Commentary | HST

Gordon Campbell: Why the HST, why now?

Gordon Campbell.

Stephen Hui

By Gordon Campbell

July 1 is the first full day the Harmonized Sales Tax takes effect and I know that most British Columbians are concerned about what it will mean to them and for their family budget. I understand British Columbians from every region have expressed frustration and anger about how the HST was implemented. I know you have many questions for our government and for me personally. Why did we say we were not considering an HST before the election? What made us change our position? Why are we bringing in the HST when much of the public opposes it? How will the HST impact my family? You deserve answers to all these questions.

Although you may not have seen much media coverage before last summer, combining the PST and GST to create a harmonized sales tax is something that has been discussed publicly for many years. Federal governments - past and present - and business organizations - large and small across the province - repeatedly asked us to harmonize the PST with the GST because it eliminates unnecessary costs, reduces administration and is more transparent.

Views on the HST

Philip Hochstein: B.C. HST is a self-compensating tax hike

Rick Jeffery: HST will help coastal forest industry in B.C.

Jock Finlayson: Why the HST is smart tax policy for B.C.

John Winter: HST is key to a strong economy in B.C.

Chris Delaney: Finance Minister Colin Hansen’s magical HST land doesn’t exist

Bill Vander Zalm: Fight against HST is chance to take back democracy in B.C.

Each time we were asked, we said we would not consider it for two primary reasons. First, it would eliminate B.C.'s ability to set our own tax rate. Second, we wanted to be able to shape our tax regime with flexibility that would allow us to exempt certain goods and services from being taxable. It wasn't until last year that kind of flexibility was available.

After the election, the Minister of Finance and I were informed that the Province's financial situation had deteriorated significantly. I asked officials to find a way to meet our budget targets without cutting core services. By late May 2009, it was becoming clear that after months of discussion Ontario had negotiated new flexibility within the HST model. Through further discussions with the federal government, we learned of additional flexibility that would allow provinces to set their own tax rate, instead of adopting a national rate of 13 per cent. This allowed us to set our own rate at 12 per cent, the lowest in the country. We were also offered new flexibility that would allow us to exempt products we felt would be important to families - children-sized clothing and footwear, books, motor fuel, diapers, car seats and a range of other products. In addition, the federal government offered $1.6 billion in transition funding. That meant we could reduce the future debt we would pass on to our children and support increased funding to both health care and education.

With those new conditions in place, we asked ourselves if the HST would strengthen the Province's economy as we move through the global economic downturn. Would the HST allow our industries and small businesses to better compete internationally and within Canada? Would it create jobs? Would it give business the ability to pay higher wages and lower prices? Study after study confirmed the HST would do all those things. World-renowned economist Jack Mintz from the University of Calgary found that moving to an HST will create more than 110,000 jobs, attract over $11 billion in new investment, increase wages and lower prices.

Those working in small business, forestry, mining, energy, agriculture, retail, transportation and construction will realize immediate and direct benefits. For the rest of us, the stronger economy will mean more job opportunities, stronger communities and more revenues to support critical public services. The HST, combined with our other tax reductions, will soon make British Columbia one of the most attractive places to invest and do business anywhere in the world.

I know many people feel like they are paying more and getting less. That's why over the last nine years our government has acted to leave more of people's hard-earned wages in their pockets. We've cut income taxes by at least 37 per cent for individuals since 2001, and British Columbians now pay the lowest personal income taxes in the country if you earn less than $118,000. The after-tax size of an average British Columbian's paycheque today is considerably higher than it was in 2001. An individual earning $50,000 a year pays $2,012 less in provincial income taxes today. That's more than $2,000 for individuals to save or spend as they choose. Cutting taxes has helped our economy stay strong enough that we've been able to make record investments into health care and education.

The HST has not been good short-term politics. But in the end, everyone has to decide whether they are going to do what is right or what is easy. I believe the HST is the right thing for our Province's economy and for our children's future. Change today will make us stronger tomorrow.

Gordon Campbell is the premier of British Columbia and the leader of the B.C. Liberal Party.

Comments

bev
I am now taking the Georgia Straight OFF my Twitter list. Goodbye
 
Bruce McAra
Mr Campbell, you gave up the right to change the rate for 3 years before even considering the fairness of the tax. That locked the province into this particular HST strategy with no flexibility to adjust after study and debate. Your took the voters of the province for granted and underestimated the backlash that occurred. This is a lot more than just poor communication it is poor policy making.
 
