Report examines violence against immigrant women in Canada

A new report calls on Canadians to confront the abuse faced by many women in immigrant communities.

“Most advocates and activists for female victims of abuse shy away from challenging the immigrant communities to examine their own traditions and cultural values in explaining the violence in their homes,” Toronto-based social worker Aruna Papp says in a statement today (July 12).

In her 20-page report, Culturally-Driven Violence Against Women: A Growing Problem in Canada’s Immigrant Communities, Papp focuses on abuse in South Asian homes.

She examines the prevalence of “honour killings”, criticizing law enforcement officials for how they approach cases where a man has murdered his wife or daughter.

“They deliberately avoid cultural finger-pointing: for law enforcement, murder is murder,” Papp writes.

“Honour killings, however, are distinct from domestic violence or child abuse,” she adds, noting the murders can relate to conflicts over wearing makeup, attending parties or clothing choices.

In Canada, at least 12 women have been victims of honour killings since 2002, the report says. Papp highlights the B.C. case of 17-year-old Amandeep Singh Atwal who in 2003 was murdered by her father because of her interest in dating a classmate who was not a Sikh.

Also included in the report, released today by the non-profit Frontier Centre for Public Policy, is a series of recommendations.

The recommendations emphasize the need for training sessions to educate women coming to Canada about their rights and gender equality, as well as shelters for females abused by members of their extended family.

The report also calls for court-ordered counselling programs for men taken into custody for domestic violence, and more action from South Asian community leaders.

Comments

12 Comments

dhcongrave

Jul 12, 2010 at 6:01pm

Much of this abuse is due to an excess of political correctness and multiculturalism (versus "melting pot") Canadians are too naive and ignorant of the customs and culture of other countries and think that "respect" of another's beliefs is absolute not relative.
Dave

ahutt57@hotmail.com

Jul 12, 2010 at 11:31pm

I like many other Canadians are tired of all these immigrants not becoming Canadian and respecting the Canadian way of life. We should stop all immigration.

Amen

Jul 13, 2010 at 4:45am

I'm glad the focus is going to finally turn where it is necessary, as opposed to vilifying every male on this planet for the actions of a remote few.

However, it is still peppered with the feminist control propaganda we've gotten quite sick of over the last 40 years. Stick to the issue, this isn't a Christmas tree to hang every wing nut's wish list to.

As for the shelters, there are a lot. You just have to kick the crackhead abusive women out to make room and Bob (Roberta?)'s your uncle. Or aunt...or tranny, or whatever.

kthx

NB

Jul 13, 2010 at 8:11am

Canada lets political correctness rule to the point where freedom of religion rules everything including primitive beliefs which fuel violence against woman. Our government needs to be much more vocal to all immigrants that if they chose to come to our country they must respect our laws and beliefs. I see mini gettos forming in Canada which almost go completely by their own rules.

IMO things are going to get worse not better unless we take hard stance against aspects of other cultures and religions which go against our Canadian values.

Krystle

Jul 13, 2010 at 9:59am

Part of the problem, which is not discussed here, is the internalized racism which can come out of law enforcement.
This prevents immigrant people (particularly women) from contacting the police as they may be viewed as racist and counter-productive.

flyboy

Jul 13, 2010 at 1:06pm

Some of the worst violence against immigrant women can be found on your computer. Just go to Craigslist, click erotic services, and hundreds of contacts for sexual services will appear. If you call a few of the numbers, you will soon realize that most of them are answered by asian males. These are nothing more than places where immigrant women are held against their will and forced into sexual slavery. They are enticed into coming to Canada for some legitimate work, then when they arrive, their passports are taken, and their families back home are threatened if the police are notified. SEXUAL SLAVERY IS ALIVE AND THRIVING IN CANADA.

Rod

Jul 14, 2010 at 7:51am

Its interesting the minister says "honor killings have no place in Canada". It is just plain stupid to start categorizing murders in the criminal code. Also, provinces are free to ignore the criminal code if they wish to. For example Saskatchewan allows, promotes and even sanctions polygamy in their family courts, which is a crime according to the criminal code. They use section 51 of their family property act to justify judicial sanctioning of polygamy.So, any province might just "adjust" their laws against murder with legislation that allows it?

BC

Jul 14, 2010 at 3:30pm

Domestic violence and "honour" killings are as much a part of White Canada as they are of immigrant communities. Any attempt to fob this off as un-Canadian is to ignore the scores of White women killed by their spouses every year, see the Statistics Canada Report in 2007 for all the details you can use. www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/85-224-x/85-224-x2007000-eng.pdf

When a White man kills his partner/family member, it's domestic homicide. When a Brown man kills his partner/family member, it is an honour killing. This is an artificial distinction that serves no one, especially the immigrant community which is now set apart as backward and un-Canadian, even though all statistics show that violence against women exercised as a form of power and control is as Canadian as hockey!

R U Kiddingme

Jul 14, 2010 at 4:45pm

@Krystal

First, your post has a logic error, i.e. if racism is shown by law enforcement, then it isn't internalized, by definition.

Secondly, women from many immigrant countries don't fear the "racism" of Canadian police. They fear the impunity, violence, arbitrariness, corruption, indifference, and misogyny of the police that they knew at home. Except in the industrialized west, it is pointless or even dangerous to complain of spousal abuse against men. In countries that follow sharia law, a woman's evidence is legally half the weight of a man's. In countries with authoritarian, masculine-dominated traditions -- which is, let's face it, all of them -- women's rights are only now becoming vaguely recognized.

bobsan

Jul 22, 2010 at 2:58pm

@ BC

thanks for your comments. Intelligent and based on facts, unlike the ignorant bigots whose comments precede your.

The group that Aruna Papp works for, The Frontier Centre for Public Policy, is a rightwing neoconservative western Canada based "think"-tank (pun intended). It's policies are just what the KKKonservative party and its leader Herr Harper profess.