vulnerable situations and are unfortunately victimized as a result”. (The newspaper later “updated” the story online and wrote that the officer was quoted “out of context” and that some readers had “misconstrued” the comment.)

Raso posted the link to the SlutWalk Toronto Facebook page; within minutes, she said, she received a text message from a SlutWalk Toronto participant encouraging her to organize a SlutWalk in Vancouver. Raso emailed several local organizations to gauge support for the idea, and by the end of the day, SlutWalk Vancouver’s organizing committee had come together.

Within four days, more than 1,700 Facebook users had confirmed their participation in SlutWalk Vancouver.

“It took off like wildfire,” Tabish said. “We did not expect things to happen this quickly. It reminds us of how important this issue is for everyone.”

Tabish is one of four men on the SlutWalk Vancouver organizing team. “No one has challenged our involvement,” Tabish said. “Most victims of sexual assault are women, but men will be coming to the walk as citizens, as family members, and as boyfriends. We want men to know that whatever role you play, you have an important role in this conversation.”

However, not all responses have been positive. Every day, individuals leave messages on the Facebook event page criticizing walk organizers for encouraging scantily clad women to parade around on the streets.

“There is no such thing as dressing like a slut,” Raso said, “Because there is no such thing as dressing for sexual assault. We encourage participants to wear whatever they would normally wear. We are trying to bring to light that when we excuse away sexual assaults by blaming the victims, we are ensuring that assaults will continue.”

Despite the controversy that a name like SlutWalk is bound to stir up, it might be part of the reason why the walk has generated so much attention and dialogue worldwide.

Natalie Hill, a former Vancouver Rape Relief & Women’s Shelter volunteer who is doing her master’s research on rape in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, had reservations about reclaiming the word slut.

“After thinking about it, I realized the irony and the satire in SlutWalk”, she said. “It’s pretty brilliant of them to take a pejorative that a Toronto police officer used and leverage that into a movement that has attracted the support of people who may not usually get involved in activist efforts.”

Becki Ross, who chairs the women’s and gender studies department at UBC, also applauds the SlutWalk organizers for working to challenge harmful cultural norms.

“To me, the SlutWalks in Toronto, Vancouver, Boston, and elsewhere reclaim slut for all women who dare to challenge constricting and punishing gender and heterosexual norms that have historically divided ”˜good women’—monogamous, virtuous, passive, subordinated—from ”˜bad women’—sexually experimental, curious, and rebellious,” Ross said.

The SlutWalk Vancouver organizers do not expect to overturn entrenched ideas overnight. However, Raso and Tabish said that the event will offer an “open and inclusive forum for people to talk about how to work together to change toxic environments”.

B.C.’s Battered Women’s Support Services is among an assortment of nonprofit agencies that support SlutWalk Vancouver. According to BWSS executive director Angela Marie MacDougall: “The paradigm in our society is that women are prey, and as prey we need to protect ourselves. There is rarely recognition [of the fact] that men are often responsible for sexual violence and the question of how can men help end violence against women. This paradigm needs to shift, and I believe SlutWalk Vancouver is a part of that shift.”

In the weeks leading up to May 15, the SlutWalk Vancouver committee will host a series of discussions on its blog and campaign to spread awareness about its goals. Raso and Tabish also said they hope to lend their support to other communities interested in organizing their own SlutWalks.

“As for SlutWalk Vancouver 2012? The absolute best thing that could happen is that we will help start a conversation that won’t have to be restarted in a year,” Raso said.

Comments (25) Add New Comment
James Peters
NOONE wants to be sexually assaulted and In NO way should the charactor and or manner of dress or lack thereof be EVEN taken into consideration in relation to deciding the guilt or innocence of the accused .Sadly however the victim seems to have less rights than the accused in Canada
2
2
Rating: 0
Andrea D. Merciless
So basically a message to women to do what they want, dress how they want, and go where they want, and never ever take any responsibility for the consequence of any of their actions. Typical femminazi BS.

Feminists: women should not be treated, perceived, or regarded as sex objects.
Feminists: women should have the right to act like sex objects.
Feminists: objectification of female sexuality is oppression.
Feminists: objectification of female sexuality is liberation.