Frank
"I asked officials to find a way to meet our budget targets without cutting core services"

Then what happened to our core services? Why were arts and education dealt such a blow?
 
Michael Watkins
Gordon Campbell rolls out the unbelievable, hoping that his cloak of plausible deniabilty is still on: "After the election, the Minister of Finance and I were informed that the Province's financial situation had deteriorated significantly. "

I - don't - believe - you. What's more important, British Columbians do not believe you or in you.

During Election 09 you were still the premier and Colin Hansen was still Minister of Finance, election campaign or not. If as you claim a sudden and significant deterioration in the Province's finances had materialized out of thin air, with no warning whatsoever, such a material development would have been communicated to you.

Before the election in FY2008 and FY2009 federal revenues had been falling off a cliff at a rate not seen in more than a decade. Those were not normal times. The unprecedented fall in government revenue led to almost 60 billion in new federal debt in FY2008 and that number was already growing in the first two months of FY2009. Equity markets had plummeted, borrowing had become all but impossible, and of specific concern to B.C., resource prices across the board had sunk like a blown up oil rig to the bottom of the sea. Provincial revenue had to have been following along the very same path as federal revenue and you had to have known all of this heading into election 2009.

Despite every opportunity to raise the obvious issue, your campaign did not. Talk about fudge-it budgets, your campaign managed to avoid the giant elephant in the room and studiously avoided talking about how you would address revenue shortfalls.

The people of British Columbia do not appreciate being told such outrageous lies and your government must fall for that reason alone, regardless of the potential merits of the HST.
 
Gordo is not God
Way to support Campbells agenday GS! Why don't you post stories from the 800,000 people who OPPOSE the HST! All this is is free publicity for the Campbell Cronie Gov.

RECALL IN THE FALL!!!!!!
 
Birdy
Dear Lordo Gordo The Globalist Great,

You're supposed to REPRESENT the citizens of BC, not impose what you think is best for us.

You're a public servant. Do you understand the concept of that term? It's not a synonym for authority or dictator. It means your job is to do what we say.

"...the federal government offered $1.6 billion in transition funding. That meant we could reduce the future debt we would pass on to our children and support increased funding to both health care and education. "

Indeed we could... Yet you're cutting education, spending over $1 BILLION on new prisons, and racking up massive amounts of debt while canoodling with the IMF boys at your first Bilderberg meeting. You're building a huge new casino while cutting the gaming money that used to go to the Arts and charities.

We're going to recall your lemming party members now, and when the NDP (Nanny-state Dependence Party) win the next election, if they screw around like they always do and fail to repeal the HST immediately we'll just recall them as well. Enough is enough, no one believes you or Carole James anymore. Stepping down and having Falcon run for Premier won't work either.

Despite my criticisms and sarcasm, I'd like to honestly thank you and your HST flip-flop for being the catalyst that got BC citizens interested in Provincial politics again.

ps: You and Colin should check out Kumon Learning, because apparently you both have trouble with math.
http://www.kumon.com/
 
Conrad Blunt
Resistance to the HST is largely based in the public's cynical view of politicians. We all know that the Government is touting the "experts" who support the HST and disregard the truth that without exception, every tax hits the consumer directly. It is all a repetition of the GST pitch. ie: lower prices on food, homes, cars and general prosperity. We all know where that has gone.
The only reason for this tax, imposed in the most deceitful manner is to help pay for useless programs, bloated ministries and disgustingly overpaid bureaucrats.
 
Argulion
On the personal level, the only 'good' I've seen come from this HST fiasco is the 1 in 4 British Columbians that live at or near the poverty line will get a rebate that might offset most of their increased costs. And I think the above 25% ratio is another good reason for a recall campaign.
 
not convinced
Yes Gordo, "the federal government offered $1.6 billion in transition funding. That meant we could reduce the future debt we would pass on to our children and support increased funding to both health care and education."
You forgot to add that instead of using it for health care and education, you immediately spent the entire amount on big business welfare: $.6 billion for a retractable roof and $1 billion in new oil and gas industry subsidies.
 
