The Myth of the Muslim Tide by Doug Saunders rebuts right-wing fear mongers

    1 of 1 2 of 1

      Doug Saunders may be on his way to becoming the most important journalist in the Canadian mainstream media.

      As the European bureau chief of the Globe and Mail, Saunders has exhibited a keen interest in the history of immigration and the integration of different cultures in cities.

      His last book, Arrival City: The Final Migration and Our Next World, was a brilliant examination of the massive movement of people from rural to urban areas, both within countries and across international boundaries.

      He pointed out how poor city planning can hamper the integration process, becoming the catalyst for political unrest, riots, and even revolutions.

      His new book, The Myth of the Muslim Tide: Do Immigrants Threaten the West? (Knopf Canada), takes on another weighty subject: whether western countries are being overrun by Muslim migrants who pose some sort of threat to democracy and free societies.

      This notion is peddled by European political parties, prominent Republicans including Newt Gingrich, FOX News commentators, and numerous authors, including Canadian right winger Mark Steyn.

      In a cool-headed manner, Saunders dismantles their claims one at a time with a relentless onslaught of facts.

      In The Myth of the Muslim Tide, he cites numerous poll results showing that Muslim immigrants are often significantly more patriotic than non-Muslims, and are increasingly tolerant of homosexuality and supportive of women working outside of the home.

      "In general, while their values still lag behind those of their non-immigrant neighbours, and that discrepancy is the source of considerable tension, immigrants of Muslim origin are very clearly progressing toward integration at a rapid pace—especially when you consider that the largest group of these immigrants has arrived in the last 20 years," Saunders writes. "Moreover, it took Europeans and North Americans decades to build the beginnings of legal and social consensus behind women's rights, homosexual equality and birth control. Muslim immigrants, coming from a far lower level of economic development, appear to be adopting those views much more rapidly."

      He notes that 63 percent of American Muslims see no conflict between being a devout follower of their faith and living in a modern society. Among U.S. Christians, 64 percent shared this view. A higher percentage of Christian Americans self-identify as Christians first as opposed to Americans first when compared with how U.S. Muslims identify themselves.

      Saunders also demolishes the widely held notion that Muslims have extremely high birth rates in the West, which will lead them to becoming a majority in countries like France and Germany.

      In addition, Saunders seriously scrutinizes Steyn's claim that Islam, unlike other faiths, "is a political project" and "a bloodthirsty faith".

      The author proceeds to dismantle this with evidence from the British intelligence agency MI5, showing that it's generally not devout Muslims who become terrorists. In fact, the types of people who place bombs on planes and trains are often well-educated "religious novices" drawn to peer groups for personal reasons.

      He reports that a study of convicted terrorists in Britain and Canada showed that religious radicals "felt genuine affection for Western values of tolerance and pluralism"; terrorists, on the other hand, "were unique in their loathing of Western society and culture". Moreover, "their degree of interest in the actual teachings of the Koran was fairly minimal."

      In many respects, Saunders shows that the types of people attracted to jihadist organizations have much in common with the young, violent left-wing extremists who, in bygone days, joined the Baader-Meinhof Gang in Germany, the Japanese Red Army, and the Weather Underground in the United States.

      At times, Saunders's book reads like a doctoral dissertation as he bludgeons readers with data. But in light of all the hype about the so-called Muslim threat, it's a prudent approach because it makes Muslim-tide authors like Steyn, Bruce Bawer, Melanie Phillips, and Christopher Caldwell look like buffoons.

      Anders Breivik's influences studied

      Unlike almost every other Canadian journalist, Saunders also took the time to read the 1,518-page manifesto by Norwegian mass murderer Anders Breivik. Last summer, he bombed a government building and coldly hunted down dozens of children on the island of Utoya while dressed as a police officer.

      It was a crime spree of breathtaking cruelty, with 77 dead by the end of it all.

      Saunders reveals that Breivik's book, 2083: A European Declaration of Independence, cited several of the Muslim-tide authors who are treated with such credibility by right-wing media outlets like the Wall Street Journal, FOX News, and Maclean's magazine.

      "He did not develop a new argument at all, but merely cut and pasted theirs, unaltered, and appended his own violent conclusion," Saunders writes.

      Breivik claimed to go on his murderous rampage to stop the enablers of "Eurabia", Saunders states, with the goal being to halt a "Muslim onslaught".

      Many readers of The Myth of the Muslim Tide will be left wondering if Breivik would have developed these hateful views had the media presented a more accurate picture of Muslims in the West.

      Distinctions lacking

      The Saunders book isn't without some drawbacks. There is not enough education for nonbelievers about the different sects of Islam or how the national origins of Muslim immigrants might be influencing their acclimatization to the West.

      In Canada, the Ismaili Muslims, for instance, have been a model immigrant community with an extremely progressive view of the rights of women. Saunders notes that in Britain, the Muslim population tends to be more conservative than in other European countries, but there isn't sufficient exploration about the role that the Saudis might be playing in spreading their repressive Wahhabi faith in that country.

      Saunders also doesn't address the arguments of Canadian writer Tarek Fatah, whose 2010 book The Jew Is Not My Enemy shows how the Koran has been twisted by jihadists to justify intense anti-Semitism. Fatah has also maintained that a great deal of "Islamic" extremism in the West originates in Pakistan.

      However, Saunders makes a good case that state power and political rhetoric are being targeted at Muslims generally in the United States, whereas in the past, elected officials used to highlight "good Muslims" and "bad Muslims". And that, Saunders suggests, is a dangerous trend.

