York University professors and students reject claims of antisemitism
Nearly 200 York University faculty members and students have signed a petition rejecting a claim by Citizenship and Immigration Minister Jason Kenney and others that the campus has become a hotbed of antisemitism. Their petition appears below:
Faculty and students reject the smearing of York, and uphold the
University’s mission to promote public debate
Over the course of the past year, York University has been targeted in
various public spaces as a site where antisemitism is rife. In a
September 12, 2009 advertisement in the National Post, B’nai Brith
Canada offers a “checklist” of antisemitic incidents likely to occur
on university campuses. Jewish students are told they can “expect ...
harassment ... intimidation by your professor or teaching assistant
... Swastikas and other antisemitic graffiti all over campus”.
Concocted accounts of “violent anti-Jewish riots at York University”
(in the words of the Jerusalem Post, February 15, 2009) have become
widespread.
Federal cabinet minister Jason Kenney was quoted just a
few weeks ago (Thornhill Liberal, September 11, 2009) as describing
what was going on at York as resembling “pogroms”.
The use of such inflammatory language cannot any longer be ignored and
allowed to fester. Its implications could be seen when the National
Post ran a piece earlier this year (Matt Gurney, February 13, 2009)
that actually called for York to be “purged of its hateful elements".
The fact is that representations of the York campus--and indeed
university campuses generally--as hotbeds of antisemitism are simply
untrue.
The B’nai Brith “checklist,” like the allegations of
“antisemitic” acts at York, let alone “riots’ or “pogroms”, are
entirely inaccurate, if not libelous, and amount to nothing but
fear-mongering. Notably, the B’Nai Brith advertisement featured a
photo of a rally in York’s central hall in which some Palestinian
national symbols could be seen, but no antisemitic imagery whatsoever.
As teachers and researchers at York, Jewish and non-Jewish, we do not,
and will not, tolerate antisemitism or any other forms of racism or
discrimination on this campus. But at the same time, we strongly
defend our university’s long-cherished mission to promote public
debate, including debate on contentious political issues.
We deplore attempts to use misinformation and fear, let alone the accompanying call for “purges”, to stifle academic freedom.
Signatories:
Faculty:
1. Adrian Shubert, Professor, History
2. Alan Simmons, Professor, Sociology
3. Allan C. Hutchinson, Distinguished Research Professor, Osgoode
Hall Law School
4. Allan Greenbaum, contract faculty, Social Science and Sociology
5. Allyson M. Lunny, Assistant Professor, Law & Society Program,
York University
6. Amanda Glasbeek, Assistant Professor, Social Science
7. Amnon Buchbinder, Associate Professor and Chair, Film
8. Ananya Mukherjee Reed, Associate Professor, Political Science
9. Anna Zalik, Assistant Professor, Environmental Studies
10. Arun P. Mukherjee, Professor, Department of English
11. Barbara Cameron, Associate Professor, York University
12. Barbara Godard, Professor Emerita and Senior Scholar of English,
French, Women's Studies, Social and Political Thought; Historica Chair
in Canadian Literature Emerita.
