Burnaby council raises fracking fear

    1 of 2 2 of 2

      Burnaby council is home to progressive civic politicians with impressive credentials as New Democrats. Coun. Sav Dhaliwal is one of them.

      Now in his fourth term, Dhaliwal was president of the B.C. NDP a few years ago. According to the councillor, he remains a “very involved member and activist”. But there’s an issue on which Dhaliwal and his colleagues don’t fully agree with the provincial party: fracking.

      The B.C. NDP is largely supportive of the gas industry and its controversial extraction method called hydraulic fracturing, or fracking. If New Democrats win the election scheduled for May this year, Dhaliwal promises one thing.

      “If they do form government, we’ll put their feet to the fire on this one,” Dhaliwal told the Georgia Straight in a phone interview on February 19.

      At the council meeting the previous night, Dhaliwal seconded a motion by Coun. Dan Johnston that calls for a moratorium on fracking. Burnaby council wants a comprehensive examination of the impacts of drilling deep through rock beds and injecting pressurized water, sand, and chemicals to release gas underground.

      Even though Burnaby is nowhere near the gas wells of the northern region of B.C. and fracking is not a municipal matter, Dhaliwal emphasized that the city has to take a stand, as it did in the past on other noncivic issues such as international trade, health care, and child poverty.

      “As part of a larger community, we have this responsibility to ensure that both the environmental and social issues that affect us all on a larger scale are generally talked about,” he said.

      Incidentally, Dhaliwal and Johnston, along with Burnaby mayor Derek Corrigan and councillors Colleen Jordan and Nick Volkow, endorsed (now energy critic) John Horgan when the Malahat–Juan de Fuca MLA ran in 2011 for the leadership of the B.C. NDP.

      An immediate moratorium on fracking doesn’t appear to be on the agenda for the party. On November 30, 2011, the B.C. NDP announced that leader Adrian Dix and the New Democrats were “committed to a plan that ensures long-term sustainability and environmental quality in B.C.’s expanding natural gas fields”. In August 2012, Horgan told the Straight in a phone interview that his party supports the expansion of B.C.’s gas industry, which, he said, is “mature here, as opposed to other places where they’ve had concerns”.

      At the Burnaby council chamber last Monday evening, Corrigan indicated that he hasn’t spoken to Horgan but he knows that the energy critic is “favourably disposed” toward fracking.

      “I don’t know that the research has been so thorough as for John Horgan to come to a final conclusion on it,” Corrigan told the Straight. “I think he wants to keep the door open. But I don’t know that he’s said, ‘I’m going to those go-aheads as soon as I get into office.’ I think he’ll find there’s opposition within his own party to him moving ahead too quickly.”

      A report to council prepared by Burnaby city staff notes that Quebec has a moratorium on fracking as well as on oil and gas exploration under the St. Lawrence River. Nova Scotia isn’t approving new fracking projects until it completes a review in 2014. According to the report, New Brunswick had a report done that notes that the province should proceed with a “phased-in approach”.

      Premier Christy Clark and her B.C. Liberal government have staked the province’s future on natural gas, a direction that has not been fundamentally challenged by the B.C. NDP.

      In the throne speech last February 12, the government talked about a B.C. Prosperity Fund generating between $130 billion and
      $260 billion from liquid natural gas revenues and a new tax on LNG over the next 30 years.

      Clark indicated that the Prosperity Fund will help pay the province’s $56-billion debt and possibly even eliminate the sales tax as well as finance public education.

      Royalties from natural gas are a major source of revenue for the province. In the 2013-14 budget unveiled at the legislative assembly on February 19, the government estimates gas royalties at $282 million for the fiscal year. It expects the amount to rise to $318 million in 2014-15, and $359 million in 2015-16.

      Unlike B.C. Liberals, New Democrats, and Conservatives, the Green Party of B.C. backs a moratorium on fracking.

      “The Liberals see it [gas revenues] as an immediate need, and the NDP see it as something that would expand in the future,” B.C. Green Leader Jane Sterk told the Straight in a phone interview. “Both of them support the industry.”


      We're now using Facebook for comments.


      Xavier Dern

      Feb 21, 2013 at 11:42am

      Since everyone else is doing it, why us?
      Why destroy our water table?

      All we need is the surplus gas in our pipes, why find more under our feet.

      As Rene Levesque said: Leave in the ground for another hundred years. The companies will want it more then.

      Enough of the nausating Corrigan crew

      Feb 21, 2013 at 12:01pm

      Corrigan and his cronies should run in the provincial election since they're always sticking their nose into other peoples, and jurisdictions, business. The self appointed expert on everything should step up to the plate and do something instead of taking pot shots from the cheap seats.


      Feb 21, 2013 at 1:11pm

      We are at a turning point in our history. We can choose the direction of the old parties, which is to bet our future on the old carbon fuel based economy or we can choose Green and focus on the new post carbon economy. Our children and grandchildren will take the brunt of the growing climate change disaster and will wonder what the heck we were thinking if we don't make what is clearly the right choice.

      Ali Said

      Feb 21, 2013 at 10:21pm

      Let's turn off the lights and furnace: caves are wonderful and life expectancy is about 25 years old. no more retirement and health care problems.
      The anti fracking campaign hates tight gas for it makes all the renewables look badly expensive and expensive energy means control over people's lives, the ultimate goal of some political parties under the guise of saving your grand children from apocalypse...


      Feb 22, 2013 at 2:47pm

      BC needs the taxes on the sale of thie gas,and to power gas to elec.stations,which are clean and cheap.Fracking has been going on for a long time without any problems.But I know the greens wont like it becouse( fill in blank).If we are going for cleaner fuel this is it.

      Bruce G

      Feb 24, 2013 at 8:01pm

      Burnaby is right and courageous to speak up and take action. We all know that we need to reduce oil and gas dependence, and that means diversifying a lot more into clean energy. We have solar heat pumps made in BC that heat space and domestic hot water for less than fossil fuels and electricity.

      Natural Gas burns relatively clean compared to coal, at 117 lbs/Million Btu. However, the well leak percentage is 7.9% of Methane, which has a Global Warming Potential of 72 (times greater than CO2), therefore true account needs to add a multiple of .079 x 72 = 568.8% more CO2 than just the combustion figure by 5.5 fold.

      Also, NG consumes 2,000,000 gallons of drinking water for each well and 800 chemicals, that all require 1000's of truck emmisions added to NG. You do the math when it takes the equiavlent of 2 barrels of oil energy to extract 1 barrel of oil from the tar sands. They burn more energy than they recover.

      Phil Miller

      Feb 28, 2013 at 2:47am

      LOL... These anti fracking supporters are all the same. What they care about least are facts. There have been over 270,000 wells fracked in Alberta and BC since 1949 without one case of ground water contamination.