      In this regard, he likens the current environment to previous attacks by politicians and writers on waves of Catholic and Jewish immigration to western countries.

      "We see it over and over again when a new group of immigrants arrives who are members of a religious minority, usually poor and ill-accustomed to the language and folkways of their new country and the workings of its economy," Saunders writes. "In response to public alarm at these strange newcomers, writers and politicians offer the same set of frightened, frightening ideas. They are different from previous groups. They do not want to integrate. Their religion compels them to impose their values on us. Their reproduction rates will swamp us. They are disloyal and capable of violence."

      Bashing Muslims has become a veritable industry, Saunders reveals, thanks to millions of dollars in funding from conservative foundations to the bloggers who led Breivik to believe a Muslim majority was in Europe's future.

      The Myth of the Muslim Tide is a welcome antidote and for that reason alone, it deserves wide readership.


      Follow Charlie Smith on Twitter at



      out at night

      Aug 27, 2012 at 11:30am

      Right on. Immigrants to the west might even be coming here, in part, to get away from the stuff Steyn et al would tar them with.

      Ain't it too bad how short memories are, and how little attention is paid to history? A brief glance back, just a century or so, reveals wave after wave of immigration from various countries and regions that were branded as threats: the Italians, Jews, Irish, Hispanics, etc. And one by one those waves integrated and took maybe a generation or so to lose most of the baggage that many said should prohibit them from entering North America. Did some less welcome attributes remain? No doubt, just like today if you scratch a standard-issue 5th generation whitey there's a decent chance you'll find a bit of a closet imperialist (only the myopia of thinking of everyone but themselves as "other" keeps them from seeing it that way).

      Pat Crowe

      Aug 27, 2012 at 12:08pm

      Hell of a cool wedding in the paper today over in Kandahar.
      Too bad Dougie wasn't over there drinking and dancing up a storm.
      And peddling western multiculturalism and tolerance to the Taliban.
      I'm sure they would of commended him with his cool dance steps...just before they cut his tolerant, infidel, head off.
      Sorry Charlie, the optics are too poor at this time for embracing the fanatics of a death cult in my little old Victoria.
      Am I a racist for calling it as I see it?
      And comparing right wing Christian fanatics or Jewish immigrant fear etc. of the past to Islamic radicalism of now is apples and oranges.
      There is an undeniable problem here.

      fidel gastro

      Aug 27, 2012 at 12:39pm

      regarding fundamentalist muslims, how can you be tolerant of intolerance?

      mutual respect and understanding is all good, but respecting and understanding to those who are diametrically opposed to that perspective?

      to not be aware of the threat of fundamentalist islam makes you a useful idiot.

      to islamists, we are all just infidels.

      out at night

      Aug 27, 2012 at 12:58pm

      @Pat Crowe - you're right, 9/11 has nothing on the holocaust. Apples and oranges indeed.

      Even though the European Jews who were slaughtered were in many cases 3rd, 4th, 5th generation Germans, Poles, Slovaks, whatever, they were still referred to as interlopers whose religion and culture were a threat to nice, normal western countries.

      Ira Zinman

      Aug 27, 2012 at 1:17pm

      Notwithstanding Mr Saunders' dhimmitude and defense of Trudeau's multiculti experiment, Islamic immigration is already having negative consequences for Canada. An example is the police enforcing Shari'a compliance:

      No thanks. Let's quit pretending that multiculturalism and immigration from cultures with vastly different--and uncompromising--mores and values from our society is a good thing. Again, this forty year old experiment was the whim of Pierre Trudeau, rather than anything 'Canadian.'

      Pat Crowe

      Aug 27, 2012 at 1:36pm

      I didn't say that, out at night.
      You did.

      out at night

      Aug 27, 2012 at 4:10pm

      @Pat Crowe -

      Baffled by your post. What, exactly did I say that you didn't say, uh, so to speak?

      Here's you: "And comparing right wing Christian fanatics or Jewish immigrant fear etc. of the past to Islamic radicalism of now is apples and oranges."

      Then me:"@Pat Crowe - you're right, 9/11 has nothing on the holocaust. Apples and oranges indeed."

      So you see what I did there right? How I addressed my response right to your point?

      The only OTHER things I said were that the Jews were seen as a real threat by the Germans and their many allies in Europe, and then I sort of described a little how they went about exterminating the Jews. And why they did it.

      Oh, wait a second...the whole "you said it not me" thing...yes, okay, it all makes sense - you're a Nazi?!

      Pat Crowe

      Aug 27, 2012 at 5:55pm

      Out at night, you have the right stuff for enabling Islamic fundamentalism in Canada.
      I applaud your forward thinking realism.
      Now go burn a Koran on the steps of a Mosque and have a great day.


      Aug 28, 2012 at 12:47pm

      Most Muslims live in peace and like us Christians want a better life for their families.

      Sure there are fringe nut bars just like in any community like Willy Pickton, Bernadino, Ex Colonel Williams. Bundy and

      Tim McVeigh the domestic terrorists like the recent arrest of the right wing nut bar militia headed by Aguiagui.

      The Muslims share prophets with us Christians and the Jewish Torah like Abraham etc.

      Indeed Islam is a sister religion to Christian and Judaism.

      Unfortunately the majority are ignorant about Muslims and perpetuate hate a very UN Christian view.


      Sep 6, 2012 at 12:16pm

      I'll believe Mark Steyn any day.