13. Barbara Rahder, Dean, Faculty of Environmental Studies
14. Bonita Lawrence, Associate Professor, Coordinator of the
Undergraduate Degree Program in Race, Ethnicity and Indigenous Studies
15. Bonnie Kettel, Associate Professor, Faculty of Environmental Studies
16. Brenda Longfellow, Associate Professor, Department of Film
17. Bruce Ryder, Associate Professor and Assistant Dean First Year,
Osgoode Hall Law School
18. Caitlin Fisher, Canada Research Chair, Associate Professor, Film
19. Carl Baar, Adjunct Professor, Political Science
20. Carla Lipsig-Mumme, Professor of Work and Labour Studies.
21. Carlota McAllister, Assistant Professor, Anthropology
22. Claudio Durán, Senior Scholar
23. Colin Mooers, Professor and Director, Graduate Program in
Communication and Culture
24. Craig Scott, Director, Nathanson Centre on Transnational Rights,
Crime and Security, and Professor, Osgoode Hall Law School
25. Cynthia Wright, contract faculty, School of Women's Studies
26. Daniel Drache, Professor, Political Science, and Associate
Director, Robarts Centre for Canadian Studies
27. Daphne Winland, PhD, Associate Professor, Graduate Program
Director, Social Anthropology, Chair, Human Participants Ethics Review
Committee
28. David Langille, Course Director, Division of Social Sciences
29. David McNally, Professor, Department of Political Science
30. David Mutimer, Associate Professor of Political Science, and
Deputy Director, York Centre for International and Security Studies.
31. David Shugarman, Professor, Political Science
32. David Szablowski, Assistant Professor, Social Science
33. Dawn Bazely, Associate Professor of Biology
34. Dayna Nadine Scott, Assistant Professor, Osgoode Hall Law School
and the Faculty of Environmental Studies
35. Douglas Hay, Professor, Osgoode Hall Law School and Department of History
36. Douglas Young, Assistant Professor of Social Science
37. Derek Hrynyshyn, Adjunct Faculty, Political Science
38. Eduardo Canel, Associate Professor, Social Science, and Director,
Centre for Research on Latin America and the Caribbean
39. Elizabeth Lunstrum, Assistant Professor, Geography
40. Enda Brophy, Postdoctoral Fellow, Political Science
41. Esteve Morera, Associate Professor Department of Philosophy and
Department of Political Science
42. Gail Fraser, Associate Professor, Environmental Studies
43. Gamal Abdel-Shehid, Kinesiology, York University
44. Gene Desfor, Professor Emeritus, Environmental Studies
45. George C. Comninel, Associate Professor and Chair, Department of
Political Science
46. Gerald Kernerman, Associate Professor, Political Science
47. Greg Albo, Associate Professor, York University
48. Gus Van Harten, Associate Professor, Osgoode Hall Law School
49. Haideh Moghissi, Professor and Associate Dean, Faculty of Liberal
Arts and Professional Studies
50. Harry Glasbeek, Professor Emeritus and Senior Scholar, Osgoode Hall
51. Himani Bannerji, Professor, Department of Sociology
52. Howard Daugherty, Associate Professor, Environmental Studies
53. Ilan Kapoor, Associate Professor, Environmental Studies
54. J. David Wood, Prof. Emeritus, Geography
55. J.J. McMurtry, Assistant Professor, Business and Society Program
56. James Laxer, Professor of Political Science, Department of Equity Studies
57. James Sheptycki, Professor, Criminology
58. Janet Owens, Contract Faculty, Social Science, and Environmental Studies
59. Janice Newton, Associate Professor, Political Science and School
of Women's Studies
60. Janine Marchessault, Canada Research Chair in Digital Media and
Globalization, Faculty of Fine Arts
61. Jennifer Foster, Assistant Professor, Environmental Studies
62. Jennifer Hyndman, Professor, Social Science
63. Jody Berland, Associate Professor, Department of Humanities, and
Editor, Canadian Journal of Cultural Studies
64. Joe Sheridan, Associate Professor, Environmental Studies
65. John Greyson, Associate Professor, Film
66. John S. Saul, Professor Emeritus, Social Science and Political Science
67. John Simoulidis, Contract Faculty, Social Science
68. Jon Sufrin, Adjunct Professor, Humanities