Feminists = spoiled little brats who wanna have it both ways.

1
4
Rating: -3
Live Free
Sadly I think the message was missed in the cops unfortunate choice of words.

2
1
Rating: +1
Sarah Donnelly
Andrea, how did you get the sense that Slut Walk is about dictating to women what they should or should not do?

Seems to me like that's exactly what Slut Walk is working to fight against. When sexual assaults happen, there is often too much focus on what the victim could have done to avoid the assault.

Rarely do people say: Why did the rapist rape? What could we as a society do to prevent another assault from happening?

Females grow up hearing the same messages over and over about how not to become a victim. Women already know that they should avoid walking alone at night, watch their drinks, carry cell phones, etc, etc.

When a sexual assault does happen, as it happens to 1 in 3 Canadian women, and a police officer makes a statement to the press reiterating the same points telling women to be careful, this does not make much of a difference. Women are already careful. Women are already afraid.

What we need to do is to overhaul our culture so that rapes and sexual assaults are simply no longer acceptable.

Instead of excusing rapists' actions by focusing on how short the victim's skirt was, or how much cleavage she was showing, we need to stop blaming the victims and we need to send rapists a loud and clear message: Don't rape!

Plus, men and trans persons are also victims of sexual assault and rape, so we should not exclude their experiences.
2
2
Rating: 0
Sarah Donnelly
And about your points on feminism...Have you ever talked to any feminists? No two feminists have the exact same opinions. Trying to make generalizations about feminists is as misguided as trying to make generalizations about white people, Asian people, black people...you get my point. Right?
3
3
Rating: 0
kaur
I think Andrea was referring to radical/extreme/militant feminists. The reality is most large power based groups have their fringe or extreme element (the Tea Party comes to mind) and often this element yields too much power and authority by using bully tactics. I agree that these type of people give feminists overall a bad name and this often undermines their credibility which is so unfortunate.

Dealing and conversing with this element can be an exercise in frustration which I experienced as recently as yesterday....
http://www.straight.com/article-386224/vancouver/twoyear-dry-spell-worth...

I wish that moderate and progressive feminists come to the forefront of the feminist movement and that it evolves in harmony with the changing dynamics of society.
1
2
Rating: -1
Lady Confusiya
I'm heading to slutwalk - and I'm wearing my niqab too - because that's my right!
Won't you join me?
Allalllllalalalaalaalalapitched yodel>
2
2
Rating: 0
sensibility > sensitivity
I'm totally on board with the women who say it's not about what you wear when it comes to reasons why people get raped. It's about some sick fuck who's out to rape someone. Slutwalk is a total overreaction though.

Maybe it doesn't change much to tell women to be careful but it doesn't hurt either. This officer was wrong to put his emphasis on a dress code but do we need to have a mass protest over one asshole's dumb comment (he might as well tell you to be as ugly as possible and smelly too). I agree that we shouldn't put the entire focus on what the victim could have done to avoid being raped but it does deserve a mention if it's something that could help other women avoid being raped as well. Even if you've heard it 1000 times before someone else probably hasn't heard it enough.

Now, I like Sarah's idea of telling rapists not to rape. We should definitely crash their next meeting. We need to make sure the pedophiles are there as well. Also it wouldn't be a bad idea to tell murderers to stop murdering, thieves to stop stealing etc... I'm sure we can solve these problems in a week or two. Sounds about as dumb as the dress code thing actually. Good thing your comments won't be scrutinized by feminists Sarah.
1
1
Rating: 0
Onni Milne
I support the SlutWalk proposed for May 15. As a woman, I am TIRED of hearing that women are used as punching bags and objects for men who haven't learned how to deal with their issues. I keep hearing about how rapists in the DRC do so with impunity because they know they will never be held to account for their actions. I suggest the same attitude is present in our "progressive" society. Rapist trials put the woman on trial instead of handing the rapist the sentence coming to him for his actions.
2
3
Rating: -1
rin
Sexual Assault Prevention Tips Guaranteed to Work!
(from http://feministlawprofessors.com/?p=12965)

1. Don’t put drugs in people’s drinks in order to control their behavior.

2. When you see someone walking by themselves, leave them alone!

3. If you pull over to help someone with car problems, remember not to assault them!

4. NEVER open an unlocked door or window uninvited.

5. If you are in an elevator and someone else gets in, DON’T ASSAULT THEM!

6. Remember, people go to laundry to do their laundry, do not attempt to molest someone who is alone in a laundry room.

7. USE THE BUDDY SYSTEM! If you are not able to stop yourself from assaulting people, ask a friend to stay with you while you are in public.

