David Suzuki: Cecil the lion’s killing shines spotlight on barbaric trophy hunting

    1 of 1 2 of 1

      A beloved animal, tagged for tracking by researchers, crosses the invisible boundary between protected and unprotected area and is killed by a hunter who has paid tens of thousands of dollars for the “experience”.

      That was the fate of Zimbabwe’s Cecil the lion, whose killing sparked torrents of online and on-air outrage. But it also happens around the world every day, including in my home province of B.C. 

      Many people are familiar with Cecil’s story. Minnesota dentist Walter Palmer and his guides, hunting at night with spotlights, are alleged to have tied a dead animal to their car near Hwange National Park to lure the lion. According to reports, Palmer wounded Cecil with an arrow, then tracked and shot the animal with a rifle 40 hours later. The lion’s body was found on the park’s outskirts, skinned and headless, along with the tracking collar.

      Killing animals solely for “sport” or “trophies” is an ongoing and worldwide practice, and something Palmer had engaged in many times and in many places, including Canada. He was even convicted of charges related to an illegal bear kill in 2008. 

      Closer to home, a grizzly that was tagged for research in Banff National Park had the misfortune to cross from Alberta, where grizzly hunting is illegal, into B.C., where it isn’t, and was legally shot and killed.

      On the B.C. coast, people were outraged when a photo surfaced of NHL player Clayton Stoner with a grizzly he shot in the Great Bear Rainforest. Coastal First Nations have banned trophy hunting there, but the government doesn’t recognize the ban. The bear, named Cheeky by local residents, was skinned and had his head and paws cut off, with the rest of the carcass left to rot. Reports have also surfaced that the winner of the Guide Outfitters Association of B.C.’s highest award in 2015 was convicted of illegal grizzly baiting in 2012. 

      Even though many grizzly populations are vulnerable and close to 90 percent of British Columbians, including many food hunters, oppose trophy hunting, B.C.’s government refuses to end the hunt, even in parks and areas where First Nations have banned the practice.

      Conservationists and other experts have challenged government population estimates, claiming they’re based on guesswork and that the real number is likely less than half the 15,000 on which the government justifies the hunt.

      Large carnivores like lions, grizzlies, and leopards that are targeted by big-game hunters are extremely vulnerable despite their size and ferocity. They range over large areas, which often puts them in conflict with humans and our infrastructure.

      Parks and protected areas are too small to provide adequate habitat, so bears often wander into areas where they can be killed by hunters or vehicles. They also reproduce later in life, infrequently, and their young often have low survival rates, so populations don't recover quickly when overhunted. 

      Large carnivores are also keystone species that play a crucial role in the food web by helping to regulate prey populations. B.C. grizzlies also contribute to rainforest growth by dragging salmon carcasses into the woods, where the fish remains and bear scat provide fertilizer.

      In B.C., trophy hunters have slaughtered more than 12,000 grizzlies over the past three decades. Like Palmer, non-resident hunters here pay large amounts of money to “bag” a grizzly because the species is protected in their home country, such as the U.S., or because populations have dwindled to a handful, as in Western Europe, where the species is now protected. 

      Killing animals purely for the “thrill” is barbaric and wasteful, and can’t be justified on economic or conservation grounds. Studies show more money can be made from people who want to view and photograph them. Research also shows very little money paid by trophy hunters benefits the local economy.

      We’re at a critical moment in human history: our population, technology, consumptive demand, and global economy are overwhelming the planet’s life-support systems—air, water, soil, and other species. We’re in a global eco-crisis that demands a redefinition of our relationship with plants and other animals. 

      It’s time to end trophy hunting. In B.C., the government must listen to citizens and conservationists, respect First Nations laws and customs, and end the grizzly hunt.




      Aug 4, 2015 at 5:33pm

      Why the fuck does our crappy BC premier continue to cater to this tiny, brutal interest group!? It's very easy to see what there is to lose by continuing with the Grizzley hunt... but what's to gain??? I just don't understand the thinking behind her decision to let this play out!! WTF is she thinking?

      I must say, i hate that women with an intense ferocity! She MUST go! This is just 1 example of her complete ignorance of, and disregard for, what is inherently right and wrong.


      Aug 4, 2015 at 6:11pm

      The reality is that animal cruelty is not even a blip on the radar when it comes to the vast majority of the world. Sure there is outrage over Cecil's death now but give it a couple of months and there will be bupkis. This is just like Kony 2012 et cetera. Eventually the outrage dies down and goes away.

      Therefore it isn't surprising that the Premier is focusing her efforts on other more compelling issues with a more direct impact to British Columbians.

      Barry Hayward

      Aug 4, 2015 at 11:27pm

      Hunting great animals places shame on all of us. We should not allow this outrageous practice to go on, here in BC or anywhere else. I am disgusted.

      the judge

      Aug 4, 2015 at 11:52pm

      The Premier feels she owes Outfitters, they have control over her decision s regarding grizzly and all big game hunting. Could there be some kind of conflict of interest?

      the judge

      Aug 5, 2015 at 9:36am

      Premier Clark defends the outfitting industry and sale of grizzlies and other animals as trophies. It creates jobs she says. She goes as far as awarding the goabc 380,000 dollars as Tourism Grants to grow their trophy hunting industry. Yes tax payers money is supporting the sale of heads in BC. Her MLA Mike Morris , guess who his campaign manager is ? A very prominent Guide Outfitter who is a registered lobbyist with goabc Micheal Schneider.


      Aug 5, 2015 at 10:59am

      So the disconnected malcontents would like to impose their will on those of us who enjoy hunting both for the hunt itself and the spoils? Who nominated you to dictate what others should and should not be doing? Animal cruelty? Hunting great animals places shame on all of us? Says you. I in the meantime, have been scouting and planning an elk hunt for this September, a hunt for a great majestic 6x6 elk. Just the thought of, spotting, stalking and killing one of these creatures gives me goose bump. Then, after the work of dragging, cleaning and butchering it ... I'll be able to feed my family organically raised, ethically treated and just plain happy elk meat. Got a problem with that?