69. Jonathan Nitzan, Associate Professor of Political Economy,
Political Science
70. Judith Adler Hellman, Professor, Social Science and Political Science
71. Karen Murray, Associate Professor, Political Science
72. Kevin Moloney, Contract Faculty, Deptartment of Languages,
Literatures & Linguistics
73. L. Anders Sandberg, Associate Dean and Professor, Faculty of
Environmental Studies
74. Laam Hae, Assistant Professor, Political Science
75. Lee Lorch, FRSC,Professor Emeritus, Senior Scholar, Mathematics
76. Leesa Fawcett, Associate Professor, Environmental Studies
77. Leo Panitch, Distinguished Research Professor, Senior Canada
Research Chair, Political Science
78. Lesley J. Wood, Assistant Professor, Department of Sociology
79. Liette Gilbert, Associate Professor, PhD Coordinator and
Associate Dean, Faculty of Environmental Studies
80. Liora Salter, FRSC, Professor, Osgoode Hall Law School
81. Lorna Erwin, Associate Professor of Sociology, York University
82. Lorna Weir, Professor, Department of Sociology
83. Louis Lefeber, Professor of Economics and Graduate Program for
Social and Political Thought (emeritus)
84. Luin Goldring, Associate Professor, Sociology
85. Malcolm Blincow, Associate Professor, Anthropology
86. Marcela S.Duran, Community Practicum Coordinator, Concurrent
Program, Faculty of Education
87. Marcia Rioux, Professor, School Health Policy and Management and
Director, York Institute for Health Research
88. Maria Legerstee, Professor, Department of Psychology
89. Marilyn L. Pilkington, Associate Professor and former Dean,
Osgoode Hall Law School
90. Marion Werner, Researcher, Gender and Work Database Project at
York University
91. Mark J. Goodman, Department of Sociology and Coordinator, Human
Rights and Equity Studies, Department of Equity Studies
92. Mark Thomas, Associate Professor, Sociology
93. Martin Breaugh, Assistant Professor, Political Science.
94. Martin J. Bunch, Associate Professor, Environmental Studies
95. Martin Thomas, Associate Professor, School of Public Policy and
Administration
96. Mary Jane Mossman, Professor, Osgoode Hall Law School
97. Michael Mandel, Professor, Osgoode Hall Law School
98. Michael Nijhawan, Associate Professor, Sociology
99. Michael Ornstein, Associate Professor, Sociology
100. Nalini Persram, Associate Professor, Social Science
101. Nick Lary, Emeritus Professor, Humanities
102. Nicola Short, Associate Professor, Political Science
103. Norene Pupo, Director, Centre for Research on Work & Society
104. Obiora Okafor, Professor, Osgoode Hall Law School
105. Patricia Wood, Associate Professor, Geography
106. Paul Antze, Associate Professor, Department of Social Science
107. Penni Stewart, Associate Professor, Sociology
108. Peter Vandergeest, Associate Professor, Geography
109. Peter Victor, Professor, Environmental Studies
110. Radhika Mongia, Associate Professor, and Director,
Graduate Program in Sociology
111. Raju J Das, Associate Professor, Department of Geography
112. Ravi de Costa, Assistant Professor, Faculty of Environmental Studies
113. Ricardo Grinspun, Associate Professor, Economics
114. Richard Saunders, Associate Professor, Political Science
115. Robert Latham, Associate Professor, Political Science, and
Director of the York Center for International and Security Studies
116. Robert MacDermid, Associate Professor, Political Science
117. Robin Roth, Associate Professor, Geography
118. Rodney Loeppky, Associate Professor, Political Science
119. Roger Keil, Professor, Environmental Studies, and
Director, The City Institute and The Canadian Center for German and
European Studies
120. Rosemary J. Coombe, Senior Canada Research Chair in Law,
Communication and Culture
121. Sabah Alnasseri, Associate Chair, Professor, Department of
Political Science, Faculty of Liberal Arts and Professional Studies
122. Saeed Rahnema, Professor, Political Science
123. Sam Gindin, Packer Visiting Chair in Social Justice,
Political Science
124. Sandra Whitworth, Professor, Political Science
125. Scott Forsyth, Associate Professor, Film and Political Science
