UVic legal scholars say it's in the best interest of the university to quickly implement a vaccine mandate

In a letter to UVic's top officials, they maintain that it should apply to all students, faculty, staff, and visitors to campus

    1 of 1 2 of 1

      (University of Victoria legal scholars wrote the following letter on August 25, one day after Dr. Bonnie Henry told reporters that students could attend classes without being vaccinated.) 


      Dr. Kevin Hall, President & Vice-Chancellor, University of Victoria

      Dr. Valerie Kuehne, Vice-President Academic & Provost, University of Victoria

      Dr. David Zussman, Chair, Board of Governors, University of Victoria

      August 25, 2021

      Dear President Hall, Vice-President Kuehne & Chair Zussman,

      In her August 24 press release, Minister of Advanced Education and Skills Training, Anne Kang stated: “Post-secondary institutions may implement their own proof of vaccine requirement as a part of these [return to physical post-secondary education] plans” (https://news.gov.bc.ca/releases/2021AEST0053- 001664). However, the Provincial Health Officer subsequently suggested that universities would not be allowed to create a vaccine mandate for students.

      In our view, the University of Victoria has the authority to go beyond the minimum safety standards set by the Provincial Health Officer to address the risks posed by Covid-19 on campus. The government has identified no legal basis for assuming jurisdiction over on-campus health and safety matters, and no legal basis for prohibiting the University from adopting a vaccine mandate. In the absence of a prohibition that has an identified source in law, the legal obligation of the University is to act in the best interests of the University by adopting a set of health measures that will advance the purposes of the University for the fall 2021 term and beyond.

      In our view, it is in the best interests of the University that the University quickly implement a vaccine mandate that applies to all students, faculty, staff, and visitors to campus. There are many reasons to impose such a mandate for the fall 2021 term. These include (1) protecting the physical health and safety of the University community’s members (and its members’ children), (2) protecting members of the community from further challenges to their mental health, (3) preventing potential discrimination against disabled, pregnant, and immuno-compromised community members, and (4) minimizing the risk of disruption to in-person learning. We urge the University to implement such a vaccine mandate as soon as possible, with appropriate exceptions for individuals who cannot be vaccinated for medical and human rights grounds.

      Sincerely, Faculty members in the Faculty of Law, University of Victoria

      Susan Breau

      Bradley Bryan

      Gillian Calder

      Kathryn Chan

      Patricia Cochran

      Maneesha Deckha

      Gerry Ferguson

      Alan Hanna

      Rebecca Johnson

      Asad Kiyani

      Freya Kodar

      Tracey Lindberg

      Geoffrey Loomer

      Colin Macleod

      David Milward

      Val Napoleon

      Andrew Newcombe

      Pooja Parmar

      Victor V. Ramraj

      Sara Ramshaw

      Tim Richards

      Supriya Routh

      Calvin Sandborn