8. Always be honest with people! Don’t pretend to be a caring friend in order to gain the trust of someone you want to assault. Consider telling them you plan to assault them. If you don’t communicate your intentions, the other person may take that as a sign that you do not plan to rape them.

9. Don’t forget: you can’t have sex with someone unless they are awake!

10. Carry a whistle! If you are worried you might assault someone "on accident"you can hand it to the person you are with, so they can blow it if you do.
1
3
Rating: -2
strouth
The problem with the Toronto police officer's speech is that he used an extremely poor choice of words, but I think the point he was trying to make -- keeping women safe -- has been lost in the furor over his vocabulary.

The key fact the officer failed to overlook is that young women in club districts like Richmond Street in Toronto or Granville Street in Vancouver, dress provocatively, simply because that's what young women in club districts do.

As long as men run on testosterone, there's always going to be a small subset of them that are going to stop at nothing to get women, and when you mix the cover of night, drugs and alcohol, these club districts will attract violent young men.

What the police officer should have said was "You're young, you're out for the night, have fun, but take care of yourself. Don't walk alone. Dress how you like, but be aware of how others might perceive you, and remember that their intentions might be much different from yours."

Unfortunately, we don't live in a perfect world, but until we do, both women and men have to take responsibility to keep women safe.
1
1
Rating: 0
No More Fairy Tales
Weird, that there is a focus on how a woman looks. I was always told rape is a power thing, not a sex thing.
2
3
Rating: -1
R U Kiddingme
The premise of Slutwalk is that women are somehow being held accountable for being raped. That would be outrageous if it is true, but is it true? That is, is it an accepted legal defence of sexual assault to assert that the woman was dressed in a particular way? I highly doubt it.

What the Toronto cop is talking about is not responsibility for the crime, which rests on the attacker, but precipitation of the crime, which is an entirely different field of criminology studies. The selection of victims is not by lottery. Therefore, there are things that we can do that will affect our risks.

That does not mean that we wear long pants all the time, or stay in our rooms and peep fretfully out of window. It means that we should take sensible precautions and look out for each other. As long as Slutwalk is a message of support for people against crime, I like it. But if Slutwalk is simply railing against a field of criminology research, then it is against sense and reason, and is the moral equivalent of telling people to tape hundred dollar bills and walk down urban alleyways to see what happens to them. After all, you have the right.
2
3
Rating: -1
R U Kiddingme
@rin

Those instructions would be useful as well as clever if universally followed but as long as dysfunctional, abusive parenting continues in the world, leaving the infants to be parented by peers, said world shall continue to suffer the creation of boorish, violent, sadistic and/or unintelligent men.

As a man of conscience, sort of, it irks and saddens me to, say, get into an elevator with a woman and have her put up an automatic self protective invisible shield, or to know that I am the reason why she is walking faster down the street to get to her car. It is a sickening feeling actually. It makes me feel guilty and then annoyed at feeling guilty.

But I get why women tighten up around men. My sex does pretty much all of the raping and killing, statistically. It would be absolutely stupid for women to not be on guard around people they don't know.

I cannot bitch and whine about that, and say, oh poor me, why must I be blamed for the way I look? Should I start a NotGuiltyWalk to support the hurt feelings of the men who aren't misogynists or at least hate the genders equally?

I hope it is obvious why that would be a bad idea.
5
2
Rating: +3
Stacy Long
Thank you for bringing up some interesting points, RUKiddingMe. I hope they lead to some fruitful discussion on how men could be involved in Slut Walk.