126. Sergei Plekhanov, Associate Professor, Political Science
127. Sergey N. Krylov, Professor, Canada Research Chair in
Bioanalytical Chemistry, and Director, Centre for Research on
Biomolecular Interactions
128. Shubhra Gururani, Associate Professor, Anthropology
129. Stanley Jeffers, Associate Professor Emeritus, Senior
Scholar, Department of Physics and Astronomy
130. Stefan Kipfer, Associate Professor, Environmental Studies
131. Stepan Wood, Associate Professor, Osgoode Hall Law School
132. Stephanie Ross, Assistant Professor, Coordinator, Labour
Studies Programme, Division of Social Science
133. Stephen Hellman, Professor, Political Science
134. Steven Tufts, Assistant Professor, Department of Geography
135. Susan Drummond, Associate Professor, Osgoode Hall Law School
136. Tania Das Gupta, Chair and Associate Professor, Department
of Equity Studies and Department of Sociology
137. Teresa Holmes, Associate Professor, Department of Anthropology
138. Terry Goldie, Professor, English
139. Wenona Giles, Professor, Centre for Refugee Studies,
Anthropology Department, Faculty of Liberal and Professional Studies
Students:
1. Aaron SanFilippo, Student
2. Adam Hilton, MA Political Science
3. Adrienne Roberts, PhD candidate, Political Science
4. Aidan Conway, Doctoral Candidate, Political Science
5. Albert R. Gaudio, MA Candidate, Political Science
6. Andrea Hopkins, MA Candidate, Political Science) and York
Centre for International and Security Studies Graduate Researcher
7. Andrea Sellinger, Political Science, MA Student
8. Baris Karaagac, PhD Candidate, Political Science
9. Brad Bauerly, PhD Candidate, Political Science
10. Bryony Halpin, PhD Candidate, Environmental Studies
11. Chris Vance, Ph.D. Candidate, Political Science
12. Claire Major, PhD Candidate, Geography
13. Cory Jansson, Phd student, Political Science
14. Dan Freeman-Maloy, PhD Candidate, Political Science
15. Daniel Moure, PhD Candidate, Political Science
16. Dave Campanella, Student, Environmental Studies
17. Derek Maisonville, Doctoral Candidate, Political
Science/Researcher, York Centre for International and Security Studies
18. Diana Abraham, PhD Student, Environmental Studies
19. Gabriel Levine, Doctoral student, Social and Political Thought
20. Genevieve LeBaron, Doctoral Candidate, Political Science
21. Graham Potts, PhD Candidate, Social and Political Thought,
22. Ian Hussey, PhD candidate, Sociology
23. Irina Ceric, PhD Candidate and Adjunct Professor, Osgoode Hall Law School
24. Isaac Asume Osuoka, Canada Vanier Scholar, Environmental Studies
25. Janine MacLeod, PhD Student, Environmental Studies
26. Janna Promislow, Adjunct Professor and PhD Candidate, Osgoode
Hall Law School
27. Japji Anna Bas, PhD Candidate, Environmental Studies
28. Jasmin Mujanovic, Political Science Graduate Student
29. Jesse Ovadia, PhD Candidate, Political Science
30. Jessica Parish, Phd Candidate, Political Science
31. John Carlaw, PhD Candidate, Political Science
32. Jordan Brennan, Tutorial Instructor, Political Science
33. Jordy Cummings, Student, Graduate Department of Political Science
34. Kathleen Mullen, MFA Student
35. Kaushalya Bannerji, Ph.D. Candidate, Law
36. Kole Kilibarda, PhD candidate and Teaching Assistant, Political Science
37. Mazen Masri, PhD Candidate, Osgoode Hall Law School
38. Michael Skinner, Researcher, York Centre for International and
Security Studies
39. Natasha Jerome, Undergraduate Degree Candidate, Honours Double
Major: Philosophy & Political Science, Faculty of Arts
40. Nchamah Miller, B.A., M.A. (york Alumni), Visiting Professor,
Institute of Philosophy of University Havana
41. Nicole Cohen, PhD Candidate, Graduate Program in Communication and Culture
42. Nishant Upadhyay, PhD Candidate, Social and Political Thought
43. Noaman Ali, MA Student, Social and Political Thought
44. Pablo Vivanco, Student, MES
45. Peter Brogan, PhD Candidate, Geography
46. Rade Zinaic, Social and Political Thought
47. Roxana Salehi PhD Candidate, Environmental Studies
48. Ryan James, PhD Candidate and Teaching Assistant, Anthropology