NDB
"After the election, the Minister of Finance and I were informed that the Province's financial situation had deteriorated significantly. I asked officials to find a way to meet our budget targets without cutting core services. By late May 2009, it was becoming clear that after months of discussion Ontario had negotiated new flexibility within the HST model"

Gordon....dont you get it? No one believes this! The vast majority feels you are a lier. Why do you feel you are the only smart guy in the room? Do you not think that 700,000 people who disagree with you are maybe right and you are wrong?

You have already become the most hated politician in BCs history, and the liberal government will topple. Why? In the end the voters have the power.
 
Lorenzo
As a person that voted Liberal in the last election I will that you dont understand the people that voted for Liberals. It doesnt matter how much you try to sell the HST we know you LIED! I am not sure if you are arrogant or just plain stupid but this HST issue is going to kill the Liberals in BC. If you dont believe this I am glad that the recall is coming because we need a leader that is TRUTHFULLY and listening the majority of the people in a democratic country.
Liberals knew the HST was coming but knew if they mentioned it before the election they would have lost. Now you expect us to buy this garbage when we know you LIED. You mismanaged the province and the HST was your only escape. When the recall happens in the fall and the Liberal party starts to crumble please dont resign like a COWARD but stay and face the music. The HST will be gone in BC whether its by recall or the next election but at the end it will be done. The Liberal party will be destroyed and you have nobody to blame but yourself.
 
UWSofty
What a load of bunk. For a spin-free analysis read this great blog http://bc2013.com/2010/06/29/sachas-spin-free-discussion-on-hst/
 
ds
What happened to all the money you got back when you tore up all the contracts and rolled back the wages? Oh, I forgot, you gave yourself a wage and pension increase. GOES TO SHOW A PERSON WHAT A BLACK CAMPBELL IS!!! HOW DO YOU KNOW WHEN IT'S B.S.? HIS MOUTH IS OPEN.
 
Birdy
Here's a list of the businesses that just filed a judicial review of the anti-HST petition, to "determine whether the draft bill is constitutionally valid" It's wayyy too long to copy and post here.

http://festiverants.wordpress.com/2010/06/30/b-c-business-community-come...
 
John M.
@UWSoftly: That article explicitly says "Q: Aren’t consumption taxes “better” than income taxes?
A: Not necessarily."

YES YES YES. Consumption taxes are *always* better than income taxes. Few (if any) serious economist argues otherwise. "Spin-free", I see.
 
G.J. W.
With the two taxes combined, the budget and the HST, the burden will be onerous, to the less fortunate. Campbell and Hansen would have the BC people to believe, one small province in the entire globe, escaped the recession, in very good shape, when the rest of the world crashed. Like, the BC Rail, would not be sold. The provincial deficit, another lie. The HST, wasn't on Campbell and Hansen's radar. Blacking out the FOI papers, to conceal the Olympic debt. The missing e-mails, regarding, the corrupt sale of the BC Rail. We see millions of our tax dollars, being given to, banks, large corporations, gas and oil company's. They also are given huge tax reductions, and now the HST. We see Campbell, Hansen and the BC Liberals, as a dictatorship government, the same as Hitler and his henchmen ran. Dictators, do evil things, to good people. The BC Liberals, have certainly proved that point. Campbell does nothing for this province, unless it benefits him and, his business buddies. I nearly gagged when Campbell said, he must keep BC strong, for our children's future. Are these the same children living in poverty for the past nine years, that he has ignored? The HST, goes directly to Harper, there will be no advantages, for the BC citizens. The HST was designed for big business, and big business only. Don't forget, Campbell is Harper's boy. Harper said, no to the HST, then turned around and gave Campbell $1.6 billion, to force the HST, on BC citizens, that have lost everything they had. Harper, Iggy, Campbell and Hansen, all lied to the people about the HST. They are all, snakes in the grass.
 
adibese
Why do all these pro-hsters mention lowered income taxes? The government isn't lowering income taxes. Hansen said it *might* be something that *may* be considered sometime in the future. All that has happened is consumption taxes have increased and income taxes have remained the same.
 
Gord-oh
Time to skim the cream off the top. Recall this greedy thug.
 
 
[Comments Disclaimer]
Post a comment
· Use your real name to have your comment considered for publication in print.
· URLs and email addresses will be automatically turned into links.