But I need to point out that you are wrong for doubting that a sexual assault victim's manner of dress could not be used against her in a court of law.

It may not be a widely condoned form of legal defense, but punishing the victim for her choice of clothing happens more frequently than you'd think.

In Winnipeg earlier this year, Justice Robert Dewar rejected a Crown recommendation that a rapist should be sentenced to at least three years in prison and instead granted him a conditional sentence.

Judge Dewar's reason for letting the rapist get off easy?

Dewar said the victim and a friend were dressed in tube tops and high heels "and made it publicly known that they wanted to party."

More info here: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1361248/Judge-facing-calls-resig...

And here: http://www.torontosun.com/news/canada/2011/02/26/17418376.html

I know that you were probably unaware of this case as I was until recently too, but before you make a claim in a public forum, please do a quick Google search to double-check your facts.
1
3
Rating: -2
kaur
I just love how newspapers report a fraction of a complicated legal court case to sensationalize it and give sensationalists fodder for their cause. I notice that feminists are mobilized and ready for action, adrenaline pumped, for anything that promotes men as brutes. The reality is that most men who rape are mentally disturbed and are victims themselves who need help.

Heaven forbid that we should ever help a man, but ultimately this approach helps all women.

As a women, It disturbs me that females (especially younger ones) feel that they have to dress like sluts these days. This is a sad trend that showcases women's lack of self esteem and the failure on the part of modern day feminists to help women.

Instead, it's about finger pointing and resources are spent on the blame game and victimhood perpetuation.
1
5
Rating: -4
cuz
@R U Kidding Me Sorry you feel guilty because someone doesn't trust people. Other people do what they do because they are in charge of what they do, not because of your mere presence - so don't ever feel guilty about something you haven't done. That is bowing down to the self righteous PC crowd. Yes, it is sad, but it is not your fault. Just yesterday I got a forwarded email about some "conscious" men apologizing to all the women of the world for the oppression they feel. I immediately deleted it. Again, it is sad that women feel oppressed. Heck, I even understand it. But for me to apologize for something I didn't do is to give up my personal power as a human in order to appease someone else. What's the point of that??? I am tired of people trying to make me feel guilty about something someone else did to them - whatever the issue. I do my part to make the world a better place. It's time for the human race to go back to the concept of personal responsibility - whether it is the perpetrator committing the deed or the victim placing the blame.
3
2
Rating: +1
Been there
As an anti-rape activist, and a woman who has been assaulted, I think it would have been far more poignant and powerful (but less media-worthy) had participants of all these slut walks been invited to simply wear what they'd been wearing when they were assaulted. Then the cop's comment would really have been illuminated for what it was - buying into rape myths that it's what we wear that put us at risk. Instead, at least in Toronto, you had a costumey effect -- "look at me! i'm wearing mesh panty hose and short skirts, and mugging for the cameras" - and honestly, i felt even more silenced as a survivor. Vancouver, do it differently - instead of posting articles like "what should you wear to slut walk" like it's a freaking party, go into your friend's closet, your mom's closet, your grandmother's - look at what they're wearing at home, at school, at work and then realize that's what you wear at slutwalk. don't buy into the myth yourself that it's nightclub attire, that's it's going to be a stranger 'misinterpreting' what you're wearing - the guy who rapes you is likely the one you know, maybe you love, and you'll be wearing the same crap outfit you wore last week.
1
3
Rating: -2
timber wolf
well let me start by saying that i have a old way of thinking about rapest,people who abuse women and children we convict them then we house them feed them which i find too be a waste of time energy and money i think charlie daniels says it best in his song simple man take a lisen too it if you wish but i think he has the right idea.
1
3
Rating: -2
Tabatha Iko
Victim blaming by a civil servant is simply unacceptable. Kudos to the organizers of the SlutWalk for holding the police accountable and mobilizing both men and women in the fight to end violence against women. Whether a woman wears a short skirt or a plastic bag, women who are raped are not to blame. In breaking down the dominant paradigm of victim blaming the SlutWalk is a great vehicle to get the message across: rape will stop when men stop raping. period.
1
2
Rating: -1

Pages

Add new comment
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.