49. Ryan O'Neill, PhD Candidate, Environmental Studies
50. Simon Granovsky-Larsen, Ph.D. Candidate, Political Science
51. Simon Tremblay-Pepin, PhD student, Political Science Department
52. Sonja Killoran-McKibbin, PhD Student, Environmental Studies
53. Sophie Voegele, Graduate Student, Sociology
54. Stu Marvel, Chair, Graduate Law Students' Association, Osgoode
Hall Law School
55. Tania Hernandez-Cervantes, PhD Student, Environmental Studies
56. Teresa Abbruzzese, Doctoral Candidate, Environmental Studies
57. Tod Duncan , PhD Student/Teaching Assistant, Social and Political Thought
58. Tyler Shipley, Doctoral Candidate, Political Science
Comments
16 Comments
Toronto Bob
Oct 25, 2009 at 4:51am
In February, at York Univeristy, a mob chased a group of mostly Jewish students, shouting: “Israelis off campus,” “Racist Zionists,” “Die, bitch, go back to Israel,” “Die, Jew, get the hell off campus,” “Fucking Jew” and so forth.
The mob then besieged the Jewish students in the local Hillel office until the police arrived and freed them.
Was this a progrom? No. Progroms killed thousands of Jews. Was it an antisemitic riot? Yes.
Do these professors and students signing the petition care? Not a whit. For them, antisemitism is something someone else does.
student york
Oct 25, 2009 at 2:54pm
No, that is not true. There was a demonstration, but the slogans "die, bitch, go back to Israel", "die, Jew, get the hell of campus," & "fucking Jew" were not said. There has been no evidence that this was said. If you actually read the accounts of the media that were present during that demonstration none of them picked up any such slogans.
They were later embedded to make it seem like something it wasn't. It was exxaggerated and concoted. Think about it, the Israeli Lobby wants to create the image of there being huge amounts of anti-semitism in Canada and other countries because then Jewish people will fear Israel is the only safe place for them. It is in their interest to exxaggerate and concoct things like this to make it seem so. Ironically Israel is the least safe place for Jews.
ADHR
Oct 25, 2009 at 3:57pm
Except, Toronto Bob, no one has been able to prove that actually happened. It depends on who you want to believe.
Besides, shifting the goalposts to defend Kenney's remarks is pretty callow.
enough bullshit
Oct 25, 2009 at 10:01pm
"In February, at York Univeristy, a mob chased a group of mostly Jewish students, shouting: “Israelis off campus,” “Racist Zionists,” “Die, bitch, go back to Israel,” “Die, Jew, get the hell off campus,” “Fucking Jew” and so forth."
anyone who was there can tell you that NONE of that was said. clearly, toronto bob, you were NOT there.
Toronto Bob
Oct 26, 2009 at 12:52pm
ADHR, who's defending Kenney's hyperbole? If you'll read my post, I said there was no pogrom at York.
As for proof of what happened:
There was a news conference to announce that enough votes had been gathered from students at York to force the resignation of the Student Council.
Angered by the fact that the students at York were throwing them out of office, a mob gathered to suppress free speech by breaking up this news conference and to say “screw you” to the will of the York student body.
The mob pursued the mainly Jewish students through the hallways, shouting abuse at them. The Jewish students locked themselves in the Hillel Office until rescued by the police.
All this is part of the public record, readily available in the media. Here, for example: http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1233304788139&pagename=JPost/...
There was also a video on YouTube (since removed) of one of the leaders of the mob, literally in the face of one of the Jewish students, blocking his retreat, and screaming “Racist!” at him, from a distance of 3 inches - close enough for the verbal abuse to be accompanied by a stream of spittle.
The only dispute is over the exact terminology of the abuse. Explicit anti-Jewish abuse such as, “Die, Jew,” wasn't caught on tape, and so you do have to decide who to believe.
