Push to give the public a vote on the Vancouver Aquarium's whales going to city council

    1 of 1 2 of 1

      Within two weeks, Vancouver city council will have to decide whether it is going to give the public a vote on whale and dolphin captivity at the Vancouver Aquarium.

      Late April 15, Green councillor Adriane Carr filed a notice of motion calling for a plebiscite on the question of ending cetacean exhibits at the aquarium in Stanley Park.

      In a telephone interview, Carr told the Straight that civic elections scheduled for November 2014 provide an ideal opportunity to seek the public’s opinion on the matter.

      “I think this is an issue dear to the hearts of Vancouverites,” she said. “People recognize that it’s not fitting to keep sentient beings—cetaceans—in captivity.”

      Carr’s motion calls for a non-binding plebiscite to be held in the event that the Vancouver park board and the aquarium fail to reach an agreement on a phase-out of cetacean exhibits. It sets a deadline of six weeks prior civic elections scheduled for November 15, which is October 4, the latest date on which Vancouver city council can vote to include a plebiscite on the ballot.

      The text of the motion states that there is “considerable scientific evidence that cetaceans (whales and dolphins) are sentient beings with complex social relations…that suffer distress and premature death in captivity in aquarium pools”.

      It also notes that a $100-million expansion is currently underway at the Vancouver Aquarium, and that plans includes the enlargement of aquatic tanks to accommodate additional dolphins and as many as 10 beluga whales.

      Currently on display in Stanley Park are two Pacific white-sided dolphins, two beluga whales, and several porpoises, sea otters, seals, and sea lions. The aquarium also owns three additional belugas it has on “breeding loan” to SeaWorld parks in the United States.

      On April 9, Mayor Gregor Robertson and other prominent members of the ruling Vision Vancouver party voiced personal opinions against the aquarium keeping whales and dolphins. But the politicians also said they oppose holding a public vote on the matter.

      “My personal view is that the Vancouver Aquarium should begin to phase out the holding of whales and dolphins in captivity,” said Robertson in an emailed statement. “I’m hopeful that the Aquarium and the Park Board can work collaboratively and come to an agreement on how to achieve this with a dialogue and review that will be informed, thoughtful, and inclusive.”

      The aquarium issued a public statement in response to the mayor's remarks. According to that email, animals at the aquarium receive "exceptional care".

      "Dolphins and belugas at Vancouver Aquarium play a direct and vital role in engaging people in key ocean issues," it continues. "In addition, with the rapid environmental changes in the arctic where belugas live, continued research, much of which must be done in marine science centres like the Vancouver Aquarium, is critical to their future."

      Carr acknowledged Robertson’s preference to see the issue resolved through negotiations with the aquarium. She stressed that she’s addressed that wish by including a provision in her motion that a plebiscite will only be held if talks with the aquarium fail.

      “The mayor is on public record saying that he hopes there will be that agreement reached between the park board and the aquarium,” Carr said. “So I’ve given room for that to happen, and hopefully that will create more of an enticement for the mayor and Vision to support this.”

      The motion calling for a plebiscite is scheduled to go before city council on April 29.

      Follow Travis Lupick on TwitterFacebook, and Instagram.



      Jim S.

      Apr 17, 2014 at 9:33am

      Adrienne Carr seems to forget that a motion requires a seconder but great attempt at trying to win votes for reelection!


      Apr 17, 2014 at 11:02am

      This is a very important move by Councilor Carr to get the City to make an agreement with the Vancouver Aquarium to phase out captivity or move on to a public vote.

      The motion at City Hall is "
      Carr’s motion calls for a non-binding plebiscite to be held in the event
      that the Vancouver park board and the aquarium fail to reach an agreement
      on a phase-out of cetacean exhibits."

      The agreement should amend the Cetacean Bylaw to guarantee a phase out of cetacean. The Vancouver Aquarium had vehemently opposed it and got it watered down. It must also be agreed to be put into the lease agreement.

      This would be the end result of any referendum and a quicker end to the captivity.

      For Freedom


      Apr 21, 2014 at 7:59am

      Thank you for opening my eyes to the enormous number of votes the Aquarium has on the Parks Board! Lifeforce (Peter), you've done us all a great service by pointing out how the shadowy and elusive Vancouver Aquarium (who hide in a park so none of us can find them and question their actions) somehow pulls the strings on the Parks Board! I wouldn't be surprised if you soon were able to tell us that they also control parking rates, the OneCard program, and the smoking bylaws! Thanks for this enlightening comment!

      Jethrine MacKae

      May 13, 2014 at 1:44pm

      ... ... I know the real reason for this is that the Aquarium employees are tired of feeding all those fish to all those whales and shovelling whale shit out of the aquarium.

      If that's not bad enough, that whale shit does not make quality manure. So, what are whales good for in captivity?