Human Rights Watch will not disclose identities of female aboriginal whistle blowers

    1 of 1 2 of 1

      A New York–based human-rights group says it will stand by B.C. victims of alleged police abuse who've asked that their identities be kept secret. 

      "If the government is committed to accountable policing, it should address the flaws in the policing system that leave indigenous women and girls feeling they have nowhere to turn for a safe, effective investigation of their complaints," Meghan Rhoad, women's-rights researcher for Human Rights Watch, said in a news release issued today.

      Rhoad led a Human Rights Watch probe into RCMP mistreatment of indigenous women and girls in northern B.C. She made the statement in response to calls from Prime Minister Stephen Harper and the Mounties for aboriginal people to file complaints.

      That came after Human Rights Watch issued an 89-page report outlining alleged RCMP mistreatment of indigenous women and girls in northern B.C. The document included allegations from some women that they were raped by officers.

      Human Rights Watch maintains that the prime minister's remark ignores the women's fear of retaliation.

      B.C. Civil Liberties Association president Lyndsay Lyster made a similar observation.

      "There are good reasons why these indigenous women who have alleged horrific abuses on the part of the police in northern B.C. have chosen to remain anonymous, including the fear of retaliation and stigma," she said in a BCCLA news release. "There is no need to have their identities revealed for the government and police to take a serious look at the problems that have plagued police relations with First Nations for years."

      Human Rights Watch revealed today that Harper's office declined its request for a meeting. Tomorrow, Human Rights Watch will meet with the RCMP at E Division, which oversees policing in B.C.

      In addition, the researchers are also meeting with the Independent Investigations Office in B.C. today.

      “We would like to be able to share the full details of the allegations of abuse we uncovered with the IIO, but the office is hamstrung by its limited mandate,” Rhoad said in the news release. “You can’t expect indigenous women and girls to come forward when some of the most egregious crimes against them have been excluded from the one existing institution that offers a meaningful, safe way to bring complaints.”

      Former Vancouver city councillor Ellen Woodsworth told the Georgia Straight before the annual women's march in the Downtown Eastside that she's "so glad" that Human Rights Watch has drawn attention to this issue.

      "It's very clear to me why they don't feel safe to go to the RCMP because they're so isolated in small communities," Woodsworth said. "There's no place to go, and until very recently, the police have not been at the table to create the safety where they can speak out against the [alleged] violence that they're experiencing from the police and the RCMP."

      Meanwhile, the federal NDP has taken up the report's call for a national inquiry into missing and murdered aboriginal women in Canada.

      NDP status of women critic Niki Ashton has claimed that it's a "disgrace that in a country like Canada, women have so little trust in the police".

      “A national, open inquiry is the only way to get justice for the women who have been murdered as well as their families and communities,” Ashton declared in an NDP news release. “Successive governments have failed Aboriginal women. Continuing to ignore this national tragedy is unacceptable and will not make it go away.”

      With files from Yolande Cole


      Comments

      6 Comments

      Dave L.

      Feb 15, 2013 at 6:43am

      Very ugly situation , these poor women are afraid to complain to the police because the police are the problem (apparently , not yet proven)
      but if they don't speak out the allegations will never be proven .
      A mechanism must be found to enable them to speak without fear of retribution , perhaps more female police officers ?

      PJ

      Feb 15, 2013 at 9:20am

      And now it becomes hearsay,how can you prove the allogations without proof.Word of mouth and he said she said is not proof.

      RUK

      Feb 15, 2013 at 2:14pm

      @DaveL

      The independent police commission?

      @PJ

      HRW is not the courts. They don't prove things to a criminal standard. That is not their job. They are just doing what they do: receiving allegations, thinking about them, contextualizing them, and writing a report.

      They are not here to test the facts, although I think it is common sense that when they get multiple people saying the same stuff, then there is more than a mere conjecture.

      PJ

      Feb 15, 2013 at 2:43pm

      re,RUK You cannot say that the RCMP are at fault which HRW claims without proving same.WE all KNOW how the media likes to run with a story true or not,these claims should have been brougt to the RCMP first for their imput befoer giving it to the media as they are good at branding guilty before proof IF ANY comes out.There are other means to complain about the polce then going directly to them.For now it is all hearsay as the HRW dose not want to show their info.

      Kiskatinawkid

      Feb 15, 2013 at 4:50pm

      Time to turf the Queen's cowboys and bring back a BC Provincial Police Force. This outfit has no credibility whatsoever!

      anonymous

      Feb 17, 2013 at 9:05pm

      Really sad.
      Recently Saw a documentary on Aboriginal suicide case.Really these people suffer a lot.