Fraser Institute vice president denies he works for a right-wing organization

    1 of 1 2 of 1

      Here's something that will surprise critics of the Fraser Institute.

      It's a video of the Vancouver-based think tank's executive vice president, Jason Clemens, denying that he works for a right-wing organization.

      The interviewer, TVO's Steve Paikin, tries without success to get Clemens to admit where the Fraser Institute is on the political spectrum.

      Had Paikin read Burnaby author Donald Gutstein's recent book Harperism, he might have zeroed in with a more precise question: is the Fraser Institute a Hayekian think tank?

      I doubt that Clemens would have denied that, given that free-market economist Friedrich Hayek inspired the type of work that he does.

      Then Paikin could have followed up by asking Clemens if he agrees with Hayek that we must live with inequality because too much government intervention interferes with economic freedom.

      Clemens would have answered "yes".

      From there, Paikin could have posed this question to Clemens: do minimum-wage laws interfere with economic freedom?

      After Clemens answered "yes", then Paikin could have asked if it's true that the Fraser Institute has often criticized minimum-wage laws.

      Clemens would again answer "yes".

      Then Paikin's closing question could be: "Okay, you oppose a minimum-wage law. You say we must live with inequality because government intervention undermines the economy. And you're an adherent of Friedrich Hayek. How does that not make the Fraser Institute a right-wing organization?"

      Checkmate. 

      By the way, this video came courtesy of Press Progress, which is a section of the admittedly left-wing Broadbent Institute.

      Comments

      6 Comments

      Mark Schneider

      Nov 28, 2014 at 8:36pm

      Charlie, why didn't TVO ask you to do the interview? Dumb!

      Hazlit

      Nov 29, 2014 at 6:33am

      This just in: Pope denies he's Catholic.

      scott7ree

      Nov 30, 2014 at 8:07am

      Politics is about issues, not some fictional spectrum.

      Tommy Khang

      Dec 1, 2014 at 9:05am

      In other news the sky is blue. But in all honest, opposing minimum wage is ascribing to full on capitalism, and even the left would say scrape minimum wage in their ideal world (go go communism) but the reality is both sides I am sure know that this answer is a pipe dream.

      Wing Wing

      Dec 2, 2014 at 8:25am

      And then suppose he had asked Clemens do you support decriminalizing all drugs and Clemens had said yes. Where on your right wing scale would he then stand? The point is that the Fraser Institute DERIVES its thinking from mainstream economics and the conclusions can fall into the zone of what simpler souls like to label as right or left wing. This is why the Fraser Institute does not have an ideology but rather a methodology of thought. But that would be a little beyond the grasp of Paiking viewers.

      Seriously?

      Dec 2, 2014 at 11:23am

      "Think tanks" are not non-partisan and everyone who isn't conditioned to believe in one party or ideology realizes this. The Broadbent Institute, Canadian Taxpayers Federation, Fraser Institute, C D Howe Institue, Centre for Policy Alternatives and every other think tank is shilling for an ideology or party. The faux outrage over this video could only come from another herd that simply follows a different master.