If you believe the victims, the mob made their antisemitism explicit. If you believe the junior fascists, then, yes, they were guilty of suppressing free speech, of verbal and physical abuse of their victims, but honest, they only screamed, “Die, Zionist,” not “Die, Jew.”
As for this petition, I’d take it seriously if they were calling for the expulsion of York’s junior fascists – particularly the one caught on video abusing the Jewish student. This sort of criminal behaviour is a far worse and more direct threat to free speech on campus than anything Jason Kenney has to say.
But rather than calling for their expulsion, several of the people signing this petition, paid the $150 fine that York imposed on the mob’s ringleader.
Really, things are not good at York. Not only are they trying to pretend that intimidation is free speech rather than its opposite, but they're also trying to erase the line between academic inquiry and propaganda.
See here, for example: http://www.hurryupharry.org/2009/07/03/academic-freedom-or-academic-circus/
JZ
Oct 26, 2009 at 10:06pm
These "victims" also called my friend the N-word. The DROP YFS had been making racist remarks towards students of colour for weeks before this happened. I conducted an interview with a pro-BDS individual on my radio show and members from DROP YFS surrounded the radio station and followed my female co-host to her car. There were a lot more dynamics that took place than what Toronto Bob said.
York Student from Vancouver
Oct 27, 2009 at 12:32am
I have attended York for numerous years, and have not once seen any sign of racial intolerance or bigotry. This is all spin - gross, unfounded spin. I'm anglo saxo, open minded and appreciative of everyone. I have not seen any antisemitism, nor anything negative towards other faiths. Why is this fictional antisemitism even being discussed?!
Toronto Bob
Oct 27, 2009 at 7:03am
The Drop YFS coaltion included people of colour.
The issue was that the York Federation of Students Council had been taken over by junior fascists. These radicals supported the striking contract faculty (led by another bunch of political radicals) who closed down the university for months with absurd wage demands.
Naturally, this made the student council unpopular with their fellow students.
The student council was also unpopular with large segments of the student body because of their support for the Hamas terrorist organization (a group which really does preach and practice the most vile forms of racism, with an open call for genocide against the Jews in their founding document).
WTF?
Oct 27, 2009 at 10:58am
Ok, you clearly don't understand any of the dynamics at York. I find it funny that you use the Jerusalem Post as a source for something that occurred at a university in Canada to start with.
Ok, where to begin? Ok, these "victims" came into a screening of Occupation 101 last week and laughed at images of dead Palestinian children. Of course the Jerusalem Post hasn't mentioned this. Ok...first off, this slate of so-called "junoir fascist" was re-elected after this event on Feb. 11 so they have immense support from the student body. They are a progressive slate, more socialist or social democratic than fascist but nevermind.
DROP YFS claims to have had people in coluor in it, but I have not seen any. Every day they were tabling they were ALL WHITE. Of course, you can go and get me quotes from an Israeli paper disputing this if you want.
Lastly, this studnet council did NOT ever support Hamas at any time or place. I have NO idea where you are getting your "facts". They passed a motion condeming Israel's excessive bombing of the Gaza Strip. I condemn the bombing personally, does that automatically mean I support Hamas by default or something? Seriously, you do not know what you are talking about. There is a rule I learned when I was young, "if you dont know what you are talking about don't talk"
RodSmelser
Oct 28, 2009 at 8:29am
Toronto Bob's use of fake sources pretty much says it all as far as the veracity of his claims are concerned.
He tips off the reader to his real motives when he mentions the York University CUPE strike. Anti union political strategists in both the Federal Conservative Party and the Ontario Liberals have been happily exploiting student anger over a lost semester and blaming it on the unions and the NDP for some time. By adding an anti-semitism complaint to the mix they are intensifying and broadening their use of this dispute for political purposes.
I am surprised actually that Toronto Bob didn't mention Sid Ryan. Maybe that will be in his next post.
Rod Smelser