Open letter calls on federal Liberals to recognize water as a human right

The following open letter calls on members of the Liberal Party of Canada to back a resolution to recognize water as a human right. The party will hold its biennial convention in Vancouver from April 30 to May 2.

April 28, 2009

Dear members of the Liberal Party of Canada,

We congratulate the Liberal Party of Canada (Ontario) for putting forward a resolution calling for a national water policy that bans bulk water exports, establishes enforceable clean water standards, calls for a conservation strategy, demands the exclusion of water from NAFTA and recognizes water as a human right.

As representatives of environmental, labour and social justice organizations, we are writing to urge all members of the Liberal Party to vote in favour of this significant resolution at the upcoming convention in Vancouver.

Numerous reports show that Canada is not immune to the global water crisis. Environment Canada warns that only one per cent of our fresh water is renewable although 60 per cent of our GDP is tied directly to the use of fresh water. Several parts of the country have been affected by drought and nearly a quarter of our municipalities have faced water shortages in recent years.

It is time for Canada to enact a national water policy to address urgent water issues and the adoption of this resolution would be an important message on the need for legislative safeguards to protect Canada’s water.

The recognition of water as a human right is long overdue.

In April 2008, the Canadian Medical Association Journal reported that 1,766 boil-water advisories were in effect in Canadian municipalities. Several communities have endured drinking water advisories for years, and 90 Canadians die from water-borne diseases every year.

Indigenous communities in Canada have been affected disproportionately by the water crisis. Despite repeated pledges to ensure they have access to clean drinking water, water is too often contaminated in First Nations communities. Last November, Health Canada reported 103 drinking water advisories in First Nations communities. In addition, Industrial water pollution is rampant in many Indigenous communities due to industrial expansion, which is either directly on land to which Indigenous communities lay claim or upstream from where they live.

The adoption of a national water policy that recognizes water as a human right will ensure that all people living in Canada are legally entitled to safe, clean drinking water and water for sanitation in sufficient quantities, and that inequalities in access are addressed immediately.

Finally, if adopted within the Liberal Party platform, we hope the resolution’s call to protect water from commoditization will extend to include measures to ensure that municipal water services remain in public hands.

We call on members of the Liberal Party to support this very important resolution.

Sincerely,

Maude Barlow, The Council of Canadians, (Senior advisor to the President of the UN General Assembly)
David Brooks, Friends of the Earth Canada
Tony Clarke, Polaris Institute
Stephen Hazel, Sierra Club of Canada
Sarah Kambites, United Nations Association of Canada
Abrahim Khan, Trinity College, University of Toronto
Tony Maas, World Wildlife Fund
Clayton Thomas- Mueller Indigenous Environmental Network
David Schindler, University of Alberta

Comments

2 Comments

MichelleN

May 1, 2009 at 9:09am

I agree with protection of water from commodification, but wouldn't saying water is a human right negate our sovereignty over our water? Couldn't the U.S. say you have to supply us with water since we don't have enough for humans on this side of the border? And if water is a human right, wouldn't food be also? Why do we allow industrialization and commodification of food at all?

Ken Erickson

May 6, 2009 at 8:17pm

Water is a commodity and the sooner we recognize that, the sooner we will be able to supply it to everyone who needs it. Of course water is free when it falls from the sky and there is nothing to stop you standing in the rain with your mouth open, but clean water coming out of a tap in your house is not free - plenty of work has to be done to achieve that. Only if water is priced according to the cost of purifying and delivering it will it be used responsibly. People living in deserts, for example, will not be irrigating their lawns if the cost of water reflects the trouble and expense of obtaining it there.

On the other hand, sufficient water for drinking and sanitation should be recognized as a human right in our affluent society, along with food and shelter. But price controls or subsidies of these essentials is not the way to make sure that we all have them. Water, food and housing must be allowed to arrive at their true values on the free market and the state should provide welfare payments to those who are in need. Price controls lead to shortages because, surprise, plumbers, farmers and builders just refuse to do their jobs for nothing. Subsidies lead to inefficient use of the subsidized resource. For example, if bread is sufficiently cheap, people will feed it to their hogs and chickens. Desert dwellers will use precious fossil water to grow wheat, as they do in Saudi Arabia, if government policy is foolish enough.

What I am saying is that we must protect the poor among us by using the force of the free market, not by fighting or denying it. This applies to water just as much as to food, clothing, education and shelter.