Vancouver Green councillor Adriane Carr calls for cigarette butt deposit and refund program

    1 of 1 2 of 1

      Vancouver’s Green party city councillor is hoping to see a provincial deposit and refund program launched to reduce cigarette butt litter.

      Adriane Carr plans to introduce a motion at next week’s city council meeting aimed at getting the B.C. government to implement a deposit and return program for cigarette butts, similar to the beverage container recycling program.

      The motion calls for the mayor to ask the Government of B.C. to implement the program, which would include a deposit fee with the purchase of cigarettes, and refunds for returned cigarette butts.

      “The problem with cigarette butts is not only that they’re just so common and out there and unsightly, but they’re actually toxic,” Carr told the Straight by phone. “And a lot of people are under the misconception that cigarette butts will just biodegrade….but no, they’re full of toxins, and those toxins do get into groundwater, do get into our marine ecosystem.”

      Carr noted the proposal for the provincial program is based on a West End Cleanup initiative during car-free day on June 16, which resulted in the collection of over 60,000 cigarette butts. As part of the pilot project, volunteers were paid about one cent for each cigarette butt collected, or $20 a pound.

      John Merzetti of West End Cleanup said the trial run indicated the deposit and refund model would be “really successful”. The pilot project was funded by a grant from the Vancouver Foundation, through the Gordon Neighbourhood House.

      “It worked better than we could have anticipated on Sunday,” he said in a phone interview.

      He noted the group has been cleaning up litter in the neighbourhood since 2007.

      “The cigarette butt is…the bane of our existence,” Merzetti said in a phone interview. “It’s the single largest per unit item in what we pick up. And they’re so small and people think they’re harmless, but when you add them all up, they’re quite something.”

      Carr’s motion also calls for the proposed initiative to be forwarded to the Union of B.C. Municipalities for consideration at the organization’s convention in September.

      “My hope is that, because this is a program that should be province-wide, that Vancouver can simply urge the province to undertake the program, but it should be done by working with Vancouver and all the municipalites in B.C.,” said Carr.

      The Green councillor expects to bring the motion forward at city council’s next meeting on Tuesday, June 25. 

      Comments

      18 Comments

      RP

      Jun 18, 2013 at 4:12pm

      Can't we all just line up for our plastic bubbles and get it over with?

      Gross Butts

      Jun 18, 2013 at 5:10pm

      No doubt, smokers who toss their butts on the grounds are pigs. Just clean up after yourself. That too much to ask? Have some respect. Gross

      Billy Bones

      Jun 18, 2013 at 5:18pm

      This seems farfetched. Who wants to count cigarette butt returns?

      uknow

      Jun 18, 2013 at 5:34pm

      let's just ban them & get it over with. if we're forced to wear a bike helmet because for our own safety then why aren't the fools still smoking being protected from themselves also?

      Pick your butt of the ground, you ash!

      Jun 18, 2013 at 6:05pm

      O.K. here's a pilot program I think we should run:

      Use all the surveillance cameras and it you catch a smoker toss a butt on the ground, make them eat it.

      Just do it

      Jun 18, 2013 at 6:45pm

      It's disappointing that there needs to be a program to encourage smokers to do the right thing.

      James G

      Jun 18, 2013 at 6:56pm

      'I'm not as green as I am cabbage looking!'

      Five free cigarette butts to anyone tracing that old saying!

      I'd still be more likely to shove the lit end of a cigarette into my own eye than vote for any Green, any time.

      Still, will back any good idea no matter it' s origins. This is a great idea. Let's get behind it!

      Jiff

      Jun 18, 2013 at 8:01pm

      @uknow

      Then we should ban cars and cheeseburgers and every single thing that carries a health and/or safety risk. We need helmets for the shower. Won't someone think of the children?

      Hugo Triptoph

      Jun 18, 2013 at 9:52pm

      Please implement this program as soon as possible.

      I will have a company in China send me a shipping container of manufactured cigarette butts which I will return over the course of several years. I have calculated that one container will hold approximately $2 million work of butts.

      And this, folks, is why this idea won't work. It works for bottles because they are too heavy to be worth manufacturing and shipping here.

      ding dong

      Jun 19, 2013 at 1:52am

      how about adding dog feces to this wonderful refund program?